| 466 American Legislative Exchange Council (ALEC) bills introduced in 2013: Legislator “scholarships” may be a factor
8/13/13
A report by the Center for Media and Democracy identifies 466 ALEC bills introduced in state legislatures across the nation in 2013. 139 of these ALEC bills affect public education. 31 of these education bills became law this year.
Only seven states didn’t have an ALEC education bill introduced this year. To view the report:http://www.sourcewatch.org/images/8/88/ALEC_report_2013.pdf
ALEC is a champion of charter schools and voucher legislation and thus is geared toward starving the public common school. K-12 Inc., the nation’s largest provider of online charter schools paid its CEO Ron Packard $5 million in total compensation in 2011. Additionally, Packard owns millions of dollars in company shares, not a bad compensation package for a school superintendent. He is on the ALEC Education Task Force.
The Ohio Virtual Academy charter school is operated by K-12, Inc. Ohioans should recognize that tax dollars (deducted from school districts) are being used to support a superintendent’s salary of $5 million plus millions in company shares while many school districts are cutting essential programs and services due to lack of funds.
Money spent on advertising is another issue. This expenditure by for-profit charter schools is not only a slap at public school districts but it shortchanges educational opportunities for charter school kids.
Ohio taxpayers are subsidizing outrageous salaries and benefits of for-profit charter operators, and slick, expensive marketing. On average, charter schools spend twice as much per pupil on administration as traditional school districts.
An August 11, 2013 Columbus Dispatch article states, “About a third of Ohio House Republicans-including Speaker William G. Batchhelder-attended the American Legislative Exchange Council gathering last week at the Palmer House Hilton in Chicago.” ALEC provides “scholarships” for legislators to attend ALEC sponsored events. The Dispatch article cites a study by Common Cause and the Center for Media and Democracy that indicates Ohio legislators have walked away with $75,000 in ALEC “scholarships” to attend such events as receptions at professional baseball games, cigar parties and skeet shoots.
During annual ALEC meetings, corporate lobbyists and allied legislators get together to vet legislative proposals. One can bet the farm that the corporate lobbyists are not trying to convince legislators to focus their efforts on improving the public common school system.
Below is listing of some of Ohio’s state officials who are members of ALEC:
House of Representatives
- Rep. John P. Adams (R-78)[1], State Chairman[2][3] andTax and Fiscal Policy Task Force Member [4]
- Rep. Ron Amstutz (R-3),[3] Communications and Technology Task Force Alternate[5]
- Rep. Marlene Anielski (R-17), ALEC Education Task Force Member[6]
- Speaker William G. Batchelder (R-69), ALEC member[7]
- Rep. Peter A. Beck (R-67), ALEC Communications and Technology Task Force Member[8]
- Rep. Terry R. Boose (R-58), ALEC Tax and Fiscal Policy Task Force Member [9]
- Rep. George J. Buchy (R-77) [10]
- Rep. James Butler (R-37), ALEC Health and Human Services Task Force Member[11] and Communications and Technology Task Force Alternate[12]
- Rep. Timothy Derickson (R-53)[1]
- Rep. Anne Gonzales (R-19), ALEC Commerce, Insurance and Economic Development Task Force Member[13]
- Rep. Cheryl L. Grossman (R-23), ALEC Commerce, Insurance and Economic Development Task Force Alternate[14]
- Rep. Brian Hill (R-94), ALEC Member[15]
- Rep. Matt Huffman (R-4), ALEC Civil Justice Task Force Member[3]
- Rep. Ronald Maag (R-35), ALEC Tax and Fiscal Policy Task Force Member[3][16]
- Rep. Kristina D. Roegner (R-42), ALEC Education Task Force Member[17]
- Rep. Cliff Rosenberger (R-86), ALEC Communications and Technology Task Force Member[18]
- Rep. Barbara Sears (R-46)[1], ALEC Health and Human Services Task Force Member[19]
- Rep. Gerald L. Stebelton (R-5)[1], ALEC Education Task Force Member[20]
- Rep. Michael Stinziano (D-25), ALEC Communications and Technology Task Force Member[21]
- Rep. Louis Terhar (R-30), ALEC Member[22]
- Rep. Andrew M. Thompson (R-93), ALEC Commerce, Insurance and Economic Development Task Force Member[23]
- Rep. Lynn Wachtmann (R-75), ALEC Health and Human Services Task Force Member[3]
- Rep. Ron Young (R-63), ALEC Member
Senate
- Sen. David Burke (R-26), ALEC Health and Human Services Task Force Member[24]
- Sen. William P. Coley, II (R-4), ALEC Civil Justice Task Force Member [25]
- Sen. John Eklund (R-18)[26]
- Sen. Randy Gardner (R-6) [27]
- Sen. Kris Jordan (R-19), ALEC Energy, Environment and Agriculture Task Force Member[28]
- Sen. Frank LaRose (R-27), ALEC Public Safety and Elections Task Force Member [29]
- Sen. Bob Peterson (R-17), ALEC Member[30]
- Sen. William “Bill” Seitz (R-8), ALEC Civil Justice Task Force[31]Co-Chair, spoke on “Saving Dollars and Protecting Communities: State Successes in Corrections Policy” at the 2011 ALEC Annual Meeting[32]
