Commonweal editors mark the departure of Scott Walker from the 2016 field with relief.
“The departure of Gov. Scott Walker from the Republican race for president should come as a relief to American working people. His campaign against public-employee unions in his home state of Wisconsin, underwritten by billionaire businessmen Charles and David Koch, proved devastatingly effective, and his goal was to take it nationwide. Not that he was the only Republican candidate to take aim at what is, by general agreement, a fading target—organized labor as both a political force and an advocate for workers is perhaps weaker now than it’s ever been. But Walker, even more than fellow Republican Chris Christie, had been especially vocal in demonizing unions. That put him at odds with many of his fellow citizens: Support for unions has been rising since 2008, according to an August Gallup survey, with 58 percent of Americans—and 42 percent of Republican voters—now viewing them favorably.
“A plan Walker issued days before stepping down, costumed in the rhetoric of freedom, flexibility, and expanded opportunity, was essentially a proposal for finishing off organized labor once and for all. Its title was “Power to the People, Not the Union Bosses,” as if Walter Reuther and Albert Shanker still strode the land, legions of auto-workers and schoolteachers massed behind them. Empowering people, in Walker’s view, would mean abolishing the National Labor Relations Board, rewriting federal law to make Right to Work “the default position for all private, state, and public-sector workers,” replacing overtime pay with unpaid time off, and stripping employees of their ability to bargain collectively. The plan appears to have died with Walker’s candidacy. But its spirit is very much alive among many in the GOP—those who recall Ronald Reagan’s decision in 1981 to fire eleven thousand employees in the air-traffic controllers union the way some remember, say, the establishment of Social Security. That they speak so cynically about labor is not surprising. That Democrats seem to speak so little of it is not reassuring.
“According to the Economic Policy Institute, since the beginning of the “Reagan Revolution” in 1980, American workers have seen their hourly wages stagnate or decline, while real gross domestic product has grown by nearly 150 percent and net productivity by 64 percent in this period. More and more of the jobs Americans hold today come without reliable, living wages or benefits like health insurance, retirement plans, training, and job security. Measures like Walker’s aren’t meant to improve things, but rather accelerate what began some time ago. The decoupling of wages and benefits from productivity has been evident over the past two decades, according to the EPI, a period that has “coincided with the passage of many policies that explicitly aimed to erode the bargaining power of low- and moderate-wage workers in the labor market.”
I seem to remember that the labor movement and the formations of unions was a violent proposition during the late nineteenth to early twentieth century. I hear even from my fellow union members that the unions are no longer needed or that the unions demanded too much. I do not believe either statement. The union brings balance between workers and owners. I fear that the loss of labor laws and unions will bring us back to this time of violence. We seem to have forgotten that many workers were in fact quasi slave labor. Workers were paid such low wages that they couldn’t change jobs because of debt owed to the company.
One of the biggest failures of teachers has been disregarding this part of American history in their classrooms.
Our foes have framed the argument so that whatever we do we are either selfish, think a reasonable wage, incompetent, think wanting more resources or lower class sizes, or violent/thuggish, think picketing or striking. We have to overcome this portrayal before we can advocate with enough force. Seattle thugs, I mean teachers negotiated elementary recess!
The idea that “it’s all about the kids” is a pernicious argument too. Of course it is about the kids, it is what we do. BUT, abusing the adults who are entrusted with caring for the children is not justifiable, reasonable, ethical or effective. Children are people and so are the adults. Both deserve respect and dignity in the school workplace. Unionize for the benefit of both and done be afraid to be a fierce advocate.
Unionized workers account for 7-9% of all employees in our country. Scott Walker’s stance always made me wonder why, in a governorship, you wouldn’t focus on addressing problems and improving conditions for the other 90% of the population. It also makes me think that his goal was to undermine a particular occupation and believe it to be teachers. Though the educator work force is relatively small, it is a massive industry that has billions of dollars flow through its hands. It is all about big business overtaking education and technology and testing erasing pedagogy.