Heather Cox Richardson applies her excellent skills as a historian to analyze the news. Open the link to finish reading and to read footnotes.
More good news today for Bidenomics, as the gross domestic product report for the second quarter showed annualized growth of 2.4%, higher than projected, and inflation rose at a slower pace of 2.6%, down from last quarter and well below projections. Economic analyst Steven Rattner noted that as of the second quarter, “the US economy is over 6% larger than it was before COVID (after adjusting for inflation). At this point in the recovery from the Great Recession, 2011, the economy was just 0.7% larger than it had been in 2007.”
Both consumer spending and business investment, which is up 7.7% in real annualized terms, drove this growth. Business spending makes up a much smaller share of gross domestic product, but it drives future jobs and growth, and much of this growth is in manufacturing facilities. In keeping with that trend, the nation’s largest solar panel manufacturer, First Solar, announced today that it will build a fifth factory in the U.S. as alternative energy technology takes off. This commitment brings to more than $2.8 billion the amount First Solar has invested in the U.S. to ramp up production…
While many of us were watching the federal courthouse in Washington, D.C., to see if an indictment was forthcoming against former president Trump for his attempt to overturn the results of the 2020 election, a different set of charges appeared tonight. Special counsel Jack Smith brought additional charges against Trump in connection with his retention of classified documents.
The new indictment alleges that Trump plotted to delete video from security cameras near the storage room where he had stored boxes containing classified documents, and did so after the Department of Justice subpoenaed that footage. That effort to delete the video involved a third co-conspirator, Carlos De Oliveira, who has been added to the case.
De Oliveira is a former valet at the Trump Organization’s Mar-a-Lago property who became property manager there in January 2022. Allegedly, he told another Trump employee that “the boss” wanted the server deleted and that the conversation should stay between the two of them.
In the Washington Post, legal columnist Ruth Marcus wrote, “The alleged conduct—yes, even after all these years of watching Trump flagrantly flout norms—is nothing short of jaw-dropping: Trump allegedly conspired with others to destroy evidence.” If the allegations hold up, “the former president is a common criminal—and an uncommonly stupid one.”
This superseding indictment reiterates the material from the original indictment, and as I reread it, it still blows my mind that Trump allegedly compromised national security documents from the Central Intelligence Agency, the Department of Defense, the National Security Agency, the National Geospatial Intelligence Agency (surveillance imagery), the National Reconnaissance Office (surveillance and maps), the Department of Energy (nuclear weapons), and the Department of State and Bureau of Intelligence and Research (diplomatic intelligence).
It sounds like he was a one-man wrecking ball, aimed at our national security.
The Justice Department has asked again for a protective order to protect the classified information at the heart of this case. In their request, they explained that, among other things, Trump wanted to be able to discuss that classified information with his lawyers outside a Sensitive Compartmented Information Facility, or SCIF, a room protected against electronic surveillance and data leakage.
Former deputy assistant director of the FBI’s counterintelligence division Peter Strzok noted that there is “[n]o better demonstration of Trump’s abject lack of understanding of—and disregard for—classified info and national security. He is *asking the Court* to waive the requirements for classified info that EVERY OTHER SINGLE CLEARANCE HOLDER IN THE UNITED STATES must follow.”
The Senate today passed the $886 billion annual defense bill by a strong bipartisan margin of 86 to 11 after refusing to load it up with all the partisan measures Republican extremists added to the House bill. Now negotiators from the House and the Senate will try to hash out a compromise measure, but the bills are so far apart it is not clear they will be able to create a bipartisan compromise. The National Defense Authorization Act (NDAA) has passed on a bipartisan basis for more than 60 years.
The extremists in the House Republican conference continue to revolt against House speaker Kevin McCarthy’s (R-CA) deal with the administration to raise the debt ceiling. They insist the future cuts to which McCarthy agreed are not steep enough, and demand more. This has sparked fighting among House Republicans; Emine Yücel of Talking Points Memo suggests that McCarthy’s new willingness to consider impeaching President Biden might be an attempt to cut a deal with the extremists.
As the Senate is controlled by Democrats, the fight among the House Republicans threatens a much larger fight between the chambers because Democratic senators will not accept the demands of the extremist Republican representatives.
