Bill Ruthhart, a reporter for the Chicago Tribune, reviewed hundreds of emails about CNN’s “Chicagoland” and discovered that the “documentary” was an infomercial for controversial Mayor Rahm Emanuel. CNN honored him at the very time that he took the historically unprecedented step of closing 50 public schools. CNN has no shame.
He writes:
“If it seemed as though some scenes of CNN’s documentary series “Chicagoland” were coordinated by Mayor Rahm Emanuel’s City Hall and the show’s producers, that’s because they were.
“More than 700 emails reviewed by the Tribune reveal that the production team worked hand in hand with the mayor’s advisers to develop storylines, arrange specific camera shots and review news releases officially announcing the show.
“Producers asked the mayor’s office to help them set up key interactions in what the cable network has billed as a nonscripted eight-part series, including Emanuel’s visits with the school principal who emerged as a star of the show, emails show.
“City Hall’s frequent correspondence with the producers illustrates how senior aides to a mayor known for shaping his media image managed how their boss would be portrayed on CNN to a prime time national audience.
“The production team for the series, whose final episode aired Thursday night, told Emanuel’s staff that particular scenes would present the mayor in a positive light, with one of the producers expressing a desire to showcase the mayor “as the star that he really is.”
“Creator and executive producer Marc Levin made a pitch to the mayor’s office last May as Emanuel’s hand-picked school board was two days away from a vote to close nearly 50 schools.”

Words fail. How can CNN justify doing such a hagiography on a current sitting mayor who clearly has presidential aspirations and then even pretend to be objective? Why should anything aired on CNN be taken as the least bit creditable? By any one of any political persuasion?
Sadly, the faux “liberals” who have been in Obama’s back pocket all along will fall all over themselves to defend this.
LikeLike
You are right! This is totally obscene.
LikeLike
Dienne & Yvonne Siu-Runyan & other commenters below: it is painful to admit that I am not at all surprised at the fawning treatment of Rahm Emanuel by the MSM.
While I give him some credit for later regretting his role in the deification of an “education reform” star, I still remember John Merrow’s love letters to Michelle Rhee.
Be prepared for worse. In a PBS story a few nights ago, Eva Moskowitz, with heartfelt passion and trembling voice, cast herself and her “most precious assets” [Michelle Rhee] as the hapless victims of a cruel mayor and politicians—this when she is attempting to evict 102 special ed students from P.S. 149 so she can expand her charter school there.
“Have they no shame?????” [Dee Dee]
None. Absolutely, positively, none at all.
😎
LikeLike
I thought something was totally strange about it which is why I had brought it to your attention. I only watched a minute and the part I saw had kids talking about having to cross gang lines to get to school. How could they have thought that would put a positive spin on Chicago’s mess?
LikeLike
They were specifically set up to whitewash the school closings, and insulate him from criticism. Here’s a direct quote about the safety of children due to his school closings:
“”This is a real opportunity to highlight the Mayors leadership – his ability to balance the need for reform and fiscal reality with compassion for affected communities and concern for the safety of Chicago’s school children,” Levin wrote of the school closings to Emanuel senior adviser David Spielfogel and two press aides. “We need the mayor on the phone in his SUV, in city hall with key advisers and his kitchen cabinet and meeting with CPS head BBB (Barbara Byrd-Bennett) and with CPD (Superintendent Garry) McCarthy.”
LikeLike
Ugh. I need to wash my eyeballs after reading that.
LikeLike
Why should we be surprised? Propaganda has usurped valid news over and over again. Our Constitution gave special attention to the importance of the media. A democracy cannot exist without valid news reporting. Only an informed public can make a democracy work. Our forefathers knew this. If I were that cynical, I might say that there are those now who know this too and thus are using the media for their own ends and now that they control the media and its “education” wish to “educate” our children to their own strictured ends. Fascism takes on many forms, whether governmental or in a plutocracy.
LikeLike
Boy, oh boy that’s for sure. I had set my DVR thinking it might be worthwhile but ended up deleting the recordings because is was so clearly propaganda. Shame on Sundance Films and shame on executive producer Robert Redford.
LikeLike
I am working on a doctoral research project inspired by Diane’s book, Death and Life of the Great American School System (2011). If the public school system–as many of us knew it, at least–is dead or near death, it would stand to reason that public school teachers who remember the system as it was prior to No Child Left Behind (2002) have experienced loss and grief. If you remember what it was like to teach prior to No Child Left Behind, if you feel as if teaching completely changed when No Child Left Behind was implemented, or if you ever felt saddened by some of the changes that resulted from educational reform, then you may be interested in taking my survey.
Professional Loss and Grief in Teachers (a survey)
https://ndstate.co1.qualtrics.com/SE/?SID=SV_5nCLnPAFadWZX93
LikeLike
Jackie, I have tried to take the survey and have typed a lot in the comment boxes. When I pressed next, the text in the second box kept disappearing and it said I cannot use the back button. But I was not pressing the back button. I was pressing next.
