Dan Rather is gobsmacked by the short memories of the delegates at the RNC. How could they have wiped their memories of the insurrection of January 6? How could they take pride in nominating a convicted felon? How could they opine for the Trump economy when Biden’s economy has been so successful? How could they endorse a man who still insists that he won in 2020 without a scintilla of evidence? Sore loser.
At their convention in Milwaukee, Republicans see themselves as celebrating what they are convinced is going to be not only a win in November, but an overwhelming one. Among delegates and others on the convention floor and around the hall, there is much chatter about an “avalanche” building.
This, as they have nominated for president a man who tried to overthrow our government.
Their hope is that a majority of voters will simply forget all Donald Trump has done to help himself and hurt this country. That strikes many Americans as falling in the narrow space between revolting and appalling.
And my goodness, the lies are flying fast and furious at the Republican fantasy convention. This glitzed-up affair is full of speeches that don’t even come close to the truth. Here’s how bad it is: Some major news organizations (although unfortunately not all) are fact-checking the speeches live, calling out the lies in real time.
But it’s more than that. Republicans must believe Americans are in a mood to forgive and forget. To forgive the insurrection of January 6 and forget the fact that the former president kept top-secret documents strewn about Mar-a-Lago like last month’s junk mail, among many other indiscretions.
How much airtime and how many column inches will be devoted this week to what the previous president has done to harm our democracy? My guess is almost none. Instead there will be a celebration, one devoid of context. It will be an anointing without proper perspective and analysis. And there will be misleading speech after misleading speech.
Tip of the Stetson to The Washington Post and The New York Times, whose fact-checkers are calling out a myriad of false claims. MSNBC is doing the same in real time. CNN is airing a fact-checking segment after the convention coverage. Unsurprisingly, Fox “News” is airing live speeches unchallenged and unchecked.
So far, the speeches have been riddled with stunning yet emphatically stated lies. Trump, the liar-in-chief, is getting a run for his money in the telling of tales. Over two days, the Post’s fact-checkers have found that convention speakers have made false claims about border crossings, gas prices, fentanyl, tax cuts, Vice President Kamala Harris, peace during Trump’s presidency, voting by migrants, energy independence, the relative wealth of young Americans, and Easter Sunday.
The lies and misinformation are meant to rile and to scare. Texas Senator Ted Cruz actually said this out loud from the convention podium: “Americans are dying, murdered, assaulted, raped by illegal immigrants that the Democrats have released.”
And then there’s the old chestnut, election denialism. According to the Post, 62 convention speakers have previously questioned President Biden’s 2020 election win.
Nikki Haley and Ron DeSantis have capitulated, forgiving Trump for his miserable and untruthful treatment of them when they were running against him. They both gave speeches endorsing him on Tuesday night.
And don’t forget House Speaker Mike Johnson’s claim that the Republican Party is “the law and order team,” as it nominates a convicted felon.
It is no secret that the political nominating conventions lost their significance decades ago. Today, they are nothing more than hour upon hour of campaign advertising, which makes them a great place to court undecided voters. This MAGA convention will be hard-pressed to appeal to middle-of-the-roaders. Republicans can no longer claim to be the party of Lincoln or even of Reagan. It is wholly the party of Trump and his MAGA extremist followers. Their newly anointed vice presidential candidate, JD Vance, is even more extreme on issues like gun control and abortion than Trump.
Vance and the convention speakers are talking some about America’s need for unity, and that’s good, if they actually mean it. But after only two days, they seem to have abandoned the calls for unity and reverted back to the MAGA talking points. Against the backdrop of Republicans celebrating in Milwaukee, let’s hope that most of the rest of the country gives itself a gut check on Trump’s record and the reality of what his victory in November would mean.

Hi Diane,Will Bunch of the Phila Inquirer has a great piece on the convention also.Scary stuff.Lisa
America will never be the same after Milwaukee’s tent revival for the cult of Donald Trump | Will Bunch
| | | | | |
|
| | | | America will never be the same after Milwaukee’s tent revival for the cu…
Will Bunch
A four-day tent revival in Milwaukee celebrated total surrender to the cult of Donald Trump — and maybe the end … |
|
|
LikeLike
Thank you! Will Bunch is the best!
LikeLike
Thanks, Diane.
LikeLike
I am a lifelong Democrat. Dan Rather is long past his time. He clearly does not understand how Trump supporters think, and why the GOP messaging is so effective. Unfortunately, neither do most of the leaders of the Democrat party, and it is killing us.
LikeLike
The gop “message” that wins election is to demonize the Democrat, with help from the so-called liberal media to legitimize it and amplify it. That’s why in 2016, every poll showed that the democrat had a huge lead over Trump when the polling question was “who is more corrupt?” Many people voted for her despite believing she was corrupt because that’s what they saw in the so-called liberal media that didn’t report on Trump’s corruption because it was “old news” so couldn’t be mentioned.
I agree that the Dem leaders who don’t realize this are killing us.
Bernie Sanders and AOC get it. They KNOW that whoever the nominee is, they will be demonized with help from the Dems themselves. Just like Biden/Dukakis/Gore/Kerry/ and HRC were. And now Biden.
