Heather Cox Richardson hits it out of the park with this column. Republicans are screaming that Hunter Biden got a slap on the wrist for his crimes, and that the Justice Department went easy on him. But Richardson points out that President Biden left the Trump-appointed U.S. Attorney for Delaware in place, and he prosecuted the case. For those upset about Hunter Biden, when will they demand to know why the Saudis gave Jared Kushner $2 billion six months after he left office?
She writes:
After years of accusations and rumors swirling around Hunter Biden, the 53-year-old son of President Joe Biden, the Department of Justice has reached a tentative deal with the younger Biden: He will plead guilty to two misdemeanor charges of failing to file income tax returns for 2017 and 2018 by the filing date, for which he owed more than $100,000 each year. Biden’s representatives say he has since paid the Internal Revenue Service what he owed. Prosecutors will ask for two years’ probation.
Biden will also admit to the fact that he possessed a firearm as an addict, for which he and prosecutors have agreed he will enter a pretrial diversion agreement that will require that he stay clean for two more years, after which the charge will be removed from his record.
Representative James Comer (R-KY), chair of the House Oversight Committee, promptly accused “the Bidens” of “corruption, influence peddling, and possibly bribery” and called the deal “a slap on the wrist.” Throughout the day, right-wing figures have insisted that the deal is proof that President Biden is using the Justice Department to shield his family and to persecute his enemies.
In fact, Biden worked hard to reestablish the independence of the Justice Department after Trump had used it for personal ends. Trump broke the tradition that FBI directors should serve out their ten-year term—a term chosen to emphasize that the position should not be political—by firing FBI director James Comey when Comey refused to stop the bureau’s investigation of the 2016 Trump campaign’s ties to Russian operatives; Biden tried to reestablish the guardrails around the position when he declined to replace FBI director Christopher Wray, appointed by Trump.
Biden also left in place the U.S. attorney for the District of Delaware—the person overseeing the investigation into Hunter Biden that began in 2018—to make the independence of the investigation clear. That Trump appointee, U.S. Attorney David C. Weiss, is responsible for the deal. Georgetown University policy professor Don Moynihan pointed out that Weiss has been investigating Hunter Biden for five years and “[b]est they could do is tax charges which rarely get this level of attention. If Comer has anything real, the prosecutor would have used it.”
Indeed, rather than going easy on Hunter Biden, there are signs that prosecutors treated him more harshly than is typical for similar crimes. Roger Sollenberger, a senior political writer for the Daily Beast, explained that “Roger Stone and his wife settled a $2 million unpaid taxes civil case with DOJ last year—they weren’t charged criminally, unlike Hunter Biden, so they didn’t even get probation.” Justice reporter for NBC News Ryan Reilly noted that it is very rare for prosecutors to bring the addict in possession of a weapon charge they used against Biden. In the past it has been used to find a charge that will stick or alongside charges concerning violent crime.
As right-wing leaders, including House speaker Kevin McCarthy (R-CA), nonetheless attacked the Justice Department for what they claimed was a “two-tiered justice system” that went easy on Biden, Greg Sargent of the Washington Post noted, “The right doesn’t seem to care about the legal process—they care about the results. Their aim is the destruction of the independence of federal law enforcement in favor of a weaponized justice system, and they will keep creating new pretexts until they get it.”
Trump had his own reaction to the Biden charges, calling them “a massive INTERFERENCE COVERUP & FULL SCALE ELECTION ‘SCAM’ THE LIKES OF WHICH HAS NEVER BEEN SEEN IN OUR COUNTRY BEFORE. A ‘TRAFFIC TICKET,’ & JOE IS ALL CLEANED UP & READY TO GO INTO THE 2024 PRESIDENTIAL ELECTION – AND THIS AS CROOKED DOJ, STATE, & CITY PROSECUTORS, MARXISTS & COMMUNISTS ALL, HIT ME FROM ALL SIDES & ANGELS WITH BULL….! MAKE AMERICA GREAT AGAIN!!!” [sic]
Eric Lipton of the New York Times reported today on the Trump family’s ties to a multibillion-dollar project in Oman. The resort project is backed by the Omani government, which has put up the land for the project and is investing up to a billion dollars to upgrade the infrastructure near the project and to fund the project’s initial phase. It will also take a cut of the profits. A Saudi real estate firm closely allied with the Saudi government brought Trump into the deal. The Trump family will not put any money into the project, but the Omani government has paid the Trump Organization at least $5 million for the use of his name and will pay the Trump Organization to manage a hotel, golf course, and golf club for the next 30 years.
