Thom Hartmann is a veteran journalist who write The Hartmann Report, where this article appeared:
Dear MAGA voter,
I’m not writing this to mock you. I’m writing because you were lied to. And it wasn’t by the people you were told to hate, but by the man you trusted the most.
You were pissed off when you voted in 2024. Honestly, rightfully angry. Your town lost its factory. Your kids can’t afford the house they’ve been dreaming of for years. The politicians in Washington kept promising you things and delivering nothing; in fact, Republicans even took away your Medicaid and food stamps as well as your kids’ school lunches. You wanted someone who’d finally blow the whole damn thing up and put regular people first.
So did I and millions of other Americans. The difference is who we trusted to do it. Let’s talk about what actually happened.
You were told Trump would “drain the swamp” of corruption in Washington DC. Instead, as Marjorie Taylor Greene can tell you, Donald Trump has built the most corrupt, billionaire-stuffed cabinet (13 of them!) in American history. Epstein-buddy Howard Lutnick. Billionaire hustler Scott Bessent. Hedge fund managers and Wall Street insiders as far as the eye can see.
And then he handed the core agencies of the federal government — with no vote, no vetting, no accountability to anyone — over to Elon Musk, the single richest human being on the planet. Not a populist or a Washington outsider: the most powerful oligarch alive, whose source of wealth came from Obama bailing out Tesla and who now gets tens of billions in annual government contracts.
Musk’s teenage hackers then stole your Social Security information and destroyed America’s soft power by gutting USAID: as Bill Gates said, “The picture of the world’s richest man killing the world’s poorest children is not a pretty one.” This is your swamp now, one that’s already literally killed at least a million children around the world while handing our nation’s soft power over to Putin.
He also said there would be no more “stupid wars.” Yet he’s spending $1 billion a day and has already destroyed six American lives in Iran and still can’t explain to us why he attacked them or what actual threat that country represented to America. It appears he just did it because Putin, Netanyahu, and Kushner all encouraged him to.
And now The Washington Post is reporting that Putin is giving Iran “targeting information” so they can kill American troops, just like when Putin put a bounty on US soldiers in Afghanistan and that was fine with Trump during his first term. Is that the kind of war you want? Somehow I doubt it.
You were also promised lower drug prices. Remember that? Trump made it a centerpiece of his campaign pitch. He looked straight into the camera and said he’d take on Big Pharma. But the pharmaceutical industry is making more money than ever before, and now the same Republican Congress that cheers Trump’s every move has cut a trillion dollars out of Medicaid (the cuts come later this year).
That’s the national healthcare program that covers roughly one in five Americans, the majority of them in rural, working-class communities that voted for the same Republicans who gutted it on Trump’s orders. Your neighbors. Your family members. People who believed in him. Cuts made simply to pay for a trillion dollars of Trump’s $5 trillion tax break for himself, Mark Zuckerberg, Elon Musk, Jeff Bezos, Larry Ellison, and the other billionaires who put him into office.
And then there’s the tariffs, which he told you China would pay. But China isn’t paying: you are. Tariffs are taxes collected at the border and paid by American importers, that are then passed on to American consumers like you and me.
The people most exposed to rising prices on clothes, appliances, groceries, and cars are working-class families who spend a higher share of their income on the necessities of life. That’s you. The billionaires in his cabinet can absorb and even profit from Trump’s inflation; you can’t.
And while all this is happening, the national debt keeps exploding. It ballooned by $7 trillion during his first term. His second-term tax proposals are deficit-financed giveaways that only benefit corporations and the ultra-wealthy.
Trump talks about “no taxes on tips” and “no taxes on Social Security” but those cuts are very, very limited and expire in a few years; the tax breaks on billionaires are deep and last forever. Your grandchildren will spend their lives paying off Trump’s tax cuts for people who summer in the Hamptons. This isn’t fiscal conservatism: it’s looting dressed up in a red hat.
Remember the wall? Mexico was going to pay for it. Mexico didn’t pay for a single inch of it. And remember when Elon Musk publicly defended keeping H-1B visas, the program Trump uses to import European workers for his shabby golf motels and that let corporations import cheaper foreign labor and hold down American wages? That caused a genuine civil war inside MAGA world for about a week, before the Murdoch/Ellison Epstein-class billionaire media moguls changed the subject. Trump sided with the billionaires; being one himself, he always sides with the billionaires.