Is there a glitch?
LikeLike
Can crony capitalism and a corrupt media destroy public education? Or, can we the people save Chicago’s public schools with our democracy and our free press? Welcome, Chicago Tribune and Bill Ruthhart.
This story has racked up 746 tweets since it went up at 10AM. We’re the conscience of the whole democratic project at this time, blogging and tweeting and reporting CNN’s massive betrayal of truth and trust.
LikeLike
There must be a department of professional ethics or ombudsman at CNN to receive complaints about this puff piece.
LikeLike
There doesn’t seem to be an ombudsman any more (anywhere). I can’t find a reference to one since 2009.
I’ve been tweeting @TeamCNN but it doesn’t seem likely they’ll respond. I also tweeted the video story at them, also. It is even more explicit that Rahm’s school agenda was the target of the project, and notes that the Chicago Public Schools office has ignored his public records requests.
The next level of the investigation ought to be, who’s behind this?
LikeLike
Can anyone contact Robert Redford? How involved was he in this project?
LikeLike
Diane, complain to Robert Redford, who was executive producer.
Redford is a classic American liberal who is shrouded in limousine liberalism. . . . If he cared as much about public schools as he does the environment, we’d have him saying the right things.
Instead, he had become a bubbled-in excusionist for Rahm Emanuel. . . . . .
Redford should stick to acting and get out of politics. Mr. Blond Boy has no real connections to every day people. His former co-star, Jane Fonda, understands labor politics better . . . . . .
LikeLike
I didn’t watch it, because it was clear from the previews that this wasn’t news reportage, but part of what journalist Ron Rosenbaum has perspicaciously termed “the publicity-industrial complex.” Yeesh to this….
LikeLike
This is what happens when the oligarchs own everything, including the press. A small number of people now own the entire networks and the public airwaves have now been bought out from under us. The first amendment has now been corrupted and sold to the highest bidder. We are now experiencing the modern version technologically advanced circuses that masked the decay of Rome, and now masks our decay. Our values seem to have evaporated.
LikeLike
I was surprised that the Chicago Tribune published such an uncomplimentary piece. Usually, they are the ones with the unabashedly biased reporting.
LikeLike
“This is a real opportunity to highlight the Mayors leadership – his ability to balance the need for reform and fiscal reality with compassion for affected communities and concern for the safety of Chicago’s school children,” Levin wrote of the school closings to Emanuel senior adviser David Spielfogel and two press aides. “We need the mayor on the phone in his SUV, in city hall with key advisers and his kitchen cabinet and meeting with CPS head BBB (Barbara Byrd-Bennett) and with CPD (Superintendent Garry) McCarthy.”
So this is like coordinated ed reform propaganda?
If it were really that wonderful, CNN and Emanuel wouldn’t have to sell it so hard.
Did they time it to go with the mass public school closings? Absolutely bizarre.
LikeLike
One really wonders what will be the tipping point, what will act to make most people believe this is ALL BS and spin, and it doesn’t matter if it’s a campaign or a news entity.
The sense of excitement and glee in the emails over the “historic” school closings is absolutely repellent. Contrast the tone of the emails with what we all saw; the huge protest marches, people genuinely mourning over the closure of those schools and you really feel sick to your stomach.
“Out of touch” doesn’t do it justice. They’re in a whole other universe.
LikeLike
Considering Rahm’s brother, Ari, is the CEO of William Morris, we should expect nothing less than Hollywood hype and spin about him in this oligarchy, regardless of the medium,
LikeLike
Reblogged this on 21st Century Theater.
LikeLike
“While 53 schools were on the chopping block, the documentary crew ended up following two that were saved. Asked how that happened, Levin said he and fellow producers have asked themselves the same question.
“I don’t know the answer to that,” Levin said. “But we did go, ‘Wow. That is unusual.'”
Emanuel’s office declined to discuss the issue.”
So did CNN get played? Emanuel’s office led them around by the nose to the two schools that remained open and CNN didn’t notice? Or, did CNN make a decision to be led by the nose in return for access? I guess we will never know 🙂
LikeLike
“I don’t know the answer to that,” Levin said. “But we did go, ‘Wow. That is unusual.’”
Even I am not that naive and I can be pretty clueless.
LikeLike
How many of you are teachers at Fenger? How on earth can you call it fake if you are not there. I think the school your children attend and your role in connection to CPS should be a prerequisite for responding to something like this.
I teach at a school very similar to Fenger and I found Chicagoland to be pretty representative of my day to day experience.
LikeLike
Nonsense. This was broadcast nationally as news, by CNN. The emails clearly show producers had an agenda to support Rahm’s closing of 50 public schools. So, who are you to claim people who don’t “teach at a school very similar to Fenger” are not allowed to respond? You sound more like another piece of manufactured media than you do like any real teacher I know anywhere.
