Over the past week, there was a surge of articles about the danger that Donald Trump poses to our democracy. Trump ratcheted up his threats to punish his enemies and to replace the civil service with Trump loyalists. When his admirer Sean Hannity asked him point blank whether he intended to be a dictator—expecting he would say “of course not”—Trump responded he would be a dictator “only on the first day,” when he would command the completion of the border wall with Mexico and “drill, drill, drill.” Trump’s rhetoric no longer sounds like a normal candidate. But he was never a normal candidate.
Some commentators noted that his threats were unprecedented, yet they barely caused a ripple. He said that certain generals who served him yet denounced him deserved to be executed. What would the press have done if Obama had made such a statement? It would have been front-page news for days, not a blip. Trump has normalized threats of violence. His base has come to expect promises of violence from him. He doesn’t disappoint them.
In his first term, he reached out to some who were not in his personal orbit. He won’t make that mistake if there is a next time.
The article that generated the most attention was written by Robert Kagan in The Washington Post, titled “A Trump Dictatorship Is Increasingly Ibrvitable. We Should Stop Pretending.”
Kagan was a noted neoconservative but left the GOP in 2016 because he couldn’t accept Trump. His recent article is 7,500 words. I read it late at night and couldn’t sleep. Kagan’s article laid out the case that Trump will win the nomination; that no elected Republican will stand up to him; that he stands a good chance of being re-elected; and that if he is, he will surround himself with toadies and wreak havoc on our democracy. He predicted, as the title says, that Trump would have no guardrails, no respect for the norms of the Presidency, and no regard for the Constitution.
He said that would use the Justice Department to harass and punish his enemies.
A few quotes from his article:
Let’s stop the wishful thinking and face the stark reality: There is a clear path to dictatorship in the United States, and it is getting shorter every day. In 13 weeks, Donald Trump will have locked up the Republican nomination.
Once Trump sweeps Super Tuesday, he writes, Republicans will fall in line behind him and so will big donors. All of the other GOP candidates except Chris Christie will endorse him.
Meanwhile, Biden will have trouble unifying his party. The news media love to run stories about disenchanted Democratic voters who will stay home. Biden faces challenges from third-party candidates, including Jill Stein, Robert Kennedy Jr., and possibly a No Labels candidate like Joe Manchin.
Trump “enjoys the usual advantage of non-incumbency, namely: the lack of any responsibility. Biden must carry the world’s problems like an albatross around his neck, like any incumbent, but most incumbents can at least claim that their opponent is too inexperienced to be entrusted with these crises. Biden cannot. On Trump’s watch, there was no full-scale invasion of Ukraine, no major attack on Israel, no runaway inflation, no disastrous retreat from Afghanistan. It is hard to make the case for Trump’s unfitness to anyone who does not already believe it.”
Trump enjoys some unusual advantages for a challenger, moreover. Even Ronald Reagan did not have Fox News and the speaker of the House in his pocket. To the degree there are structural advantages in the coming general election, in short, they are on Trump’s side. And that is before we even get to the problem that Biden can do nothing to solve: his age.
Trump also enjoys another advantage. The national mood less than a year before the election is one of bipartisan disgust with the political system in general. Rarely in American history has democracy’s inherent messiness been more striking. In Weimar Germany, Hitler and other agitators benefited from the squabbling of the democratic parties, right and left, the endless fights over the budget, the logjams in the legislature, the fragile and fractious coalitions. German voters increasingly yearned for someone to cut through it all and get something — anything — done. It didn’t matter who was behind the political paralysis, either, whether the intransigence came from the right or the left.
Today, Republicans might be responsible for Washington’s dysfunction, and they might pay a price for it in downballot races. But Trump benefits from dysfunction because he is the one who offers a simple answer: him. In this election, only one candidate is running on the platform of using unprecedented power to get things done, to hell with the rules. And a growing number of Americans claim to want that, in both parties. Trump is running against the system. Biden is the living embodiment of the system. Advantage: Trump…
If Trump does win the election, he will immediately become the most powerful person ever to hold that office. Not only will he wield the awesome powers of the American executive — powers that, as conservatives used to complain, have grown over the decades — but he will do so with the fewest constraints of any president, fewer even than in his own first term.
