Thanks to G.F. Brandenburg, who posted this very important report about The Battle of Blair Mountain, a largely forgotten milestone in the history of unionism.
Brandenburg opens his post by reminding us that the rich and powerful usually control history and write the narrative.
He adds this dramatic story of The Battle of Blair Mountain, which is unknown to most people and barely remembered in the state where it happpened. The famous but almost-forgotten battle pitted underpaid, impoverished miners against the coal industry’s hired and well-armed detectives and union-busters. After several days of fighting, federal troops were sent in to stop the combat.
The story was written by Irina Zhorov and appeared on PBS WHYY.
The site of the conflict is marked by an inconspicuous plaque. The land is inaccessible because its owned by a coal company.
Here is the lead-up to the Battle of Blair Mountain:
In early 20th-century Appalachia, miners in the southern West Virginia coal fields lived in company towns. They were dependent on their bosses for every necessity, including their homes and food. Pay was low. Living and working conditions were deplorable.
The United Mine Workers union attempted to organize miners in the region, but the coal companies fought back, often violently. In a series of clashes now called the Mine Wars, both union and company supporters were killed.
By 1921, tensions were coming to a head. Miners in Mingo County, south of Blair, had joined the union. In retaliation, the company had evicted them from their homes. The miners had been rounded up and were being kept in pens. State police had cut off food supplies, so families were starving.
Then private detectives who worked for the coal companies brazenly murdered a union sympathizer named Sid Hatfield, a hero to the miners. It was broad daylight, and Hatfield’s wife was by his side. Tensions boiled over.
One week after the murder, Frank Keeney, the leader of West Virginia’s United Mine Workers chapter — and Chuck Keeney’s great-grandfather — gave a series of speeches to rally miners in the coal fields.
Miners—10,000-15,000 of them—marched 50 miles to Blair Mountain to protest and fight.
Clearly, there are many people in West Virginia today whose parents or grandparents took up arms against the tyrannous coal companies. They know the history because it’s personal.
Yet this legacy of labor militancy does not seem to have any role in today’s politics. West Virginia is a red state with a Republican-controlled legislature. The Governor, Jim Justice, was a Republican who became a Democrat for his election in 2016. Seven months after his election, he reverted back to being a Republican, at a political rally with Trump by his side. Governor Justice is a billionaire who controls many businesses, mostly in agriculture and coal mining.
Why do West Virginians keep electing and re-electing Republicans who are hostile to the interests of poor and working-class people?

Ex West Virginian here. There’s a bunch of us. Truth to tell, the Dems couldn’t do much about the extractive economy that wrecks the environment and people’s health. They sold out, but at least supported social programs. There are several books about Blair Mountain now. People didn’t talk much about it when I was growing up. Many of the combatants were still alive; maybe that was why. It was never taught in school.
LikeLike
Read (or re-read) Zinn’s People’s History and you’ll find story after story like this throughout our history. And in every case, local, state and federal governments, regardless of party, have invariably supported businesses at the expense of the people, often at the cost of hundreds or even thousands of lives.
LikeLike
Our local military (105th MAW) base commander was caught, by one of his own SPs (Security Police), dumping a tanker full of fire-fighting foam containing toxic PFOA into the city water supply – poisoning the drinking water of thousands – including base personnel.
The SP reported this to the state and was threatened with M-16s. Years later the USAF was forced to pay millions for water remediation for the city which now gets its water from the NY City water supply – leaving anyone who ingests the old water subject to cancer.
No criminal charges were ever brought against the Commander or his men but the former SP’s life was wrecked.
LikeLike
Why do West Virginians keep electing and re-electing Republicans who are hostile to the interests of poor and working-class people?
Keep them focused on imaginary caravans of rapists and murderers, imaginary Antifa, imaginary Socialists, imaginary homosexual and transgender recruiters of youth, imaginary indoctrination in “CRT,” abortion. Keep telling them that the people working every day against their interests are the champions of them, the real Americans.
LikeLike
Bob,
Case in point to prove your assertion.
