The Port Washington Union Free School District on Long Island in New York wrote an excellent letter to their representatives in Congress. It is a model letter that should inspire other local and state school boards.


We are the officials entrusted with overseeing the education of over 5.300 students in the Port Washington Union Free School District in Nassau County, New York. We arc writing to urge that Congress act ‘immediately’ to enact legislation that will waive all testing mandates under the Every Child Succeeds Act for the 2020-2021 school year. This would include not only the grades 3-8 ELA and math assessments, but also the 4th and 8th grade science assessments, any ELA, math, and science assessments required at the middle and high school levels, as well as any English Language Learner assessments required, and alternative assessments.
The pandemic has caused our country’s children immense psychological harm and stress. Children arc best served by face-to-face interactions and connections with teachers. staff. and know students, in a school building setting. Our school buildings arc our children’s ccosystem, and for many, it’s their primary source of emotional and social sup, (not to mention food and nutrition and sometimes even clothing). Last March. all of that was taken from them. literally overnight. Sadly. to this very day. many schoolchildren nationwide. including in Ncw York Statc, have yet to rctum to in-person instruction, and even for those who have rcturned. in-person instruction is often not full time and is plagued by constant quarantines of both students and staff.
Safely reopening our schools during this pandemic and creating a fully virtual K-5 school required spending to the mine of over S3.7 million – a staggering amount for any local school district. Yet. even with this immense expenditure. only our elementary school kids arc attending school in person full time, and our secondary students arc still in a hybrid cnvironmcnt that is less than ideal. Additionally. we have the constant quarantines of classes and teachers that further stalls Teaming.
These federally-mandated tests constitute an unfunded mandate. Many districts, such as Port Washington, have already dipped into reserve funds in order to safely reopen our schools. Administering the ESSA assessments is an incredibly wasteful endeavor, and a breach of our fiduciary duty to our taxpayers. Every moment that a teacher has with our nation’s children should and must be spent on substantive learning while focusing on their social and emotional well-being. Our students arc living in crisis. The very last thing these children need is to be subjected to assessments. Congress must act now to enact legislation that will waive all testing mandates under the Every Student Succeeds Act for the 2020-2021 school year.
Good morning Diane and everyone,
I feel the need to vent today. This is my situation:
1. I have some kids who just went into quarantine at home.
2. I have some kids who are coming in to school 2-3 times per week depending on our rotating schedule.
3. I have some kids coming to school in person every day.
Do you know what it’s like to try to plan for some organized teaching in this absurd situation? Well, it’s not easy. I don’t have to prepare my students for any standardized tests. I can’t imagine how teachers are coping if they have to prepare kids for these tests. It’s ridiculous. Of course, me, being the contumacious type, I’d probably say, “F” it and just teach. And where is the equity in this situation? Teachers have had kids rotating in and out and remote all year. Even if we could glean anything from these tests, how can we possibly do it in this situation? It’s completely nuts.
I understand your frustration. When I taught ELLs, I had a one room schoolhouse for half the day with students in grades one through five. Planning for such a group often kept me at school until about five o’clock. In ESL most of our students have a limited educational background. The term we use is “Students with Limited or Interrupted Formal Education (SLIFE) “English language learners who have experienced interrupted education. Now many of our American students have had a year of interrupted learning.
Teachers do not need to waste time on standardized tests in order to determine what students’ need. There are many way to assess students without administering standardized tests. The last thing our young people need this year is mindless test prep. They need human interaction and encouragement after the year we have had. We should put our students’ needs ahead of our compulsion to collect useless data.
AMEN, retired teacher. Agree with “We should put our students’ needs ahead of our compulsion to collect useless data.”
I am so sick and tired of hearing about TESTING kids. It’s INSANE.
Bet those FEW who make $$$$$ from those stupid tests and who also have connections with politicians (YUCK) are saying that our students need to be TESTED.
Those TESTS are JUST political and do nothing for our young and our country, except make a FEW very rich.
Follow the $$$$$.
I agree, its frustrating. I teach special ed- completely understand the stupidity!
Sorry for being off topic but I just read this jaw dropping article from Jersey Jazzman. Quote: The 6,000-student district faces chronic budget gaps, owing in part to a state school-funding formula that fails to account for the fact the district must also pay transportation costs for 37,000 Lakewood students attending private schools.
Yes, that’s right: only a small fraction of Lakewood’s students attend the public schools. And, yes, that is very unusual — especially for a state like New Jersey. end quote
80.8% of the kids in Lakewood NJ are in private schools!
http://jerseyjazzman.blogspot.com
This number of students in private schools in Lakewood is less a rejection of the public schools and more about a large, growing ultra-orthodox community there.https://www.jns.org/as-the-orthodox-jewish-community-in-lakewood-n-j-grows-tensions-are-spilling-over-into-neighboring-towns/
The ultra Orthodox Jews don’t send their children to public schools.