- Sen. Joseph W. Uecker (R-14)[1], ALEC Commerce, Insurance and Economic Development Task Force Member[33]
Former Representatives
- Rep. Louis Blessing (R-29)[3] (replaced by his son, Louis W. Blessing, III, representative-elect)
- Rep. Danny Bubp (R-88)[1]
- Rep. John A. Carey, Jr. (R-87), ALEC Education Task Force Alternate[34]
- Speaker Jo Ann Davidson [35]
- Rep. Dale Van Dyke [35]
- Rep. Bruce Goodwin (R-74), ALEC Energy, Environment and Agriculture Task Force Member[36]
- Rep. Casey Kozlowski (R-99), ALEC Public Safety and Elections Task Force Member [29]
- Rep. Jarrod B. Martin (R-70), ALEC Public Safety and Elections Task Force Member[29][1][3]
- Former Rep. Robert Mecklenborg (R-30), ALEC Member
- Rep. Craig Newbold (R-1), ALEC Member[37]
- Rep. Pat Tiberi [35]
- Rep. Todd Snitchler (Chairman of the Public Utilities Commission of Ohio as of 2011)[1][3]
- Rep. Ronald Suster (D) currently Cuyahoga County Common Pleas Judge. [38]
- Rep. Tim Greenwood (R) currently outside counsel OH AG. [39]
Former Senators
One of the missions of ALEC is to replace the public common school system with private market-driven education thrift stores. Some Ohio legislators will press forward the concept of a voucher for every student. Read the next email from the E & A Coalition.
William Phillis
Ohio E & A |
I’ve posted this before but please watch, only 2:24. ALEC ROCK: how a bill becomes a law, ALEC style. Please share:
LikeLike
I watched it the last time you posted t and not only have I shared it on-line, I’ve pulled it up on my computer when someone is visiting and shown it to them myself!
LikeLike
I wish school reformers would address the advertising issue. This money is coming directly out the classroom. How do they defend this? Should taxpayer money that is slated for education go to media outlets and advertising firms?
Because guess what’s happened. Because charter schools inundate Ohio parents with ads, public schools are now forced to advertise. Toledo Public Schools has an ad up in my market.
Can education reformers explain how spending student money on advertising helps students? Wold they agree to a moratorium on charters spending ed money on advertising? Toledo Public Schools, like all public districts in Ohio, have had their budget gutted thanks to the lobbying efforts of StudentsFirst. They cannot afford to compete with charters in an advertising money race.
I’d also like to know how for-profit charters are getting student lists. I got a direct mail piece from a for-profit charter and my 5th grader attends a local public school. The charter is 70 miles away. I’m unlikely to enroll an 11 year in a school that is located 70 miles from his home, so this advertising blitz I’m paying for is a complete waste of public money.
LikeLike
One of the local news stations in Toledo had the toll-free phone number for K-12 online running on the news ticker. Unbelievable!
LikeLike
K-12 is particularly egregious. I would LOVE to know how much taxpayer cash they throw at media outlets.
USA Today (which is good on investigative reporting on reform scams, BTW, they broke the Michelle Rhee cheating story while our “elite” newspapers gullibly recited her claims with no due diligence) did a piece in 2011 on the money charters were spending on ads, but they didn’t break it down by charter.
I haven’t seen an analysis since then.
LikeLike
you voted Democratic Party, how have they helped? You need to follow right from wrong not along party lines. What did union money for Obama Campaign get us ?
No Help . If you know about Chicago politics, why vote him into office. Sleeping with the enemy. How Naive!
LikeLike
Socha sweetie, this post is about OHIO and its legislature. Not about Obama. Go back and reread it.
LikeLike
Socha, I share your frustration. I do though have to admit that it’s a quandary of stickiness. ALEC is primarily a GOP organization that has linked arms with big business. This spider’s web covers most of the US and seems to be driving the CCS train.
I agree with you that the “democratic party” as such has seemed to not provide much more help, but then with the frame work ALEC (and others) have in place perhaps Obama’s administration has accepted what it thinks is the inevitable and supports CCS and testing, spouting the same verbiage as the educational majority. Thus it looks like a “unified” front, similar to the partisan support for NCLB.
I’m not affiliated with any party, but as one who is more conservative than liberal in my thinking, I will be the first to admit that the GOP hasn’t helped matters in education for quite some time. That’s assuming that there was some help in some beginning of some GOP president’s administration.
GW Bush was instrumental with his “across the aisle” work with Ted Kennedy and staff in bringing about NCLB in a very partisan manner. Just as in the CCS debacle, NCLB was a process that ignored trench level educators. So it has taken since 2001 for NCLB to fail, actually it had a broken leg right out of the gate.
