Putin has finally gotten rid of his chief opponent, Alexei Navalny. Officials announced that he died after taking a “walk” in the remote prison where he was confined.
Navalny was a strapping handsome man of 47 who bravely stood up to Putin. He previously survived an attempt to poison him, a near-death experience. Navalny recovered in a German hospital.
He could have stayed in the West and remained a free man, risking the possibility that Putin’s agents would kill him.
Instead, after his recovery, he returned to Moscow to lead the struggle against Putin. He was arrested the instant he stepped off the plane.
Navalny was repeatedly moved into solitary confinement and suffered harsh conditions. While imprisoned, his jail term was increased again and again.
Mr. Navalny was given a three-and-a-half-year prison sentence in February 2021 after returning to Russia from Germany, where he had been recovering from being poisoned with a nerve agent the previous August. In March 2022, he received a nine-year sentence for embezzlement and fraud in a trial that international observers denounced as “politically motivated” and a “sham.” And in August 2023, he was sentenced to 19 years in prison for “extremism.”
Mr. Navalny had effectively returned from the dead after his 2020 poisoning and had conducted multiple hunger strikes to improve his treatment, with many of his supporters believing him to be all but invincible.
During his detention, Mr. Navalny was repeatedly placed in solitary confinement, and complained about severe illnesses. In December, he disappeared for three weeks during his transfer to a penal colony 40 miles north of the Arctic Circle.
Navalny was interviewed by the New York Times in 2021.
An excerpt:
What is the likelihood you will be killed in prison?
In interviews, at points like this, there’s usually a remark in parentheses (laughter). You cannot see me right now, but I assure you, I’m laughing.
For many years, I was forced to make excuses in response to questions like: “Why haven’t you been killed yet?” and “Why haven’t you been jailed?” Now that I have both these boxes checked (the one about murder with a side note: “Well, almost”), I’m asked to gauge the probability of my own death while in prison.
Well, the answer, obviously, can be taken from a joke: 50 percent. I’ll either be killed or not be killed.
Let’s not forget that we clearly have to deal with a person who has lost his mind, Putin. A pathological liar with megalomania and persecutory delusion. Twenty-two years in power would do that to anyone, and what we’re witnessing is a classic situation of a half-mad czar.
Putin is at last free of the one man who led a movement to oust him.
Please Google and watch the documentary “Navalny.” The world has lost a man of courage and principle.
Putin killed Navalny, but he never broke his spirit.

Putin is a vile little murderer. Those who work for him (Trump) or carry his water (Carlson, Tupperville) are themselves criminals. If we had any sense, we would arrest such people and try them for colluding with our enemies, i.e., for treason.
LikeLike
I wonder if Putin told Tucker that he intended to kill Navalny this week.
LikeLiked by 1 person
A little something he neglected to mention
LikeLike
Or I wonder if Tucker carried a message from Trump and his Republican cronies that if Navalny did happen to “accidentally” meet an untimely end, Putin would hear no criticisms from them. Could be a Putin-test before he goes full out with his help for the Republicans. If he gets away with this without any criticisms from the Republicans, he knows he can do what he wants.
LikeLike
From John Sweeney:
https://www.patreon.com/posts/alexei-navalny-98586600?token=eyJhbGciOiJIUzI1NiIsInR5cCI6IkpXVCJ9.eyJyZWRpc19rZXkiOiJpYTI6NTk3N2ZkZGEtYWY5ZC00NDU1LTk3NTEtMDMwYzJhMjcyMjg4IiwicG9zdF9pZCI6OTg1ODY2MDAsInBhdHJvbl9pZCI6MTcwODE4MjJ9.brN-vIlMHgViktyGOd6Wo_eDlR8C487oAnLTG6kAROE
LikeLike
A beautiful piece. Thanks for sharing it, Christine!
LikeLike
Thanks for the link, Christine. I just joined Sweeney’s blog so I could read it.