“There is a big wealth concentration in the world, which means that those people will more and more demand more exclusive products and more exclusive projects,” the chief executive of the London-based DarGlobal subsidiary of the Saudi real estate firm said earlier this year. The project is being constructed by migrants paid as little as $340 a month for ten hours a day of grueling work in heat above 100°F, or 38°C.
Tonight news broke that on Friday, Owen Shroyer, who worked alongside Alex Jones at the right-wing conspiracy media site InfoWars, will change his plea for charges associated with the January 6, 2021, attack on the U.S. Capitol to “guilty,” which might signal that he has flipped.
Shroyer was at the so-called “War Room” on January 5 with Trump lawyer Rudy Giuliani, advisors Steve Bannon and Roger Stone, General Michael Flynn, and Christina Bobb, the lawyer who later signed off on Trump’s statement that he had returned all the classified documents in his possession (he had not). Trump’s chief of staff, Mark Meadows, repeatedly expressed interest to his aide Cassidy Hutchinson in joining the people in that command center, but in the end was talked into calling the group rather than going over.
Shroyer was also part of the 47-member “Friends of Stone” encrypted chat group that organized in 2019 to support Trump in the upcoming election and then to keep him in office after he lost in 2020. If Shroyer has, indeed, flipped, he could provide an important window into the upper levels of the attempt to overturn the results of the 2020 presidential election.
Both the New York Times and the Washington Posthave recently reported that several months ago, officials in the Biden administration began indirect talks with Iran in hopes of stopping Iran’s proxy attacks on U.S. forces in Syria, bringing home three Iranian American business executives being held on charges the U.S. considers false—Emad Shargi (detained 2018), Morad Tahbaz (detained 2018), and Siamak Namazi (detained 2015)—and reining in that country’s nuclear weapons development program. In 2018, Trump pulled the U.S. out of the Joint Comprehensive Plan of Action (JCPOA) with Iran that limited Iran’s nuclear research and development. Tehran quickly restarted its uranium enrichment, research and development of advanced centrifuges, and expansion of its stockpile of nuclear fuel. According to Colum Lynch of Foreign Policy, this cut in half the time Iran would need to produce enough weapons-grade fuel to build a nuclear weapon.
Biden yesterday announced a $600 million investment in addressing climate change, with that investment focused on coastal areas and communities around the Great Lakes. Funding for projects, including modernizing electrical grids to make them resilient to extreme weather events, national disasters, and wildfires, comes from the Inflation Reduction Act and the Bipartisan Infrastructure Law.
—
Notes:
To read the footnotes, please open the article.
Twitter links:
SollenbergerRC/status/1671180412498878464
donmoyn/status/1671163439333650436
MuellerSheWrote/status/1671262234352451589
ThePlumLineGS/status/1671226546676170787
SykesCharlie/status/1671230641831129088
harrylitman/status/1671179022313865220

Hopefully, Hunter Biden can put his legal difficulties behind and return to the business of sharing his expertise within the fossil-fuel industry.
LikeLike
It was ever thus. Remember “Billy Beer”? And the banking expertise that Neil Bush brought to serving on the board of Silverado Savings and Loan, as well as the education expertise he brought to founding an ed-tech company?
LikeLike
Grift is a bipartisan undertaking.
LikeLike
So freaking common, and it stinks to high heaven.
LikeLike
lol James what is wrong with you!!!! He has no expertise!!! He is Joe Biden’s son. Just like his artist drawings of 500,000 which is hysterical. Laundering money.
Crazy BOB!
LikeLike
Josh, that was Mr. Eales’s point. He was being sarcastic.