Sen. Joe Manchin, multimillionaire beneficiary of the coal industry, just killed Biden’s Build Back Better bill, which raised 300,000 families in West Virginia out of poverty and intended to curb climate change. Due to his ties to the coal industry, Manchin oppose all efforts to push against climate change.
LikeLike
I hope the DNC has some ads in the can ready to go nonstop in WV media. Theme: Here’s what your state, community, constituency didn’t get that was in the bill Joe Manchin single-handedly killed. Imagine a world with the things Manchin took away from you. But knowing what I do of Democrats, I doubt they thought that far ahead, or at all for that matter.
LikeLike
Yep, Diane, just thinking the same thing about Manchin. Doesn’t do one thing for his constituents (except hurt them) yet keeps getting reelected.
LikeLike
Joe Manchin, mountaintop removal coal tycoon
LikeLike
It’s a four letter word. Begins with r. Or a seven letter word in plural. It’s the never ending yearning to join with other people “like them” by and through “the hollowed collegiality of shared skin.” They never catch on that it will not ever be fulfilled, but they accept it as long as you-know-who doesn’t get ahead of them.
LikeLike
Greg, you may be right but I don’t know how to square your view with the fact that West Virginia is 94% white.
LikeLike
I’m guessing someone has studied this, but in my anecdotal experience, some of the deepest bigotries people have are for those with whom they have little or no contact. Indeed, I think this has something to do with rural/suburban disconnect with see with urban voters. People in New York, for example, come into contact with more ethnicities than those in the Dakotas. Having contact with “the other” seems to lessen fear. Anti-Semitism is quite strong in places where they’ve never seen a Jewish person. Or anti-Muslim sentiment here. Or CRT for non-existent bogeymen.
In the case of West Virginia, they are no different than the majority of white voters who consistently vote for candidates who do not represent their interests and maintain the status quo. Kevin Phillips figured that out way before Lee Atwater. But at least Phillips genuinely atoned for his sins. Walter Johnson explains this in his analysis in his analysis of how race and violence have shaped St. Louis and, by extension, the nation, in his book The Broken Heart of America.
LikeLike
Bob Dylan or LBJ . Take your pick for that citation. 60 years of treading backwards.
32% of income in West Virginia is from Federal transfers. That is highest in the Nation . And we are pushing to deliver more, tell me whose nuts .
Now unlike Virginia as Krugman pointed out last week ; who has Federal employees and contracts, Naval Bases , this is services delivered to people of West Virginia (and Kentucky Krugman’s example) from Medicare and Social Security to Food Stamps ,Welfare and support for hospitals …
Beam me up Scottie
LikeLike
Thanks to the late Sen. Byrd, WV has a CIA facility, and a strange top secret community that is impenetrable to modern surveillance— no internet access, cellphone, nothing. After all the extractive wealth that has exited the colony of West Virginia—it is barely a state—I don’t grudge any federal aid. I just wish the residents would wake up and recognize Joe for what he is: selfish, clannish, backwards, corrupt, and contemptuous. His colleague Sen. Shelley Moore Capito isn’t far behind. Her governor father went to prison for bribery and she inherited his political machine. So there is a tradition of “me first” from many, many politicians in that state. It creates a lack of opportunity for everyone else. Which is why young people leave.
LikeLike
Why does Trump think himself a genius? Because Don the Con, the Teflon Don 2.0, has almost always been able to get away with whatever scam he was pulling. A case in point: there’s a famous photo of Trump in his Offal Office, head sort of bowed, with a crowd of fundamentalist preachers around him, some laying hands on him, all engaged in a prayer for his success. After these people cleared out, one of Trump’s flunkies left in the room with him, reported that he said, “What a bunch of idiots. They all believe that s–t.” Trump constantly made fun of Pence the Dense for his choir boy faith. Pence responded with utter slavishness until the very end, when he refused to go along with the Cuckoo Coup of 2021. Trump his like P.T. Barnum, who got the rubes to exit his exhibitions by posting a sign and a one-way door “This Way to the Egress!” Ofc, it doesn’t take real intelligence to do this kind of thing. It just requires a low cunning.