LikeLike
Don’t forget that the murdering of dissidents in Russia began during Boris Yeltsin’s reign, the person the Clintons openly campaigned for in Russia. This is from a 2013 article by Stephen Cohen. “The corruption rampant in Russia today, from seizures of major private investments to bribes demanded by officials, is a direct outgrowth of the violent and other illicit measures that accompanied “privatization” under Yeltsin. It was then that the “swindlers and thieves” denounced by today’s opposition actually emerged.” “According to the American Committee to Protect Journalists, 77 Russian journalists have been murdered since 1992—41 during Yeltsin’s 8 years in power, 36 during Putin’s twelve years.” Since these murders started happening 8 yrs before Putin came to power and actually decreased during Putin’s first 12 yrs it gives me cause for skepticism when the assumption is made that Putin is ordering all these hits. Who was ordering these hits before he came to powerd?
LikeLike
What you fail to take into account here is the Yeltsin-Putin nexus.
After the fall of the Soviet Union, the KGB Agent posted in East Germany Vladimir Putin went to work first for the mayor of Leningrad and then for the mayor of St. Petersburg, Anatoly Sobchek. During the Sobchek administration years, there was a program whereby the Russian state would pass ownership of raw materials like wood and oil to St. Petersburg so that the city could sell these for food because people there were hungry. Instead, Putin and Sobchek sold the raw materials and transferred the earnings to their own accounts. Yeltsin recruited Putin, who for a time worked on the transfer of ownership of assets of the former Soviet Union to the Russian Federation. Then, Yeltsin sold off former Soviet assets for nominal fees to his cronies and family members, thus creating the modern Russian oligarchy. He also promoted the relatively unknown Putin to be head of the FSB, the successor to the KGB. In the meanwhile, back in St. Petersburg, Sobchek was about to be indicted for his theft of government resources, and Putin arranged for his former boss and co-conspirator to be whisked out of Russia to Paris via a private plane in the middle of the night. Yeltsin saw this and it dawned on him that Putin was the solution to a problem Yeltsin had. Yeltsin was a drunk and in failing health. He had corruptly practically given away enormous former Soviet assets to his buddies and family members. Because of his ill health, he needed to step down and devote himself to getting treatment, but the moment he did, the new administration would probably indict Yeltsin for massive criminal misappropriation of state assets. So, Yeltsin cooked up a plan. He announced that Putin as his successor for President of Russia. Putin would then protect him from any criminal prosecution. There was only one problem, though. Putin was relatively unknown. So, all of a sudden, apartment bombings started occurring in the middle of the night throughout Moscow and then in other Russian cities. Putin was appointed to get to the bottom of these and went on television to say that they were being carried out by Chechen terrorists and that he would hunt them down and kill them as they sat on the toilets of their outhouses. This raised Putin’s profile and made him a national hero. He easily won the presidency and then pardoned Yeltsin.
However, there was a problem. One of the bombs in one of the apartments failed to explode. And when it was discovered, it was found to contain explosives ONLY AVAILABLE TO THE FSB and the Russian Military. Furthermore, investigation pointed to FSB officers who had been at the building at the time when the bomb was planted. These officers, however, mysteriously got murdered, and the evidence disappeared.
So, Putin and Yeltsin bombed a bunch of Russian apartment buildings in the middle of the night and blamed this on terrorists in a false flag operation to raise Putin’s profile so that he would be elected President so that he could then pardon Yeltsin, with whom Putin had collaborated to steal Russian assets.
THEN, after becoming president, Putin called a meeting with the oligarchs who had gotten their riches from Yeltsin and told them all that from that point all, Putin would get his vig from their business dealings (a vig is a mobster’s cut from an operation). And he promptly arrested the most high-profile of those who refused to make the payoffs. He had police stop the President of the oil company Yukos, throw a bag with an unregistered handgun into his car, and arrest him for possession of it. The oligarchs got the message.
LikeLike
Yup. Nailed it.
LikeLike
Did you really just say that the murdering of dissidents in Russia BEGAN during Boris Yeltsin’s reign? Didn’t realize it was so safe for Russian dissidents from 1917 – 1991.
Clinton was governor of Arkansas when Yeltsin took power in 1991, so he wasn’t “openly campaigning” for any foreign leader. When Clinton took office in 1993, he was certainly more pro-Yeltsin (who was already the leader) than pro-those who challenged Yeltsin’s power, although hindsight is 2020. Yeltsin – who did some terrible things as you point out – ruled for only 8 years and stepped down a year before Clinton left office. Little did he know that he could pull a Putin and not just kill of journalists but all political rivals and stay in power 3 times as long.
