Margaret Hartmann, a senior editor at New York magazine, compiled six examples (by no means definitive!) of Trump rants.
Hartmann’s article includes tweets and videos that I did not include. Open the link to read the article in full.
She writes:
Donald Trump’s rally speeches have always been a dizzying mix of fearmongering, conspiracy theories, threats against his enemies, and laments about how America is a “nation in decline.” Since Trump made Joe Biden’s decrepitude the centerpiece of his 2024 campaign, even before the Democrat’s calamitous debate, you might have expected the Republican to focus on appearing more competent and presidential at his MAGA gatherings. Yet Trump’s rallies are now weirder than ever.
It’s not just that the substance of Trump’s remarks has grown more disturbing, though it certainly has (for example, he regularly celebrates the January 6 rioters and uses Nazi rhetoric to describe migrants). These days his speeches are also littered with pointless and astoundingly strange musings, like his anti-shark diatribes and tributes to a fictional serial killer.
Trump insists he isn’t incoherent; he’s just misunderstood. “The fake news will say ‘Trump is rambling,’” he declared recently in Philadelphia. “No, it’s genius what I’m doing up here, but nobody understands.”
You can be the judge of that. Here’s a running list of Trump’s most bizarre rally rants from the 2024 campaign trail.
Trump claims magnets don’t work underwater.
Trump likes to brag that he’s “like, a really smart person,” often citing his MIT professor-uncle as proof that scientific brilliance is in his genes. But it seems Uncle John forgot to cover the basics properties of magnets.
“Think of it, magnets,” Trump said at a January 2024 rally in Mason City, Iowa. “Now all I know about magnets is this, give me a glass of water, let me drop it on the magnets, that’s the end of the magnets.”
Fact check: It is not.
Trump brags about putting on pants.
Okay, so Trump isn’t smarter than a fifth-grader when it comes to magnets. But as he revealed at the same January rally in Mason City, he does dress himself like a big boy.
“First they say, ‘Sir, how do you do it? How do you wake up in the morning and put on your pants?’” Trump mused. “And I say, ‘Well, I don’t think about it too much.’ I don’t want to think about it because if I think about it too much maybe I won’t want to do it, but I love it because we’re going to do something for this country that’s never been done before.”
Trump is so proud of his ability to put on pants that he bragged about it again at a rally in the Bronx in May.
Trump blasts Abraham Lincoln for not negotiating his way out of a Civil War.
Trump has a longstanding rivalry with Abraham Lincoln. It seems he knows this will not be received well by the public, as Lincoln is beloved, and also dead. But during a January rally in Newton, Iowa, the 45th president could not resist jabbing the 16th president for failing to prevent the Civil War via negotiation.
“So many mistakes were made” ahead of the Civil War, Trump said. “See, there was something I think could have been negotiated, to be honest with you. I think you could have negotiated that. All the people died. So many people died.”
Trump went on to suggest that concerns about his legacy might have prevented Lincoln from embracing the lessons of The Art of the Deal.
“Abraham Lincoln, of course, if he negotiated it, you probably wouldn’t even know who Abraham Lincoln was,” Trump said. “He would’ve been president, but he would’ve been president, and he would have been — he wouldn’t have been the Abraham Lincoln.”
Trump imitates Dread Pirate Robert E. Lee in Gettysburg.
In April, Trump showed off another thing he has on Lincoln: His predecessor’s Gettysburg Address did not feature a pirate impression. (As far as we know!)
After describing the Battle of Gettysburg, in which about 50,000 soldiers died, as “so beautiful in so many different ways,” Trump delivered a fake quote from Confederate general Robert E. Lee in a Captain Jack Sparrow voice:
Robert E. Lee, who’s no longer in favor — did you ever notice it? He’s no longer in favor. “Never fight uphill, me boys, never fight uphill.” They were fighting uphill. He said, “Wow, that was a big mistake.” He lost his big general. “Never fight uphill, me boys,” but it was too late.
Trump reveals he’d rather die by shark than by electrocution.
The chances of Donald Trump being caught on a sinking boat and forced to choose between electrocution and being devoured by a shark are fairly slim. Yet he seems to think about this dilemma quite a lot.
He debuted his shark-versus-electrocution riff during an October 2023 rally in Ottumwa, Iowa. There was no context that would have explained these remarks, other than the fact that Trump has a well-documented shark phobia and an irrational disdain for electric-powered vehicles.
No one had any idea what Trump was talking about, but that did not keep him from telling the tale again and again during rallies, or insisting in June that we’re dumb for not understanding his “smart story” about ways he might die at sea.
Trump praises ‘great man’ Hannibal Lecter.
If there’s one Trump rant that’s guaranteed to make your brain melt, it’s the one where he gushes about fictional serial killer Hannibal Lecter. Praising the Silence of the Lambs villain is now a regular part of Trump’s stump speech, but most people only noticed in May because he went on and on about it.
Trump does sort of have a reason for bringing up Lecter: He’s invoking the movie villain to demonize migrants. But Trump’s tale is all wrong, both factually and dramaturgically. Here’s why:
• Trump says many migrants have been in mental institutions like the one shown in Silence of the Lambs, but there is no evidence that criminals and mentally ill people are flooding into the U.S.