Circular firing squad indeed. The Republicans unite for the guy who refused to leave office and incited an insurrection.
LikeLike
J. Henry,
I worked for the first President Bush. I respected him, Lamar Alexander and many intelligent, honest Republicans I worked for and with. I knew them as people of integrity and principle.
None of the Republicans I knew are in Milwaukee.
I don’t understand those who are. How can they ignore the attack of January 6? How can they tolerate Trump’s vile rhetoric? How can they treat this sexual predator as a gift from God? I admit I don’t understand them.
LikeLike
I am certainly no expert, but I did teach high school in Appalachia (I’m from DC). The best analysis of how a Trump supporter thinks (that I have heard) came from Alexandra Pelosi’s interview on NPR’s 1A. To paraphrase, you cannot argue with them based on facts and logic. They do not source their ‘news’ from credible sources that fact check. They feel ‘not heard,’ invisible, not represented, not listened to. Add to that, they are threatened by the establishment and outsiders (especially economically), and have huge trust issues. They simply are seeking ‘community,’ and Trump and the GOP are filling the bill.
LikeLiked by 1 person
The psychology of Trump supporters (or any supporters for that matters) is driven by tribalism, the idea that humans are inherently tribal by nature and have a tendency to find and commune with their own “tribe”. We all do this, as evidenced by this blog, but trouble happens when tribes feel threatened, like with facts and evidence. At that point, the members (say, MAGA) double down on their beliefs and absolutely no amount of logic and reason will change their belief system because it’s perceived not just as an individual threat, but a threat to the entire tribe. (“La, la, la, I do not hear you!”) Social media is the spark that has created the polarization dumpster fire that we have now. IMO we need to differentiate between groups of Republicans (MAGA, Repub nose-holders, and Never Trumpers) and realize that while MAGA (which is a cult) has captured our attention, thanks to chaos-loving MM, MAGA votes won’t put Trump in office and we should not be wasting good oxygen on them. It will be those disenfranchised voters that stay home, that will make or break this election. The Democratic party has got to stop wrestling with itself, get on to the business at hand, and create a strong, unwavering united front around Candidate X (not taking sides here). And they need to do it NOW. The Dems never should have thrown Biden under the bus publicly and now you can’t put the genie back in the bottle. If they keep waffling and can’t commit collectively to a path forward, why should they expect undecided Dem/independent voters to have any confidence in them? It just makes them look weak and indecisive, and that’s not a good look right now.
LikeLike
Right, Oakland Mom. Get a replacement for Biden and move on.
LikeLike
Dr. Ravitch,
I’m still trying to comprehend how Lamar Alexander could vote to acquit Trump when he was impeached for Jan 6. Lamar Alexander had already announced his own retirement from politics, yet he still voted to acquit.
LikeLike
I never understood it either. A lot of Republicans were watching Lamar. He stepped back. Beats Me.
LikeLike
Calling the 2024 RNC a fantasy is an understatement.
Amazon has a genre called Dark Fantasy Horror, that’s a better fit.
LikeLike
It must be hard for Dan Rather to see the profession he worked so hard in and did so well for come to this.
LikeLike
agreed
LikeLike
t
Thank you for Rather’s article.
The RNC is a circus filled with lying, evil clowns.
LikeLiked by 1 person
nailed it, Yvonne!
LikeLike
The Convention is so violent. The speakers keep calling for civility from the crowd after saying fight fight fight (Who are we fighting, and why are we fighting them?), and the VP candidate squeaking about how his grandma hid loaded firearms all over her house, and she threatened to run over his childhood friends with her car like Charlottesville, and the audience should laud her fear and hatred of her fellow countrymen, but not out loud, please.
LikeLike
Diane: A grandmotherly Trump supporter, I think from Wisconsin, who had a big cheese slice on her head, was interviewed by one of ours–don’t know his name–on the floor of the GOP Convention . . . a darkhaired fellow, who asked her politely and with no guile why she was there.
It was, for me, another upside down experience:
She was the picture of a nice and articulate person who was obviously sincere and well-meaning–no joke. But what she said she wanted and sincerely thought she would get from the MAGA republicans was a list of things that read like the democratic platform: medical care for seniors, young people having good support to get started with home owning, middle class having enough money to live on, stuff like that.
To me, it sounded like (a) a good and sincere person willing to take a stand at the convention who was just (b) extremely misinformed. I think probably one can divide MAGA into two common human problems (1) sincere but naive and ill-informed and (2) self-hating and resentful of those who mirror what they, themselves could or should have been and done.
If she is any indication of what is needed, it is a FIREHOSE of TRUTHTELLING coming from well-known (to them) people and from every outlet in the country between now and the election.
Did anyone see Kamala Harris’ speech from North Carolina? I was amazed. (paraphrased) “I was a prosecutor and prosecutors look for the truth.” Her communication skills are superb and substantially informed. In my view, Joe Biden has done a superb job with his original idea of being a transition president by bringing Harris’ name and face recognition the National scene. CBK
LikeLike
There have been many reports from White House insiders about how Biden has generally sidelined Harris through most of his administration.