What limits those powers? The most obvious answer is the institutions of justice — all of which Trump, by his very election, will have defied and revealed as impotent. A court system that could not control Trump as a private individual is not going to control him better when he is president of the United States and appointing his own attorney general and all the other top officials at the Justice Department. Think of the power of a man who gets himself elected president despite indictments, courtroom appearances and perhaps even conviction? Would he even obey a directive of the Supreme Court? Or would he instead ask how many armored divisions the chief justice has?
Will a future Congress stop him? Presidents can accomplish a lot these days without congressional approval, as even Barack Obama showed. The one check Congress has on a rogue president, namely, impeachment and conviction, has already proved all but impossible — even when Trump was out of office and wielded modest institutional power over his party.
Another traditional check on a president is the federal bureaucracy, that vast apparatus of career government officials who execute the laws and carry on the operations of government under every president. They are generally in the business of limiting any president’s options. As Harry S. Truman once put it, “Poor Ike. He’ll say ‘do this’ and ‘do that’ and nothing at all will happen.” That was a problem for Trump is his first term, partly because he had no government team of his own to fill the administration. This time, he will. Those who choose to serve in his second administration will not be taking office with the unstated intention of refusing to carry out his wishes. If the Heritage Foundation has its way, and there is no reason to believe it won’t, many of those career bureaucrats will be gone, replaced by people carefully “vetted” to ensure their loyalty to Trump.
Trump might decide he wants a third term. Who will stop him? The Constitution? The 22nd Amendment? The Congress? Not likely.
Trump as President will pursue those who tried to stop him. He pledged in his Veterans Day speech to “root out the Communists, Marxists, Fascists, and Radical Left Thugs that live like vermin within the confines of our Country, lie, steal, and cheat on Elections, and will do anything possible, whether legally or illegally, to destroy America, and the American Dream.” Note the equation of himself with “America and the American Dream.” It is he they are trying to destroy, he believes, and as president, he will return the favor.
What will that look like? Trump has already named some of those he intends to go after once he is elected: senior officials from his first term such as retired Gen. John F. Kelly, Gen. Mark A. Milley, former attorney general William P. Barr and others who spoke against him after the 2020 election; officials in the FBI and the CIA who investigated him in the Russia probe; Justice Department officials who refused his demands to overturn the 2020 election; members of the Jan. 6 committee; Democratic opponents including Rep. Adam B. Schiff (Calif.); and Republicans who voted for or publicly supported his impeachment and conviction.
But that’s just the start. After all, Trump will not be the only person seeking revenge. His administration will be filled with people with enemies’ lists of their own, a determined cadre of “vetted” officials who will see it as their sole, presidentially authorized mission to “root out” those in the government who cannot be trusted. Many will simply be fired, but others will be subject to career-destroying investigations. The Trump administration will be filled with people who will not need explicit instruction from Trump, any more than Hitler’s local gauleiters needed instruction. In such circumstances, people “work toward the Führer,” which is to say, they anticipate his desires and seek favor through acts they think will make him happy, thereby enhancing their own influence and power in the process.
Prepare for a new McCarthyism as Trump and his MAGA lackeys go after the “anti-American” Democrats whom he calls “”Communists,””Marxists,” “Fascists,” and “vermin.”
How will Americans respond to the first signs of a regime of political persecution? Will they rise up in outrage? Don’t count on it. Those who found no reason to oppose Trump in the primaries and no reason to oppose him in the general are unlikely to experience a sudden awakening when some former Trump-adjacent official such as Milley finds himself under investigation for goodness knows what. They will know only that Justice Department prosecutors, the IRS, the FBI and several congressional committees are looking into it. And who is to say that those being hounded are not in fact tax cheaters, or Chinese spies, or perverts, or whatever they might be accused of? Will the great body of Americans even recognize these accusations as persecution and the first stage of shutting down opposition to Trump across the country?
Kagan says that the odds of a Trump dictatorship are growing by the day. In 2016, it was completely improbable that a man such as trump would win the Republican nomination, and completely unlikely that he would win the Presidency. And it was unthinkable that when he lost in 2020, he would insist that he won in a landslide, and even crazier that his base would believe the Big Lie. Republicans will cower in fear before him; Democrats will protest, maybe take to the streets, but Trump will invoke the Insurrection Act to shut them down.
