The Washington Post says that Trump has latched on to school choice and a fast reopening as issues that will win back white suburban women, whose support for him has faded.
This may indicate how out of touch he is. Parents move to the suburbs because their property wealth creates good schools. There is no unmet demand in the suburbs for vouchers or charter schools.
Furthermore polls clearly show that parents want their children to return to safe schools. They do not want their children to go to full-time in-person instruction without safeguards in place.
Trump is unaware that vouchers are not popular, that they have lost every state referendum by large margins.
But Republicans won’t let school choice go, even though only a tiny percentage of parents choose to leave public schools, even when choice is easy and free.
The Post writes:
President Trump sees two school issues as key to reelection, and after paying almost no attention to education for most of his presidency, he’s pushing both in negotiations over the next pandemic relief bill.
The president’s first priority is getting schools to reopen this fall, which he sees as central to economic recovery and getting parents back to work. Trump regularly tells advisers that he believes it is “totally safe” for children to return to school, a senior White House official said.
He is also newly focused on school choice policies, which let families use tax dollars for private school tuition. Aides see both as political winners with suburban women and, in the case of school choice, black voters, too…
Now the White House is pushing Congress to tie tens of billions of dollars in new federal aid to whether schools restart in-person education, even as cases of covid-19, the disease caused by the novel coronavirus, climb. Trump also wants 10 percent of new K-12 spending set aside for private schools, including tax credits that would support private tuition scholarships, a form of vouchers.
Senate Republicans are proposing $70 billion for K-12 schools as part of the larger pandemic relief package, and Sen. Roy Blunt (R-Mo.) said half of that would be reserved for schools that are “going back to a traditional school setting” as opposed to only distance learning. He said that’s because operating in person creates new expenses.
For private schools, Republicans plan to set aside the 10 percent Trump wants, but they are not planning to include his tax credit plan. Rather, lawmakers are considering direct payments to private schools, or funneling dollars through scholarship funds, which help families pay private school tuition, a GOP Senate aide said. The aide, who spoke on the condition of anonymity to speak candidly, said these two options will be presented to Democrats, who could pick…
Presumptive Democratic nominee Joe Biden has taken a more nuanced tack. Last week, he released a plan that urged caution, saying that each school district should make decisions based on local conditions and that schools in areas with high infection rates should not reopen too soon.
“Donald Trump’s disastrous mismanagement of the coronavirus response is the top roadblock stopping schools from reopening,” said Biden spokesman Andrew Bates.
White House spokesman Judd Deere said: “If Disney World can be open, so can our schools.”
Politically, Trump’s gamble is that voters are more eager for their children to return to classrooms than fearful of the virus. Mercedes Schlapp, a top campaign adviser to Trump, put it this way at an online event aimed at women: “The suburban mom will say, ‘I am going to stick with President Trump on this one because he wants to make sure my kid gets back to school.’ ”
But the polling suggests that is a tough sell.
A Kaiser Family Foundation Health Tracking poll released Thursday found 6 in 10 parents with children in schools said it is better to open schools later to minimize infection risks, even if students miss out on academics and social services and some parents will not be able to work. About half that — 34 percent — said the reverse. A recent Quinnipiac University survey found voters disapproved of Trump’s handling of school reopenings by a margin of more than 2 to 1. Voters also said, again by a 2-to-1 ratio, that it was unsafe to send students to elementary, middle and high schools in the fall.
Republican allies have showed polling like this to Trump, warning him that pushing for full reopening will not be popular. Nonetheless, the White House is pushing forward, as Trump argues that reopening schools will eventually be widely popular.
“The president sees it as a metric of success that we are getting back to normal,” said a senior administration official, who spoke on the condition of anonymity to share internal discussions.
Bill Stepien- Trump’s new campaign manager
The public recognizes his name from the Bridgegate (Chris Christie) scandal where the lone woman on the team, Bridget Kelly, was thrown under the bus.
It’s shocking that Republicans like Stepien got away with deliberately harming a bunch of NJ commuters for the sole purpose of getting something they wanted that they knew they couldn’t get using democratic means. The Republicans could have used their vast resources from their billionaire donors to run ads or send mailings to the constituents of politicians they wanted to pressure to vote their way. But they don’t believe in real democracy.
Republicans and Putin have their Orwellian definition of “democracy” — where “democracy” is defined as “Once we win an election, we can do anything we want, including acting illegally to intentionally harm people who aren’t rich enough to threaten us in order to keep power.”
Since Stepien believes that making up a reason to cause a traffic jam so that people who need medical assistance die is a perfectly legal and good thing to do to punish their “enemies”, can you imagine what he will do to help Trump win the election? The Republicans are running Trump’s election with the philosophy that causing great harm to those who don’t support you is the way to win elections if you can’t win by convincing voters using facts. And William Barr’s insistence that Republicans presidents can do anything they want, period, is why we are already in very dangerous times.
