For the past two years plus, Mayor Michael Bloomberg fought legal battles to try to avoid releasing a series of emails written about the time that he named publisher Cathie Black as chancellor of the New York City public schools.
The mayor finally lost in court, and the emails were released.
They are surprisingly banal.
There is no bombshell, no smoking gun. Just a frenzied PR campaign to figure out how to build the appearance of public support for a person who had no qualifications for the job.
Many emails were written to and from Gayle King, Oprah’s confidante, to persuade Oprah to endorse Black as the person best qualified to lead the nation’s largest school district. Oprah agreed, and the Chicago talk show host’s praise appeared on page one of Rupert Murdoch’s New York Post.
Black suggested that they enlist Ivanka Trump’s support, but a mayoral aide wisely shot that idea down.
Then it was on to Caroline Kennedy, with the assurance that she was a member of the DOE team and could be counted on.
The PR people decided to play the gender card. They drew up a long list of prominent women who would be asked to sign a statement endorsing Black. Gloria Steinem endorsed her, though of course Steinem had no connection to the New York City schools.
At one point, a City Hall advisor makes the telling comment that Joel Klein was a male prosecutor who had no educational experience, and Cathie Black was a female publisher with no educational experience. Implication: Rank sexism. (Maybe neither should have gotten a waiver from the State Commissioner since both were clearly unqualified and neither had the experience or education credentials that the law required.)
Then there was a flurry of emails about her donations to a charter school called Harlem Village Academy and her participation with the school leader in showing “Waiting for ‘Superman,'” an anti-public education film. That burnished her connection to education.
The most amazing part of the dossier is the cluelessness of the mayor’s team about who really counts in building credibility for someone chosen to be chancellor. They focused on high society and celebrity, but it never occurred to them to find educators or parents to support her candidacy. Of course, that might have been impossible because Cathie Black probably did not know any educators or public school parents.
PS: Black lasted three months. Then Bloomberg yanked her.

Hey, Let’s not forget she had 9 honorary degrees which are worth at least the paper they are written on. (Are they written on paper?)
LikeLike
This: ” They focused on high society and celebrity, but it never occurred to them to find educators or parents to support her candidacy. Of course, that might have been impossible because Cathie Black probably did not know any educators or public school parents.”
LikeLike
Yes, educators are toxic unreliable agents to the testing/privatizing crowd. Klein/Black and now Walcott have no schl backgrounds worthy of running NYC DOE which prefers hiring MBAs up and down its central office. Rejection of educators is the smoking gun–this entire school war is not about schooling, learning, teaching, knowledge-making, achievement, etc. The corporate crew are at war with pub schls to seize their assets, to demolish teacher unionism, to depress the wage package req’d for a labor-intensive service profession like teaching, to build a profitable private sector on ruins of pub sector. They turn away from educators at all levels b/c this is not about education; it’s a class war about enlarging the power and wealth of the private sector.
LikeLike
What a crock!! Even Whoopi endorsed her. And I have very little respect for Oprah after her Waiting for Superman shows with absolutely no real teachers or Diane of that panel. But real joy came when both the Post and News were calling for her to go. And anything that puts egg on the face of the mayor is a good thing.
I wonder if those are all the emails?
I do recall that many high-level DoE staff left after her appointment and are now making teachers in other cities and states suffer.
Just in case you missed this op ed piece….http://www.nytimes.com/2011/05/01/opinion/01eggers.html?_r=0
LikeLike
Even Caroline Kennedy…
LikeLike
What “smoking gun” had anyone imagined might be in these emails?
LikeLike
Well, his plot to destroy NYC teachers and the union, as well as close as many schools as possible.
I still love her line about birth control……She wasn’t bright enough to realize a meeting with parents wasn’t the same as cocktail conversation.
LikeLike
“Cathy, remember, not a word to Oprah about my plan to destroy teachers . . .”
LikeLike
LOL…..but I have a strong feeling you hit the nail on the head and he told her that. btw, everywhere she went, Walcott followed and was always whispering in her ear. In fact many of her press conferences were cut short to keep her mouth shut.
\btw, Gov. Cuomo is also paranoid when it comes to emails and phone calls. He has two sets of phones and only the public ones keeps records. He won’t allow anyone in his inner circle to speak to the press, and if they do, they are fired. And, he wants most meetings in person. How is this open government???
This celebrity endorsements have to had proved embarrassing, but you never hear apologies. Even the stars of Won’t Back Down couldn’t care less.
And now Rhee given an award to someone who proposed legislation to make it easy for Gay students to be bullied by teachers and students in school, and where is Oprah and the press now??? I would respect these people and Obama if they came out and made a statement against Rhee and her choices.
LikeLike
I’m from the community she told to use birth control. Now DOE representatives are telling us to stop bothering them and just send our kids to private school.
LikeLike
Wow. Yet another slap in the face of public education. When will it ever stop? I am so disillusioned and frustrated right now.
LikeLike
You do not need to know how to teach in 2013.
You need to have contacts in the TESTING HIERARCHY and
KNOW ONLY HOW TO READ THE SCORE ON A TEST..
THAT’S ALL!
LikeLike
Wasn’t Gayle King also prominently mentioned in the NJ school reform industry emails the ACLU had to sue to get?
Do the parents of public school kids in these cities know that celebrities are running their schools?
Also. Is there anyway we can pay off these wealthy dabblers and convince them to go “help” someone else? I don’t remember asking the millionaire community for help.
Thanks but no thanks!
LikeLike
Entertainers will read whatever script is put in front of them. They don’t know anything.
LikeLike
Have we tried FOILing emails about her departure too? I battle NYC DOE FOIL Director Joseph Baranello every week. I FOILed all emails pertaining to my warrantless and wrongful removal from my classroom. Waiting a year now. I guess going to court is the only way.
BTW, easy steps on my site on how to FOIL : http://wp.me/P31ecs-do
LikeLike
This information is more sickening than I imagined.
LikeLike
The fact that she was no more suited for the job, in terms of credentials and the law, than Klein speaks volumes (and volumes, and volumes…). He was with (against) us for a decade. And he is still acting as though he knows what’s best for education.
LikeLike
One could not make this stuff up. Sadly these people in DOE Still run the dog and pony show!
LikeLike
LOL!
Sorry. I thought at first that I read that “Joel Klein was a male PROSTITUTE who had no educational experience.”
Never mind. 😉
LikeLike
Not that readers of this blog needed proof, but the emails conclusively demonstrate how Oprah is nothing a shill for so-called education reform.
LikeLike
Caroline Kennedy is the one who surprised me. Why lend her name to this heinous privatization movement? Thank God she didn’t become a Senator, because um, you know, that would have been awful for what is left of public education in NY.
LikeLike
Caroline Kennedy worked closely with Klein and Bloomberg to raise hundreds of millions for their pet projects.
LikeLike
I always thought she raised money to help the public schools. Foolish me. Thank you so much for this blog. A few weeks ago, I was vaguely aware of school reform, but had no idea what it really meant or who was behind it.
LikeLike
Much of the money she raised was for the Leadership (now Broad) Principal’s Academy, Bloomberg rewarded her with his backing for NYS Senator. And let’s not forget that her uncle and Obama both endorsed NCLB.
LikeLike
This is wrong:
Oprah agreed, and the Chicago talk show host’s praise appeared on page one of Rupert Murdoch’s New York Post.
The New York Daily News ran a front-page story headlined, “O Backs Cathie”
LikeLike