Senator Joe Manchin of West Virginia and Senator Krysten Sinema held the power to block the Democrats’s ambitious bill to reduce carbon emissions and improve healthcare. Each of them extracted a hefty price in exchange for their vote, one that benefited either their state, their campaign donors, or themselves personally.
This analysis by the New York Times shows that Manchin got a trifecta: a win for the coal industry (big in his state), a win for his campaign donors, and a win for himself. Sinema demanded the removal of taxes on private equity firms..
Plenty of West Virginians are angry at Manchin. They are environmentalists. Senator Manchin takes care of the fossil fuel industry, not them.
BLACKSBURG, Va. — After years of spirited opposition from environmental activists, the Mountain Valley Pipeline — a 304-mile gas pipeline cutting through the Appalachian Mountains — was behind schedule, over budget and beset with lawsuits. As recently as February, one of its developers, NextEra Energy, warned that the many legal and regulatory obstacles meant there was “a very low probability of pipeline completion.”
Then came Senator Joe Manchin III of West Virginia and his hold on the Democrats’ climate agenda.
Mr. Manchin’s recent surprise agreement to back the Biden administration’s historic climate legislation came about in part because the senator was promised something in return: not only support for the pipeline in his home state, but also expedited approval for pipelines and other infrastructure nationwide, as part of a wider set of concessions to fossil fuels.
It was a big win for a pipeline industry that, in recent years, has quietly become one of Mr. Manchin’s biggest financial supporters.
Natural gas pipeline companies have dramatically increased their contributions to Mr. Manchin, from just $20,000 in 2020 to more than $331,000 so far this election cycle, according to campaign finance disclosures filed with the Federal Election Commission and tallied by the Center for Responsive Politics. Mr. Manchin has been by far Congress’s largest recipient of money from natural gas pipeline companies this cycle, raising three times as much from the industry than any other lawmaker.
NextEra Energy, a utility giant and stakeholder in the Mountain Valley Pipeline, is a top donor to both Mr. Manchinand Senator Chuck Schumer, Democrat of New York, who negotiated the pipeline side deal with Mr. Manchin. Mr. Schumer has received more than $281,000 from NextEra this election cycle, the data shows. Equitrans Midstream, which owns the largest stake in the pipeline, has given more than $10,000 to Mr. Manchin. The pipeline and its owners have also spent heavily to lobby Congress.
The disclosures point to the extraordinary behind-the-scenes spending and deal-making by the fossil fuel industry that have shaped a climate bill that nevertheless stands to be transformational. The final reconciliation package, which cleared the Senate on Sunday, would allocate almost $400 billion to climate and energy policies, including support for cleaner technologies like wind turbines, solar panels and electric vehicles, and put the United States on track to reduce its emissions of planet-warming gases by roughly 40 percent below 2005 levels by the decade’s end.
Read the rest of the story in the New York Times.
Ever wonder why Manchin is still chair of the Committee on Energy and Natural Resources? Ever wonder why Biden gave his wife a plum job? Ever wonder why Democrats never threaten to investigate Manchin for any of his obvious conflicts of interest or other corruption?
Could it be because Dems need Manchin’s vote or nothing passes?
Ever wonder why dienne77 wants Manchin’s seat to be held by a Republican when the Senate is tied 50-50?
Could it be for the same reason she celebrated her “victory” when the Democrat was defeated in 2016 just like she wanted? Could it have been because she knew that Democrat would be choosing the replacement for Justice Scalia (with the Supreme Court tied 4-4) and she did NOT want Citizens United repealed so that corporations could continue to have enormous influence in government?
There isn’t a real progressive in the country who believes it was terrific that the Democrat was prevented from choosing a replacement for Scalia in 2016. The real progressives know that if RBG had 3+ years to lead a Supreme Court majority that repealed Citizens United, this country would be far more progressive and Manchin and Sinema would lose power.