Yeltsin did rule at a time when the Soviet Union was breaking up and countries once under the Soviet thumb became independent. Putin didn’t like that much, did he? After much bloodshed and – thanks to Clinton – peace agreements like the Dayton accords, you might argue that some of those countries who gained independence during Yeltsin’s rule moved to democracy. Putin doesn’t like that much.
Not sure why you are defending Putin’s murdering his political rivals by invoking previous leaders from decades ago, especially the ones that stepped down from power and were pardoned by Putin.
LikeLike
Yeltsin started off as a hero. He was the guy who stood on top of a tank in front of the Russian White House, defying the soldiers, including the tank crews, that the Soviets had sent to squash the dissidents. All this was on live TV. So, Yeltsin was THE hero of the revolution that brought down the Soviet Union, that horrific and corrupt autocracy. However, Yeltsin was a drunk, and he became really corrupt. He created the Russian oligarchs by transferring former Soviet assets to his [Yeltsin’s] own buddies for pittances. And Putin helped him do that and then protected Yeltsin from prosecution. So, yes, the corruption began earlier. And yes, the entire reign of the communist dictatorship in the Soviet Union was corrupt. What’s your point?
LikeLike
Lord Acton:
“Power tends to corrupt and absolute power corrupts absolutely. Great men are almost always bad men, even when they exercise influence and not authority; still more when you superadd the tendency of the certainty of corruption by authority.”
“Despotic power is always accompanied by corruption of morality.”
LikeLike
My point is the same as yours. That what ArtsSmart posted was ridiculous. I appreciated your response, Bob. However, I was busy writing my own response, so I didn’t see your reply until after I posted mine. I probably would not have bothered to reply myself if your comprehensive reply had already been there.
I was not responding to you and I had no idea you were writing your own reply at the same time as I was (they posted one minute apart).
I hope you aren’t ascribing bad motives to me that simply don’t exist.
LikeLike
No, NYC. Not at all.
LikeLike
I’ll never understand how he could have returned to Russia, knowing he’d be arrested and likely eventually killed. He could have done so much more outside of Russia to expose Putin’s corruption and rally resistance against him & his regime. He got away with failed murder attempts previously and had to know that returning would eventually lead to his demise. He has a family & many supporters in his cause to resist Putin, and could have been much more effective from abroad by speaking out against the plans & crimes of Putin & his regime.
LikeLike
Same with Vladimir Kara-Murza. I fear for him.
LikeLike
I agree, I don’t understand his reasoning for returning to Russia except for the fact that he was a very brave man with deep convictions. Of course Putin probably would have still tried to assassinate him if Navalny had chosen to stay in exile. As you state, he could have done so much more in exile than being in the mouth of the tiger.
LikeLike
Given the ability of Putin to reach beyond Russia’s borders, no opposition leader is truly safe. Litvinenko, the attempted poisoning of Skripal are truly chilling.
I hope that Navalny’s family will be protected.
This is a very sad and troubling day.
LikeLike
Returning to Russia was courageous and crazy. Putin would not let him live. He was the last critic standing. There are others but none with the notoriety of Navalny.
LikeLike
Because he truly was a hero. A man who gave his life for his country. Men like Navalny are few and far between.
LikeLike
Lisa, the more you see of him in videos, the more you appreciate his equanimity, humor and courage. He showed that he was not afraid of Putin. The only Putin could stop him was to kill him.
LikeLike
Diane, I am sitting here in tears. I lived and worked in Russia and the FSU for twenty years from 1992 to 2011. The country gave me my daughter, who was adopted from the here.
I don’t know if you remember me but I’m with Support our schools in Sarasota Fl. We talked about your Angela Caputi necklace during a breakout session in DC in October.
Thank you for reaching out. The world lost a light today. But we can’t give up. Alexei would be disappointed if we did.
LikeLike
You are one awesome person, Lisa Schurr!!! Thank you for your posts. I so agree with you. Every good to you and yours. –Bob S.