The House left for its August recess today without passing 11 of the 12 appropriations bills necessary to fund the government after September, setting up the conditions for a government shutdown this fall if they cannot pass the bills and negotiate with the Senate in the short time frame they’ve left. Far-right Republicans don’t much care, apparently. Representative Bob Good (R-VA) told reporters this week, “We should not fear a government shutdown… Most of what we do up here is bad anyway.”
Representative Katherine Clark (D-MA), the second ranking Democrat in the House, disagreed. “The Republican conference is saying they are sending us home for six weeks without funding the government? That we have one bill…out of 12 completed because extremists are holding your conference hostage, and that’s not the full story: the extremists are holding the American people hostage. We will have twelve days…when we return to fund the government, to live up to the job the American people sent us here to do. This is a reckless march to a MAGA shutdown, and for what? In pursuit of a national abortion ban? Is that what we are doing here?

You do understand that people don’t give a rat’s rear what the GDP is or what official unemployment is, right? They care whether or not they can make rent and utilities (preferably only having to work one job), buy food and fuel, get medical care and afford medications when they need to. They want to be secure in their homes and not face living in their cars or on the streets. None of that is reflected in those fancy numbers the Biden administration likes to brag about.
As for inflation, it’s still going up, just more slowly. If I gain 20 one month, 10 the next, 5 the month after that, then only two the next, I can’t brag about losing weight. I’d still be 37 pounds heavier than I was four months ago and still gaining. Similarly, prices skyrocketed over the course of 2022 and part of 2023 and have not come down – they’re still going up. And, contrary to the Biden administration lies which have been debunked, wages have gone down not up in inflation adjusted terms based on federal data.
If “Bidenomics” consists of gaslighting people working multiple jobs who still can’t afford basic necessities with fancy-schmancy voodoo statistics and convincing them that they’re doing better than they think they are, all I can say is good luck with that.
LikeLike
Moderate inflation has been the rule in the American economy since the Great Depression. Deflation has its own problems, as it usually accompanies massive unemployment. Political leaders usually exaggerate their contribution to good economic times and downplay their influence on more difficult times.
I have often wondered if our economic system can withstand a stable population. Without expanding markets, I wonder if our system will implode. Expanding population is often the stimulus for expanding markets.
While you are correct at being concerned for the people who are not keeping up, it is good news that prices are not ascending as fast.
LikeLike
dienne77’s comment invokes a narrative that was heard during the 1980 elections, when Jimmy Carter haters were saying that Carternomics did nothing except gaslight people into believing that the dishonest and untrustworthy Jimmy Carter cared about the economic hardships of poor and middle class Americans. “Are you better off today than you were 4 years ago?” asked Reagan. Jimmy Carter haters celebrated because they loved demonizing Jimmy Carter and convincing Americans that Carter didn’t want to do anything to help the middle class and poor people but was simply trying to gaslight Americans into believing that he cared when he didn’t care at all. (The proof that Carter didn’t care about those people and didn’t want to help them is that the people knew they were all worse off! If Jimmy Carter HAD wanted to make things better for them, those people would not have felt that they were worse off! You really can’t argue with that, can you?)
Hey, it worked. Reagan won big because voters just “knew” that Jimmy Carter didn’t care about helping them and Reagan did. It doesn’t matter if it’s true that Carter didn’t want to help those folks; what matters is that presenting it as something Carter didn’t fix because he didn’t care about those people and didn’t want to fix it does win election for right wing Republicans whose policies always make things worse for them.
LikeLike
You can take that analysis back to 1960, when a noisy segment of the left insisted there was no difference between JFK and Nixon. Arthur Schlesinger Jr. wrote a book in the middle of the campaign to rally support for Kennedy.
LikeLike
Y’all keep telling people that they’re just too stupid to know how good they’ve got it under Biden. I’m sure that will be effective. Again, wishing you the best of luck.
LikeLike
Missing Trump?
LikeLike
LOL, Diane, that’s the lame response one gives when one knows one has no better response. Game, set and match. Good night.
Oh, but before I go, I have to say, if Trump ever does go away, you will be the one missing him. How else are you going to convince people to re-elect the incumbent dumpster fire?
LikeLike
Biden is a good man. He has gotten extraordinary programs through a closely divided Congress. I will vote for him with conviction. You can vote for No Labels or RFK or Trump. I won’t disparage your choice. Don’t disparage mine.