I don’t get it, I always assumed that private/religious schools had to supply their own transportation. Do the Catholic schools or any other religious schools aside from the ultra-orthodox also get tax payer funded bussing? That’s some weird state school-funding formula.
In NY, districts must provide transportation to students without regard to private or public, within certain distance limits. State law. Not sure of the law’s history.
AND “strict requirements in the Orthodox community lead to girls and boys in the same family riding on different buses to more than 100 different private schools scattered throughout the 25-square-mile township”! The Lakewood issue had already spread into next-door Toms River by the time this 2017 article was written. Their bused-to-privates numbers swelled from 150 to 1100 in 5 yrs.https://www.nj.com/news/2017/05/lakewood_busing_issues_expose_private_school_rides.html
See same issue in E Ramapo NY: https://www.lohud.com/story/news/local/rockland/ramapo/2019/11/20/state-audit-east-ramapo-schools-busing/4251859002/
East Ramapo School District is a disgrace. The school board is dominated by Orthodox Jews whose children attend Yeshivas. The board takes every opportunity to direct state and federal funds to their Yeshivas. The kids in the public schools are mostly black and Hispanic. Their education is shortchanged.
Local control of public schools is the ideal until it is not. Politicians controlling schools is essential only as long as we agree with the decisions they make.This is, I think, a fundamental dilemma of the orthodox posters on this blog.
That’s true of every institution and decision in this country. People are free to do whatever they want until they break the law. I can wear whatever I want but I can’t walk outside naked. I can drive wherever I want, but not at 90 miles per hour. Cities can make their own decisions, within the law. 95% of public schools are overseen by elected school boards, which must act lawfully.
Public schools providing transportation for religious schools was declared constitutional and not a violation of the first amendment in 1947 in Everson vs. Board of Education. It was considered a public safety issue. Religious schools reimburse public schools for the service. https://www.oyez.org/cases/1940-1955/330us1
“Religious schools reimburse public schools for the service.” Perhaps true in other states, but not in NJ. This is a local taxpayer subsidy to private schools. In NJ, we also subsidize them with regards to textbooks, nursing, and security through state taxes.
Los Angeles just made an agreement to return to campus. As soon as we do, it will be testing time. The first thing we will do when we return will not be to educate or support students.
That is so appalling and unfair. What universe do these “higher ups” live in. Testing should be waived.
Union Free School District, free of unions I presume. Th reformers must love this school district, (snark alert).
cx The
Just be pedantic because it is who I am – The term Union Free School District is from the 1850’s and actually refers to a union of two school districts not labor unions. I grew up in Port and can assure you there is a teacher’s union there.
Thanks for the background about the name. My comment was an attempt at humor (snark alert), I couldn’t resist with a name like that. So bold and sassy, see we don’t have any stinking unions. Just kidding. The right to work states would love a name like that. NY is a strong union state as is NJ.
This is a change, though, with the Biden Administration:
“Join us for a powerful final keynote session this Thursday with U.S. Education Secretary, Dr. Miguel Cardona, Connie Britton, and Dr. Tinisha Parker.
Secretary Cardona & Dr. Tinisha Parker in Conversation Moderated by Connie Britton
Students’ social emotional wellbeing goes hand in hand with improving student achievement and outcomes beyond school. Join Connie Britton as she moderates a conversation between U.S. Education Secretary Miguel Cardona and Dr. Tinisha Parker as they discuss how schools and communities can meet the social, emotional, mental health and academic needs of students, particularly as we grapple with the extraordinary disruption caused by COVID-19 and the disproportionate impact of the pandemic on communities of color and other underserved communities.
Dr. Tinisha Parker – Dr. Tinisha Parker has dedicated her life and twenty-year career to educating and supporting young people as they navigate life’s challenges. She has served students directly in the capacity of teacher, counselor, and administrator. She spent seven years supporting school counselors directly at the district level and was promoted to a executive leadership position where she currently serves as the Executive Director of Student Services for Gwinnett County Public Schools. In this role, Dr. Parker supports school counselors, social workers, and school nurses in addition to several student service programs including homeless, foster care and the career academy programs. She is also the Chair of the Board for the American School Counselor Association, which represents over forty thousand counselors nationwide, and a Past President of The Georgia School Counselor Association.”
They’re getting advice from people who work in public schools. That alone is a big difference from Bush, Obama and Trump.