Who will have the courage to stand up to Trump when the risk is not just losing your political office but arrest, detention, public humiliation, and the loss of your freedom?
It is just astounding and mind-numbing to think that people will vote for this blow-hard killer clown after all he has said and done. It’s beyond tragic for this country.
yup
Trump is a unique danger for sure, but millions of people who don’t much like him will grudgingly vote for him as the only way to prevent Joe Biden and eventually Kamala Harris from being President from 2025-2029. That Biden does not lead Trump in polls by a wide margin – he trails Trump at this time – shows how politically weak Biden is. He is likely to only get weaker over the next year as more revelations about the Biden family influence-peddling activities become known to even more people.
Democrats should replace Biden with a stronger candidate who isn’t compromised by the ethics and legal challenges that Biden faces. Biden will not voluntarily step aside – he’ll have to pushed aside – because his entire 50+ year political career has been devoted to the goal of becoming and then Remaining President.
Good grief. Numerous polls say that around 70% of American voters do not want a Trump vs. Biden matchup in 2024, but very likely that’s what we’ll get.
I agree. Biden needs to resign. It’s time. And then we need actual debates for actual primaries.
Let’s rewrite this:
“Republicans should replace Trump with a candidate who isn’t compromised by the ethics and legal challenges that Trump faces.”
“Trump will not voluntarily step aside – he’ll have to pushed aside – because his entire newly discovered political career has been devoted to the goal of becoming and then Remaining President.”
No hyperbole: Trump is, quite literally, insane.
And he is leading Biden in most polls.
On Trump’s watch, there was no full-scale invasion of Ukraine, no major attack on Israel, no runaway inflation, no disastrous retreat from Afghanistan.
I live, these days, in an apartment. My rent went up 27 percent his year. It went up over 25 percent each year before that. My grocery bills have increased by 50 percent. My electricity bills have also increased by 50 percent. I just got notice that I will be getting a 3.2 percent Social Security Cost of Living increase.
I don’t know what universe the folks who create the federal food prices indexes live in, but it isn’t this one.
My groceries and electricity have increased by around 50 percent IN ONE YEAR’S TIME.
A 75 percent increase in rent in three years’ time.
And I’m getting a 3.2 percent COLA. Oh boy. Isn’t that freaking grand.
Quit complaining ya freeloader! 😉
Yes I got that huge SS increase notice. It won’t even buy a half a tank of gas. Went to the grocery store, had a little cart nowhere near full–over $100.
Haaaa!!!! Yeah, the COLA is a joke. A really bitter bad joke. Half a tank of gas. Half a concert ticket. Almost two rib eye steaks.
Duane and Bob:
You two have it all wrong. Us old people are getting stronger. I used to fight to haul $100 worth of groceries. Now I walk out of the store with it in one hand. I am becoming a marvel character as fast as I age.
I’m also getting prettier and prettier. But that’s another story.
I posted this one one other blog site but believe it is worth reading. It’s B.S. and creative thinking at its highest.
I got this from a Trump lover. I guess we’re now supposed to bow down to this great leader who is under indictment and is being sued many times.
……………………………………………….
This is the complete list of President Trump’s accomplishments over his four years in office originally posted at WhiteHouse.gov and archived here because of the likelihood that the Biden Administration will remove it. https://newstalk1130.iheart.com/featured/common-sense-central/content/2021-01-19-the-complete-list-of-president-trumps-accomplishments/
It’s amazing they can make the laziest, craziest President ever look like FDR.
Bob – your comment is a perfect example of my question. This man rants and raves daily. He consumes more air time and media attention of all kinds than any other politician. Has he ONCE UTTERED A SENTENCE ABOUT food prices? Your rent? Quality of education (not culture war diversions)? Jobs? Health and education shortages? Fighting cancer? Crime? Demise of public services in rural America. NOTHING.
Add it the regular jobs like FDA and other agencies that help and protect us.
There is all we hear bloated about in the news yet we live in what is now the alternate universe: our day jobs, family, and getting through the week.
All his ranting does not lead to change in domestic public policy and governance to make our world a little better. All his ranting does is set up scapegoats when problems are ignored and not addressed and he can round up the predictable suspect.