LikeLike
I really am trying to go to bed but, (a) you know perfectly well I’m not voting for any of those and (b) you routinely disparage third party votes – you are convinced that the Democrats own everyone from GWB leftward.
Now, good night for real.
LikeLike
I repeat: I don’t disparage your choice. Don’t disparage mine. Biden has been a superb president.
LikeLike
You’re absolutely right, Joe Biden is a mensch. After only four years or so, he’s finally acknowledging his granddaughter. https://www.nytimes.com/2023/07/28/us/politics/biden-hunter-navy-joan-roberts-grandchild.html
LikeLike
Biden is the most unliked president since Carter. The messaging is now that his family has been collecting nearly $50 million for nothing and he has been acting as a foreign agent for many years. A fact known to Hillary and Obama. Documents are now in the Way and Means committee before getting to Comer’s committee. Biden has offshore money in banks and so many shell companies that do absolutely nothing but scuffle millions from foreign entities to the Bidens.
The only reason he has been able to get some of his radical pieces of legislation is because of a few RINOs who are afraid to leave the McConnell band wagon and some pretty spineless Democrats who refuse to represent the will of their constituents (Patty Murray is hopeless and refuses to address her constituents or even debate any competition)
LikeLike
Why did dienne77 write this absolutely false statement lying about the people who support Biden – which includes Bernie Sanders and AOC and Diane Ravitch:
“Y’all keep telling people that they’re just too stupid to know how good they’ve got it under Biden. I’m sure that will be effective.”
This is such an ugly mischaracterization of Diane Ravitch’s, AOC’s and Bernie Sanders’ support for Biden — for dienne77 to assert as fact that Bernie and AOC and Diane “KEEP TELLING PEOPLE that they’re just too stupid to know how good they’ve got it under Biden” is propaganda specifically intended to attack and disparage Biden supporters like Bernie and AOC and Diane Ravitch. Making that kind of false innuendo that those Biden supporters are “telling people that they’re just too stupid to know ” is a comment designed to undermine the credibility of Diane Ravitch and Bernie and AOC simply because they support Biden’s re-election.
Not one of those 3 folks who have said they support Biden’s re-election has told people that they are “too stupid”. All of them have simply pointed out the ways that Biden’s policies have mitigated the damage done by four years of Trump/ right wing Republican policies and all 3 of them understand that things will get better only if Democrats have a sweeping victory.
While those who profess to care about the middle class and poor keep pushing right wing lie that the Republicans are no worse than the Democrats.
I am really sick of dienne77’s ugly innuendo that Diane Ravitch and Bernie Sanders and AOC are telling voters they are stupid. They are simply telling voters THE TRUTH and dienne77 equates telling voters the truth with telling voters they are too stupid. That’s how insidious right wing propaganda is — we have been put on warning by dienne77 that she will characterize every attempt to correct a right wing lie as telling voters they are too stupid. Catch 22. Let the lie stand, or be a despicable person who tells people they are too stupid. All discussions about Biden are framed as this “heads Republicans win, tails Democrats lose” choice. Do we allow right wing propaganda to go unchecked, or do we tell voters they are “too stupid”? The right wing and their useful idiots use this framing all the time to destroy Democrats and empower the far right.
AOC has a brilliant way of countering folks like dienne77 who push the dishonest right wing narratives of Republicans and attack anyone who contradicts them. She doesn’t play into their games where the debate of the day is “how stupid does AOC believe voters are and did she call them stupid or just imply they were stupid?”. Instead, she re-frames the question and answers it. The only way to fight those who want to empower the far right is to destroy the false narratives they push instead of treating those false narratives as a valid “opinion”.
dienne77 says Diane Ravitch tells people “that they’re just too stupid to know how good they’ve got it under Biden”. Diane Ravitch says that isn’t true. Some folks here believe the world would be much better if we all agree that dienne77 has her opinion that Diane Ravitch tells people they are too stupid, and Diane Ravitch has her opinion that she doesn’t tell people they are too stupid, and we should all just agree to disagree since both opinions are equally valid. I am NOT one of those people. If that makes me a pariah, so be it. Maybe dienne77’s ugly innuendo that Diane Ravitch “keeps telling voters they are too stupid” doesn’t bother Diane, but it is wrong to allow that blatant lie to go unanswered.