Agree.
Who knew so many cared so little about decency? I thought the Koch bros. were extreme outliers – but, they’re the tip of the iceberg- AEI, Fordham, Hoover Institute, state Catholic Conferences, Republican politicians like Yoho, DFER, Bipartisan Policy Center, education professors at Harvard, Brown, Johns-Hopkins, Stanford, billionaire- funded economics professors at various schools, “researchers” at
Catholic universities. the Federalist Society, tech tyrants,…
If Disney World can open, then schools can open 🤦♀️ How about if Disney can open, the RNC can happen. It’s not safe for any of that right now. Not in Florida at least. Maybe in select rural areas but not universally.
White House spokesman Judd Deere said: “If Disney World can be open, so can our schools.” Judd Deere is so stupid that he does not know the differences between Disney World and a school classroom. Deere is a political huckster who does not know what he is talking about—a perfect shill for the no-nothing President whose own son is not attending a school that will be fully open.
Not to mention that Disney World is only running at about 25% capacity, but Trump and hiscglcrony governotmrs want schools open full time, full student.
If it’s not safe to hold the Republican convention in Jacksonville, why is it safe to open schools?
Wow! I should never post on my phone! Sorry about the terrible spelling.
The Trump Administration education team came right out of the ed reform echo chamber and are absolutely mainstream in ed reform circles:
“Jim Blew serves as the assistant secretary for planning, evaluation and policy development at the U.S. Department of Education. He was confirmed by the U.S. Senate on July 17, 2018, after being nominated by President Donald J. Trump on Sept. 28, 2017.
Prior to joining the Department, Blew advocated for education reform across the country. His roles included serving as director of the 50CAN affiliate Student Success California, national president of StudentsFirst, and national director of the Alliance for School Choice and its predecessor, the American Education Reform Council.
Blew also helped guide the Walton Family Foundation’s K-12 reform investments for nearly a decade.”
50CAN, StudentsFirst, Walton. The same work history as every other high profile ed reformer.
What we’re seeing out of the Trump Administration is “ed reform”. There’s not a dime’s worth of difference between “liberal” ed reformers and Donald Trump on education. They call come out of the same narrow pipeline and they all promote charter and private schools over public schools.
Please read this and “reblog” if possible. This is not my site, but I would love to view the commentary of this community since there are no comments on the blog and the blog’s Facebook page.
https://accountabaloney.com/index.php/2020/07/26/is-the-push-to-reopen-schools-really-a-plot-to-dismantle-them-floridians-want-to-know/
While I was grinning from ear to ear as reformers who pushed online learning pre-COVID now repeatedly state the value of in-person learning, I wonder if there is a bigger and more sinister game at play.
Friend,
I am so proud to be your President.
Since the very day that I announced my Presidential Campaign in 2015, I promised you that I would always put America FIRST no matter the cost.
Now, we’re only 100 DAYS OUT from what will be the most important Election in our Nation’s history, and with your help, I am ready to WIN AGAIN.
Today marks a huge day for us, and I need to know that you’re still in this fight with me.
I’ve asked my team to print and frame the 100 Days Out Presidential Donor List made up of the first 100 Patriots who choose to step up at this critical time. This list will proudly hang in my office for me to admire, and I want to see your name on there.
http://trk.cp20.com/click/g97n-26abvp-p3mm30-eckyzaw4/
Oh come on! Aren’t you ALL going to donate to the best president this country has ever had?
Ewwwww and UGH! and BS and YUCK on the thought of giving that Lying-Pussy-Grabber-in-Chief some money.
Hi Diane – Based on your decades of experience, including serving as a top official in the federal government, give us the short list of Biden’s secretary of education candidates and tell us what a President Biden will mean in the lives of teachers, students and parents. Thank you.
Biden on education.
I expect he will add generous new funding for Title 1 schools (poor kids) and special education, which Congress has never fully funded.
I worry that he will choose a Secretary of Education nominated by DFER or CAP to protect charter schools. I worry that he will not abolish the $440 million a year slush fund for new charters called the federal Charter Schools Program.
I don’t know what he will do on the federal testing mandate. It should be eliminated ASAP but CAP, Duncan, and the Obama veterans love standardized testing.
These are issues I and NPE will watch closely.
The best Secretary of Education would be Diane Ravitch. If progressives ran the show, I think the position would be hers.