Don’t forget Social Security and Medicare. He swore — repeatedly, explicitly — that he’d never cut them. Watch what the fine print says, particularly since he fired over 7,000 Social Security workers to make it really hard on people who are trying to sign up. That’s about encouraging people to move to the Medicare Advantage scam plans that are so profitable to his insurance industry donors.
Watch what DOGE is circling. Watch the budget proposals coming out of his own party’s Congress. The cuts aren’t coming for the people at Mar-a-Lago: they’re coming for you.
And perhaps the cruelest irony of all: the communities hit hardest by Trump’s policies are the communities that supported him most. Farmers crushed by retaliatory tariffs from trading partners. Rural hospitals dependent on federal funding now facing existential pressure. FEMA cuts hurting people in bright red Southern states. The economic pain is landing heaviest on the people who believed in him the most.
None of this is an accident. This is what happens when you elect a pathological liar who talks like a populist but governs for the donor class. Your anger was real. His betrayal is real.
I’m not asking you to become a Democrat. I’m not asking you to agree with me about anything except this: a man who fills his cabinet with hedge fund managers, hands power to the world’s richest oligarch, lets Big Pharma walk, starts a war to distract us from news he raped 13-year-old girls, and watches your grocery bill climb while calling it “victory” is not on your side.
He never was.
The swampy system you were furious at? It’s still there. It just has a new Dear Leader.
You deserve better than this. Heck, we all deserve better than this.

MOST MAGA MINIONS DON’T CARE about anything other than deporting all the non-White people possible, and terrorizing non-White citizens the way they were terrorized during the “good ol’ Jim Crow days” to “keep them in their place”.
The foundation factor of MAGA is racial hatred, and so long as Trump and his ICE goons keep doing what they’ve been doing, the MAGA Minions will remain faithful, even though they express their dislike for high gasoline prices and increasing inflation in general.
The battle over the decisive midterm elections is only just beginning — and it’s going to get brutal. The SAVE America Voting Act MUST NOT PASS. Let’s hope that ol’ Chuck Schumer is up to the task of preventing it from passing. Let’s hope.
Also: Most MAGA Minions think that the SAVE Act is only going to block non-Whites from voting but isn’t going to affect them — so, it would help if every one of us made it a point to inform the MAGA people they know, and to post on MAGA media, that the SAVE Act is very much going to impact them. Most MAGA Minions think that they will still be able to vote if they have a Real ID driver’s license and a utility bill to confirm their address — but the SAVE Act states that a Real ID driver’s license won’t be accepted unless its an “enhanced” Real ID that states right on the face of the license that the person on the license is a U.S. citizen.
Only 5 states issue enhanced Real ID driver’s licenses: Michigan, Minnesota, New York, Vermont and Washington. One more state, Idaho, in 2023 began offering IDs with an optional citizenship marker, although it’s unclear whether all are Real ID compliant.
Only 14% of the nation’s population lives in those states, so 86% of Americans don’t have an enhanced Real ID and cannot use their Real ID as proof of citizenship for voting under the SAVE Act. MAGA people need to be told that and told that they had better contact their U.S. Senator and tell them to hold up on the SAVE Act.
MAGA minions also think that they can present their birth certificate as proof of citizenship — they need to know that they can’t use the birth certificate that most Americans have, which is the birth certificate that was given to their parents by the hospital when they were born.
Under the SAVE Act, the only birth certificate they can use is one that has been issued by the state in which they were born and bears the state’s official seal.
If they don’t have that, they have to contact the state in which they were born, request a certified copy of their birth certificate, and pay a fee to the state.
If MAGA Minions everywhere are informed of these and other SAVE Act requirements, a great many are going to be shocked…and they should be urged to phone, text, or email their federal Senator IMMEDIATELY to tell them that the SAVE Act must not be passed.
LikeLike
I read a recent column by Jamelle Bouie that was highly critical of the SAVE Act, whose purpose is to suppress Black votes and help Republicans. But he also pointed out that it might cut both ways and disqualify even more Trump voters. I’ll find the link.
LikeLike