I was recently checking out at a local supermarket. In the checkout lane were magazines, one of which was a 90-page, four-color, glossy photoessay magazine called: The Faith of Donald Trump. LOL. Trump worships Trump and Mammon. Two Corinthians and Trump walk into a bar. Trump says, “Six plates of Mozzarella Sticks and two Diet Cokes for me. Nothing for them. They are imaginary. Oh, and Mexico will pay for it.”
LikeLike
Surely you jest! The “Faith of Donald Trump”? Faith in what? Not in religion. Faith in Mammon, to be sure.
LikeLiked by 1 person
A few points on the History . The term redneck which has pretty much become an ethnic slur has its origins in the red bandanas worn by Union workers to identify themselves in the mine wars. So yes history is written by the elites.
The UMW which had 100,000 members in the region at the start of the mine wars lost 90,000 members .
The National Guard refused to fire on their friends and neighbors which prompted the dispatch of Federal Troops. The miners being vastly out numbered many of them veterans viewed the Federal Troops as neutral put down their arms . Over 500 Hundred miners who refused to fire on those Federal Troops were sent to Federal Prisons only to pardoned by an act of congress in 1928 when investigations revealed among other things that General Billy Mitchell had given lessons to the mine operators on how to use the Bi-Plane to drop bombs on the miners.
The Median family income in West Virginia is 42,600 the 95 percentile is at 150 k .Making it one of the poorest States in the Union . West Virginia is one of the Whitest states in the Union 94% White only. Less than 4% Black or Hispanic, relevant because unlike other poor states citizens can see poverty as a affecting the other with large minority communities.
Joe Manchin just killed the Build Back Better Bill. He can’t explain it to the people of West Virginia . You can not fix the stupidity of the people of West Virginia who voted for Trump by 68%.
LikeLike
LikeLike
Just as long as they’re kickin’ hippies’ asses and raisin’ hell.
LikeLike
They may get what they want when Republicans take power and gut the rest of the safety net.
LikeLike
Roman Empire’s ‘Bread & Circuses’ (Cicero)
LikeLike
In the early 20th century, there was literal war against workers and their unions; even in one instance, they used airplanes to bomb the strikers. Violence was not uncommon on both sides of the dispute; once the companies resorted to goon squads and the Pinkertons to quash the strike or union, then the miners would resort to violence in return to defend themselves and their families. I am not trying to draw some kind of equivalence between the 2 sides. The company or the employer were the true culprit and cause of the violence because they refused to even sit down and talk to the miners or workers, they treated the workers as so much trash to be ignored and ruthlessly exploited.
From wikipedia: During the labor strikes of the late 19th, 20th and 21st centuries,[5] businessmen hired the Pinkerton Agency to infiltrate unions, supply guards, keep strikers and suspected unionists out of factories, and recruit goon squads to intimidate workers. One such confrontation was the Homestead Strike of 1892, in which Pinkerton agents were called in to reinforce the strikebreaking measures of industrialist Henry Clay Frick, acting on behalf of Andrew Carnegie.[6] The ensuing battle between Pinkerton agents and striking workers led to the deaths of three Pinkerton agents and nine steelworkers.[7][8] The Pinkertons were also used as guards in coal, iron, and lumber disputes in Illinois, Michigan, New York, Pennsylvania, and West Virginia as well as the Great Railroad Strike of 1877 and the Battle of Blair Mountain in 1921. end quote
LikeLike
I’m not sure if my comment actually got posted. So I repeat it below.
Sincerely, Bobbi Bobbi Eisenberg Chairperson, UFT Math Teachers Comm.
