Thom Hartmann, journalist and blogger, describes the loathsome identity of the Republican Party. It was once a sensibly Conservative Party that believed in local control and minimal government. It boasted leaders like Dwight D. Eisenhower, Howard Baker, Leverett Saltonstall, and Margaret Chase Smith.
What does the GOP believe today, other than cutting taxes for the richest?
Today, the GOP leaders peddle lies and conspiracy theories. On social media, they take turns smearing Biden (“the Biden crime family”) and retailing any charges they stumble across on the internet. I am appalled whoever I read any Tweet (X) posted by Ted Cruz, Josh Hawley, Jim Jordan, or other current GOP leaders.
You will not hear from any of them a hint of bipartisanship. It’s all hate, hate, hate. They call their opposition whatever names come to mind: socialists, Communists, radical left, fascists. Their words have no substantive meaning. They are intended to spread hate and fear.
Hartman explains why they stoke hate: They have no substantive ideas to improve people’s lives.
Hartmann writes:
So, Donald Trump says that if Judge Tanya Chutkan orders him not to reveal details of the prosecution’s case before they can be presented to a jury, including the names, addresses, and testimony of witnesses against him, he’s going to do it anyway and challenge the court.
And there’s little reason to believe he won’t do it: he’ll take what he’s asserting as his First Amendment right to troll and threaten witnesses against him all the way to the Supreme Court he packed with three rightwing crackpots. If nothing else, it may buy him enough time to get elected president and pardon himself before he’s convicted.
In this, Trump has raised vicious social media trolling into a form of electoral performance art. He’s become our troll-in-chief.
America has been under the sway of rightwing trolls before. When I was a child in the 1950s, Republican Senator Joe McCarthy was conducting an active witch-hunt for “communists” in the federal government. This was the era when Robert Oppenheimer lost his security clearance for, in part, declaring himself a “New Deal Democrat” and standing up to the witch hunters, as characterized in the new movie about his making the bomb.
McCarthy destroyed the lives of thousands of people, and many were imprisoned because of his efforts. Historian Ellen Schrecker estimates his victims at over 10,000. He — and his right hand man, Roy Cohn (who went on to be Trump’s mentor) — were classic trolls in the worst sense of the word.
Some of McCarthy’s efforts live to this day, including his insistence throughout the Army-McCarthy hearings on never saying “Democratic Party” but, instead, always saying, “Democrat Party.”
Similarly, McCarthy echoed the John Birch Society’s (JBS) argument that America is not a democracy but a republic, an argument that James Madison made — and then refuted — when he was trying to sell the US Constitution. McCarthy’s and the JBS’s apparent rationale was that “democracy” sounds too much like Democratic while “republic” evokes good feelings for the Republican Party.
Nelson Rockefeller, who would become Gerald Ford’s Vice President, got a dose of this with the John Birch Society-pushed Goldwater sweep of the Republican Party at their 1964 convention.
“It is essential that this convention repudiate here and now,” he said over boos and chants, “any doctrinaire, militant minority, whether Communist, Ku Klux Klan, or Bircher (pause for ‘republic not democracy!’ chants set off by his attacking the John Birch Society)…”
Today’s trolling, however, has gone beyond the fringes defined in that era by the JBS, Cohn, and the occasional McCarthyite wannabee. It’s become the core, the essential identity, of the post-Trump GOP.
From “rolling coal” trucks blowing poisonous smoke at Prius and EV drivers, to “Free helicopter rides for liberals” tee shirts invoking Pinochet’s murders, to hate groups and militia members showing up at school board meetings, today’s Republican Party has fully embraced hate and trolling.
“Owning the libs” is the main online sport of many Republicans today, as you can see by following the social media feeds or reading the hate mail of any high-profile progressives or Democrats.
In large part that’s because Republicans don’t have anything else to present to Americans as a positive national governing agenda.
Please open the link to read the rest of this excellent post.

There was a time when Thom Hartmann was a nuanced, in-depth thinker. How has he devolved into this shallow partisan hack constantly going after obvious low hanging fruit? Does this article contribute even one word that hasn’t been said ad nauseum? And Trump’s followers/rabid right-wingers certainly aren’t going to be converted by anything in here. This is just punching-the-clock level work from someone who should be better.
LikeLike
He is trying to “wake” people like you.
LikeLike
The words have no substantive
meaning. The acrimony is not in
the way of the MIC, big pharma,
insurance complex,prison complex,
wealth complex, on and on.
Vote Joe, he’ll fix things
that unfolded under his
watch. He’s got the power
now. Damn republicans…
LikeLike
?
LikeLike
K.I.S.S. YES
LikeLike
The GOP has no meaningful plan to move this country forward. Yet, so many people believe they do because they respond to the erroneous belief that schoolyard bullies have leadership skills.
Democrats need to actively improve their messaging to countermand the GOP messaging that Biden is weak and feeble. As Hartmann notes:
“Joe Biden has seen more jobs created on his watch than the last three Republican presidents combined.
Inflation is down and both unemployment and factory construction are at levels we haven’t seen since the 1960s.
The country is rapidly greening its power and transportation systems.
People of good will are showing up in record numbers to vote for women’s rights, civil rights, and a return to fair taxation of billionaires. Yesterday’s Ohio vote is a very good sign.”
Democrats need to do a better job of selling Biden’s policies. Biden is not responsible for continuing inflation, but regular people are often on the media blaming Biden. The economy, that still is not serving the bottom two thirds of Americans well, will be a key issue in 2024. The left should not allow the radical right to get away with their false narrative. Robert Reich thinks Democrats need to adopt economic populism, but it would mean Democrats would have to stop giving Wall St priority over Main Street, and the DNC would lose some of their big donors. https://www.commondreams.org/opinion/economic-vs-cultural-populism
LikeLike
Biden needs to step aside now.