LikeLike
https://newrepublic.com/article/143586/trumps-russian-laundromat-trump-tower-luxury-high-rises-dirty-money-international-crime-syndicate
LikeLike
If America’s corporate boards were only filled with those with expertise that was a benefit to the company, The board rooms would be empty
LikeLike
This is just the crumbs. I mean Wesley Snipes and others had much more jail time for the same crime. Hunter has taken million of dollars from China, Ukraine, Russia. He is more qualified as a crack head than he is at Burisma.
This sick individual has pictures on young kids on his laptop with him in his room. This sicko had sex with his dead brother’s wife.
Sounds like the people who have Trump derangement are in this blog. All those supposed “conspiracy theories” have all come true, keep listening to the CIA trained media.
LikeLike
This is the same kind of person who thinks Greg Gutfield is funny. This one’s for him.
LikeLike
Gufeld is hilarious, Colbert loser, fallon= despicable
LikeLike
Repugnican humor is an oxymoron, like Congressional ethics.
LikeLike
The only thing hilarious about this guy is that he is unintentionally self-parodying.
LikeLike
He’s Lindsey-esque. Doesn’t realize he’s been out of the closet for decades.
LikeLike
I thought it hilarious when Fox decided to start running a right-wing comic because these people–Dennis Miller is another example–just cannot be funny. They are far too narrow-minded, constricted, uptight, humorless.
Welcome to the Puritan Magistrate Comedy Hour, with yur host, Cottie Mather! “Thank you. Thank you. Let us pray. OK. Guy says to me, ‘Don’t put me in the stocks, and I’ll give you some wampum.’ So, of course, I had to have the bailiff whomp ’em. Ha ha ha.”
LikeLike
LikeLike
Josh has serious issues.
LikeLike
I thought the case against Hunter Biden was in a computer repair shop in Delaware.
LikeLike
Ever since Nixon, the GOP has been working overtime to get payback by going after Democrats like the Clintons and now the Bidens.
Still, since Nixon, the GOP hasn’t learned a thing or made any attempt to change the fact that it has continued to become more and more fascist.
LikeLike
By all means dig into any improper business relationships that Donald Trump or his family members have had; given their track record, there’s likely lots of dirt to uncover. At the same time, apply this same standard to all government officials who have potentially incriminating business dealings. Don’t make corruption a partisan matter, where you criticize your political opponents but rationalize whatever your political allies did.
I was a career bank auditor for a big name CPA firm, eventually making it to partner (I write here under a pseudonym because of confidentiality rules). I had in-depth knowledge of how people would try to hide embarrassing or criminal activities using various techniques for money laundering, multiple shell companies, etc. We audited those activities because bank regulators also scrutinized this area as well. What the Bidens did fit exactly into these patterns of conduct. They received millions of dollars for very nebulous activities. Instead of direct, on-the-table payments for clearly defined services, money was shifted around to multiple shell corporations. That’s what people do when they’re trying to hide activities they don’t want to be publicized.
Ask yourself the common sense question: why were foreign entities paying Hunter Biden millions of dollars when he had zero expertise in what those entities did to make money? Same question about James Biden, Joe’s brother. The public deserves to know if Joe was paid off to do things not in the best interest of the country. It’s long past time for the mainstream media to do its job, even if doing so hurts politicians they favor.
LikeLike
Don’t make corruption a partisan matter.
Agreed, emphatically.
LikeLike
Thank you Mark, nice to see. They have been after trump for 7 years and nothing yet. They want him to not run and will do everything because they are so scared of an outsider
LikeLike
josh,
don’t you mean they have been after Hillary Clinton for 15 years and nothing yet? They wanted her not to run because they are so scared of a woman with integrity.
Of course, if you hate that low income children have health care, you should blame Hillary for that.
I find it odd that folks like josh worship Trump, but I do think josh is just like the people who said they were happy they paid Trump lots of money to attend Trump University. Either liars or fools.
LikeLike
I don’t think that is what Mark was saying. You cherry-picked his response and missed the point. Also, I don’t know what rock you’ve been hiding under, but many things have been found on Trump.
