Michael Barajas wrote a while back in The Texas Observer about an inhumane practice that is especially notorious in Texas prisons: long-term solitary confinement. He spoke with prisoners who had been in solitary for 22-24 hours a day for decades. They described losing their sense of reality, depression, thoughts of suicide.
He began:
Three years ago, guards came to Roger Uvalle’s cell to tell him he was “catching chain”—being shackled and transferred to another prison. As the guards escorted him to the chain bus with about 60 other inmates, Uvalle began trembling, overcome by anxiety. He turned so pale another prisoner told him he looked like a ghost. He didn’t relax until guards put him in his new solitary confinement cell, a 6-by-10-foot space where he’d spend 22 to 24 hours each day, alone, just as he had every day for the past two-plus decades.
Years of almost no human contact have warped Uvalle’s sense of time. Weeks, months, even years blend together. He says his memory has degraded to the point where he now struggles to keep track of the few personal items he’s allowed to have. He sometimes spends hours turning over his cell looking for stamps, letters, art supplies.

ROGER UVALLE. LAUREN CROW
His recollection of the time before 1992, when he went to prison for two armed robberies, is hazy. He knows he spent time in state hospitals; that his family struggled to find him mental health care growing up in San Antonio; and that as a teenager, he once tried to kill himself by swallowing a bottle of Valium. He knows that he was self-medicating on a cocktail of booze and whatever drugs he could find at the time. He knows that when he first went to prison, he was housed with the rest of the general inmate population and received mental health treatment, which he says helped.
And he knows that about 12 months into his 40-year sentence, guards sent him to solitary confinement after they accused him of being involved in back-to-back fights and hiding a makeshift knife in his cell. Two years later, while he was still in isolation, guards accused him of being affiliated with the Mexican Mafia prison gang, a scarlet letter officials use to justify keeping people in solitary.
About five years in, Uvalle says, he stopped getting medication for his mental illness, started hallucinating, and then struggled to keep himself and his cell clean. “I couldn’t care for myself and didn’t care about much and was experiencing psychotic behavior on a regular basis,” he wrote in a letter to me. When I visited him in prison recently, he talked about his most recent hunger strike, his third in the past two years. He had refused food for seven days before giving up this time. “Most of the time, they don’t acknowledge your hunger strike if you don’t have outside help,” Uvalle says. “They’ll let you die right there. They don’t care.” It reminds me of a line from one of the letters he sent me before our visit, when he described how some inmates set fires in protest. “There’s fires literally every day,” he wrote. “Never been in a place where there are fires every day.”
During our conversation, Uvalle seems shaken to be speaking with a stranger. His slow, soft speech hardly carries through the buzzy closed-circuit phone that connects us through the cracked plexiglass pane. He tells me he’s worried he’s getting worse. He’s struggling again to keep himself and his cell clean. He cries randomly sometimes, but doesn’t know why.
Uvalle went into solitary confinement in 1993, when he was 21 years old. Now, at 47, he’s been in solitary for 26 years—more than half his life…
Solitary confinement is a uniquely American form of punishment. It began as a misguided attempt at rehabilitation. America’s first prisons, built in the 1800s, housed inmates in near total isolation based on a Quaker belief that solitude fostered penitence and reformation—hence the word “penitentiary.” In reality, foreign attachés dispatched to study American prisons in 1831 were horrified after witnessing a degree of isolation “beyond the strength of man.” Charles Dickens was revolted by what he saw while touring an American penitentiary in 1842, writing, “I hold this slow and daily tampering with the mysteries of the brain to be immeasurably worse than any torture of the body.” In 1890, the U.S. Supreme Court sided with a prisoner who challenged his placement in solitary for 45 days, stating that inmates subjected to even brief isolation tended to slip into a “semi-fatuous condition” or became violently and irreversibly insane.
By the turn of the century, solitary had mostly gone out of style as a core correctional model in America. But in Texas, as convict leasing and prison farms replaced slavery as the primary tool for black oppression after the Civil War, solitary was still reserved as a severe punishment. Inmates on Texas’ prison plantations were locked in pitch-dark boxes, sometimes for so long or in such great numbers that they suffocated to death. In 1947, Oscar Byron Ellis, who had operated a money-making penal farm in Tennessee, took over the Texas prison system and built a new “segregation unit” in Huntsville to quarantine “hopeless cases.” Under Ellis, the authoritarian control Texas exerted over its prisoners became the model other states tried to emulate. Penologists drooled over what they called the “Texas Control Model.”
Please open the link and read the rest of this horrifying article.
I’m surprised Texas doesn’t just kill them rather than waste precious tax dollars on solitary confinement.
aSolitary confinement is a uniquely American form of punishment. It began as a misguided attempt at rehabilitation. America’s first prisons, built in the 1800s, housed inmates in near total isolation based on a Quaker belief that solitude fostered penitence and reformation—hence the word “penitentiary.” I
The Quakers believed — and probably still believe that a person should “tremble at the word of the Lord”.