My take: Trump has only one policy priority: Make me look good. So, opening schools, “getting back to work”, rising stock market, crushing dissent, etc to look normal, if not good, is what he wants. He will lie, suppress information, and claim authoritarian powers to do it. His Republican enablers, on the other hand, have ideological priorities: Remain in power in order to protect and advance the wealth of the (white) few. Democracy, justice, human rights are is just inconveniences for them, easily dispensed with if they gets in the way. Racism and the pretense of disorder are their tools. I think that’s called Fascism.
scary to think how the ‘pretense of disorder’ will affect an increasingly blind, willing-to-hate-science nation
Ed reform’s “contribution” to public school students and their families in this crisis has been 1. to step up their criticism of public schools and 2. to promote funding for charter and private schools at the expense of public schools.
Zero advocacy or assistance to public schools or for public school students. No positive, practical contribution at all. They’ve created a corps of full time, paid public school critics who do nothing else.
Meanwhile, back in reality-land, the +/- 50 million children and families who use and rely upon the unfashionable public schools? No one has time for them. No one works for them. It’s almost August and other than 1 million words of cutting public school criticism generated and churned out by the Professional Public School Critics Association members in ed reform, no one has done anything of practical value to assist our schools.
I want to see my students. Make no mistake, virtual learning is an oxymoron. Still, I hope we do not have a Covid outbreak. We will not know until it is too late.
The funniest part is, public schools know they’re irrelevant to our schools. Raise your hand if any of your local public school discussions on opening schools mentioned or referenced the US Department of Education or any of the thousands of ed reform groups.
No help there. We all know that. This “debate” operates exclusively within the ed reform echo chamber. Completely irrelevant to public school students and families.
Romney, yesterday: Trump will win because young people and “the” minorities poll well but don’t show up at the polls.
Isn’t it remarkable how revealing simply using the word “the” can be?
I always think of Romney making his remarks about the 47% inside a closed room where members of that 47% he was denigrating were serving the White attendees — Romney couldn’t see them
Spot on, Ciedie!!! They just weren’t there. They didn’t matter.
Trump is seriously out of touch with what most parents think about school choice. Interest in choice is waning because s-called choice has failed to deliver on its promises. Most suburban moms from middle class areas support well funded public education. They understand that their quality public schools are a public asset that adds value to their property. Privatization is a disinvestment in one’s own community investment. Charter chains loot the common good and send money out of the community. I seriously doubt that most suburban moms see privatization as a bonus when they realize it weakens their community schools.
But be heartened. Trump can identify a picture of an elephant. The man is a genius. Nobody knows elephants like Trump. Elephant. Bing!
What is the secret to Trump’s amazing identification of a picture of an elephant ability? Well, who knows. Genius is so mysterious. Perhaps it has something to do with his lifting the ban on bringing elephant and lion trophies into the United States.
Recognizing a picture of an elephant is the sign of a stable genius. He told us so. Now he has proof.
This “stable genius” phrase has always bothered me. Trump’s intellect does not compare favorably to that of the animals typically found in stables.
Yes, a genius as compared to the other animals in the stable.
Anyone who describes himself as a genius is very stupid.
But Diane, toward the end, the questions get REALLY hard. Recognize that bicycles and trains are transportation devices. Name some words that begin with F. Of course, even Einstein and Von Neumann wouldn’t be able to do those! But Trump answered those questions with ease!!!!
Let’s see. Words beginning with F.
Uh. Apple. A P P. No.
Uh. Boy. B O. No.
Darn. See how hard it is?
Nobody knows five words that begin with F like Donald Trump! I’m in awe.
And his mastery of higher mathematics!!!
Subtract 7 from 100.
Subtract 7 from 93.
Subtract 7 from 86.
We already know that Trump should get the “Noble” Prize. He has said so himself. Too bad he’s over 40, for if he weren’t, he would clearly be a candidate for the Fields Medal as well!
The only time I’ve ever seen Jabba the Trump show compassion is when, in the recent interview with objective journalist Sean Hannity, he said that he might lose because “some people don’t like me.” Oh. What a sad pouty face. Poor Donnie!
There’s a general lesson to be learned from the Trump presidency. Male egos are very fragile. They are like delicate flowers. Protect them at all costs. Sure, hundreds of thousands of people are going to die if we reopen schools fully in the middle of a surging pandemic, but get your priorities straight. If Donald had to backtrack on this, it might make him feel sad.
So, people who say that Donald Trump is incapable of compassion are simply wrong!!! Wrong I say!!! Donald Trump has enormous compassion for Donald Trump.
“This may indicate how out of touch he is. Parents move to the suburbs because their property wealth creates good schools. There is no unmet demand in the suburbs for vouchers or charter schools.”
Not all parents live in a suburb that has a lot of property wealth. What about them?
Trump hits parents with tear gas and flash bang grenades. Suburbs, urbs, BLM, Wall of Moms, doesn’t matter.
No one should pay any attention to what that dump says.
tRump is hopeless. He has no redeeming features at all. He’s a hateful person, a national embarrassment, and a socio-psychopath.
He belongs in jail.
Will the non-affluent suburban voters go for Trump because he promises vouchers?
