I read this story with a sense of incredulity and impotence. Could this be happening in Tennessee in 2023?
A couple were driving through rural Tennessee on their way to a funeral in Chicago. They had with them in the car their children, one of who was breastfeeding. A police car pulled them over for a minor traffic violation. They had tinted windows and were driving in the left lane on the highway.
Instead of giving them a warning or a ticket, the couple was detained. Both were given drug tests, then hair follicle tests. The authorities decided they were unfit parents. Their children were taken away, including the breast-feeding baby.
A Black family from Georgia is fighting for the return of their five young children from the custody of the Tennessee Department of Children’s Services after a traffic stop in Manchester, Tenn. last month.
Bianca Clayborne and Deonte Williams were on Interstate 24 heading to a family funeral in Chicago — kids asleep in the back of the car — when a Tennessee Highway Patrol officer pulled them over for “dark tint and traveling in the left lane while not actively passing,” according to Feb. 17 citations issued to the couple.
The trooper searched the family’s Dodge Durango then arrested Williams for possession of five grams of marijuana, a misdemeanor in Tennessee. Clayborne was cited but not arrested.
Clayborne said she was told she was free to leave with the children, but could follow a THP car to find her way to the Coffee County Justice Center in order to bond Williams out.
Six hours after the traffic stop, as Clayborne sat on a bench in the criminal justice center waiting for Williams’ release, the five children — a breast-feeding baby now four months old along with 2-, 3-, 5- and 7-year-olds — were forcibly removed from her side while an officer restrained her from reaching for her crying baby, she said….
Inside, “the process seemed slow,” Clayborne said. She waited on benches with her children until about 3 p.m. — nearly six hours after the 9:40 a.m. stop. It was then, according to court records, the children were taken from her.
Uniformed police officers approached Clayborne and her children and “circled me,” she said.
“Then my baby started crying so I reached for my son, and as I’m reaching, a man held me and told me, ‘don’t touch him. He’s getting taken away from you,’” Clayborne said.
One woman was walking her five year old son out the door; another picked her daughter and walked away. Someone else took the stroller with her baby inside.
“I just sat there crying, crying, crying,” she said, her voice shaking as she recounted the events via a Zoom meeting from Georgia.
Clayborne said no one asked her for any information – her phone number, the children’s health or nutritional needs and no one immediately provided her contact information so she could learn where they were or a court order showing why they were taken.
“My kids – they have asthma and you’re not asking about nothing,” she said. “I breastfeed.They didn’t give me anything. They just ran off with my kids.”
When the hearing concluded, the court decided to retain custody of the five children and ordered the parents to take additional drug tests, including hair follicle tests, which are not reliable but might show drug use months ago.
Your Critical Race Theory quiz: Please read the articles in full and respond to these questions:
If the couple were white, do you think the police would have acted differently? How? Why? Why not?
If the couple were white, would they have been subject to search to arrest and detainment? Why or why not?
If the couple were white, would they have lost custody of their children? Why and why not.
NOTICE: this post should not be read or shared in Florida, as it is illegal to discuss these questions.
Sounds like kidnapping.
It is kidnapping. Evil.
Never, ever drive through a rural red state if you look liberal or have skin that isn’t white. Unless you are driving an APC and the weapons are hot.
So who’s actually weaponizing government?
yup
It sounds like behavior reminiscent of The Third Reich. The culture war is a catalyst to racism, homophobia and xenophobia. In the hands of those with small minds and big power, abuse is a likely outcome. I hope the Clayborne-Williams get a good lawyer.
I grew up in Tennessee in the 1960s and 1970s. Al Gore Sr. was our Senator and some Jim Crow police officials were beginning to get kicked out of office around the state. Integration was becoming the rule. In the 1990s’ Tennessee had two well respected Democratic Senators including AL Gore Jr. We had some hope then. I Just moved to Georgia and left a Tennessee that has been taken over by Christian Nationalists and a governor that is a DeSantis clone. It’s a hard pill to swallow.
You are correct. Kefauver and Gore 1 were two of the three southern senators who refused to walk out with the Dixiecrats. Now the state elects buffoons
I remember when Indiana had a Democratic Senator.
Wyoming has Jon Tester. He’s probably the most vulnerable Democratic Senator in 2024.
Yep, it’s frustrating. I’m afraid Tennessee isn’t the only state voting for such politicians. We still have a majority of states with Republican legislatures pushing voter restrictions and anti-LGPTQ legislation and they aren’t all Southern. Democrats are going to have to understand that they have to invest in a long game to root these people out of power. Stacy Abram’s has provided a road map to get this done, but the power structure on the coasts doesn’t seem to feel obligated to help.