“When Miners March” https://www.amazon.com/When-Miners-March-William-Blizzard/dp/1604863005/ref=sr_1_6?crid=6AIIRS8YX5L9&keywords=the+battle+of+blair+mountain&qid=1639931319&s=books&sprefix=The+Battle+of+Bla%2Caps%2C137&sr=1-6
I had the honor of meeting the author, who was a very young child when his father led organizing meetings in their kitchen. By the time I met him c.2005, he was already in his 90s. Shortly after my retirement as a hs math teacher, I was taking a stained glass class at the Cedar Lakes Conference and Crafts Center in Ripley, WV. (Yes, the Ripley of “Ripley’s Believe It or Not”.) There was an evening presentation by the author and the social studies teacher, Wess Harris, who had found him. Harris was amazed to learn about the manuscript of this book, still in a dresser drawer after many decades, and saw to getting it published.
In addition to what you wrote in your blog, planes were sent to bomb the miners.
Thanks for alerting your readers to this mostly unknown bit of Labor History.
More good info – https://www.nytimes.com/2021/09/06/us/coal-miners-blair-mountain.html
The oppression continues to this day with the mountaintop removal method of mining and the shenanigans of the WV senator, Joe Manchin (their former governor and whose family owns coal company interests). His wife was their former head of the state’s education dept. I met her not too many years ago when she was a guest speaker at an AFT Convention. She was working with AFT on its efforts to help WV educators. I spoke to her at length after the speech and offered to do math workshops for the teachers (gratis) if they could be coordinated before or after my 2-3 times a year at Cedar Lakes (more stained glass + 2 other crafts). Nothing ever came of it although she seemed receptive to my offer.
I really love WV and its people! I strongly object to the statement of the poster who referred to their supposed “stupidity” when the problem for generations has been exploitation of extremely poor people, whose children also had to work in the mines instead of going to school, and who are not represented by Joe Manchin and their other politicians over the ages who have promised to keep coal mines going. Those pols know that coal mining is finished. For more than 20 years the preferred method of mining has been “mountaintop removal”. The top of a mountain is cut off to reveal veins of coal. Many fewer workers are required to do this. The remains are mixed with harmful chemicals to get the coal. The remaining toxic mix is dumped into and filled in the hollows (“hollers”) below with the result that water and people have been poisoned.
Once when I was driving to Cedar Lakes, I saw one of these raped mountains. It was a sad, horrible sight for the state known as The Mountain State and whose state university students are called The Mountaineers.
>
LikeLike
Yes, I don’t call West Virginians “stupid.” Exploited, yes. Joe Manchin is a multimillionaire polluter, but he’s not the only one. Most of those folks live on the upper East Side, Cape Cod, Back Bay Boston, even Mayfair. They make a good living from those folks with whom they wouldn’t be caught dead socializing. There is a class issue many Americans don’t understand. West Virginians are often made fun of, yet their work fueled the Gilded Age and built fortunes—for other people. It’s a sad story.
LikeLike
Roberta M. Eisenberg
Stop already with the excuses. Mining has been dead ever since Mountain top removal killed the Jobs. By the 70s those mountains were being destroyed. Being that this post is about unions , there are no major union mine operators left in the entire state. Long before environmental concerns and natural gas killed Jobs, the vast majority were gone while production was up as 6 story land movers plowed down the mountains. I might add with the blessing of Tony Boyle before they sent him to Prison for murdering his union opponent.
We have to stop manufacturing excuses for people’s actions. Those Children stopped working in the mines when the Fair Labor Standards Act was passed in 1938. That was near a century ago. By contrast Jim Crow did not officially end till the 60s and in reality long after, if ever.
As Krugman said the other day, referencing Kentucky( similar dynamics):
“So, in a real sense, Kentucky’s economy lives on federal dollars.
And that’s OK! The main reason Kentucky is such a large net recipient of federal funds is that the state is relatively poor — it’s in a region that has to some extent been economically stranded as production and wealth concentrate in large, highly educated metropolitan areas. As a lower-income state, Kentucky receives the full benefit of federal programs like Medicare, but pays relatively little in income or payroll taxes, so it gets much more than it pays in. And that is actually how the social safety net is supposed to work. We want individuals who for whatever reason are hurting financially to receive support from the more fortunate, which necessarily implies large transfers from rich states like New Jersey to lower-income states like Kentucky.
What’s not OK is when states that are huge net beneficiaries of progressive taxation and the social safety net preen and posture about self-reliance and the evils of big government. It’s even worse when they assert some kind of moral superiority over the metropolitan areas that pay their bills.”