LikeLike
Hi, Lisa,
Of course, I remember you and I’m glad you reminded me about the necklace.
Tomorrow is Navalny Day on the blog.
I am a huge fan of Alexei Navalny.
So charismatic, so courageous, so brave.
LikeLiked by 1 person
From the film “Navalny”
NARRATOR: The Kremlin hates Navalny so much they refuse to say his name.
[cut to}
NAVALNY: I was banned from everything and blacklisted, but as I became more and more famous, I was totally sure that it would be problematic for them to kill me.
INTERVIEWER OF NAVALNY: And boy, were you wrong.
NAVALNY: Yes, I was very wrong.
Find a picture of Navalny. Look upon it. That’s what courage looks like, folks.
LikeLike
Imagine a President Trump ordering the CIA director to obtain poison from the FSB in order to silence critics.
Far fetched? I don’t think so. Yesterday the NYT ran an article about the continuous slander of Democrats by GOP politicians. Their disgusting efforts to smear opponents has become normalized. A thoroughly politicized intelligence establishment is what Trump and his buddy Putin want.
LikeLike
You nailed it.
LikeLike
but her emails….
but he’s old……
LikeLike
Not even remotely far fetched. Remember this is the man who wanted to shoot nonviolent protesters in the legs.
LikeLike
Lisa,
Navalny Day in the blog is Sunday, not tomorrow.
CNN will air NAVALNY tomorrow at 9.
It won the Academy Award in 2023.
LikeLike
This news was the saddest thing I have heard in a long time. Navalny should have stayed in Europe. Like Solzhenitsyn he might have been a persistent voice for justice.
LikeLike
Sorry, James, but I don’t put Assange in the same tier as Navalny.
Navalny sacrificed his life while standing up to a brutal dictator. He faced a penalty of 30 or so years in fail. His crime: criticizing Putin. He spent his last days in a prison camp in the Arctic.
Assange leaked documents (Wikileaks) that helped elect Trump.
Sorry, but I don’t view him as a hero.
LikeLike
As I understand it, Assange leaked material that included the names of confidential informants in Afghanistan and Iraq and so put these people’s lives in danger. That is not a noble thing to do. It’s despicable. And criminal.
LikeLike
Newspapers publish “leaked” information every single day. Assange is not an American citizen. Assange is in prison because he revealed U.S. war crimes. Should Daniel Ellsberg have been jailed for many years–before being put on trial–for “leaking” the Pentagon Papers?
LikeLike
I’m not questioning what he did or didn’t do.
What I said was that his leaking of DNC emails was crucial to the election of Trump.
He may be a hero to you. Not to me.
LikeLike
I don’t consider any journalist a hero. Either you believe in press freedom or you don’t. Russia killed Navalny because he embarrassed Putin. Ukraine killed American journalist Gonzalo Lira because he embarrassed Zelensky. Julian Assange should not die in prison for practicing journalism. Free Julian Assange!
LikeLike
I first went to the Soviet Union in 1981 and then continued with bi-annual outbound trips with psychologists, psychiatrists, medical practitioners, and educators delegations. The 1983 trip was my first with the Association for Humanistic Psychology. The trip was headed by Francis Macy, then President of the AHP, longtime peace core director, and Harvard-educated Russian scholar. For twenty years, I worked with Soviet (Russia and Georgia) and Russian psychologists, scientists, and researchers at the Soviet Pedagogical Institute and schools in six different cities (Moscow, St. Petersburg, Yaroslavl, Pushchino (a secret scientific town with more than half a dozen biological and information sciences research institutes, and one of the largest radio telescopes in the country. We also supported multiple inbound trips to Georgia (US) of researchers, science teachers, and Russian students.
We had confrontations with the KGB, and Fran Macy insisted if we talked about sensitive topics, we would do it outside. The period that we (I worked with administrators and science teachers in Georgia, as well as professors from local universities in the state. It was a time of radical change during collaborative projects with Soviet and Russian colleagues. I recall staying in one of Moscow’s hotels and noticing that there was a conference on the topic of taxation in a democracy. Oddly, one of the graduate students in physics, Wong Hu, worked with our team to design the website for our project in 1992. But, he also informed me that he was working with a team at GSU who were helping the Russians figure out how to tax.