Behind both of these initiatives was the ALEC, among others.
I saw the pain and suffering of both educators and students with NCLB and its rigid requirements.
And, it’s not that I don’t agree in principle to having national standards. I agree with that whole heartedly, but if NCLB was a 16 ounce hammer, CCS is a 100 ton mallet.
ALEC claims to be an organization bent on Federalism but their “free market” mentality is the killer of public education. For instance, it has privatized much of what was the federal government work force, promising cost cutting with increased performance. Where does that money saved go? Back to the taxpayers? Nope; not a chance. It lines some corporate executive’s pocketbook.
What will replace CCS when it fails?
I can guarantee you that many GOP and other “conservatives” have been duped by the same politicians who are pulling at the ALEC strings.
Maybe I’ll just call myself a Libertarian but in any event Socha, both main political parties have rats wearing business suits and there doesn’t seem like there’s enough rat traps to go around. There are even Libertarians who are falling for the educational mush.
Hang in there though. We have to keep fighting this behemoth.
Jim
LikeLike
ALEC is disgusting. I was disappointed in how the Alabama state legislature (majority Republicans) passed the Alabama Accountability Act despite the fact that I teach in a Catholic School. Would it help if we voted in a majority of Independents?
LikeLike
Arne Duncan @arneduncan 17 Aug
KIPP is building strong relationships with higher ed – great model for other districts & charter networks to follow
Has anyone ever seen Arne Duncan promote a public school?
Anyone? ever?
Reading his tweets, one would think every public school in the country is failing. It’s pretty amazing that an entity called “The Department of Education” has abandoned the 95% of kids who attend public schools.
LikeLike
Tweet back and fill in the name of a local school.
LikeLike
He does nothing but promote propaganda for corporatized schools. It is sad. It is as if he has completely turned his back on our public schools.
LikeLike
Here’s a Stand For Children promotion Duncan linked on his twitter feed:
“Muñoz is well-informed about Common Core, learning about it as a volunteer with the advocacy group Stand for Children Arizona. She said that she was surprised when she went to meet-your-teacher night recently and more parents did not have questions about it, or about their role in helping kids learn at home.”
Still looking for where the Secretary of Education promotes a public school! Coming up empty!
LikeLike
I live in OH. under a bridge in the NE. I wear a tin foil hat when I collect tolls. Most of the
travelers seem to be stuck in the default option of the divided- the Left/Right Paradigm.
Pattern recognition, or connecting the dots, has disturbed the complacency formed by
believing we have a Representative Democracy. Yet,they still turn on each other, L /R,
and project a political/educational solution to an engineered problem.
As each layer of the onion is peeled, the stench grows stronger. For all it’s intent and
purpose, be it Government or Education, the U.S. Has The Worst Income Inequality In The Developed World.
•76% of Americans live paycheck to paycheck
–27% of American have no savings at all
–46% of Americans have less than $800 in savings
–The conversion of America into a part-time working society and the country’s second largest employer – a temp agency.
–The college trap and the student loan bubble
–And of course, foodstamps, foodstamps, foodstamps and the nearly 50 million poverty-level Americans who need them to survive.
Since the 1970s, the top 1 percent of earners in the U.S. has roughly doubled its share of the total American income pie to nearly 20 percent from about 10 percent.
“The historical trajectory from the mid 1970s to today places the instantiation of neo-liberal ideology into public perceptions several generations deep. And the build-out of totalitarian infrastructure—public-private lawmaking through ALEC (American Legislative Exchange Council), public-private policing, public-private incarceration (‘private’ prisons) and the public-private surveillance state has taken place gradually enough to be missed by those not looking very hard. And ironically, neo-liberalism has been better sold to the public by well known political liberal icons in Ivy League universities than by the conspicuous purveyors of right-wing ideology. Princeton University economist Paul Krugman is a self-described ‘free trader’ in the older ‘Washington Consensus’ incarnation of neo-liberalism. But his trade economics call for a top-down restructuring of the global economy that is fundamentally anti-democratic. And none other than economist John Maynard Keynes, of whom Mr. Krugman is an acolyte, identified the totalitarian tendencies of Western economics toward making policy prescriptions in profoundly anti-democratic ways. As an ideology reified in global economic architecture, neo-liberalism forces its view of both what it is human beings want—wealth as capitalist production, and how to get it—through reorganizing economic relations according to its dogma.”
ROB URIE
Public Schools effect on the trajectory of neo-liberal economics is evident-NIL.
LikeLike
ALEC Lobbying Group Accused of Masquerading as a Charity to Avoid Taxes
http://chasvoice.blogspot.com/2013/11/alec-lobbying-group-accused-of.html
LikeLike
Plutocracy is TREASON! Get me the Koch bros. neck-sizes. #TheAmericanGuillotine Listing #TheOnePercent #BernieOrBust #WhatIsALEC
LikeLike
xxxxxxx
LikeLike