The Republicans know that the way for Susan Collins to lose power is to not need her vote for their regressive agenda. Not to primary her out so that a Democrat wins that seat and makes the entire Republican party irrelevant.
There is a line in the movie “October Sky” when a garrulous West Virginia miner assures Homer Hickam that he will be fine slaving in mines for the rest of his life because he will take to it “like a tick to a dog.” Quite the appropriate metaphor of a parasite slowly draining the life out of its victim while pretending to do no harm. The mining industry has held many in Appalachia hostage to a life of poor health and poverty since its inception. Joe Manchin simply continues this tradition while pretending to be all about West Virginia’s miners who have suffered for his wealth. West Virginia miners continue to endure in devastated small towns and through toxic environmental exploitation. Yet, those who do vote continue to support the fossil fuel industry and thus, Manchin and Republican chicanery. The worst irony is that the coal and fossil fuel industry is facing a slow painful death while the politicians in Appalachia, including Manchin, Mitch McConnell, Chuck Shumer et al., comfortably establish their golden parachutes while ignoring the economic devastation ahead for the citizens they supposedly represent. One can only hope we get to renewable energy soon. Meanwhile watch the parasites keeping sucking the blood of their constituents until there is none left.
Paul,
I recall that the governor of West Virginia, Jim Justice, is a billionaire and the richest man in the state. He was elected as a Democrat, then switched parties. When the state’s teachers went on strike in 2018, they got lots of promises. In addition to a pay raise, the governor promised no charters, no vouchers. He lied.
I remember the 1960s Tennessee Ernie Ford song “Sold my Soul to the Company Store”, yet West Virginians continue to support their oppressors.
This is just one more indication of whose interests get served by Congress.
There is a very big irony in Manchin’s claiming he is doing everything in the name of fiscal conservatism, when he is effectively requiring a “toll” for every bill Congress passes.
And he’s hardly alone.
Especially on military spending, Congress is like a giant toll plaza where every Congress member takes the toll for their own state (and sometimes for themselves).
That’s why the spending always goes up, never down.
Even folks like Sanders who criticize the 3/4 trillion military budget are not willing to cut projects when they directly benefit their own states, not even in boondoggles like the F35.
I don’t blame Bernie for looking out for his state. At least he is not a corporate shill that ignores the needs of his constituents like most of the Republicans and many Democrats as well. I think of Bernie as an idealistic realist. He knows how to play the game, but he remains free from corporate strings tries to actually represent his people and nation. Maybe that’s the key to his longevity in politics, trustworthiness.
I certainly did not claim or even imply Sanders was a “corporate shill”.
What I did was point out a fact.
And if Sanders is going to criticize bloated military spending, he is certainly fair game for criticism onn continuing to support Pentagon contracts fof f35 in his own state.
I didn’t mean to imply that Bernie works for corporations. It is his freedom from corporate strings that allows him to better represent his constituents. He doesn’t have a “quid pro quo” arrangement with billionaires and corporations so he can be more independent than most other politicians.
retired teacher,
It is amazing that you understand that about Bernie Sanders but not the many, many other Democratic Senators. There is a double standard where the compromises for constituents made by Bernie are fine, but the ones made by Dems like Amy Klobuchar are not.
Give the Senate a significant majority and Manchin and Sinema become insignificant.
Not to mention the fact that every Senator is a millionaire even if they didn’t start that way their freshman term. They don’t get wealthy on their salary of 174,000 per year. A lot of padded wallets in Washington.
Members of Congress get free medical care for the rest of their lives.
So should we all.
The reduction in emissions ensures that many of the children today (even the pre-born!!) will get various cancers, respiratory diseases, and immune deficiencies without the prospect of any support when they get older. And it’s going to hit West Virginians the hardest (and their neighbors to the east), even the ones who want to protect their race from the invasion of librul Mongrel herds to becoming pawns of their corporate masters.
It is apparent that Joe has sold his soul to Democratic interests. We will know too soon.