The title of this post may sound absurd. Of course, children should play; it need not be a “right,” as defined in law, but it should be common sense. Play is an essential part of childhood. Most of us remember the games we made up, the pots and pans that we turned into playthings, the music we created on our own. But children today have been denied the fundamental time needed for unstructured play at school. The enactment of No Child Left Behind in 2002 prioritized academic skills and caused many schools to eliminate recess as a “frill.”
Today, happily, there is a movement to bring back recess. Whereas schools used to provide recess once, or twice, or three times a day, it is now legislatures that are mandating recess. Crazy, no? When I attended Montrose Elementary School in Houston, we had recess twice a day, without benefit of a state law.
Today there are several states that mandate recess, which seems to be the only way to guarantee that it is provided.
Parent activists in Illinois just won a victory in the Illinois legislature, with the passage of a bill that requires 30 minutes of recess daily and guarantees that children cannot be punished by withholding recess.
In Texas, where the state legislature spends most of its time figuring out how to increase the number of charters and how to pass vouchers, some districts have taken the initiative to make play available.
Others have decided to rethink recess at the school or district level. A program called LiiNK—Let’s Inspire Innovation ’N Kids—in several Texas school districts sends kids outside for four 15-minute recess periods daily.
Debbie Rhea, a professor and associate dean at Texas Christian University, launched the initiative after seeing a similar practice in Finland. It reminded her of her own elementary school years.
“We have forgotten what childhood should be,” said Rhea, who was a physical education teacher before going into academia. “And if we remember back to before testing—which would be back in the ’60s, ’70s, early ’80s—if we remember back to that, children were allowed to be children.”
LiiNK was a big change for the Eagle Mountain Saginaw Independent School District, where schools saw their recess time quadruple after implementing the program four years ago.
“We’ve seen some amazing changes in our students,” said district LiiNK coordinator Candice Williams-Martin. “Their creative writing has improved. Their fine motor skills have improved, their [body mass index] has improved. Attention in the classroom has improved.”
Some educators claim that play increases test scores, but that’s a shaky foundation for supporting one of the most important building blocks of childhood. Everyone needs time to play, even adults.
A right to play?
Children have no right
To jump and run and play
Restrictions should be tight
Should have to pay their way
Should always have to work
From dusk to dawn to dusk
Like Star Trek’s Captain Kirk
And Tesla’s Elon Musk
A child should have no time
To while away the day
It’s really just a crime
When children get to play
Stop writing poems and get serious, SomeDAM!
Twenty-first century! College! Career!
Learn how to code! Use data to diagram
The damn VAM flimflam sham edu-veneer!
Play NOT with your words — no wordsmiths allowed
In the dysto-globo economo show,
Test prep yourself, disrespect yourself, to the test scores be cowed!
Deplete yourself…
I must go to school now. Mark ‘incomplete’.
Given the headstrong philosophical nature of my daughter’s schools, she was given recess clear into middle school. Her little group mostly chose to role play in fantasy games based on their latest reading menu. They played roles from Harry Potter and the like .
My grandson has been home schooled this year. During the year my daughter has sent me a number of homemade videos in which my grandson dresses up and acts out different characters from the news or something else he has seen online. He is an only child so he hasn’t had much peer to peer interaction all year. He often uses his two dogs as his “audience” or props, and my daughter can be heard laughing off camera as she tapes the video. He has been a Proud Boy, a BLM member, Barack Obama, an old cowboy, a rock star, Dr. Fauci and the funniest one, the walking cartoon, DJT. These “performances” generally take the form of a soliloquy or rant depending on the character. They satisfy a need for creative, self expression and play, and they show how this eleven year old is making sense of the world we live in.
Very cool!
They certainly do. In fact, the inevitability of this is such that there are already a number of rent-seeking organizations seeking to commodify play as “play-based learning” and sell it to schools. Sickening.
