Scott Maxwell of the Orlando Sentinel explains the power dynamics behind DeSantis’ fight with Disney. DeSantis just hired four law firms, at the taxpayer expense, of course, to fight Disney’s secret coup to retain control of its property.
Maxwell writes:
If you look at Mickey Mouse’s hands, you’ll notice he doesn’t have a middle finger. But if he did, he most surely flipped it at Ron DeSantis this past week.
Florida’s governor had told the world that he’d taken on Disney and won. But while DeSantis was busy tweeting, Disney operatives were busy working, quietly rewriting legal papers in an attempt to ensure the governor’s tough talk never amounted to anything more.
Basically, Disney was playing 4-D chess while the governor’s legal team was fumbling with a bag of checkers. And by the time Team DeSantis figured out what had happened Wednesday, its members could do little more than fume and pout.
DeSantis is so used to picking on easy targets — drag queens and transgender teenagers — that he wasn’t prepared to do battle with someone with the power to fight back.
It’s easy for DeSantis critics to laugh and scoff. Donald Trump certainly did, mocking his former protégé for getting bested by a cartoon mouse.
But the reality is that this whole situation stinks.
Ron DeSantis and GOP lawmakers are trying to use bully power and petty politics to punish a private company for expressing opinions they dislike — in this case, Disney’s opinion that LGBTQ families should be treated like human beings….
Still, Disney doesn’t deserve to run its own government. Many of us have argued as much for years. Unfortunately, lawmakers in this state have been happy to do Disney special favors for decades — as long as Disney cut them checks.
Just two years ago, DeSantis signed a law exempting Disney from a crackdown on social media companies after the company gave his political committee $50,000.
The ludicrous bill, which was invalidated by a federal judge who noted the special-interest favoritism, included a carve-out that exempted any company that “owns and operates a theme park.” DeSantis signed the bill less than two months after cashing Disney’s check and after records show his staffers swapped emails about the language Disney lobbyists wanted in the law.
DeSantis clearly did a favor for a corporate donor, blowing a castle-sized hole in the tough-on-corporations narrative he tries to peddle. In fact, a big part of why corporate America likes DeSantis is that they know he plays ball….
DeSantis had vowed to make Disney “follow the same laws every other company follows in the state of Florida.” I actually like that plan. That’s how it should’ve been all along. But that’s not what he did.
Instead, he put a group of hand-picked political appointees in charge of the private company. No other company in America works like that. DeSantis didn’t put Disney on the same footing as everyone else. He tried to put Disney under his own personal thumb. And Disney seems to have found a way to at least temporarily thwart him.
If these guys actually had a desire to do the right thing — before Disney cut them off financially — they wouldn’t have tried to twice ram through poorly thought-out laws. They would’ve asked a team of smart government-law experts to devise a way to sunset Disney’s special status in a logical, legal matter.
But logic has taken a beating in Tallahassee over the last two years as book-banning, pronoun-legislating and drag-queen-bashing have become the rage.
I don’t begrudge anyone who laughed at DeSantis last week for getting out-brained by a mouse. It was cringe-inducingly amusing to watch his campaign team stage a meltdown on Twitter, claiming that the governor’s clear loss was really a big win because (just you wait) the governor is always thinking “10 steps ahead….”
So sure, laugh at DeSantis. But I’m still not rooting for Disney.
While the company has done some great philanthropic things in this community, it has also used money, power and even free park tickets to warp public policy in this state for decades. Everything from secret text messages with county commissioners to try to deny sick time for local workers to back-channel messaging with the governor’s staff to request special favors.
I’m not cheering for the powerful corporation or the pandering politicians. I’m rooting for good government that doesn’t cater to special interests — the one thing neither side seems to want.
Disney plays rough. It is a generous campaign donor, and that’s one reason there are no national safety standards for rides at amusement parks. It also sucks up a lot of public money. Read Team Rodent by Carl Hiassen.
The whole story does have a Brer Rabbit-esque plot, don’t it? The only way to beat a bad guy with power is to have another bad guy with power, but that might make the first bully look more sympathetic. And the same thing will happen when the second bad guy wins again. And so on.
Correct. Unfortunately the person most likely to stop DeSantis is Donald Trump. I cheer on their feuding and want the media to ask Trump every single day why DeSantis is so superior to him and why DeSantis has been quietly implying that Trump is such a loser? Does Trump agree with DeSantis that DeSantis is so much smarter than Trump? That question should be posed to Trump every day.
Florida is a stand your ground state. May the worse man win.
In the midst of a tantrum, the combative DeSantis announced,” I will “win” against Disney come hell or high water.” He plans on retaliating through tolls on roads, taxes on hotels and developing some of the land the district owns. Going to war with Disney runs the risk of hurting Florida’s main source of income, tourism. All of these retaliatory gestures demonstrate that DeSantis is a petty, vindictive, ego driven authoritarian, unfit for national office.
For a while there, it looked as though the smarter oligarchs in the U.S. were backing DeStalinist. They knew and know that if Trump is the Repugnican candidate, they will lose AGAIN. However, DeStalinist has been working overtime to make himself appear to be a tantrum-throwing toddler with extreme authoritarian instincts–not at all an attractive candidate for the GENERAL election. Consider, for example, the Ron Ron is all set to put on his white go-go boots and trample all over reproductive rights by signing the six-week abortion ban into law, OVER THE OBJECTIONS OF THE MAJORITY OF FLORIDIANS (a majority that is even larger in the rest of the country).