LikeLike
“Biden is the most unliked president since Jimmy Carter”
So you are saying that presidents like Carter and Biden who have a lot of integrity are “unliked”?
Or are you saying that the right wing smear machine successfully pushes lies about Democrats with integrity?
April, would YOU have voted for someone other than Jimmy Carter because you felt it would be no different if Reagan won? Let me introduce you to dienne77 over here as I bet you have a lot in common.
LikeLike
Sent from my iPhone
dienne77
Enough with the crocodile tears. The bottom quin-tile of workers actually saw wage increase that exceeded the rate of inflation.
https://www.cnbc.com/2023/03/30/low-wage-workers-saw-tremendously-fast-wage-growth-since-2019.html
While 14 million other American families refinanced their mortgages at the lowest rates ever during the pandemic.
https://libertystreeteconomics.newyorkfed.org/2023/05/the-great-pandemic-mortgage-refinance-boom/
Then there are the 25% of American Workers working from home ,2 ,3 ,5 days a week saving boatloads on transportation, on food away from home, even on the dry Cleaner.
“This has significantly increased housing demand and is a key factor explaining why U.S. house prices grew 24% between November 2019 and November 2021. Analysis shows that the shift to remote work may account for more than half of overall house price increases and similar increases in rents.Sep 26, 2022”
Remote Work and Housing Demand | San Francisco Fed
And then this, Wage growth is now outpacing inflation.
https://www.nbcnews.com/business/economy/americans-are-finally-getting-raise-thanks-lower-inflation-rcna93844
Lastly
“Thats according to a new analysis from the JP Morgan Chase Institute, which studied accounts from nine million Chase customers and found Americans across all incomes have nearly 10% to 15% more in their checking and savings accounts than they did pre-pandemic. “Americans really were able to squirrel some money away.
Jul 21, 2023”
https://www.kulr8.com/news/national/report-americans-hold-more-in-bank-accounts-compared-to-pre-pandemic/video_ad22be22-2802-536d-9ca7-06ea7ba07cff.html?mode=nowapp
I normally have to do this with Trumpanzees. I have to wonder dienne?
As Chomsky said in 2016.
“However, the left should also recognize that, should Trump win based on its failure to support Clinton, it will repeatedly face the accusation (based in fact), that it lacks concern for those sure to be most victimized by a Trump administration.”
Do you feel at all guilty?. Probably not !
LikeLike
Given that AOC and Bernie already endorsed Biden for re-election, it is obvious that the smart and truthful progressives aren’t buying the false narrative that both Republicans and the same faux progressives who told us Trump was no worse than a Democrat are saying.
If you trust Bernie and AOC, then you would believe Biden is a good choice to help middle class and poor Americans.
If you trust Republicans and the few on the left who said Trump was no worse than a Democrat, and defeating the Democrat is more important than having a progressive Supreme Court that would repeal Citizens United, you would be validating and amplifying the same right wing narrative that defeated Carter in the hopes it will defeat Biden and empower the far right once again.
LikeLike
You’re talking about families with mortgages and bank accounts. You realize the poor families don’t have those things, right? And anyway, really, a study by JP Morgan Chase about economics? Next up please post a study by Phillip Morris about smoking.
LikeLike
Dienne
I take have extra patience with slow learners. You seem to have missed the first point I made about wage growth. But as that CNBC is not much better than JP Morgan Chase. Perhaps you can find fault with the Economists from the Economic Policy Institute.
Real Wages at the tenth percentile saw growth 9% ABOVE inflation through2019 -2022. The 20th to 40th percentile 3.9% above inflation. The 40th -60th percentile 2.4% above inflation ……
https://www.epi.org/publication/swa-wages-2022/
LikeLike
Nice observations Dienne. The Putin puppet’s two trillion tax cut to billionaires was designed to permanently cement the wealth gap and create an underclass of impoverished armed MAGAs bent on “retribution”.
LikeLike
What dienne’s comment reflects is the false narrative pushed by Fox and right-wing “news” sites and the Republican Party.
The truth is that the economy – even with inflation – is much better now than it was under the traitor. These charts are from February, and things are even better now than they were then:
https://www.politifact.com/article/2023/feb/06/whats-the-economic-state-of-the-union-under-joe-bi/#:~:text=3%20event%20at%20the%20White,product%20during%202022's%20fourth%20quarter.