LikeLike
Bob: He may have “sidelined” Harris (I don’t doubt it) but its influence didn’t do as much damage as one would think–what happens next will tell that tale.
How refreshing she is. By comparison, Biden’s optics are horrible; and it’s very hard for any of us, especially if we are doing what we know is right, to grasp how others might view us, even if wrongly.
Democracy is like no other in the import of this point of human development on its own survival as a political order. CBK
LikeLike
CBK,
AOC just explained that the “Biden must go” camp wants to get rid of Kamala Harris too.
That is always what I assumed, because their extreme “Biden must go” actions seemed odd given that this is not comparable to the Supreme Court, because there IS a designated person to step in for the president – the VP. But the big donors don’t want Kamala.
AOC on Instagram Live:
“https://www.independent.co.uk/news/world/americas/us-politics/alexandria-ocasio-cortez-replace-joe-biden-b2582412.html
LikeLike
Biden will step down sometime in the next few days.
LikeLike
Bob: I really like most of your posts. But good guessing, or even informed speculation, is not knowing, not in the critical sense. If an event has not occurred yet, and even if your speculation plays out when it does, it remains speculative, wishing, belief, logical, probable, plausible, or whatever. To confuse those with knowing, however, is an excursion that does your credibility no good. But I still like reading most of your posts. CBK
LikeLiked by 1 person
Yes. It is the difference between deductive and inductive reasoning.
LikeLike
Bob: Yes, deductively, we can know generalities; but empirically, we know concrete reality only after events actually occur in history.
General knowledge, spoken of as historical knowledge, is a good definition of dogmatism–claiming to know details of an historical event before that event occurs. CBK
LikeLike
Bob: A philosophical afterthought: It’s a matter of understanding (or not) the role of contingency in human agency and history, which is also the source of human freedom. CBK
LikeLike
NYC public: I also heard yesterday about the anti-Kamala movement–which is an entirely unnecessary confusion that, considering the political circumstances, is also extremely irresponsible. CBK
LikeLike
NYC public: The big donors cannot anything if Biden just resigns, and the presidency goes over to Harris, even in the short time left.
Does anyone know WHY they don’t want Harris to run? It’s disgusting to even know how much power these unelected people have–it’s like they think their dollars are votes. Even if it’s about racism (???) look at the black vote–or is THAT the issue in the first place? These are the same people who benefit from recent SCOTUS decisions. CBK
LikeLike
Bob,
And it is unlikely to be Kamala that replaces him, because the big donors rule and they want her out.
And people think this isn’t going to be a mess? The big donors don’t want Kamala. And soon the news will be all about how “the polls” show Kamala can’t win. AOC speaks the truth.
I will be discouraged but not surprised to read many future posts here with the same message: “The polls say Kamala can’t win, we need someone else to beat Trump”. Bernie and AOC saw this coming and tried to speak the truth, but the bid donors will get their way.
LikeLike
Kamala will be the nominee.
LikeLike
Bob,
Kamala MIGHT be the nominee.
If your comment was a prediction, then I would call the odds 50/50 that you are correct.
AOC has been in meetings.
If you look at the polls and the politicians and “elite” who have been calling for Biden to step aside, and those who have NOT been calling for Biden to step aside, you will see a significant difference in where they are in the political spectrum.
But I am very relieved that you aren’t going to post that Kamala can’t win in another couple weeks. I agree with you that she SHOULD be the nominee, but I know that the powerful folks calling for an open convention will be manufacturing consent to prevent that.
LikeLike
Biden will step aside. Kamala Harris will be the nominee. The sun also rises. Sloths are slow but not slothful. Circles are round.
LikeLike
Bob,
Why do you find it so hard to reply to me in a civil manner? I am not your enemy.
LikeLike
CBK,
Thank you for that description of the grandmotherly Trump supporter. There are undecideds leaning toward Trump who believe similar stuff. One reason I sound like a broken record in talking about the media is that mainstream media no longer informs, it just reports what people on both sides say. While the rightwing media informs people of the “truth”.
Jennifer Rubin (who was hired to be a conservative voice at the Washington Post, and sounds more progressive these days than many white male liberals):
“CNN and other broadcasts have reached a new low in RNC coverage, fawning over “unity” and “young Vance” – ignoring we are seeing a fascist party overflowing with criminals plot the downfall of America, a VP who is the single most radical and unqualified in history. No pushback on lack of information on Trump’s injury. It’s access journalism at its worst. It’s not the media we need to defend democracy.”
LikeLike
NYC public: . . . and the irony is that the MAGA movement is about trashing the foundations of the Press itself. CBK
LikeLike
BTW to ALL: What looks like confusion from a MAGA-brain perspective is a good example of how reasonable people work things out to get to the best and most appropriate way to go forward (in this case, aka: DEMOCRATS).
. . . and it’s what occurs when one already knows one WILL NOT BE ATTACKED, JAILED, or HUNG just by disagreeing with or failing to kiss the “ring” of the dictator.
I think we all can say rightly that NO ONE in this camp feels like they must stay away from high-rise windows. CBK
LikeLike