• Trump has repeatedly said that Hannibal Lecter is a “great man’ who deserves our “congratulations” — so why keep him out of the U.S.?
• Trump seems confused about whether Hannibal Lecter is a character or the man who played him. He’s remarked, “Hannibal Lecter, how great an actor was he?”
• Trump has said he loves Lecter because the actor once said “I love Donald Trump” in a TV interview. It’s unclear who he was referring to, but all the actors who have portrayed Lecter — Anthony Hopkins, Mads Mikkelsen, and Brian Cox — have said they dislike Trump.
• Trump often refers to “the late, great Hannibal Lecter,” but the character does not die in any of the book, TV, or film adaptations.
• By the end of The Silence of the Lambs, Lecter has escaped from the Baltimore State Hospital for the Criminally Insane and is stalking his next victim in the Bahamas. So this is an example of the United States unleashing its inmates on a foreign country, not the other way around….
Trump isn’t stressing about any of these details. The once-and-possibly-future president of the United States just loves yelling “Hannibal Lecter!” at his rallies, even if it doesn’t make any sense.
Even at his rambling 92-minute speech accepting the Republican nomination, he went off-script to refer to “the late, great Hannibal Lecter.” Why? Any ideas why he is obsessed with this film creature?

If only all these repetitions of the incoherent, inane, insane, bigoted, violence-praising and anti-democratic Trump proclamations had persuasive power with the remaining constituencies that have yet to decide to vote and to vote for Democrats. I think to win, Harris and other Democrats need to lead with what they will do to make Americans lives better, to acknowledge why so many people are struggling and have lost confidence in their own political agency and in elected representatives. The last thing they should do is respond defensively to GOP charges against Democrats related to immigration, wokeness, “radical leftness”, and yes, equating the call for an end to US arms for Israel with anti-semitism. And, of course Dems need to stand firm and proudly for public education and against charter schools and vouchers.
LikeLike
”Hannibal Lecter, how great an actor was he?”
Biden may have been a dotard but Trump has taken leave of reality in a way most actors would only hope to duplicate. Someone in his camp knows this, and finds it useful, but he has no idea.
LikeLike
Trump injects Hannibal Lecter into many speeches, including his acceptance speech at the GOP convention. Lecter is not a real person, he is not great, and he’s not dead.
LikeLike
There may be brains in the Trump lineage. since Mary certainly has more than her fair share of them. I do not think Trump cares about learning anything unless it is a manipulative way to acquire money and power. As Bob has noted, Trump is more of a pop culture screwball. There are so many non sequiturs in Trump’s rants that it’s hard to remember them all. The one that had my jaw on the floor was one of his 4th of July speeches where he claimed, “Patriots stormed the airports.” The man is a mess, but he is a skillful demagogue. He has the potential to set himself up as an evil emperor, and as such he is an existential threat to democracy.
LikeLike
The link didn’t work for me.
LikeLike
And I couldn’t find it on the site. Any help will be appreciated.
LikeLike
Take it to the bank.
When Traitor Trump says he puts his pants on, he doesn’t.
When he calls himself a stable genius, we know he isn’t stable or a genius.
When he calls President Biden a crime family boss, we know Traitor Trump just admitted that Trump is the crime family boss.
During the 2016 debates with Hillary, the Liar in Chief said the United States doesn’t make anything anymore. Another LIE. The US has the 2nd largest Manufacuring sectors in the world and it is still growing but with declining labor numbers since robots are counted as labor.
During the debates, the traitor also said he’d never had a bankruptcy. By then, i was onto him. If he says something that makes him sound good, fact check it. That’s how I found out about the traitor’s six big bankruptcies. The largest was his casino hotels. I also learned that the traitor got $800 million in government subsidies to build those casino hotels.
How much does an almost billion-dollar bankruptcy + $800 million in government subsidies to build what went bankrupt later add up to?
If Trump accuses a rival of a crime, find out what crime that is and then you’ll discover the traitor has committed that crime and probably settled out of court with an agreement that he wasn’t guilty. — Trump University, Trump’s non-profit, discrimination…
LikeLike
So right, Lloyd. Trump projects every time he makes an accusation.
When he talks of the “Biden crime family,” think “Trump crime family.”
LikeLike
Trump appeared today at the National Association of Black Journalists convention. Here’s a link, which makes one wonder why we didn’t leave this guy at the end of the bar, where he belongs. Harris as his opponent is a problem for the guy; he will not be able to refrain from his sexism, racism and misogyny.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=jgod-nqFEEc
LikeLike
Yes, Trump was outrageous today. He questioned whether she is black. He thinks she is Indian and only recently “turned black.” Fact is she is half black, half Indian. Her mother was a research scientist from India; her father is an economist from Jamaica.
Kamala chose to enroll at Howard University, a historically black university. She joined a black sorority. That was more than 40 years ago. Yet that dotard Trump claims she “turned black,” presumably for political advantage. When she was 18 years old. What an idiot he is!
LikeLike