As I stated 95% of Families in West Virginia would have gotten the benefit of programs like the Child tax credit.
Manchin could have whittled the Build Back Better act down to a tooth pick after the New Year . He is bolting the party and the issue is not BBB. The removal of the Filibusterer for voting rights would have forced him to vote on it. A vote for it and White Virginia throws him out on his butt.
A vote against it and he loses anyway.
Any bets.
LikeLike
With neither party helping workers, the choice voters in many rural areas make boils down to regulation of fossil fuels and food production — jobs, not wages. Workers wind up supporting big energy or big agriculture instead of supporting a brighter future for themselves. I understand. I’d rather administer the heinous standardized tests to my students than give up my teaching job, and neither party helps me. I feed big tech and I vote holding my nose. I think West Virginia does too. If one party were to put it’s full weight behind unions, private and public, and stop giving unions lip service and even calling them socialists, that party would win elections in urban and rural areas.
LikeLike
Mansion will vote the way that will be most financially beneficial for himself and his son.
It’s that simple.
He and his family are personally invested in the coal industry and Manchin himself has made millions off it since he joined the Senate.
It’s no accident that he says he will vote no on — effectively killing — the Build Back Better plan, which includes provisions to get America off its deadly coal addiction.
LikeLike
Should have gone below retiredbutmissthekids comment below
LikeLike
Yep, Diane, just thinking the same thing about Manchin. Doesn’t do one thing for his constituents (except hurt them) yet keeps getting reelected.
LikeLike
The Dens had better come back with ads detailing just what Manchin isn’t supporting: jobs, child care, bridge/road repair, clean energy, and—the biggie—clean water. The state needs to wake up. I was encouraged when the WV teachers were the first in the country to start fighting back.
LikeLike
The Man from La Mansion
Manchin in his mansion
Gutting Build Back Better
Corporate expansion
Trumps his voter’s letter
LikeLike
Manchin Bodes (with apologies to John Denver)
Senator Manchin, West Virginia
Bullshit mounting, never will deliver
Lies are older, older than the trees
Stronger than a skunk scent
Blowing on the breeze
Manchin bodes
Ill for Dems
In the fall
In mid terms
West Virginia
Joseph Manchin
Takes us right
Off a cliff
LikeLike
All his funders gather ’round him
Coal mine owner, fouler of blue water
Dark and dusty, painted on the sky
Vision of his mOOnshine, sticking in my eye
Manchin bodes, ill for Dems
In the fall, in mid terms
West Virginia, Joseph Manchin
Takes us right, off a cliff
I hear his voice in the mornin’ hour, he calls me
Whiny voice reminds me of his fake, lying way
Drivin’ down his road, I feel the certainty
I should’ve dumped him yesterday, yesterday
Manchin bodes, ill for Dems
In the fall, in mid terms
West Virginia, Joseph Manchin
Takes us right, off a cliff
LikeLike
Here’s a link to the one-take recording (John Denver, I ain’t. Sorry)
https://drive.google.com/file/d/1V9CcNeWTtcfBn-qxQMqOmHsS-vYwC9OU/view?usp=drivesdk
LikeLike
Your Manchin Roads is one of your best yet, SomeDAM! Well done!
This man is a human wrecking ball. And it’s more profound, even, than the destruction of Build Back Better. Hobbling Biden increases the changes, ofc, of a Repugnican sweep in 2022 and 2024.
LikeLike
Manchin might as well be a Republican. He votes like one.
LikeLiked by 1 person
His latest excuse for his opposition to the child tax credit is that he thinks parents will ” waste monthly child tax credit payments on drugs instead of providing for their children”.
I wonder if Manchin is speaking from experience.
LikeLike
Manchacity
Manchin never intended
To vote for Biden’s plan
Truth, it was upended
Before it was a plan
Those who fell for this
Will surely fall for that
Ignorance is bliss
Dog is just a rat
LikeLike
You’re right. He loved the attention, though.
LikeLike