At times policies have unintended cruel effects that will hopefully be fixed immediately when found. But to literally make cruelty the goal of policy? This cult is deranged, dangerous, and has an easier message to sell to a willfully gullible audience than do the defenders of democracy.
very hard to “like” this story…. Unbelievable. 😦 I lived in TN for 20 years, and I grew up in FL, and now I live in TX…. are we in the United States of America/!
Nope. We are Germany in 1932.
What a horror story! This amounts to child abuse, those poor kids are traumatized for life.
OMG! Such a horror story! As a parent, I shudder. I do remember traveling (while white, but Yankee) through Tennessee on my own first trip through the South. We had two small children and a handicapped person. We stopped at a rural gas station and waited (in those days when someone pumped your gas and served you, and you didn’t get out). A guy got up slowly from his chair and walked around to check our license plate. When he saw “Ohio,” he sat back down, pulled the hat back over his eyes. We noticed the two drinking fountains and three rest rooms–Male – Female – Colored. We drove on and luckily did not run out of gas. Found a somewhat more hospitable station in the city. We had numerous trips to Tennessee much later, without a problem, but that first memory of deep racism and regional antipathy never leaves me. Today, I contribute to Southern Poverty Law Center and other groups that work on alleviating this age-old problem.
Good for you, Jack!
A case study to support an academic paper on critical race theory? YES
ALL THOSE PEOPLE in this saga (police at scene, everyone at the station, a judge, children’s services are SEPARATE, ISOLATED departments and functions – YET THEIR ACTIONS ALIGNED BASED on race
Did they have some meeting and decide all this in advance? Of course not. No need.
While SEPARATE government offices/people, hey were ALL PART OF THE SYSTEM. In the case, every action was based on race.
THAT is critical race theory.
If the only thing that happened was the cops pulled them over, detained them for driving in the left lane too slowly (and tinted windows?) then that’s racism, not crt. The police prejudice because of a stereotype caused that.
They found marijuana. Ok. Deal with that. Bring HIM in for possession but that’ it. Same thing. Racism.
The mom and kids. No violation but detained and kids taken. Racism.
Separately. Racism. Collectively in one story within one system support the academic thesis of critical race theory in action.
Wait, What, you get an A for CRT analysis.
Coming from Professor Ravitch, that means a lot! 🙂
Now trying to help legislators “get it”
That’s a Herculean task—getting legislators to understand.
Easier to clean the Augean stables.
It’s this kind of bs that led the NAACP to issue a warning to black people against traveling to Florida. Note to NAACP: add darkest Tennessee to that warning.
I think it important to interject here that the death of George Floyd along with police abuse tragedies in Cleveland, Ohio, New York City et al are evidence that this is not a problem merely propagated by a sociopathic loyalty to the “Lost Cause.” This is a national problem that comes out of a fraternal police culture that values power over justice backed by abject fear mongering. A significant number of the participants on January 6, 2021 were from districts where Biden won. What the Republican Party has unleashed is a Pandora’s box of racism that the country seems helpless to stop. This his not of Southern origin, it is a national disgrace.
emphatically agreed, Paul
This story is truly disturbing and brings up serious concerns about systemic racism and abuse of power in law enforcement. It’s hard to believe that something like this could happen in Tennessee in 2023. Are there any updates on the situation with the Black family from Georgia and their fight for their children’s return?
mr w
http://www.primarytinting.net
As of two hours ago, the five children are still in police custody. A few legislators and the Tennessee NAACP have called for their release. Even the nursing baby!
https://tennesseelookout.com/2023/03/25/deeply-concerned-and-disturbed-tennessee-naacp-demands-investigation-release-of-children-taken-after-traffic-stop/
It is appalling how little people understand the damage it causes to the nursing dyad – both child and mother – when breastfeeding is interrupted in this way. A four month old infant is deprived of its food! The siblings have asthma, so the baby might also have a reaction to many commercial infant formulas.
More egregious still is the police lied to the mother about what was happening to allow time for child services to get paperwork permitting them to kidnap her children. Imagine these parents’ despair.
This is disgusting. This couple had no rights and shouldn’t have had this happened. What is wrong with our justice system? This is so unbelievable you would think we lived in a martial law universe!
Jeanne,
When I read the story, my jaw dropped. How could this happen? Why did the police seize their children on account of a minor traffic violation. I didn’t know it was illegal to have tinted windows. I didn’t know it was illegal to drive in the left hand lane unless you are passing.