LikeLike
Who would you put in his place. I happen to think he has done a fantastic job. Unemployment at 3.6% while inflation falls. Name a country in the G20 with a lower unemployment or inflation rate. Would I prefer a left wing fire breathing populist demigod capable of delivering pain to the Right ,absolutely. Could that person make it through a primary?
LikeLike
see below
LikeLike
Who do you see replacing Biden for the Democrats?
LikeLike
I think that Biden has been an outstanding president. Much better than I expected. Newsom or Warnock. I think that Raphel Warnock would make an outstanding president. Maybe a ticket of Warnock and Buttigieg.
LikeLike
I love Robert Reich. He has done a series (The Common Good) on his Substack. This is how we got to where we are today (Trump is a symptom…the “cause” started 50 yrs ago). It’s a good read
https://robertreich.substack.com/p/the-common-good-chapter-4-exploitation
LikeLike
I’m dismayed by what the Republican party has become: a cult of personality, led by the lowest character person to ever be President. We need two responsible major parties that disagree on policy matters while staying within long accepted norms of personal conduct.
But this blog continues to ignore the serious issue regarding the attempted bribery of Joe Biden. There is no plausible explanation for the Biden family receiving $20+ million from shady foreign entities – and then hiding it in 20+ shell companies – other than it was attempted bribery of Joe. Most journalists are trying to convince the public that absent clearcut evidence of Joe personally receiving the $20+ million there is nothing questionable here. Bunk – many people have accepted bribes to benefit their family members, and it’s still a criminal act. I speak from authority here – I’ve personally investigated scenarios like the Bidens are involved in. Democrats would advance the public interest by picking a more honorable candidate in 2024 than Joe Biden.
LikeLike
Mark
Mix it up a bit- which Republican candidate and which Democrat can beat him (Nikki doesn’t have a prayer at getting the nomination)?
LikeLike
Thank God for that.
LikeLike
If Nikki was the nominee, the base would stay home for obvious reasons ( a good thing)
LikeLike
It’s sad that there are commenters here who just parrot what right-wing media and right-wing Republican cranks like James Comer say, and then expect to be taken seriously.
Lies are still lies.
Take a read:
https://www.washingtonpost.com/politics/2023/08/17/how-republicans-overhype-findings-their-hunter-biden-probe/
LikeLike
Democracy,
I could block the Trumpers who have been brainwashed but I find their comments interesting. Interested that adults could swallow lies so completely.
LikeLike
A lengthy discussion yesterday with my neighbor who rejected the Covid vaccine was insightful about the GOP base’s insecurity. The specific topic was one that isn’t in Fox’s wheelhouse so, my neighbor’s original thinking was interesting. The neighbor has bladder cancer. The doctor’s prescription is chemo and radiation. Instead, the neighbor searched the internet and went to the Hoxsey clinic in Mexico. Hoxsey’s personal stories were relatable. The medical info. he found on-line was baffling and it made him suspicious. He wanted to craft a feeling of control.
Before the trip to Mexico, the neighbor sat, while the doctor walked out midway through his appointment after the neighbor tried to explain that ivermectin cures cancer. Hoxsey’s tonic reflected the idea that one “medicine” can cure all cancers. The plan was soothing to my neighbor. Based on experience, he had anticipated the dissonance of being powerless, surrounded by people he thought felt superior and that required he trust in things he didn’t understand.
Trump taps into the base’s processing of the world around them better than most.
Dems have a tough job trying to get a segment of the GOP base. They’ve got to first find a sweet spot that boxes out bigoted views based on demographics. Then, they’ve got to shed the image of intellectual elites. And then, tap into decision making by people who rely on emotion.
LikeLike
I just checked online, and this is really unfortunate because bladder cancer is extremely survivable IF one gets actual treatment.
Darwin Award
LikeLike
cx: unfortunate
LikeLike
Why you or I would want a highly educated specialist who knew more than we did and my neighbor wouldn’t, must have an explanation.
LikeLiked by 1 person
it will be Michael I mean michelle Obama
LikeLike
One of the most important articles that I’ve read in a long time:
https://www.msn.com/en-us/news/world/worldwide-fascism-is-being-accelerated-by-the-one-thing-few-people-want-to-talk-about-opinion/ar-AA1fBp5i?ocid=msedgntp&cvid=bd7c4bd601b04c949163aa2bea89565e&ei=13
LikeLike
Koch is behind the campaign that denies the world the opportunity to stop global warming. He is aligned with right wing religionists which echoes the Great Hunger period in Ireland when 1,000,000 starved to death. And, gross income inequality, is the result of his GOP economic strategy.
He wants everything to burn down with him. I hope he goes first.
LikeLiked by 1 person
A lawyer has been charged in Ohio for voting twice for trump in the same election year, once in Ohio and once in Fla.
The Republican Party is a party of hate, trolls and corruption.
LikeLike
The GOP Oligarchy is an organized crime syndicate. Like all such mergers of convenience they have no coherent belief system, united only in their self-anointed right to absolute power. But they are masters in exploiting the hate and fear and just plain stupidity of their base to get what they want.
LikeLike
Yes, Jon. They want to be sure that their base stays stupid.
LikeLiked by 1 person
The Republican Party became soulless decades ago. First, it was embraced by the wealthy who decried the sacrifice of progressive taxation and then recruited those who saw no reason to give for the greater good. Then the Southern Strategy, Gingrich revolution, and the neo-cons all decided to wrap it in a bow for MAGA. I keep hoping this black hole will implode, yet 74 million voted for Trump in 2020. This is as much an indictment of America as it is an autocratic movement.
LikeLike