This is pretty sick, folks.
American adults clearly do not pay much attention. They are clueless about this. They think that the price of gasoline is due to Joe Biden. They think that Trump cares about “the little guy.” We have to deal with the electorate as it is. And as it is, it is possible that Trump might actually win, with disastrous consequences.
Last weekend, two things happened that point out the complex nature of politics. Both explain why so many people vote for people that hurt them.
I had a conversation with a guy who was a truck driver/mechanic. He blamed Biden for the extra $50 that recently began to come out of his paycheck. He is a great guy. He is a caring and giving person, and has hosted more than a thousand foster kids over the years. But he gets his news from sources that are not news, but are Republican spin factories. He will never vote for a democrat, because his sources tell him otherwise.
The second thing that happened is way more sinister, but it also underlines why a democrat cannot hope for a vote from certain people in this generation. We were having a fundraiser in which we served breakfast. One of the choir children serving food is of mixed race background. aA person she was serving asked that she be served by a “white” person. This second story I got second hand or third hand, but the kids said it was real. The person who did this would vote for Trump because it is he who gave her or him the freedom to crawl out from under the rock that covered this type of attitude.
Both these things are alarming when it comes to the maintenance of democratic norms.
I am not a religious person, but I am almost inclined to start praying that Trump is imprisoned before the election.
I’d vote for Biden even if he was 300 years old, given the alternative. The choice is simple, Attila the Hun or a very decent and competent president, Joe Biden. Trump is not exactly a spring chicken.
But here is the bottom line: Biden could well lose. Despite how you and I will vote, and we should not be taking that risk. The risk is too great. The Precautionary Principle applies here, big time.
In other words, it’s not a matter of how committed progressives like you and me will vote. It’s a matter of Biden’s breathtakingly low approval ratings and the history of Democrats not coming out to vote when that is the case.
WE DO NOT HAVE THE LUXURY OF RISKING RUNNING A CANIDATE WHO COULD WELL LOSE TO TRUMP. Why? Because this time, even Trump, the slowest of slow learners, will put yes men (mostly men) in place to do his vile bidding. And the Extreme Court that he engineered will let him do that.
in the spring of 1864 the growing conventional wisdom was that Abraham Lincoln’s presidency was toast. The incompetence of his generals on the battlefield and the war fatigue of the citizenry would bring someone else to the White House requiring negotiations for peace with an unrepentant South. Although we have are dealing with a social media sphere that was not available for the Southern cause in the 19th century, the philosophical underpinnings of bigotry and autocracy are similar. Also, Lincoln won that November in a landslide. Something more contemporary you ask? In the fall of 2011, Nate Silver of 538 fame, I do not understand why he still has a job, declared Obama had a 17% chance of retaining the presidency in 2012. Obama won handily. Is it possible for Trump to win in 2024? Certainly. However, this “Chicken Little” reporting that has become so prevalent in recent weeks ignores what has been happening with the electorate since 2016. Every election with national relevance has gone Democratic. Yes, Biden’s poll numbers have been down, but three of the last four Presidents have had similar numbers at this stage in their presidency and the two democrats, Obama and Clinton, won reelection. Government is not popular, thank you Ronald Reagan, but compared to the other branches and other leaders around the world, Biden is polling well. Part of what we are witnessing is an eastern political establishment that has little regard for the American electorate and is scared to death of the right wing bench that is the intellectual underpinning of Trumpism. Trump won in 2016 because the American People were fed up with that same establishment and was willing to take a gamble on Trump. In 2020, the electorate saw the dangers of Trump and more voted for Biden than any other president before him providing a seven million vote cushion. Yes, it was close in the “battle ground” states, but there are steps Biden has taken in the form of legislation and support for unions that will help going into 2024. In 2022, all we heard from “legacy media” was of the impending red wave that turned out to be a low tide. Do we have work to do? Yes. Democrats need to not only remind voters of Trumps impending dangers, but they also have to articulate what they stand for, what they have done, and what they plan to do. Political elites need to stop cowering and get out in the country to win.