LikeLike
Josh,
What do you think of a man who has been involved in more than 3,000 lawsuits and at least four bankruptcies? Not during his presidency but over his years in business. He’s not worthy of your reverence.
LikeLike
Mark Jackson, I assume you are directing this at Republicans since they are the only ones who believe that their family members should be making big bucks.
Hunter Biden got punished. But the families of Mitch McConnell, Trump, Bush did not.
Why aren’t you asking the same questions of them?
I am very concerned that you seem to be admitting you audit banks — a very Republican industry – and find lots of wrongdoing, but those people never go to jail. Did you cover up for them? Do you know how many accounting firms were complicit with the bank failures and Trump business failures?
A REPUBLICAN prosecutor dug through Hunter Biden’s finances and found almost nothing. You have a lot of chutzpah as an “auditor” making nasty innuendo about the Biden family without a shred of evidence.
Did you work for Arthur Andersen, “Mark Jackson”??
LikeLike
NYCPSP,
I’ve read a few dozen of your comments in the past. Your response to me is like all the others: an uninformed personal attack.
At the big bank level that I audited for 30+ years, most senior bank executives are closely tied to the Democratic party. My CPA firm was never implicated in bank failures, but others have been. Many Democratic politicians – Jim Wright, Barney Frank, et al – tried to protect wrongdoers in exchange for campaign cash. Some Republicans did as well. Well-informed people know these historical facts.
You don’t have the knowledge or even the common sense to realize that the money paid to Hunter Biden was obviously paid in an effort to influence Joe. The Biden shell corporations that are now a matter of public record are a way to avoid being caught in questionable activities. Why did foreign businesses tied to corrupt governments pay Hunter millions of dollars? He had no expertise in those industries – an obvious effort to curry favor with Joe.
Friendly advice: next time you launch a personal attack, at least know what you’re talking about. That means accessing news sources outside the partisan left-wing bubble.
LikeLike
“Mark jackson,”
Hunter Biden was prosecuted by a lawyer selected by Trump five years ago.
Please explain why the Saudis gave Jared Kushner $2 billion? What was that for?
LikeLike
This one has all the hallmarks, NYCPSP!
First, one has read “a few dozen” (!!!) of your comments and therefore does not need to respond with substance because you are “uninformed” (and they claimed to have read “a few dozen” [!!!], they don’t know you vewwy well, do dey?) and “personal” (!!!).
And he’s a senior exec who knows all, you peon!
Obvious, obvious, I tell ya. Not a republican has ever done a thing like this. Ask Jared, ask Rudy’s son, ask Sununu’s son, and let’s not even get into the Idiot, Jr and his brotherly growth.
Popped that bubble with b.s.!
LikeLike
Mark Jackson
Of course the payments to Hunter were an attempt to influence Joe. Like many celebrities on corporate boards who have no clue
about the corporations they manage.
Or law firms that are hired because of their industry or government connections .
But it takes a lot of hutzpah to rant about the chump change given to Hunter Biden after his father left office
When the Trump crime syndicate received a 1/2 billion while in office and a cut of a 2 billion dollar investment since.
And that is only Jared Who met with the Russian Ambassador then Russian bankers right after the 16 election.
Take your crocodile tears on the road
LikeLike
And Trump is now a partner in a multibillion resort under construction in Oman. Described in todatmy’s New York Times.
LikeLike
The hits just keep on coming.
As described by many including Dana Milbank, the Republican strategy is to keep throwing mud regardless of how little substance there is to the charge or how out of proportion to reality it is. White Water, Vince Foster, Benghazi, Hunter Bidens laptop. Just keep repeating the big lie and enough will buy into it. Democrats in turn seldom use language effectively enough to counter it
LikeLike
I don’t defend Hunter Biden’s behavior. He is damaged goods. He was a coke addict. The contents of his laptop —so I have read—showed him doing drugs and sharing nude pix of himself. He’s a guy with serious issues. According to the LA Times yesterday, he was a member of an erotic dinner club in LA. I’m a bit of a prude, so this kind of behavior is loathsome to me. But it’s not criminal. I feel sorry for him. Back in the day, we would say he threw his life away. Maybe because he survived the car crash when his mother and sister were killed. Maybe because he lived in the shadow of his accomplished older brother Beau. He’s made a mess of his life.