What’s even MORE important is that dienne’s false narrative is shared by lots of people who think that Republicans are “good” for the American economy, and its workers and citizens, when – in fact – they are most assuredly not.
“there has been a stark pattern in the United States for nearly a century. The economy has grown significantly faster under Democratic presidents than Republican ones…It’s true about almost any major indicator: gross domestic product, employment, incomes, productivity, even stock prices. It’s true if you examine only the precise period when a president is in office, or instead assume that a president’s policies affect the economy only after a lag and don’t start his economic clock until months after he takes office. The gap ‘holds almost regardless of how you define success’…”
Yes, dienne, there are – in fact – “stupid” people out there who think that tax cuts for corporations and the rich actually “trickle” down to everyone else (what actually trickles down is the bill for it), that climate change is a hoax, that white people are routinely discriminated against, that January 6 wasn’t really “all that bad.” The overwhelming majority of these people are Republicans, or perhaps people with severe cognitive issues (calling April).
Why is dienne so afraid of the truth?
LikeLike
The false narrative that many believe is that Republicans are better for the economy. Biden may not be perfect, but no politician is. He needs the support of the American people because he is the only thing standing between us and authoritarianism.
LikeLike
I didn’t say Republicans are better. Republicans and Democrats both serve the rich the same way the right cross and the left jab both serve the same boxer. The jab might do less damage, but it is a necessary component of the set up for a knock out punch.
LikeLike
dienne77, why do you keep implying that Bernie and AOC are TOO STUPID to know that the Democrats are working to hurt the poor and middle class just like the Republicans are?
It seems to me that it is the height of arrogance for someone to imply that Bernie Sanders and AOC are TOO STUPID to know that the Democrats must be defeated in order to achieve any progressive victories.
FYI – those people who are claiming to be more knowledgeable than Bernie and AOC about what’s good for the country are the SAME people who think it is perfectly reasonable for Putin to bomb children and their families in Ukraine. They are likely saying that Bernie and AOC are TOO STUPID to realize that Putin is doing something good by annihilating civilians in Ukraine.
LikeLike
dienne says that “Republicans and Democrats both serve the rich the same way the right cross and the left jab both serve the same boxer.”
Are Democrats perfect? Of course not. But are they essentially the SAME as Republicans? That’s just pure nonsense.
How do I know it’s nonsense?
Here are two of the longest-serving and most respected Congressional scholars in the country with their observations from more than a decade ago (pre-Trump), and the Republican Party has only gotten WORSE — MUCH worse — since then:
“We have been studying Washington politics and Congress for more than 40 years, and never have we seen them this dysfunctional. In our past writings, we have criticized both parties when we believed it was warranted. Today, however, we have no choice but to acknowledge that the core of the problem lies with the Republican Party.”
“The GOP has become an insurgent outlier in American politics. It is ideologically extreme; scornful of compromise; unmoved by conventional understanding of facts, evidence and science; and dismissive of the legitimacy of its political opposition. When one party moves this far from the mainstream, it makes it nearly impossible for the political system to deal constructively with the country’s challenges.”
https://www.washingtonpost.com/opinions/lets-just-say-it-the-republicans-are-the-problem/2012/04/27/gIQAxCVUlT_story.html
LikeLike
Oh, and there’s this:
https://www.usatoday.com/picture-gallery/news/nation/2021/01/07/front-pages-capture-chaos-riots-us-capitol/6577931002/
LikeLike
No matter what the facts say, Trump will lie, as usual, and say the economy is a mess under Biden, and the traitor (he won’t call himself that, I think — but if he did, I don’t think that would surprise me) is the only genius who can fix it.
Since Traitor Trump’s fascist loving MAGA voters doesn’t fact check or listen to anyone outside of extreme right lying, cherry picking, exaggerating propaganda media, they’ll never hear those facts and if they did, they’d call them lies and threaten the lives of anyone, and their families, that reported those facts.
LikeLike
Lloyd how is Trump the traitor ? All your stories have been hoaxes and lies you understand that right? All impeachments, smollett hoax, nascar hoax, the Trumpcovington hoax, russia hoax, trump telling russia about soliders all lies.
