American media covers the pro-Palestinian protests on college campuses, but ignores the protests in Israel, usually led by the families of the hostages who were seized on October 7. Rescuing the hostages was one of the main goals of the Israeli invasion of Gaza, but that goal has taken a back seat to the other goal—eliminating Hamas. Prime Minister Netanyahu seems determined to pursue the destruction of Hamas, but the brutality of the invasion guarantees the emergence of new terrorists.
Yesterday, Hamas released a video featuring one of the hostages. Such videos must be seen with the understanding that the hostage is in captivity and is not free to say what he wants. Yet his plea to rescue the hostages is heartfelt. Many of the hostages, he says, have already died. Some were killed by Israeli bombs, some by the negligence or brutality of their captors.
And yet this young man’s voice must be heard. This terrible, violent, vengeful war must end. The killing must stop. The only solution is a two-state solution. Despite Hamas’ determination to eradicate the state of Israel, Israel will survive.
The only way the war will end is through pressure by other nations on the combatants and negotiations.
The fact that Israel was protected from Iran’s massive bombardment of drones and missiles by not only the U.S., the UK, and France, but by Jordan, Saudi Arabia, and other Arab nations suggests hope for a new Middle East. There is a new longing for peace, stability, and regional cooperation. This new world can’t emerge until the violence ends.
This is an excerpt from Haaretz, a valuable source of news in Israel:
Harsh Goldberg-Polin was seriously wounded in Hamas’ attack at the Nova festival on October 7, and appears in the video with an amputated arm. Hundreds of protesters march in Jerusalem and Tel Aviv in what they’re calling a ‘rage demonstration’ prompted by the video’s release.
Hamas released a video on Wednesday showing Israeli hostage Hersh Goldberg-Polin who was kidnapped to Gaza on October 7 – the first sign of life from his time in captivity.
Goldberg-Polin had attended the Nova festival at Kibbutz Re’im with friends and sought refuge in a shelter when Hamas stormed the outdoor rave. He sustained serious wounds and is seen in the video with an amputated arm.
He was born in California to Rachel and Jon and moved to Israel in 2008. He celebrated his 24th birthday four days before he was kidnapped.
Shortly after the video was released, hundreds of protesters, including friends of Goldberg-Polin, marched towards the prime minister’s residence in Jerusalem, lit a bonfire, and called for his release. At least two protesters were arrested. Police deployed skunk water against demonstrators blocking streets.
The video, approved for release by Goldberg-Polin’s family, begins with Goldberg-Polin introducing himself and recounting his abduction. “I went out to have fun with my friends, and instead, I found myself fighting for my life with severe wounds all over my body after trying to shield myself and others because there was no one to protect us that day,” he said.
He addressed the prime minister, saying, “Benjamin Netanyahu and the Israeli government, you should be ashamed for abandoning me and thousands of citizens on that day. You should be ashamed. For almost 200 days, we’re here, and all the IDF’s attempts to rescue us have failed.”
Goldberg-Polin further stated that “Air Force bombings killed around 70 hostages like me, and you should be ashamed that every deal that comes to the table, you and your government reject. Don’t you want to end this nightmare already?”
“Benjamin Netanyahu and members of the government, while you sit and celebrate holidays with your families, think of us, the hostages who are still here, in hell beneath the ground. Without water, without food, without sunlight, without the medical treatment I so desperately need,” Goldberg-Polin added.
“I demand from you, Prime Minister, and your government and cabinet: Every day we’re here is another day you abandon us, another day you allow our blood to be shed. Do what’s expected of you already, and bring us home now. Or is that too much for you? It’s time to clear out your offices, and go home,” he said.Open gallery view
In the end of the video, Goldberg-Polin addressed his family, saying: “One last thing, and most importantly: Mom, Dad, Libby, and Orly, I love you very much and miss you terribly, and I think of you every day I’m here. I know you’re doing everything possible to get me home as soon as possible. I need you to stay strong for me and keep fighting until each one of the hostages comes home safely. I expect and hope to be with you soon, after all this is over. I won’t be here anymore, but I hope I’ve given you some peace of mind this holiday.”

I really feel for the hostages and their families because I know personally what it’s like to live in that war-torn country. I was living on a kibbutz that’s situated on the Mediteranian coast when the Yom Kippur War broke out and Israel was attacked by Arab countries on two fronts. All but a few old men on the kibbutz immediately went off to fight for Israel. Women were left to take care of the kibbutz and were also tasked with monitoring the coastline for a possible invasion by sea, after being warned of the high risk of being raped, wounded and killed if that occured. Children slept in bunkers and adults were often sent to them as well, as air raid warnings were constantly going off. It was just awful.