LikeLike
Markie is snarky too.
LikeLike
Whattabout Jared’s $2 billion from Saudi Arabia? See what I did there?
The loonies are really coalescing. Congrats, Diane!
LikeLike
Either Markie didn’t read the Heather Cox Richardson piece or he didn’t comprehend it.
LikeLike
Both are likely true. Not “didn’t”, but “couldn’t possiby.”
LikeLike
Markie either didn’t read the Heather Cox Richardson piece, or he didn’t comprehend it.
LikeLike
https://abcnews.go.com/Politics/frank-biden-leveraged-famous-business-gain/story?id=68202529
LikeLike
I’m glad Frank Biden got out of the charter industry.
Hunter’s no bargain. He’s caused his father no end of headaches.
But Joe loves him.
LikeLiked by 1 person
yup
LikeLike
Trading on the family name is ugly but not illegal. Would John F. Kennedy have had the opportunity to be elected president, to pull the air cover off the Bay of Pigs invasion and cause our people to get slaughtered, to get this country embroiled in the disaster that was Vietnam, to party in the penthouses in Vegas with the prostitutes and the Rat Pack, or to force himself on White House interns if Daddy hadn’t been rich? If he had been John F. Finkle? Would Robert Kennedy, Jr., who has the brains of a gerbil, be able to run for president and get airtime for his looney conspiracy theories if he wasn’t the son of the brother of John F.?
Uh, no.
In the entertainment industry, that’s just the way things are. It’s slimy, but usually not illegal unless there is a political quid pro quo like, you know, I’ll send you arms, Mr. Zelensky, if you find dirt on my opponent and his son. When someone does something that blatantly illegal, we prosecute him or her and send the crook to prison, right?
Oh. Wait a minute.
LikeLike
I always learn from reading Heather Cox Richardson. She’s brilliant and extremely well-informed. And she’s a fine, fine writer to boot, which makes reading her all the more pleasurable.
LikeLike
From comment above: “The public deserves to know if Joe was paid off to do things not in the best interest of the country.” Can we add a few Supreme Court justices, a former president, and their pals to the list for public deserved information.
As for Hunter Biden – – finally – – something happened. On a scale of 1 to 10 on the scope of the investigation and severity of the punishment, it could be a 1 or it could be a 10. But finally something is out there so we can move beyond the rallying cry (literally, right after “lock her up”) of “Whadabout Hunter’s laptop?”
LikeLike
“move beyond”? Funniest thing I’ve read in years. The republican playbook is the play a few plays over and over again. Got started with Reagan and been refined to a moldy science ever since. “move beyond”! Truly a classic.
LikeLike
Yeah, not going to happen. These morons are still having tantrums about Benghazi. And Clinton’s email server.
LikeLike
Not “close the book” on it because their playbook is never closed and it is being used for school board elections and legislation everywhere. The “beyond” part is their cry has been Hunter got a free pass, that the President and democrats pretended he or it is not a problem, and it was the answer too many reporters bought when being asked about Republicans being held accountable. They can still and will bring him up, but they can’t say his issues are untouchable or the liberal media refuses to cover his issues because finally, something happened. (Was that defensive enough 🙂
LikeLike
🍻 or 🥂, depending on your preference.
LikeLike
This just in: Lester Ballard has thrown his hose into the race for the 2024 Presidential nomination. This could be a game-changer. As a Trump supporter recently told Diane Ravitch Blog Action News Reporter Bob Sheephead: “I don’t always agree with him but he says whut’s own his mind.”
LikeLike
Excellent letters to the editor in today’s NYT on this topic. As there were on Monday about the Mississippi “miracle.”
LikeLike
I wish Nick Kristof would stop writing about education.
LikeLike
Greg,
I read about 10-12 newspapers online every day. One is the NYT.
Would you mind posting the letters from yesterday and today?
LikeLike