Student Play Potential (SPP)
“We need a test
For ‘growth’ in play
To find the best”
Reformers say
“And also score
For teachers too
A VAM that’s for
The chosen few”
Guess that would be “PAM” (Play Added Model)
Ah, perfect,
The “Rent-Seekers” could be a dystopian film, where every policy decision by a govtl agency calls forth holographic ads hawking digital apps invented on the spot, which then haunt every step of potential buyers. Oh wait, they did that in “The Minority Report.” (Send in the clowns– don’t bother, they’re here.)
Oh-that’s perfect, Bethree. I actually just saw “Minority Report” (though I read the short story in high school in the 70s) the other night. Fine movie and, yeah, eerily prescient.
Me too, Mark! Don’t know why I passed it up for so long. That scene where’s he’s trying to escape into crowd, while giant holograph ads keep popping up at each step, calling him by name to peddle sneakers etc! Iconic.
“Parent activists in Illinois just won a victory in the Illinois legislature, with the passage of a bill that requires 30 minutes of recess daily and guarantees that children cannot be punished by withholding recess.”
I bet this will not stop the practice of keeping kids in for remediation.
Here’s the ed reform plan for summer school in the public schools they don’t support and don’t attend:
https://mercuryllc.app.box.com/s/wse3fs55ll635j7oi92gsv3a0uyw6uwz/file/817680950770
It’s a very “diverse coalition”, as you can see. The Koch family wrote this one, which makes it slightly different than when the Walton family writes one.
A very lively debate among and between the funders of the echo chamber and their employees. No public schools allowed.
I do not understand your comment. I clicked on your link, and found that parents had a clear preference for outdoor activities and experiential enrichment activities (STEM, museums, arts, etc) instead of academic remediation. When asked where they would prefer these activities take place, 67% of parents included public schools in their multiple choices, but only 25% included private schools, and 25% included religious schools. I finished the article wondering why the Koch Foundation had made the study public. The parent responses do not appear to support the agenda of the echo chamber.
Glad to see this finally turning around, & sad that it took so long. The research has been there all along. We can blame the counterintuitive elimination of play/ recess on govtl micromanagement of curriculum [NCLB & its sequels]. Now we’re stuck with that model and have to legislate to undo wrong-headed implementations.
I’ll add though that this kind of crap was going on, at least in my chi-chi NJ town, well before NCLB. K was already the new first grade, maximizing academics and minimizing play/ recess time. PISA wasn’t around until nearly a decade after my eldest started public school. I guess it was the general trickle-down from A Nation at Risk et al fear-mongering in the wake of manufacturing decline.
When my child was in fifth grade, the teacher gave massive quantities of homework. The school had a policy that students that did not complete all of their homework, lost recess that day. That fifth grade class had about twenty five students. Out of the twenty five students, there were only two students that were able to complete all thirty of the math problems given out each day. One student had a parent that was an engineer and spent hours each night helping the child work out all those problems. The other student had a parent with a STEM Ph.D. and also spent many hours each evening helping the child work out all the problems. The school policy of taking the few paltry minutes of recess away was child abuse.
This is such an important topic. Thank you for this post – and similar posts in the past.
Anyone interested can also so visit the Lego Foundation’s site for supporting research:
https://www.legofoundation.com/en/learn-how/knowledge-base/learning-through-play-a-review-of-the-evidence/
When I was in grade school, we had 3 recesses per day – morning, after lunch, and afternoon. Running and playing cleaned out the pipes and got the heart pumping oxygen-enriched blood to the lungs and brain. It strengthened muscles, bones, and circulatory systems. It worked off nervous energy and helped us settle down and pay attention when back in the classroom. It helped us develop social skills.
Any parent who’s really involved with their children has known these benefits all along. I guess that tells us what we need to know about who’s been making educational policy in Washington and State Houses the last 20 years.
I also follow this twitter account, whichI think I learned about through this blog a few years ago. Working in a (rigorous / data informed) public elementary school it’s easy to lose sight of what is developmentally appropriate for young children. It’s important to be continually reminded.
https://twitter.com/earlyplay?lang=en
From generation to generation, the educational pendulum swings back and forth. From my vantage point as a parent, grandparent, and retired educator, playtime fuels dreams which in turn become goals.