One event that had an impact on me was the struggle that Soviet Jews had if they wanted to immigrate to Israel. In 1983, I joined many Jewish colleagues to go to the only operating Synagogue in Moscow to celebrate Yom Kippur. The plaza outside the Synagogue was crowded with hundreds of people, most of whom were refuseniks denied permission to emigrate. They lost their jobs and depended on friends and family for survival. We talked with many in small groups out on the plaza. This was part of the emigration movements in the Soviet Union beginning in the 60s. For those who’ve grown up in a democratic society, listening to them tell their stories of resistance and survival was important. One young man told me he was making money teaching Hebrew to children. The people I met were brave and believed that they would eventually make it out of the country.
Alexei Navalny was an epic Russian dissident and leader of a political party that opposed the authoritarian dictatorial rule of Putin. In the 20 years going to Russia and receiving inbound groups of Russians at the Hartsfield-Jackson Airport in Atlanta, we came in contact with dissidents. But more importantly, because I worked with so many Russian teachers and educators, many teachers and professors opposed the Soviet system and saw the openings by Gorbachev as a chance to fulfill some of their dreams. One mathematics teacher in St. Petersburg (Leningrad at the time) told me that he was thrilled by these opportunities because he published his first book of poetry in Paris. I went to dinners with dozens of Russian teachers who established a more liberal approach to education in their schools.
Yet, a reality hit me while I was sitting in my office at Georgia State University. The phone rang, and the person on the phone said he wanted to arrange a meeting with me. I asked who he was and where he worked. He said, oh, I’m from the Agency. Agency, I said. What agency? He said the CIA. We arranged a meeting, but he told me not to tell anyone about it and would arrange campus parking. Yes, to both. When he arrived, he said they had noticed I made 4 or 5 trips to the Soviet Union. What was I doing there? I gave him the details of our project to bring Russians and Americans together. I had to leave my office for a minute, and when I came back, he had looked at some of the books I had written on science and science teaching. He asked if I brought any of these books to Moscow. I said yes and gave them to folks I met. Then he asked, do you think these books will affect Soviet Education? I looked at him and said, I don’t think so; they’ve not affected education in the USA. That was that. Two years later, he called and asked if I would write a letter of recommendation for his application for an MBA at GSU. Of course, I did.
LikeLike
Wow. Fascinating!!! Thanks for sharing this.
LikeLiked by 1 person
Thank you, Bob
LikeLike
I think being forced to take a walk outside in the artic circle during winter will kill anyone, who isn’t allowed to wear any clothes except what he had on when the guards dragged him off of whatever slab of concrete he was sleeping on without a blanket, not let him put any warm clothing on, push him out a door into the cold below freezing artic weather in his skivvies and shout, “Go for a walk. If you return in a few hours, we might let you back in. Don’t bother knocking.”
LikeLiked by 1 person
Yup. It was probably something like that.
LikeLike
That sounds about right, Lloyd. I would add the possibility that they hosed him down before the walk.
LikeLike
You have to wonder what threatening message Putin means to send, as the Munich Security Conference is in progress, and Navalny’s wife Yulia is in attendance there. There is video of Navalny at a hearing yesterday, joking with the judge and guards. Then, he was dead. Putin just beaming out he’s untouchable – and dangerous.
LikeLike
Clear message: anyone who defies my absolute power is a dead man walking. Remember Progozhin, head of the Wagner Group; his airplane exploded shortly after takeoff. Now Navalny. A vigorous 47-year-old man goes for “a walk” in the Arctic and suddenly dies. Hmmm. Did they hose him down before they sent him out to take a walk in subzero temps?
LikeLike
I lived and worked in the FSU for 20 years. Putin is a thug. Navalny was a hero. Sometimes it takes a death to know what a life is worth. I hold Trump equally culpable for this murder. He told Putin and the world that he was willing to let Putin do “whatever the hell” he wants. And he just did. Do wereally think the timing was coincidental?
To Julia Navalny and her children: Мы скорбим вместе с тобой.
LikeLike
takze
LikeLike
takzhe
LikeLike