Sorry, but this is everybody’s business.
LikeLike
I’m not surprised. I couldn’t watch the whole thing because it seemed like propaganda to me. How the heck did Robert Redford get involved in it? I guess he’s an actor whose work I will boycott from now on.
LikeLike
I watched most of it, and did not see Emanuel in a positive light at all. They show him as very likable, but ambivalent to the concerns of the population affected by the closing of the schools. It is factual – it leaves it up to the observer to come to a conclusion. It is not the show’s fault that Emanuel places himself into positive situations. It is clear that the issue of violence and education are not being corrected. It is pointed out that funds are being reduced negatively affecting schools still open. I think you have to think about what is presented – you have to think about what you see.
LikeLike
Did you read the emails? Rahm placed himself in staged “meetings”, as he was instructed by the directors.
LikeLike
Let’s not forget that the directors of this informerical for Rahm are Marc Levin and Mark Benjamin being clients of the mayor’s brother, Hollywood super-agent Ari Emanuel.
Rahm cannot help but insult us. There is a scene where he is speaking to a group of outstanding students and reminds them of the importance of civic engagement and suggests that when they are ready they run for school board. He neglected to tell them that he selects their school board and that the members are not democratically elected. Really, has he no shame.
LikeLike
Bizarre. I chose not to watch the show because it looked like a propaganda show from the get go.
LikeLike
One of the insidious things happening now is that online news outlets depend increasingly on news aggregators to deliver lots and lots of copy at very low prices. The aggregators get the copy for free from public relations firms that have taken to embedding their messages into “news” stories.
LikeLike
Isn’t this a premise for “Anchorman II?” I haven’t seen the whole movie, but what I gleaned from the trailer was Ron Burgundy questioning why he has to give people news, & why not tell them what they want to hear (or make it up)? This is comedy, and at an exaggerated level–surely it’s not really happening?
But–sadly–it is. I have stopped watching Nightline (which used to be an excellent news program), 20/20 (it’s just been ridiculous–more like a spin-off of What Would You Do?) and Dateline (which is now always 48 Hours). I’m just about done with 60 minutes, as well. Pure pablum–all of it.
LikeLike
The news aggregation services sell stories in bulk at extraordinarily low prices, and many are run without editing and are, in fact, news stories written by PR firms with their clients’ particular gospel woven seamlessly into the story.
This works because people assume that news is accurate in a way that advertisements commonly aren’t.
LikeLike
A rather dated documentary called “Toxic Sludge is Good for You” chronicles news aggregation services and the stories they create. Former students still talk about it. Too few people know about “canned” news. Of course, too few watch or read news at all.
LikeLike
I saw the episode about the destruction of the school system. There was some indication that the people were upset, particularly when a young boy pleading to keep the school open was told to be quiet during a city meeting. There was also a part when Rahm promised to fix a problem a teacher wanted, said he would, then did the opposite the next day.
The main problem with the film was that it used stilted network news framework. There must be two sides to the story, but instead of investigating, they just used sound bytes and rahm’s PR machine. The kids/teachers had some recorded speeches at city meetings. One without any info on the situation would think that rahm was cutting budgets and people were angry, not that the whole system was being destroyed for graft.
LikeLike
I have watched the documentary and not sure the Mayor’s staging worked too well. He comes off as clueless—I would add that other players in the documentary, the high school principal, make you feel that at the end of the day, it is always people in the trenches who make things happen.
LikeLike
I think the show was commissioned to burnish the Corporate Education image, and not Cuomo at all. If you look at the script they presented to Cuomo, that was the focus all along.
Media ownership by the privatizers is a big issue, starting with Murdoch at Fox and the WSJ, but it doesn’t stop there.
LikeLike
I am originally from Chicago and I watched this show and then stopped because I felt that the take on Rahm seem to good to be true. Many in my home town know what sort of Mayor he is and what he is not. He has added a new way to further segregate Chicago on the lives of countless children.Yet knowing now that this was a sham only goes to show how CNN as a news outlet joins the ranks of the likes of Fox. What a huge disappointment.
LikeLike
THEY, CNN, don’t realise, it seems, that the world is changing, that ordinary humans are no longer sweepingly lay people, that it’s mostly the very elderly now that still believe in the integrity of the system (I am not going to burst my old mother’s bubble). They don’t seem to realise that we see through them totally and that we walk away feeling repulsed for their soullessness. They overact, over-talk – so much noise with zero content. SO afraid to have a proper opinion. But of course, the first one who does, will be fired summarily and they don’t realise that we see this too and it only exacerbates their irrelevance. They absolutely adore this story of the Sterling fellow – because now they have what is in their minds, an evil person, to legally expound upon. And so forth…
LikeLike