Each day I pray for peace there again now, and for a two state solution which will, hopefully, meet the needs of both Israelis and Palestinians, and reduce the likelihood of such unexpected attacks from occuring again.
LikeLike
Terrifying.
LikeLike
“The fact that Israel was protected from Iran’s massive bombardment of drones and missiles by not only the U.S., the UK, and France, but by Jordan, Saudi Arabia, and other Arab nations suggests hope for a new Middle East. There is a new longing for peace, stability, and regional cooperation. This new world can’t emerge until the violence ends.”
Thank you for putting my thoughts about this terrible affair into words better than I could ever have hoped to use. Each day I fervently pray that all this will end, and the hatred will subside. I never thought I would see the end of the Irish-British conflict. I never thought I would see the end of the Soviet Union or the reunification of Germany. I still hope for peace in Sudan. Perhaps it is time for another miracle.
LikeLike
Even considering that he was monitored by his captors, the excerpts here don’t sound like anything he’d have to be coerced to say. They’re what a lot of the Israeli public is saying. A friend just returned from 2 weeks volunteering in Israel said the hostages are by far the main concern. Many protesters want Netanyahu out of office.
Doesn’t anyone know where we can view the actual video? The news source I find all have headlines screaming about the video release, & then display clips of reporters talking about it, without showing the actual video. CNN showed about 5 seconds of it while the reporter talked over it. Where was the video released?
LikeLike
Lenny, I think the video is in the Haaretz article. I will search for the link.
LikeLike
Lenny,
Here is the hostage video, as it appears on Haaretz and Twitter.
https://www.haaretz.com/israel-news/2024-04-24/ty-article/.premium/hamas-airs-video-showing-israeli-american-hostage-hersh-goldberg-polin-in-gaza/0000018f-10d7-d361-a3ef-52f7a0400000?utm_source=App_Share&utm_medium=iOS_Native
LikeLike
Thanks, Diane!
LikeLike
What appears in Haaretz condemns Netanyahu with ferocity.
LikeLike
This analysis is sincere but is pure sentimentality. Hamas will never agree to anything short of the destruction of Israel. That destruction of the Jewish homeland is a religious imperative for extreme Islamists – they cannot be persuaded out of it.
There are awful tradeoffs involved in the decision whether to proceed with crushing Hamas or to end the war with Hamas still in place. Continue the war and Hamas will be effectively vanquished for at least several years; the tradeoff is thousands of additional Palestininan lives and likely the lives of any still living hostages. End the war with thousands of Hamas terrorists still alive in Gaza and Hamas will soon retake control of Gaza and rebuild their forces for the next attack on Israel, which they have vowed to do as long as necessary.
This blog wants to blame Netanyahu for Israel’s continuance of this war. 100% wrong. A large majority of Israelis wants Hamas crushed. Citing a left-wing Israeli publication does not refute the polling data showing what most Israelis want, which includes Netanyahu being ousted after the war ends.
LikeLike
Ken Bowman,
I think we agree on most issues. As I have often written, Hamas is a terrorist organization whose overriding goal is to exterminate Israel. I am not convinced that Hamas can be eliminated, no matter how long the war goes on.
Netanyahu’s great error was believing that he could collaborate with Hamas, and that Hamas would be so concerned with governing Gaza that it would stop being terrorist. Bibi turned a blind eye to the massive cash transfers from Qatar to Hamas. Hamas used that aid not to improve life for Gazans but to build an elaborate tunnel network where they could hideout, store their military arsenal, and move freely.
When there is an election, Netanyahu will be ousted. He bears responsibility for the lack of protection on the Gaza border, he bears responsibility for the many hours it took for the military to arrive on October 7, and he bears responsibility for a military response that has leveled most of Gaza.
I agree that a ceasefire without safeguards will allow Hamas to rearm and attack again. On October 8, the Hamas spokesman promised that Hamas would do it again and again.
The only way this dreadful impasse will end is if a combination of Western nations and Arab nations combine to guarantee an outcome that ends the war, protects Israel, and establishes a demilitarized Palestinian state under control of the PA, not Hamas. The great powers of the west and the region can maintain security. The existential threat of terrorist must end for all those in the region.
What I find disgusting about the campus demonstrations is that they are based on ignorance. They want peace but if the war stopped today, terrorism would resume in a few days or weeks or months. Hamas has promised it. I believe them.
