New York City has received thousands of migrants busses by Governor Greg Abbot of Texas. The city is doing its best to help them. Their children are in public schools.
Parent activist Leonie Haimson visited a school that has enrolled 50 new migrant students. She was stunned to learn that the New York City Department of Education has not provided funding for these students.
She writes:
The school I visited hasn’t received an extra penny, and the principal was told that she would have to wait until November or beyond, for the standard mid-year adjustment to their budget.
When asked when these schools with large numbers of migrant students would receive more funding, Chancellor Banks said at the CPAC meeting this week,and again at a D75 Town Hall meeting, that they were waiting for federal government to kick in with more aid. Here’s the exact quote from the Chancellor at CPAC meeting.
“You might want to be as helpful as possible but if you don’t have the dollars I think the sense here is that the federal government will at some point is going to come and provide a level of support um you’ve got midterm elections that are happening over the next couple of weeks so that’s a lot of this is political as well in terms of when the aid and the support will come but I think I think here in New York the leadership feels as though the federal government is not going to abandon us here.”
However, the DOE still has over more than four billion dollars of unspent federal Covid aid, and an $8 billion reserve fund, so the idea that they couldn’t front the money to schools before the feds provide more dollars is absurd. The account of my visit to this school follows.

Not only is the Chancellor’s answer completely outrageous, but it is an embarrassment that the head of the DoE can’t produce a grammatically correct and coherent sentence!
LikeLike
Unless all the Title 1 money has been encumbered, these newcomers should be eligible to receive federal funding as well.
LikeLike
BTW as a retired ESL/ENL teacher, I know what it is like to be swamped by needy newcomers. If the district cannot access funds until certain times, perhaps they can find the money to pay for an additional TA until such time another teacher can be hired. Some colleges also require education majors to get field experience before student teaching, and these trainees can assist students under the direction of the ENL/bilingual teacher. Even national honor society volunteers that must do community service can be of some use, but they are no long term solution.
LikeLike
From my over thirty year experience with ELLs, I also know that many administrators drag their feet on hiring new teachers for this population. Secretly, some of them hope these students will move, and some may leave since parents will follow other family members and jobs. Generally, other ELLs will arrive to take their place.
LikeLike
In Utah we don’t even get extra funding for Multi Lingual Learner’s. They are just put in our classes. Many of them speak little English.
LikeLike
New York has a mandate that requires it to provide eligible students with appropriate bilingual ESL/ENL services.
LikeLike
Not for nothing ridership is down on the NYC MTA by 38% this in large part due to the work from home culture that accelerated dramatically in 2020. This change has affected the tax base of NYC dramatically. The Commercial Real Estate ,Construction , Retail ,Restaurant sectors in the Business districts, taking a huge hit. While the Travel and leisure sector is still not up to 2019 levels . This exacerbates unemployment in the mostly low wage sectors, causing an increased need for social services a drop in income tax receipts and crime to spike . As much as I maintain that crime is very over hyped in NYC what’s true is that the media disinformation has created a perception of crime that threatens to put a Republican Fascist in the Governors office. That should be great for Public Schools. Is now the time to cut police budgets . You got my vote for that , but I am a small minority getting smaller by the day.
. Eric Adams finally went on National TV yesterday to complain that violent crime is over hyped in NYC and was down 15% year to date . He over hyped the violent crime problem in his campaign and right up till yesterday. Now that perception of crime is biting him in the butt. Grand Larceny a non contact theft (mostly Shop Lifting and some Pick-pocketing ) is through the roof and car thefts. The only crimes surpassing levels seen in 2012 and 13 when Bloomberg was calling NYC the safest city in America . But when the media fail to put numbers in perspective they shape public opinion.
States and Cities do not print money it does not seem unreasonable for the City to wait for Federal Assistance a few months for a problem that arrived on our door step a little over a month ago.
LikeLike
Gross incompetence… btw, are charter schools scrambling to enroll the migrant children?
LikeLike
Sure. Same as Trump is scrambling to find a yoga studio in Palm Beach that can fit him in.
LikeLike
Do migrant children have high test scores? No? Then neither charter schools nor their advocates in office will lift a finger for them. People are not people. People are human capital. That’s all they are to the demented proponents of corporate school “reform”.
LikeLike
Welcome to education these days. Expect the teachers to pick up the slack for everyone’s lack of help with no additional funding
LikeLike
Of course a huge influx of kids who speak little to no English causes financial strain on public schools and other public services. Do the readers of this blog now finally recognize that the intentionally lax immigration policies of the Biden administration have caused this problem? Of course not: open borders immigration is the woke policy, and any opposition to massive immigration is “racist”, even though not long ago many prominent Democratic leaders publicly said that massive immigration was not good for the country.
LikeLike
Ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha!
Thanks for the laugh!
LikeLike
The Biden immigration policy is the same as the Trump policy with these exceptions:
1. No kids in cages
2. No taking babies from their mothers
3. No wasting billions on an ineffective Wall
LikeLike
So why is the number of border crossers so much higher than when Trump was President? Why did most prominent Democratic politicians favor restricting immigration until fairly recently? Wokeism won’t allow you to face this problem honestly.
LikeLike
I wish DeSantis and Abbott would send some immigrants to Long Island. The hotels, restaurants, farms, and vineyards are all short of workers to do the hard work that the locals shun. Grant them green cards so they can work legally. The pay is good.
LikeLike
OK, I must ask again. Do you have any evidence to support this claim? If not, your screeds are simply a matter of opinion–and not a very informed opinion. Try harder, won’t you?
LikeLike
Would you care to produce any evidence to substantiate these dubious claims?
LikeLike
Your comment exposes your bigotry and agenda. Define lax immigration and how it compares to U.S. law. Define “open borders.” And if you think you have any integrity at all, define “massive immigration.” Is there a starting/expiration date for your definition? Do the people who maintain the yards, staff the kitchens of their favorite restaurants or do much of the essential gruntwork of this nations have any linkages to middle-to-upper-class Americans?
LikeLike
Do you favor unlimited immigration – no restrictions at all. How will the benefits that tens of millions of low-skilled, low-income people be paid for? You casually throw around the epithet of bigotry, but no doubt haven’t given a single second of thought to the financial ramifications of open borders.
LikeLike