Jersey Jazzman reports that New Jersey will not approve the state’s first online for-profit virtual charter school. K12 has been told to come back next year, perhaps on the hope that citizen outrage will have died down by then. Jersey Jazzman, you may recall, memorably referred to New Jersey as “the cesspool of school reform.”
This is two wins in a row against the K12 giant, first in North Carolina, where the school boards banded together to stop the raid on their own strained budgets, and now in New Jersey, where concerned parents and educators blew the whistle.
It’s important to remind everyone that the reformers are vulnerable. They are vulnerable to public exposure because the fact is that their harmful ideas have no public support once the public understands what they are up to. There is no public support for handing taxpayer dollars over to corporate interests and calling it “reform.”
The public loves its community schools and doesn’t want to see them impoverished by corporate raiders.
So, yes, learn from New Jersey. Learn from the parents of Florida, who stopped the fake “parent trigger” legislation. Learn from the school boards of North Carolina.
You are not alone. Work in coalition with others to understand the theft of public education that is underway. You can make a difference.

The public does, indeed, love its public, community schools. In NY, luckily, consolidations of districts must be approved by voters. The consolidations almost always go down in flames (and votes). I wish we could have put our participation in disgRace to the Top up for a public referendum — it may have staved off the mess in which we now find ourselves.
LikeLike
Thank You for your constant support and encouragement. For those of us fighting, we are in debt to your willingness to turn your life over to this fight. We could not do it without you. We acknowledge a bit of a victory in New Jersey, but we realize the fight is far from over – the 2 pure virtual schools have been granted ‘planning years’ so we must keep up the pressure, make the legislative changes needed and fight for our children and schools. But yes, these victories do demonstrate the potential we have to change the tides of corporate reform and we will keep fighting.
LikeLike
Wonderful news. Good for New Jersey citizens!
LikeLike
Thanks so much for the good news, Diane. I was wondering when the tide would begin to turn on the issue of “virtual schools.” there are two issues for me: first is the matter of siphoning public funding to private interests, the second is a matter of definition… To me, learning should be grounded in real communities. I’m an advocate of online learning for lots of reasons, but draw the line on one point… deep learning is socially constructed, and the sense-making that is so much a part of deep learning should be grounded in the communities where students live.
LikeLike
These online charters have two obnoxious points: 1. They are for-profit, which is wrong. It’s one thing to pay a profit to a vendor, but something else when the school itself siphons off money to pay investors. 2. There is no community, no social skills, just a child alone in front of a computer, interacting with a person online.
LikeLike
Thanks Diane, and thanks for all your help in highlighting the story. I’d only add that this is far from over: K12 did get approval for two “blended” charters, brick-and-mortar schools that use an on-line curriculum. These schools, however, can’t draw from all over the state like the fully on-line version. If these are the “call-center schools” we’ve heard so much about, we’re going to have to keep a close eye on them.
To be clear – and I’ve said this at my blog – there may indeed be a place for fully on-line instruction. I have grave doubts about spreading it widely, but I do think it could help kids with severe illnesses, or in special circumstances.
But charters with little oversight, little accountability, and no local control? No way.
LikeLike
Thanks so much for the good news – gives us hope to keep fighting the fight against privatization and cyber charters! All the billboards and commercials in LA sometimes remind me of my late father – he used to make fun of the “matchbook schools”. If you are old like me, you remember these ads on matchbooks and in comic books telling us we could be an artist, or a secretary, or an electrician. Wonder if those are still around, but now instead of matchbooks they’re online?
LikeLike
Hello Diane,
We still have a virtual charter “Spirit Charter School” in Newark, NJ (Not sure if it is for profit). It is a high school being offered to our students.
LikeLike
Great news about New Jersey! Indiana has some good news, too. The mayor has decided to close one of his sponsored charter schools. For those of us who believe the corporate/education reforms are dysfunctional,this is certainly encouraging.
http://www.indystar.com/article/20120717/NEWS04/120717024/Mayor-Greg-Ballard-intends-revoke-Project-School-s-charter?odyssey=tab|topnews|text|IndyStar.com
LikeLike