The Bureau of Labor Statistics collects price data to determine the Consumer Price Index; CPI is the most commonly used measure of inflation, although there are other indices. A few months ago an article in the Wall Street Journal described how CPI is compiled. Hundreds of BLS employees go “shopping” at thousands of retailers of all types in all areas of the U.S. BLS then uses various statistical methods – which I don’t begin to understand – to calculate an average inflation rate for the entire country over given time periods, most commonly over the last twelve months.
It’s unavoidable that the inflation rates that different people experience vary – in your case, varies widely. If memory serves me this morning, you live in the Tampa area. Population has grown rapidly there as in most areas of Florida. Housing construction hasn’t kept pace with demand for rental units, so building owners have been able to raise rents substantially. Over the weekend the Wall Street Journal published an article saying that rents have started to level off or even decline in many areas because of overbuilding; I’m not sure about Florida. Fortunately for me and my wife, we have a fixed 2.125% rate mortgage on our house; housing cost inflation has no impact on us other than increasing property taxes.
I do at least half of the grocery shopping for my wife and me now that we’re empty-nesters. My sense is that food price inflation hasn’t leveled-off, but I don’t have exact data.
The facts you cite in your comment are precisely why the execrable Trump leads Biden in the polls right now. Like it or not, dissatisfaction with day-to-day realities like inflation are – for most people – more salient than potential threats to democracy in the future.
I replied in the wrong area! I was responding to Bob Shepherd’s first comment. Time to go to work.
Yeah, I’ve looked into that, Jack. But there is a disconnect between that STORY and the reality that I see in my local supermarket. Amazon Fresh has rib eye steaks right now (I just looked) at $37.73/lb.
And yes, for a couple years, Tampa led the nation in rental cost increases.
Here’s an idea, why can’t the freaking geniuses who run SS index the increase to the COL of the primary residence?
A high-school kid could write a program to do that.
Kagan’s analysis- no mention of right wing religious voters?
– lot of support for his opinion that they’re not relevant voters for the outcome -it’s a viewpoint- somebody else might expand the narrative and ask if the religious right will give Haley ( a non-man and non-Christian/Catholic, a primary vote).
As regards Soc. Sec., it was never meant to replace a pension or be your only source of income in retirement. SS was meant to supplement your pension (if you belong to that lucky club) and your savings, if you have any. Sadly, a huge chunk of Americans don’t have a pension or any substantial savings. So they depend on SS solely which the GOP is determined to cut, slice and destroy. Why do so many folks hate teachers? One of the reasons is teachers have pensions, how dare they. Thanks in large part to the teachers’ unions. I think a 3 legged stool describes the ideal situation in retirement = SS+pension+savings.
I started with nothing. I built a successful business and became a successful executive. I was quite well to do. But then I lost it all in the real-estate crash of 2007-8. Crash and burn. LOL. So, I’m one of those. But I’m fine. In comparison to most people in the world and throughout history, I live like a freaking raja.
Joe,
You know quite well that Republicans led the crusade to eliminate pensions and unions, leaving most retirees dependent on Social Security only.
Absolutely correct, the GOP hates unions and pensions. Yes, most folks do depend on SS only but that’s because there’s a war on unions in this country. In addition, the GOP, (like some slathering ghoul), wants to make cuts to SS and raise the retirement age to 99 or something like that. The GOP candidates are talking about “fixing” SS. What a cruel joke, their idea of fixing is like a surgeon performing an operation with an unsanitized butcher’s knife.
Any problems with SS could be fixed by raising the tax cap, problem solved for generations. SS is Not going bankrupt, that’s a lie. The trust fund could be depleted in the 2030s if nothing is done but SS itself could still pay 75% of benefits.
Traitor Trump cannot end Democracy without help from his MAGA RINO base. Trump complains about someone in the justice system or the Democratic party or an election worker, and it is the traitor’s fascists MAGO RINO base that threatens those individuals: juries, judges, prosecutors, court workers, election workers, Republicans that dare to stand up to Trump, Democrats that refuse to cower and hide…
What about a hero list for those that are standing up to Traitor Trump and his MAGA RINOs, regardless of the threats.
I’ll start the list.
Jack Smith
Liz Cheney
Mitt Romney
Rick Wilson
Steve Schmidt
George T. Conway III
John Weaver
Reed Galan
Jennifer Horn
Alvin Bragg Jr.
Fani Willis
Letitia James
E. Jeanne Carroll