Mother Jones published an excellent article by Reverend Rob Schenck about how he became a leader of the Christian nationalist movement and why he decided to leave it. He recalls when real estate developer and playboy Donald Trump was first introduced to the world of evangelicals. And he describes his own role in connecting rich donors to Republican Supreme Court justices.
Reverend Schenck begins:
In 2014, at an elegant gala inside the Supreme Court’s gilded Great Hall, a tuxedoed Justice Clarence Thomas turned to me and voiced his approval for my work. I glanced over to where Chief Justice John Roberts and his wife, Jane, were entertaining two of my associates, trustees of the Supreme Court Historical Society, a private, nongovernmental entity for which Roberts served as honorary chair. At that moment, I knew the secretive operation I had run, aimed at emboldening Thomas and his conservative colleagues to render the strongest possible decisions in favor of our right-wing Christian agenda, had succeeded.
My organization, Faith and Action in the Nation’s Capital, had created an initiative we called “Operation Higher Court” that trained wealthy couples as “stealth missionaries,” befriending Thomas and his wife, Ginni; Samuel and Martha-Ann Alito; and Antonin and Maureen Scalia—lavishing them with meals at high-end restaurants and invitations to luxurious vacation properties. Alongside these amenities, our ministry offered prayers, gift Bibles, and the assurance that millions of believers thanked God for the decisions this trio of justices rendered on abortion, health care, marriage, and gun ownership….
But Reverend Schenck began to understand that his activities and beliefs were toxic to democracy. What triggered his change? Perhaps it was his late-in-life doctoral studies, when he read about the German Christian movement in the 1930s, which supported the Nazi party. He wrote: One of the most respected Bible scholars of that period, Paul Althaus, declared Hitler’s ascent to the chancellorship to be a “gift and miracle from God.”
He was shaken by his research. He began to change his views. He wondered whether Christian evangelicals in the U.S. were on the same dangerous path.
Following the insurrection of January 6, when Christian banners, Bibles, and prayers in Jesus’ name appeared in the assault on the Capitol, I felt even greater urgency in warning my fellow evangelicals of the grave danger Trump and his MAGA cult posed to Christianity and US democracy.
My change of course so late in life has been painful, disorienting, and costly. Besides losing decades-long friendships and enduring menacing threats, my wife and I have faced a significantly reduced income. I’ve even driven Uber to cover household expenses. One night, I picked up an organizer of the National Prayer Breakfast, an event in which I had once played a significant role. I was wearing a mask and said little, but then, with trepidation, I realized I would be dropping him at the home of a congressman I had worked with closely for more than 20 years. When my passenger got out, I was relieved to have gone unrecognized. Still, I’ve never questioned the decisions that brought me to that moment.
In my third conversion, I realized that when religion is placed at the service of a political party, it corrupts both. To claim that one political figure uniquely represents God’s will for the body politic is a form of anti-Christian idolatry. To elevate one set of spiritual beliefs above another and do it by force of law removes a nonnegotiable tenet of evangelical faith—free will. We are born again when we choose to believe in the Lord Jesus Christ, not when we’re forced to do so.
Because it is immoral, I believe Christian nationalism is inevitably doomed. But in the meantime, the pain, suffering, and injury it will inflict will be enormous—just consider women facing difficult pregnancies, trans children seeking care, librarians attacked for certain books. “We want to fill our culture again with the Christian spirit. We want to burn out all the recent immoral developments in literature, in the theater, and in the press—in short, we want to burn out the poison of immorality, which has entered into our whole life and culture as a result of liberal excess.” This may sound familiar—maybe some overheated Republican talking points. In fact, it’s what Adolf Hitler promised the German people in 1933.

“In my third conversion”
Oh boy
LikeLike
As a non-believer, I have respect & tolerance for those who choose to be religious practitioners. However, I do NOT have any tolerance for religious people imposing their beliefs on others, but especially imposing those beliefs on our public, SECULAR institutions. Learn from history that whenever a country’s ruling sovereigns embraced a particular religion, abuses & mayhem usually ensued. Self-righteous religious believers feel that everything should be done according to their own beliefs, so if others differ from those beliefs, they must be subjugated, punished or worse. So there!
LikeLike
I am glad to read that Schenk has realized the error of his prior beliefs but the nation is already paying a very high price for the unholy union of Evangelical Christians and the GOP.
LikeLike
“[W]e want to burn out the poison of immorality, which has entered into our whole life and culture as a result of liberal excess.” Chilling that that’s a quote from Hitler before he took power.
Thanks for posting this, Diane.
LikeLike
You are welcome.
LikeLike
It would be great if these guys could recant BEFORE the damage is done, rather than after.
LikeLike
Better late than never.
LikeLike
I have a very good friend who is an evangelical and she feels like the church has left her. I gave her a copy of Tim Alberta’s book, The Kingdom, the Power, and the Glory: American Evangelicals in an Age of Extremism. It’s an excellent read and it helps give evangelicals permission to stop supporting the cult.
You are right, the damage is done, but we need more of these pastors and faith leaders to renounce this disasterous trend. There are far too many “christians” in name only “CINO’s”, as it were, that refuse to see what is happening. tRump goes against everything they say they believe in and what is happening at the highest court is an outrage.
It’s all about the power.
LikeLike
Granny,
I don’t understand how evangelicals chose Trump as the one they follow. He is an unusually flawed person. I think he sees them as suckers. He has a mob mentality.
LikeLike
Agreed, he is the opposite of everything they supposedly have as values. My gf says the same thing. She finally was able to get her mother to see it. Her mom said, “But they fought against him the whole four years!”. She explained he did have a majority in the Senate, and the House in the beginning, but lost it in 2018. She finally told her mom, “I am voting for decency.” Her mom said she understood and would do more research. Life long GOP’s.
She doesn’t go to her church anymore. Such a strange choice for these people. One that baffles me is Franklin Graham. How in the world and why in the world would he make that choice? His father is probably turning in his grave.
LikeLike
I’m almost finished reading Joe Conason’s The Longest Con. He has a lot on the hypocrisy and avarice of the likes of Pat Robertson and Jerry Falwell, as well as the malign influence of religion in the Republican Party.
LikeLike
This is a piece I’m still pondering today. I was aware of the Brights. And of course the long game played by Leo/ Federalist Society. But the extent of the organization and reach of the Christian Nationalist movement exposed by Schenk is sobering. I hope he stays true to his pledge and spreads this story far and wide.
LikeLike