No…..But only if someone explain the implications to them and that is not happening.
Non-affluent and even affluent suburban kids go to public schools. They are not taking vouchers and they don’t want charters (tax credits, maybe).
WHEN EXPLAINED TO THEM They understand that the WH wants to take money from their schools, their kids. They need help following the money… being taken from their children.
In our bright red state, surprisingly the rural communities and some state legislators do not support charters in their districts (only allowed in urban districts) because it will hurt their budgets and kids.
The first two words of the headline negate the entire post. “[The Idiot] thinks…”? We’ve seen enough to know that can in no way be possible, probable or conceivable.
Off topic- First Energy’s CEO donated $12,700 worth of food and beverage to the Dewine Husted campaign.
Mercedes Schlapp, a top campaign adviser to Trump, put it this way at an online event aimed at women: “The suburban mom will say, ‘I am going to stick with President Trump on this one because he wants to make sure my kid gets back to school.’ ”
The suburban mom will add, however…”Make sure my kid get back in school BUT ONLY IF YOU CAN GUARANTEE MY SCHOOL GETS THE FUNDING To INSURE HEALTH STANDARDS (you know, science) for social distancing in every room, aggressive sanitizing, everyone tested, masks on all adults and kids at right ages, working ventilation…
I bet even his loyal base put their children’s health ahead of their blind loyalty to this fool.
They have to be shown he could care less if a few hundred thousand kids get sick
As soon as one child or teacher gets COVID, as soon as anyone dies, Trump will be blamed. This will not end well for him.
I’m reminded of how risky it is to recommend a dentist or other professional to friends. If things don’t work out, it’s your fault.
Oh, Trump won’t get blamed. The schools will. It was ever thus. Damned if you do, damned if you don’t. Another way to make public schools scapegoats during all of this and push more money to online charters and other crap. As Arne Duncan said, “never let a crisis go to waste.”
“Man. Woman. Camera. Person. TV.”: Noam Chomsky Responds to Trump Bragging He Aced a Dementia Test
JULY 24, 2020
Is the United States being run by a madman? “What can you say about a person who, before speaking before an adoring crowd, raises his eyes to heaven and calls himself the chosen one?” says Noam Chomsky, responding to President Trump’s boast that he aced a mental acuity test…
So I don’t think it is fascism. It is essentially tin-pot dictatorship. And he is desperate, will do anything, almost anything imaginable to try to keep himself from being tossed out of the White House. How this will eventuate, we don’t know, but it is going to be a very difficult couple of months ahead.
https://www.democracynow.org/2020/7/24/man_woman_camera_person_tv_noam
Donald Trump Is a Broken Man
Peter Wehner
Contributing writer at The Atlantic and senior fellow at EPPC
In another time, in a different circumstance, there would perhaps be room to pity such a person
The most revealing answer from Donald Trump’s interview with Fox News Channel’s Chris Wallace came in response not to the toughest question posed by Wallace, but to the easiest.
At the conclusion of the interview, Wallace asked Trump how he will regard his years as president.
“I think I was very unfairly treated,” Trump responded. “From before I even won, I was under investigation by a bunch of thieves, crooks. It was an illegal investigation.”
Peter Wehner: The president is unraveling
When Wallace interrupted, trying to get Trump to focus on the positive achievements of his presidency—“What about the good parts, sir?”—Trump brushed the question aside, responding, “Russia, Russia, Russia.” The president then complained about the Flynn investigation, the “Russia hoax,” the “Mueller scam,” and the recusal by his then–attorney general, Jeff Sessions. (“Now I feel good because he lost overwhelmingly in the great state of Alabama,” Trump said about the first senator to endorse him in the 2016 Republican primary.)
Donald Trump is a psychologically broken, embittered, and deeply unhappy man. He is so gripped by his grievances, such a prisoner of his resentments, that even the most benevolent question from an interviewer—what good parts of your presidency would you like to be remembered for?—triggered a gusher of discontent…
Read More:
https://www.theatlantic.com/ideas/archive/2020/07/trump-wallowing-self-pity/614434/?utm_source=atl&utm_medium=email&utm_campaign=share
Today, Daily Beast connects Will and Jada Smith to a school (2008-2013) that was allegedly linked to L. Ron Hubbard’s Scientology. Three years ago, Huffpo posted, “Inside the voucher schools that teach L. Ron Hubbard…”.
While the schools of other celebrities have attracted attention, with luck, the top tier celebrity of the Smith’s may garner more questions from the public. Situations in which taxpayer money is siphoned off for religious schools should provoke disgust. If Applied Scholastics International (mentioned in the Daily Beast article) gets tax money, we know who deserves shame, among them, Gates, Fordham and, state Catholic Conferences. Diversion of tax dollars, without democratic consent from the American people, no scruples.