A reader writes that Change.org continues to offer deceptive petitions to recruit members for StudentsFirst (petitions like “do you support great teachers?” “are you against bullying?”). Frankly, I don’t think any of the organization’s membership claims are meaningful because no one pays dues, and no one knows how many names were added by deceptive petitions on websites like Change.org. I am still a member of StudentsFirst, even though I never knowingly joined. How many hundreds of thousands of others are there listed as members who are in the same boat? I was a “member” for over a year and never knew it. I was informed by a spokesman for Change. org when I complained about the same deception described here:
| Diane, you’ve written a lot about how Michelle Rhee’s group StudentsFirst recruits most of their members from Change.org. Two months ago, on June 19th (acc. to HuffPo article about it) Change.org very publicly said they were dropping StudentsFirst as their client, and would stop recruiting new supporters for StudentsFirst. Now it turns out that they were lying hypocrites of the most cynical kind. In fact, for anyone like me who has been paying attention, it seems that Change.org (which is a for-profit company, by the way) has actually DRAMATICALLY INCREASED how many people they are signing up to be members of StudentsFirst. Back on June 19th, the number of Change.org “supporters” for StudentsFirst was listed here… http://www.change.org/groups/studentsfirst …as about 1,100,000 people. I remember thinking that was a lot of people already. But if you check that same page today, you will see that it has increased over the past two months to 1.6 million people. That’s an extra 500,000 people that Change.org has recruited for Michelle Rhee’s group in only two months. (And some of us have noticed how many times when we sign a Change.org petition we are “invited” to sign up for Michelle Rhee’s email list). So instead of dropping StudentsFirst, as they so publicly said they were doing, Change.org has actually “stepped on the gas” to accelerate their work for Michelle Rhee over the past two months and earn a ton more money from her. I looked into Change.org’s pricing and was told they charge their clients $1.50 for each person who signs up. So that means that those extra 500,000 “recruits” were worth $750,000 to Change.org, in payments from Michelle Rhee over the past two months. Where is the outrage? Change.org should be held accountable for lying to progressives like this. They don’t deserve support from any progressive organizations if they are going to lie like this in a baldface way. Notice that none of this is insider knowledge. It isn’t necessary. It’s all out in the open for anyone to see. Again: Where is the outrage? The news coverage? The boycotts of Change.org? Let them go work for Romney if that’s the kind of people they are. |

Here’s the link to issue a complaint with Change.org
http://helpdesk.change.org/anonymous_requests/new
There is an option to have your name taken off of a petition (Reason/English/I am a petition signer/remove my signature from a petition)
The problem is that Students First has posted 34 petitions, and the form asks that you post a link to the one you are complaining about. Maybe some people will know and can have their name removed. Others should write in to complain.
LikeLike
I am a “member” of StudentsFirst, and I have no idea which petition I signed in April 2011. I will never sign a petition on Change.org again
LikeLike
I used the link jshanker posted and asked that my name be taken off ALL petitions and that I would never sign a change.org petition again and I would tell every single human being I encounter to do the same.
Sorry for the run-on…PO’d!
LikeLike
Thanks Linda – I did the same thing.
LikeLike
I will never sign a Change.org petition again.
LikeLike
I told Students First to remove me from their “membership”, was asked to give my reasons, shared them, and never received any response. I now refuse to endorse anything from change.org!
LikeLike
So how many people @ $1.50/each would need to sign up via Change.org in order to bankrupt RheeFirst? Might be worth boosting her numbers with antagonists if it will cost her money. Just a wicked little thought.
LikeLike
I just received a response to my complaint about Students First (btw, I didn’t complain about receiving emails. This is clearly a cut-and-paste response.):
Your request (#139020) has been deemed solved. Tickets are marked solved if: 1) The question has been answered or the problem has been fixed. 2) Additional information is needed from you, the ticket requester. When this occurs, the ticket is automatically re-opened upon receipt of the information requested (or your subsequent reply). Please take care to read the contents of the reply to confirm whether we require additional information to appropriately address your inquiry. To review, comment and reopen the request, follow the link below: http://helpdesk.change.org/tickets/139020
Change.org, Aug 16 10:35 am (PDT):
Hi Jennie,
Thank you for contacting us. We are not immediately ending our relationship with Students First but rather concluding the contract per the terms of our agreement – that’s why you are still seeing sponsored petitions on the site. In the meantime, we are conducting an internal review of our client policy so we can determine whether groups like Students First might advertise on the site in the future.
Our business model is essentially advertising on a cost-per-acquisition basis. We allow organizations to sponsor petitions on the website; from there, it is up to Change.org members as to whether or not they want to sign the sponsored petitions and join an organization’s cause. If someone is receiving emails from Students First, it is because they both opted to sign the petition that is clearly sponsored by Students First and opted to receive additional information. Change.org does not manage their lists, but as is always the case, users are welcome to opt-out at any time.
Again, we appreciate you contacting us and I will be sure to pass on your feedback to our staff during this internal review.
Best,
Carol Scott
Community Manager, Change.org
LikeLike
I got the same exact response word for word…loved this part:
“petition that is clearly sponsored by Students First”….NO it is not.
I am done with them never to sign a change.org petition again!
LikeLike
New changes at Change.org
http://www.huffingtonpost.com/2012/10/22/changeorg-corporate-gop-campaigns-internal-documents_n_1987985.html
LikeLike