So make no mistake, solitary confinement had nothing to do with penitence and everything go to with instilling “fear” int.
Its a version of the chicken and egg problem.
Which came first, evil or religion?
Religion!
I think you are right.
Evil is pretty much defined by religion — to say nothing of perpetrated by it.
I just hope that ChatGPT and other AIs are not being trained on the Bible and other religious books.
Otherwise, they will surely already consider wiping out the “evil” human race as the logical completion of the human story.
The claim that the Quakers had the first prisons is simply false.
The Puritans were “religiously” imprisoning people — particularly native Americans pretty much from the moment they arrived.
But only those who were impure, of course.
Imprisoning and enslaving.
Little surprise that the Puritans felt unwelcome in England and left for the New World in order to be free to mete out their version of religious ” justice” (on “witches, native Americans and anyone else they deemed a threat to their beliefs) without interference from silly English laws.
Solitary confinement was one of many tortures regularly employed at GITMO and the other sites in the U.S.’s world-wide network of torture-prisons. Out of 780 GITMO prisoners, fewer than 20 were ever charged with any crime, only two convicted. Statistics are unknown for the other prisons. The Bush administration tortured hundreds of innocent men (and plenty of women) all based on lies.
This is a deeply disturbing article about those that have no agency or advocates that can ensure humane treatment for this forgotten population. If states are providing such disparity in the treatment of inmates, the US should at the very least insist that we adhere to the basic UN standards of treatment for all in this country. We often complain about how other nations like China, Iran or Saudi Arabia violate human rights. If we want to be considered a beacon of democracy, we need to do a better job ensuring that states cannot violate inmates’ human rights. Keeping inmates in a permanent state of isolation is “cruel and unusual punishment.”
When my daughter lived in Brazoria County outside Houston, I used to drive by the Clemons Unit. A large sign near the prison on the road warned drivers to not pick up hitchhikers. Clemons looked like a large farm. There were often guards riding horses and carrying rifles. They were in charge of keeping an eye on prisoners that were picking crops. I remember seeing for the first time in my life a chain gang of two groups of prisoners. It was like a scene from the film “O Brother, Where Art Thou,” a film about prison life during the depression. We can do better than this. All prisons, public and private, should be subject to some type of periodic human rights review from an impartial third party that has the authority to force states to follow humane standards of treatment.
Evil
In other news, here’s Donald Trump’s “unclimbable” border wall:
Calling bs on Repugnicans (Trump, DeSantis, Abbott, Cruz, etc) is a full-time job.
Thank you, Diane, for drawing attention to this horror.
Long-term solitary confinement is cruel and unusual punishment. Unconstitutional.
It certainly is!!!! Thank you, again, Diane.
Here is how the poor get treated in the United States by our “Just Us” and healthcare for the rich systems:
What it really comes down to is if the goal of prison is rehabilitation and reintegration or retribution. For the vast majority of prisoners, even those seemingly hopeless, the former must always be the goal. Norway, Finland, and Germany seem to be on the forefront of that philosophy. But as a raging liberal, I will admit there are a few for whom retribution is appropriate, especially since I completely reject the death penalty under all circumstances. For the few who would “qualify,” murderers, serial child molesters (like the Baltimore priests we recently learned about), those involved in any phase of genocide, I have no problem giving them their 2-3 meals a day in their cell, letting them have a toilet, and not much, if anything more. And if they go nuts, put them in a padded cell. But this would apply to very few.
“But as a raging liberal”
I can agree with the raging part, not sure about the liberal part. 😉
I do confess to being in a near-constant state of rage since the republican convention of 2016. It’s getting stressful.
Dear Dr. Ravitch,
I live in San Antonio, Texas where my home 🏡 is your home.
At the past you generously gave wonderful insights to my late wife Sonia who was a public K-8 teacher.
Now I am coming to meet you to ask the blessing of your insight. I want to help to create policy or influence funding policy for public education where be stated in the U.S. Constitution sufficient funding increased every year and never be less than previous year.
In order to get ready for the task, I am considering an online 2-Year Master’s Degree in Policy Education and Leadership at the American University in Washington, DC. Is this path correct!
I am a late bloomer 71 years old and I am strong and healthy. What do you recommend to make true an educational policy of such magnitude to fulfill the cause without pause.
Thank you in advance for your time, help and feedback.
Please take care, and stay safe and secure.
Respectfully,
Guillermo Rivera
San Antonio, Texas
guillermorivera95@yahoo.com
Is possible for any Texas governor to change such state of things. If so I will advocate for it happens or/and become myself Governor of Texas.
Thank you in advance for your time and insights.
Please take care,
Guillermo Rivera
San Antonio, Texas
guillermorivera95@yahoo.com
Thank you. Of course, Governor Abbott could end this inhuman practice. If he cared.