Investigative reporters David Sirota and Matthew Cunningham-Cook, writing in the International Business Times, detail Vice-President Joe Biden’s role in making it harder for college students to reduce their debts.
Jennifer Ryan did not love the idea of taking on debt, but she figured she was investing in her future. Eager to further her teaching career, she took out loans to gain certification and later pursued an advanced degree. But her studies came at a massive cost, leaving her confronting $192,000 in student loan debt.
“It’s overwhelming,” Ryan told International Business Times of her debts. “I can’t pay it back on the schedule the lenders have demanded.”
In the past, debtors in her position could have used bankruptcy court to shield them from some of their creditors. But a provision slipped into federal law in 2005 effectively bars most Americans from accessing bankruptcy protections for their private student loans.
In recent months, Democrats have touted legislation to roll back that law, as Americans now face more than $1.2 trillion in total outstanding debt from their government and private student loans. The bill is a crucial component of the party’s pro-middle-class economic message heading into 2016. Yet one of the lawmakers most responsible for limiting the legal options of Ryan and students like her is the man who some Democrats hope will be their party’s standard-bearer in 2016: Vice President Joe Biden.
As a senator from Delaware — a corporate tax haven where the financial industry is one of the state’s largest employers — Biden was one of the key proponents of the 2005 legislation that is now bearing down on students like Ryan. That bill effectively prevents the $150 billion worth of private student debt from being discharged, rescheduled or renegotiated as other debt can be in bankruptcy court.
Biden’s efforts in 2005 were no anomaly. Though the vice president has long portrayed himself as a champion of the struggling middle class — a man who famously commutes on Amtrak and mixes enthusiastically with blue-collar workers — the Delaware lawmaker has played a consistent and pivotal role in the financial industry’s four-decade campaign to make it harder for students to shield themselves and their families from creditors, according to an IBT review of bankruptcy legislation going back to the 1970s.
Biden’s political fortunes rose in tandem with the financial industry’s. At 29, he won the first of seven elections to the U.S. Senate, rising to chairman of the powerful Judiciary Committee, which vets bankruptcy legislation. On that committee, Biden helped lenders make it more difficult for Americans to reduce debt through bankruptcy — a trend that experts say encouraged banks to loan more freely with less fear that courts could erase their customers’ repayment obligations. At the same time, with more debtors barred from bankruptcy protections, the average American’s debt load went up by two-thirds over the last 40 years. Today, there is more than $10,000 of personal debt for every person in the country, as compared to roughly $6,000 in the early 1970s.
That increase — and its attendant interest payments — have generated huge profits for a financial industry that delivered more than $1.9 million of campaign contributions to Biden over his career, according to data compiled by the Center for Responsive Politics.
Student debt, which grew as Biden climbed the Senate ladder and helped lenders tighten bankruptcy laws, spiked from $24 billion issued annually in 1990-91 to $110 billion in 2012-13, according to data from the Pew Research Center.
According to the Institute for College Access and Success, as of 2012, roughly one-fifth of recent graduates’ student debt was from private loans that “are typically more costly” than government loans.
Consequently, every major Democratic presidential candidate has introduced his or her own plan to reduce college debt. Biden himself has spotlighted the issue as he has publicly pondered a White House bid. Earlier this month he attended an event to discuss student debt at community colleges, telling students at Miami-Dade College: “I doubt there were many of you who could sit down and write a check for $6,000 in tuition without worrying about it.” His comments amplified his rhetoric from the 2012 election, when he decried the fact that “two-thirds of all the students who attend college take out loans to pay for school.” He said that the accumulated debt means that when the typical student graduates, “you get a diploma and you get stapled to it a $25,000 bill.”
But advocates for stronger protections for debtors argue that Biden was a driving force in creating the laws that made the problem worse.
“Joe Biden bears a large amount of responsibility for passage of the bankruptcy bill,” Ed Boltz, president of the National Association of Consumer Bankruptcy Attorneys, said in an interview with IBT.
That legislation created a crisis, said Northeastern University law professor Daniel Austin. Federal Reserve data show that about 1.1 million people face student debt loans of $100,000 or more, and roughly 167,000 face student loans of $200,000 or more.

Diane, I am chagrined that you would post an article that largely presents, at best, circumstantial evidence to support the headlines’ assertion that Joe Biden has put the wood to college students who want to obtain workouts on private sector college debt. To wit … “Joe Biden bears a large amount of responsibility for passage of the bankruptcy bill,” Ed Boltz, president of the National Association of Consumer Bankruptcy Attorneys, said in an interview with IBT.” What is the basis for this assertion/conclusion? Joe lived in Delaware, the financial/banking industry is ‘big’ (present and politically influential) in Delaware … Really? To substantiate such a broadside against Joe Biden requires a little more than what you have provided or appears to be included in the Sirota article. Very unlike you to present such a weak case. Jack Polidori
LikeLike
Not my case. It is David Sirota, and I have always found him to be a solid investigative journalist.
LikeLike
Follow Biden’s voting record.
LikeLike
Diane, you posted it on your blog. Which, I guess, ‘judging’ by my preferred standard, doesn’t make it guilt by association either. 🙂
Sirota is a good reporter but Biden’s record — like that of any long-term elected official — can be disected ad infinitum and ad nauseum. Hope you are well. Jack
LikeLike
It’s difficult to count the reasons for refusing to support Biden.