Where I disagree with the campus demonstrators is they are bringing a simple answer to a complicated issue. They want the war to end. So do I. But they don’t care if Hamas unleashes massacre after massacre on Israelis. I do. The honest intellectual answer to the dilemma demands thoughtfulness, knowledge, creativity, and persistence, not self-righteous performance.
LikeLiked by 1 person
Yes, Diane, yes. This problem is not so simple as attempting to sweep one side or the other into the sea, or as turning a blind eye as one side or the other does the attempted sweeping. The solution must involve cooperation over discord.
LikeLike
Can you point me to somewhere I could read about a workable two-state solution? That is, what territory would Israel agree to cede to form the second state? This doesn’t seem realistic to me but you may know more about it than I do.
I’m horrified by your post and the responses but I want to take your position seriously regardless.
LikeLike
Every world leader who wants peace in the Middle East agrees that there must be a two-state solution. Netanyahu opposes it, so does Hamas.
The Oslo Accords show what is possible. The Israeli Prime Minister Yitzhak Rabin and PLO leader Yassir Arafat collaborated in a process to achieve peace and a two-state solution. Both shared a Nobel Peace Prize. U.S. President Clinton encouraged and supported their agreement. The two sides entered into a process intended to create a two-state solution. The PLO recognized the State of Israel. Israel recognized the PLO as “the representative of the Palestinian people.”
The two sides agreed to a process in which they would negotiate the boundaries of the two states.
The two leaders shook hands. Rabin said, “Enough of blood and tears. Enough!”
Extremists on both sides denounced the agreement. Rabin was assassinated by an Israeli zealot. The peace process collapsed.
Many more tears and much more blood since then.
LikeLike
Thanks for your reply I am interested in anyone’s credible plan for what a two-state solution would look like. It sounds like there isn’t one? World leaders who advocate for a two-state solution also know it is not possible. It’s like the US’s strategic ambiguity regarding Taiwan. Advocating for a two-state solution is like taking no position at all because it’s not possible.
You mentioned the assassination of Rabin. The faction that wanted his death is in charge now and it goes well beyond Netanyahu. As with many assassinations, the movement behind it benefits when we think of that person as a lone wolf. It was not just a zealot. It was a right-wing zealot.
LikeLike
Netanyahu was part of the faction that assassinated Rabin. The rightwing group did not want peace or a two-state solution. It wanted the status quo. In the twenty years that Netanyahu has been prime minister, he has favored Hamas and undermined the Palestinian Authority. He has enabled major transfers of money to Hamas. He thought they had reached an accommodation. That illusion was shattered on October 7.
As soon as there is an election, Netanyahu will be ousted. I pray that he will be replaced by a government that wants peace and two states. The shape of those states will be determined by the two parties in negotiations. In my personal view, the Israeli settlements in the West Bank must be dismantled. That will be a bitter pill for Israelis but necessary for a lasting peace.
LikeLike
The only lasting peace in the Middle East requires a two-state solution. Start with the assumption that Israel is not going away. It is a highly prosperous, technologically advanced nation.
Are you opposed to a Palestinian state? I am not. No one can give you the contours of a two-state plan because that must be negotiated between Israel and the Palestinian Authority, not imposed by outsiders.
LikeLike
Unfortunately neither side wants the war to end, between the ultra Orthodox in Israel and Iran backed Hamas in Gaza the war will continue… perhaps during a Biden second term he can intervene, Trump will walk away…
LikeLike
Trump completely sides with Netanyahu, without reservation. In his term in office, he proposed a complete ban on Muslims coming to the U.S. it’s ironic that the campus demonstrations may help Trump, who is Bibi’s bro.
LikeLike
Trump was furious with Bibi because he congratulated Biden on his win. When did they make up?
As for the perameters of the two state solution, the problem is that Hamaas is demanding that Israel return to the borders that existed prior to the Six Day War in 1967. This would mean that, once again, Jews would not have access to the Jewish Quarter in Old Jerusalem and they could not go to the Temple Mount and Western Wall to pray –as occurred for 19 years after the State of Israel was established in 1948. Since that is THE most holy place in Judaism, such a demand is a non-starter for most Jews.
Jerusalem is a holy city for people of all three monotheistic religions of the book. Israeli’s did not stop Christians or Muslims from going to their holy sites in Jerusalem and I see no good reason why Jews should ever be prevented from doing so either.
LikeLike