How is BIDENOMICS Lol working?????? WE are paying 10,000 more. a year and you all sit around talking about how Trump is terrible, and Biden is great, I cannot name 1 thing this trash resident has done for our country. You people support a very racist, pedophile, senile traitor.
LikeLike
Perhaps you should wean yourself from right-wing propaganda sites. Be a patriot. Broaden your news sources.
LikeLike
I’d say it is incontrovertible that when anyone encourages a mob to March on the Capitol and lay siege to it while Congress is tallying the votes for President—that person is a TRAITOR and a SEDOTIONIST.
LikeLike
The peaceful transfer of dollars…
“Our healthcare system is broken.
While the insurance companies and
the pharmaceutical industry make
hundreds of billions in profit,
85 million Americans are uninsured
or underinsured, our life expectancy
is declining…
Our educational system is teetering.
While we have one of the highest
rates of childhood poverty of almost
any major country, millions of parents
cannot find affordable and quality
childcare. The number of our young
people who graduate from college is
falling behind many other countries
and 45 million Americans are struggling
under the weight of student debt.
Our housing stock is totally inadequate.
While gentrification is causing rents
to soar in many parts of our country
some 600,000 Americans are homeless,
and 18 million are spending more than
half of their limited incomes on housing.”
Bernie Sanders
The above conditions didn’t
just happen under JB. JB
has had a ring side seat, to
the “mess” for decades. He’s
not alone. He’ll fix it now,
right?
LikeLike
Bernie was one of the first politicians to endorse Biden’s re-election. Because Bernie isn’t swayed by right wing propaganda, he believes his own eyes, and sees how Biden’s policies are versions of his ow. How dare you insult Bernie by invoking him to support a lie that JB is NOT working to fix it. Bernie knows he is.
LikeLike
Nobody insulted Bernie Sanders more than Clinton supporters during the 2016 and 2020 Democratic Party primaries (which were rigged).
LikeLike
Nobody insulted Bernie Sanders more than you just did when you basically implied that Bernie Sanders and AOC are evil and corrupt greedy politicians who are lying to all of us about Biden.
James, you have a lot of chutzpah invoking Bernie Sanders when Bernie Sanders has already endorsed Biden for re-election.
I find it disgusting that you are telling us not to trust Bernie and AOC because YOU don’t trust them and you know they would lie to us.
Sorry, but it is YOU who shouldn’t be trusted, James, not Bernie Sanders.
Please stop attacking Bernie and stop implying that Bernie is a liar who shouldn’t be trusted. No one except the far right Trump supporters believe you.
LikeLike
“These are some of the crises
our country faces. And we’re
not dealing with them…
Let’s be clear. Defending the
American people is not only
about pouring money into the
Pentagon. It’s about making
sure our children go to good
schools and will have a
habitable planet when they
get older. It’s about making
sure that every American has
a decent standard of living
and can enjoy quality healthcare
and affordable housing.
As a nation, the time is long
overdue for fundamental changes
to our national priorities…”
LikeLike
Bidenomics is 1920s Republican “supply-side ecomomics” (aka “trickle-down economics) with some identity politics mixed in. We live at a time when more than 37 million Americans are living in poverty, when thousands of workers across multiple industries are currently on strike, when about 60% of American workers live paycheck-to-paycheck, when hundreds of thousands of workers earn $7.25/hour, when corporate CEOs “earn” 288 times the pay of their median employees, and when only about 11% of workers are organized and represented by a union. There’s no mystery why President Biden’s popularity among working class voters is sooooooooooo low.
LikeLike
James,
I am a big fan of Tim Hartford and his podcast More or Less. On of his common questions when looking at some statistics is to ask the question “is that a big number?”.
Let’s go through a few of yours. About 11.6% of the population lives below the poverty line. That is much less than the late 1950s and about as low as it has ever been in the last 60 years. See https://www.census.gov/content/dam/Census/library/visualizations/2022/demo/p60-277/figure1.pdf
Hundreds of thousands of workers earn $7.25 an hour. There are a little under 160 million workers in the country, so even 500,000 would be about .3% of the people working are paid $7.25 an hour. This is such a small number that I have to think that your figure is too small. What was the source?
LikeLike
“The messaging is now that his family has been collecting nearly $50 million for nothing and he has been acting as a foreign agent for many years.…”
April wins today’s “Putrid Putin Propaganda” award. Congratulations April!
LikeLike