In addition to his subservience to Finance, as former head of the Senate Judiciary Committee, we largely have him to thank for having Clarence Thomas on the Supreme Court, since Biden allowed scurrilous attacks against Anita Hill, and paved the way for Thomas’ approval by the Committee. He was also instrumental in the downfall of Lani Guinier. Perhaps he just has an aversion to strong, successful Black women.
We can also “thank” Biden for the emergence of the US as the world’s leqding incarcerator, via the Comprehensive Control Act – note the language here, with its focus on control rather than public safety – of 1986, which expanded civil forfeiture and with its infamously racist crack/powder cocaine sentencing disparities. Biden was also instrumental in passing the 1994 crime bill, which expanded jail construction, harshened sentencing and removed sentencing discretion from judges.
While Biden may have his fans in the media and around the Beltway, outside of his home state he has been consistently and forcefully rejected by voters, with both of his previous presidential campaigns ending with embarrassment.
Democratic presidential primary voters have in the past shown wisdom in rejecting this affable hack, but there’s absolutely no reason to support him now.
LikeLike
The Bush tort reform of 2005 not only mandated that education debt could not be stopped by declaring bankruptcy, but also medical debt which at that point was the main cause of bankruptcy and also followed the debtor for their lifetime.
Now student debt has taken first place, with medical debt right behind.
It is a comment on our nation that these two vital areas of life are so ill-treated, though with student loans by banking sharks being more avoidable. Uninformed students who attend private ‘colleges’ which are advertised as job producers, must be more careful and not be fooled by the duplicitous ‘puffery’ of unscrupulous ‘education’ entrepreneurs.
Health care is a different matter, and we would do far better with single payer universal health care for all, and getting the insurance industry and Big Pharma out of the mix entirely. We are the only Western industrial nation that has not done this…and it is all based on the Free Market lower depths that are foisted on us by the Wall Street profiteers.
LikeLike
How do you spell potato?
Q-U-A-Y-L-E
alternate spelling:
B-I-D-E-N
LikeLike
Good one.
LikeLike
The funniest thing about that is what the 12 year old student that he “corrected’ said: it “showed that the rumors about the vice president are true – that he’s an idiot.”
After that, I can never remember the proper spelling of potato. To this day, I have to look it up.
Dan Quayle ruined me for life.
I should probably sue him.
LikeLike
Middle class pronunciation – “shaft’-ed”.
LikeLike
I don’t find this surprising and it;s difficult to be disappointed cuz it’s so commonplace. i think it’s impossible to be elected w/o access to substantial money. and getting the money brings all politicians into relationships w/the wealthy. the money is never cost free. Absurd to think that. So, the norm is to take the $$ and make the best deal you can. Moreover, the more elections a pol has, the more times s/he needs the $$, and each new chunk must come w/new demands, further entangling the pol and the money people/the rich. Thus, when I read Hiliary is close to Eli Broad right after I read he’s engaged in one of the most anti-democratic schemes involving education I remember during my long life, I see her comments about teacher unions and charters just as i see Biden’s about student loans, as more than hypocrisy and reaching into the domain of lies, damned lies.
LikeLike
It sure is popular to let cynicism fly free right now. But there is a difference between a politician who takes donations from the wealthy, and one whose entire state economy is made up of the financial industry. How many of us have paid credit card bills and sent those pre-addressed envelopes to some place in Delaware? Those are the companies, whose executives and employees live and vote in Delaware, that have driven Biden’s lifetime of policy-making.
LikeLike
My son is drowning in debt as his credit ratings go lower and lower. He will never be able to take out a loan without paying exorbitant interest rates. How is this getting students ready for the real world…and he doesn’t have any where near the debt the woman in the 2 paragraph above does!
LikeLike
It’s been really nice to watch young voters flock to Bernie Sanders. I don’t think anyone would have predicted a 70-something Senator who has been around forever would end up filling giant rallies with young people.
Maybe they figured it out after the finance sector crash 🙂
LikeLike
But do not breathe easily yet, Chiara…please remember it was the young voters, 18 – 26, who pushed Obama into office. And look how it turned out. Yes, of all the candidates, Bernie is the one I am supporting, but I want to hear much more from him. The debate between Hllary and Bernie next Tuesday will hopefully clear some of the air on these issues.
LikeLike
Here’s the Biden piece where they talk to his younger voters. It’s really the most positive thing I’ve read in ages.
I hope they win 🙂
http://www.newyorker.com/magazine/2015/10/12/the-populist-prophet?intcid=mod-most-popular
LikeLike
SANDERS, sorry, not Biden.
LikeLike
Say it ain’t so, Joe! I’m glad to see America’s favorite sidekick beginning to face some serious scrutiny. Leave it to David Sirota to do the detective work.
If Biden decides to enter the fray–conveniently, after next week’s debate–all of this becomes a lot more relevant. He must be the first VP in US history to be as far down in polls as the frontrunner.
LikeLike
*vs the frontrunner.
LikeLike
What?? I can’t go to a $60K a year college and then disown on my debts once I graduate? What an abomination!!!!
P.S. How come discussions on student debt never mention the crazy tuition costs at Universities?
LikeLike
Here’s hoping people seeing Biden as a viable progressive alternative will think twice… and look harder at Bernie!
LikeLike