Like many other states, Texas is facing a dramatic shortage of teachers. Teachers are fed up by low pay, poor working conditions, and the disrespect heaped on them by hare-brained politicians like Governor Gregg Abbott and Lt. Governor Dan Patrick. While the politicians blabber on about “parental rights,” by which they mean the right of parents to dictate curriculum and to censor books, none of them talk about the value of teachers and their importance.
Politicians tell teachers that they must not discuss gender or sexuality. They must not discuss the past or presence of racism, which is alive and well in Texas and everywhere else. Politicians prattle on about “critical race theory,” which they do not understand and cannot define. Bottom line, they don’t want teachers to talk about racism because it makes the politicians uncomfortable; it makes racists uncomfortable when you mention their bigotry.
The Houston Chronicle reports:
More Texas teachers are considering leaving the profession than at any point in the last 40 years, according to new polling from the Texas State Teachers Association.
The survey found that 70 percent of teachers were seriously considering quitting this year, a substantial jump from the 53 percent who said so in 2018, the last time the typically biennial survey was conducted. Teachers attributed their grim outlook to pandemic-related stress, political pressure from state lawmakers, less support from parents and stretched finances.
I don’t know where they got that “last 40 years” number, because there was never a time when so many teachers were ready to throw in the towel and walk away from their classrooms.
Texas can’t afford to pay teachers more? Nonsense. Texas, under Abbott’s non-leadership, doesn’t want to pay teachers more. Abbott sees more to be gained politically by demonizing teachers.
In the survey, which was completed by 688 Texas teachers, 94 percent said the pandemic increased their professional stress, and 82 percent said financial stress was exacerbated. Experts have pointed to better pay as a key way to recruit and retain teachers. Respondents taught for about 16 years on average, and their average salary was around $59,000. That’s about $7,000 below the national trend, according to the teachers association.
Besides salary, Texas teachers on average also receive some of the worst retirement benefits of those in any state, a separate study from June found. Teachers who have retired since 2004 have not received a cost-of-living adjustment, although the Legislature has passed some “13th check” bills that send extra annuity payments.
In addition to pay, 85 percent said they felt state lawmakers held a negative view of teachers, 65 percent said the public held a negative view and 70 percent said support from parents had decreased over the last several years.
Abbott and fellow Republicans in the Texas Legislature have recently enacted several high-profile education policies, over opposition from teachers groups and education experts.
Last year, the Legislature placed restrictions on social studies curriculum, prohibiting certain discussions about racism. Abbott banned school districts from instituting mask mandates last fall, as COVID-19 cases surged. And schools are now facing calls for censorship of books that include discussions about race, gender or sexual orientation.
“For political reasons, Gov. Abbott has been trying to drive a wedge between parents and teachers, and this has definitely hurt teachers and hurt their students as well. It threatens the future of public education in Texas,” wrote TSTA President Ovidia Molina.
“Many of these teachers will be missing from our classrooms this fall, and for others, it is only a matter of time.”
Abbott has defended the measures as a way to depoliticize education and restore power to families about what their children do and don’t learn. He is calling for “Parental Bill of Rights” legislation next year to give parents even more control, as conservatives criticize the public school system as too progressive.
“Many parents are growing increasingly powerless about what to do to regain that control. That must end,” Abbott has said. “No government program can replace the role that parents play in the education of their children.”
A spokeswoman for the governor, Renae Eze, emphasized his commitment to education funding and “support for our hardworking teachers.”
“In 2019, the Governor signed into law one of the biggest teacher pay raises in our state’s history—over $1 billion in annual investment—and established the Teacher Incentive Allotment, which puts teachers on a pathway to earning a six-figure salary while prioritizing high-need areas and rural schools,” Eze said.
The Teacher Incentive Allotment gives raises to high-performing teachers. It has been rolled out to about 10 percent of Texas’ roughly 1,200 school districts, but almost all of the funds for the statewide program go to Dallas ISD — receiving 10 times more than any other district. The program is opposed by teachers unions, which advocate instead for universal raises.
Here are a few thoughts for Governor Abbot.
You have done everything possible to politicize the classroom with your bans and censorship.
You have insulted teachers.
You have pitted parents against teachers.
You have put your money into a merit pay incentive program that has never worked anywhere in the nation. Ever.
Your gag orders, your insertion of politics into what teachers teach, your hostility to public education demonstrates your contempt for teachers.
Your devotion to vouchers shows that you prefer schools where teachers have no certification, no preparation at all to teach. If you get your way, employers will avoid Texas. You favor indoctrination over education. You oppose freedom of thought. Your students will finish high school poorly educated. Texas will go backwards.
Shame on you.
Texas would like nothing more than for public education to fail so they could enact vouchers, charter schools and privatize public education!
Privatize public education?
Did you mean Christianize public education?
Because that is what the regressive reactionary xtian fundies like Abbot want-an xtian theocracy in America.
My guess is “the last 40 years” simply means they don’t have data from earlier than that.
Steve A,
I agree with you about “the last 40 years.” When I was a kid in Texas, in the 1950s, the schools I attended were staffed by teachers who had been there for many, many years. There was no exodus 50-60 years ago.
No one wants to work for low pay in conditions of low autonomy in which they are constantly micromanaged and disrespected. That should be obvious enough.
Thanks to Bill Gates and to all those deformers of US education who have fed and are feeding at his trough.
Bob and Roy both make excellent points.
I think Bob and Ray make a better point about working conditions.
OMG, Greg. Freaking hilarious.
LOL! 😀
No trough for the paper clip workers. Last night, I watched the Motorcycle Diaries movie about Che Guevara. The final frame of the movie said Guevara was murdered with the support of the CIA.