As several recent elections have shown, that’s not a winning position. And a lot of this comes down to whom the voting public LIKES. Peevishness and bullying and tantrum-throwing and knee-jerk authoritarianism ARE NOT ATTRACTIVE PERSONAL QUALITIES, and a LOT of people are now seeing this from the former front-runner for the nomination.
If the DeStalinist people were smart (they aren’t), they would be working hard to rehabilitate this image.
I think that this article does not take into account the special nature of Disney World. The property controlled is the size of San Francisco and the special district was created so that Walt would have the control to prevent the mess that happened around Disneyland after it became successful.
The special district is also not unique in Florida. The Villages provides another example. However, none of these were touched by DeSantis’ legislation.
Agreed that Disney, and all corporations, should have the power to lobby reduced. I just think that the special district does not fall into this same category. To pretend that it does lends credence to DeSantis’ propaganda.
The Villages is a stronghold of right wing zealots that always vote for the GOP, regardless of how awful the candidate may be.
I’m rooting for Disney in this showdown.
Of course you’re rooting for Disney. You oppose corporate power unless that power advances your objectives. You favor the same type of corporate power when you agree with its goals. Your guiding principle: whatever it takes, by any means necessary.
Paula Goldman
Of of course your concern is corporate power.
Paula Goldman– Get real. We are all reduced to rooting for those corporations that champion our causes in some way—while knowing that ultimately, they are hurting us. Hence boo Koch Industries for squelching democracy, yay Disney for taking a dangerous potential prez candidate down a few pegs. This is how it’s going to be until we figure out how to tame the burgeoning oligarchy.
Will the citizens of Florida finally understand that DeSantis’ culture wars are costing tax payers in the state millions of dollars every time he wields his pen? That his take over of New College resulted in the firing of the president of the school who was making just under $300,000 while installing a buddy as president at the salary of over $600,000 of, yes, tax payer money? The problem facing Florida is that they have chosen corruption over good governance. A problem very common in Republican states with veto proof majorities. Hey citizens of these states who claim they are doing all of this for freedom, they are getting rich on our money!
Most of the Florida GOP lacks foresight when they write their knee-jerk bills and laws. It will take them some time before they actually understand the consequences of their far reaching politicized policies.
Yes. These are not smart people.
What consequences?
This stuff has been going on forever in Florida and there are certainly no political consequences because the same people keep getying elected.
They may notice when the lack of tourist dollars hit the state’s bottom line.
All companies put profit over people. That is why they often fail at offering decent social services. Bob Iger’s argument is that the state does not have the constitutional right to tell a private company what to do. How this will play out in court remains to be seen.
Paul– Yup! Case in point, the expanded voucher bill DeSantis signed into law 3 wks ago. Per the Education Law Center, “Even under conservative estimates, Florida Empowerment Scholarship (FES) vouchers would cost the state about $4 billion dollars in the initial year of HB1 implementation. This does not include costs for the proposed expansion of the Florida tax credit scholarship vouchers ($568 million in 2021-22).”
Disney pays its employees crap. Not even close to a living wage. And it is in the process of further enriching shareholders by firing 7,000 employees (in response to strategic failures in the streaming market).
Desantis is fighting a fight that needs to be fought, but not for the reasons he is fighting. Besides, the generosity of Disney to his political operation simply reveals that in the end this is all for show.
A while back, Disney fired their entire IT department of American workers and replaced them with foreign workers.
But before the Americans were fired, they were forced to train their replacements.
Disney is interested in one thing ONLY: money.
Because they could pay the foreign replacements less.
Disney laid off my husband’s cousin one year before she was eligible for a full pension. Nobody can claim Disney is a wonderful company, but it still shouldn’t be under the governor’s thumb.
!!!!!
Strictly anecdotal: I am a parent to fine-artsies, as is one of my brothers. Between us, we know a fair number of millennials (including one of his daughters) who were enticed to Disney with promises-promises, and left within one year. Bait and switch [low pay, no career path].
Job well done, then, Ginny!!! xoxoxxo
Late to this party again….was tied up in a classroom yesterday and didn’t see this post. But gotta say….
Wow, a well written piece. Love the lead.
It all makes me want to re-read some Carl Hiassen -as Cindy suggested above. And, causes me to really worry about the 2024 elections and beyond…
Of course, Florida is a huge, diverse state. (I’d love to see a rocket blast off at Cape Canaveral. The Villages? Rather die this moment than drizzle away the hours there waiting to be six feet underground.)
If this crapstorm is happening in the “Sunshine State”, what about the rest of the often cloudier nation?
I still want to write something about demographics and how the aging Baby Boomer generation (incl, moi) seems to be helping to fuel the destruction of the United States. Florida looks to be ground zero for that.
I will be waiting for that piece, John, eager to defend my generation!!
Thanks for the vote of (future) confidence, LOL.
My baby boomer screed is in about the same place as my still unwritten guide, “How to Lose Weight -for Liberals Only”.
And, my “Map to the Stars Homes -Catskills Borscht Belt edition.”
They make me chuckle when need be.
John, I, too, am a fan of Hiassen. And Tim Dorsey.
And here, to whet your appetite for Flor-uh-duh: my paean to my adopted state.
Yeah, we boomers have a lot to account for. It’s a good thing for us that hell is fictional!!!
I was about to turn off the computer for the night and I spotted your reply, Bob. Visiting your site again is a fitting way to wrap up the first warm spring day here.
Whatever else may be true, I’m pretty sure DiSneytis is looking out for their own interest.
And that interest has little to nothing to do with the interests of the general public.