Teachers are the latest wedge issue for those who want to rob your pocket
The last holdouts (along with some other government workers) among unionized employees. The American oligarchical class will not be happy until it has snuffed out all remaining vestiges of unionism.
The workers at Starbucks seem to be leading the revival of unionism.
The day will come when the fight for unions will really be on again. Such a shame that that ground has to be taken once again. But it has to be, and eventually, will be. After a period of horrific darkness, I’m afraid.
Texas and some other states are making a deliberate decision to disinvest in public education. The Texas economy is strong and stable so there is no excuse for the permanent state of austerity. A strong economy may also mean that teachers can find employment elsewhere without the lack of support and disrespect they get from the Abbott administration.
Some rural districts in Texas have been unable to fill vacancies. They have decided to have a four day a week school week. This does not bode well for the future of public schools in the state. https://www.texastribune.org/2022/07/19/texas-schools-four-day-weeks/
Next, Abbott will say there’s only enough money to educate boys, no money for girls. The religious schools will only allow boys to enroll- Tex ali ban.
Nah, not a gender issue. It’s one of educating xtians for an xtian theocracy. To hell with non-xtians.
Not mentioned here, but the laundry list making it hard to attract teachers to the state should probably include
–Texas abortion law bans abortion after “heartbeat”[not] at 6wks with vigilante/ bounty enforcement.
–Texas gun laws allow people to carry handguns without a permit.
Texas is the home of a Republican Party that simultaneously declares itself to be patriotic and calls for secession from the Union. The Republican Party of Texas has gone totally off the deep end into insanity and sedition and never met a program that hurts the little guy and supports superstition/fundamentalism and fascism/nationalism that it didn’t like.
Bob, that’s a good desecription of the Texas GOP. The party has descended into insanity.
The election this November is crucial.
The state’s voters must show whether they support a fanatical fundamentalist team running the state.
Or rejoin civilization.
Amen, Diane.
Texas the only state that went to war twice to preserve slavery!
Exactly!!!!! Not something they want their little white students to learn. Might hurt their little white snowflake feelingses.
A warning to the people of Texas:
You are living in Texas.
I believe that Russian intelligence has kompromat on the loser guy, to our shame, our last president, and on a number of high-level U.S. officials and public figures, including Senators and loser guy lawyers and academics who defend the loser guy. Here’s a tell: For years, person x derided Trump as a charlatan and crook. Then, suddenly, he or she was willing to go to extremes to support Trump, uttering falsehoods, breaking the law, and supporting enemies of the United States like the regime of Tzar Vladimir Putin. Those who meet this criterion–the sudden flip on Trump and the extreme and otherwise incomprehensible support for the craziest of Trump positions, such as the Ukraine quid pro quo, the attempted overthrow of the incoming government after the last election, and the private mishandling of the most highly classified of national secrets–are very likely people on whom the Russians have significant dirt. These kinds of weirdness, so common in recent years, requires explanation. These are huge red flags. These are sure signs that these people have been turned and are now assets or agents of Putin’s intelligence services.
cx: require explanation
Imagine a similar situation: A prosecutor in a district attorney’s office suddenly becomes a high-profile defender, in the press, of members of a local crime family. One day he is sending these folks to prison; the next day he is telling reporters that Vito “Fast Fingers” Crookabino is “a highly respected businessman” and that “The Mafia is a creation of journalists and doesn’t exist.” What does this tell you?
It tells you that they’ve gotten to him. The mob has gotten to him.
Oh, come on. Abbott has no deeply felt positions about teachers and education. He just wants as many of them to quit as is possible to be able to replace them and their schools with charter schools. Public schools without enough teachers will soon be targeted by the State of Texas for closure, to be replaced, of course, mark my words. This is not an education issue, it is a political issue. It needs to be addressed as a political issue. Expose the strategy for what it is. Expose Abbott’s ties to the charter school industry. We need to attack, not defend.
The attacks on public schools are based on politics, not merit. Texans need to vote for BETO as he is the best hope of a more equitable future.
Correction: “He just wants as many of them to quit as is possible to be able to replace them and their schools with CHRISTIAN schools.”
In how many red states, are the number of students at Catholic schools greater than the number at Christian schools? Are anti-abortion lessons taught at both?
What percent of Christian schools are single sex (30% of Catholic schools are single sex).
Which is more likely, a dress code for girls (skirts) at Christian or at Catholic schools?
Which religions prohibit women from clergy roles?
Btw- until Paige Patterson’s leadership of the Southern Baptist conference, women were not prohibited from ministerial roles in their churches.
Which religions operate as patriarchies?
Linda,
When I use the term xtian, it includes the Catholic sector, of which I know quite well from having experienced a Catholic K-12 education.
“the politicians blabber on about “parental rights,” by which they mean the right of
parentspoliticians to dictate curriculum and to censor books”Fixed.
The whole “parental rights” thing is just a phoney baloney excuse made up by politicians to get away with forcing their own ideology down people’s throats and the parental rights organizations are almost always astroturf groups funded by billionaires who also happen to be funding the campaigns of the politicians claiming to support parental rights.
Thank you for this post. We are following the USA (particularly Republican states) closely here in Alberta, Canada where our current government seems hellbent on dismantling our public services including public education. Our current politicians are borrowing bad ideas from the USA and we are working hard to counter this action and narrative!
Buena suerte!
Yes, alas, bad education ideas deriving from Gates and Pear$on, have now metastasized and are worldwide phenomena. Finnish education theorist Pasi Sahlberg calls this the Global Educational Reform Movement, or GERM.
The world needs a Gates vaccine.
Just not in the way he believes.
Maybe Biden could get Moderna to make a mRNA vaccine that would tell the cells to produce the Gates spike protein in order to build up anti-billies.
antibillies. LMAO!!!