Trump demanded that schools reopen for in-person instruction in a few weeks, as the pandemic surges in more than half the states. He and his party have refused to pass the HEROES act to provide additional resources for schools.
DeVos blasted school districts that hesitate to open, fearing risk to students and staff. She said, patronizingly, that life has many risks: get over it.
THE ANSWER IS NO! TRUMP AND DEVOS ARE WILLING TO SACRIFICE LIVES TO RESTART THE ECONOMY! NO!
Trump doesn’t care about the lives of students and staff. He cares only about his poll numbers. DeVos is arrogant and doesn’t care what might happen to students and teachers and other staff in public schools. She never has.
Opening schools without elaborate and carefully planned protocols for testing, daily screenings, masks, small classes, and social distancing is insane.
Opening schools in the middle of a raging and uncontrolled pandemic is irresponsible. Whose loves will be sacrificed?
What example has Trump set by refusing to wear a mask? Didn’t he just falsely claim that 99% of COVID infections are “totally harmless”?
DO NOT OPEN—DO NOT EVEN THINK OF OPENING—UNLESS EVERYONE IS SAFE, STAFF AND STUDENTS ALIKE.
CORONAVIRUS IS DANGEROUS. IT IS NOT LIKE THE COMMON COLD.
President Trump on Tuesday dialed up pressure on state and local authorities to reopen schools, even as coronavirus cases spike, accusing officials who keep them closed as being motivated by politics.
He said in-person education was essential for the well-being of students, parents and the country as a whole, and he vowed to keep up the pressure on governors to open buildings. “We want to reopen the schools,” Trump said. “We don’t want people to make political statements or do it for political reasons. They think it’s going to be good for them politically, so they keep schools closed. No way.”
The president did not mention that his own reelection prospects may depend on whether voters see the country as having recovered from the economic and social devastation of the novel coronavirus pandemic.
It’s also unclear whether the schools push will be a political winner for Trump.
Some parents are eager to return to normal but many others, fearful of the virus, have told districts they want to keep their children home this fall.
Virtually every K-12 school in the United States closed this spring in an effort to control infections, abruptly moving to online learning.
The system worked reasonably well for some families in some school districts but was an outright failure in others.
Colleges and universities also shut down, though their remote learning was generally seen as more successful. Now schools at all levels are struggling to develop plans for the fall, with many planning a mix of in-person and online classes…
During an afternoon dialogue at the White House, federal, state and local officials made the case for in-person schooling, saying it was imperative for the education and social-emotional well-being of children, and critical for parents who need to go to work.
They noted that schools provide children with meals, mental health counseling and socialization. “Parents have to get back to the factory. They’ve got to get back to the job site. They have to get back to the office. And part of that is their kids, knowing their kids are taken care of,” Health and Human Services Secretary Alex Azar said.
Children, officials added, are far less likely to become ill and die of the virus than older people, though little was said about the teachers and staff who might be at risk. “We cannot simply focus on virus containment at the expense of everything else,” said Elinore McCance-Katz, assistant secretary for mental health and substance use at HHS.
The confidence projected from the White House stood in contrast with the angst in many local districts working to develop plans for the fall. Most big cities and many others are developing hybrid models that alternate days in the building and days at home to minimize the number of students present at any given time.
Those models are being developed in part to comply with guidance from the Center for Disease Control and Prevention that recommends “enhanced social distancing” in buildings. For instance, the CDC recommends that desks be placed at least six feet apart, something that might not be possible if all students are on site.
Administration officials did not address these hybrid plans directly, though Education Secretary Betsy DeVos said that schools “must fully reopen and fully operate this school year.”
One guest, Patrick Daly, principal of St. Vincent de Paul High School in Petaluma, Calif., said he plans a hybrid system, where students learn from home on certain days. Trump replied that he hoped the school could be in-person full time.
“I know you want to try,” he said. CDC Director Robert Redfield noted that the agency never recommended that schools close in the first place. And he appeared concerned that his agency’s guidance has made districts reticent to open. “Nothing would cause me greater sadness” than learning that schools view the guidance as reason not to open, he said.
Schools can safely reopen if they arrange for appropriate social distancing, face coverings and strong personal hygiene including hand-washing, Azar said.
He and some other administration officials were seen wearing masks at the White House, something the president has resisted.
Making his case for a return to normal, Trump repeatedly played down the rising number of coronavirus cases, saying treatments and vaccines are coming soon. He said there are only more cases because the country is doing more testing, a point health experts dispute.
Politico reported on a phone call that DeVos had with the governors, in which she demanded that schools reopen and ignore the risks.
Lily Eskelsen Garcia responded:
“The reality is no one should listen to Donald Trump or Betsy DeVos when it comes to what is best for students,” said Lily Eskelsen García, National Education Association president. “Trump has not once proven credible, compassionate or thoughtful when it comes to this pandemic.”
The White House is hammering a message of reopening schools even as coronavirus cases spike throughout the country, insisting it’s okay to move ahead and that decisions last spring to close doors came from states rather than health experts at the CDC.
Ignore them. They don’t care about human life. They care about the stock market and the election.
🍽 🦠 & ⚰️ XLV
“They care about the stock market and election.” That is the prime reason for attempting to return to normalcy while ignoring a pandemic that has raged out of control on their watch. All the working people in this country are expendable in their eyes. Only extremely wealthy people have value in Trump’s America. It’s the “Hunger Games,” and Trump has put working people on a team where they have to fight for their survival. It is the age of Darwinian politics, and we are all potential collateral damage.
Who is “they?”
working families and the poor
The referent of the pronoun is folks in the White House.
You’re right, Bob. The first they=cronies, the second they =working families and the poor.
I sent information about the rising number of cases in the U.S. to a Malaysia friend. Here is her response:
All I can say is my condolence to USA.
He [Trump] and his family get tested everyday while the rest of USA no need to because it will shows the number ? Test result available in 10 days ??? In Malaysia ..test result within 24 hours (with immediate isolation unless proven negative)
No one gets near Trump unless they are tested.
Good morning Diane and everyone,
I have now seen 3 people interviewed on tv telling of their experience of “recovery” from Covid. They are ALL having after effects from this virus including cognitive issues, physical coordination problems, fatigue, cough, shortness of breath, etc. They had the virus months ago and are STILL having medical problems. So, again, we know very little about this virus and what will be the long-term effects. We know even less about how this virus will affect children in the long term.
This is the wisest comment about the reopening schools issue that I have read on this blog.
Also agree with Mamie Krupczak Allegretti.
We are looking a virus that is a “genius” but hardly stable. There is still too little known for anyone to make for-certain plans on behalf of others, least of all congregations of children and teachers who are traveling to school by different methods from locations that could (in fact) be tracked, but only with a China-style surveillance systems.
I know that “plans are being made” and that many schools and districts have several if-then contingency plans.
If you can stand it, here are transcripts from those invited to Trumps’ love-fest and self-promotion on reopening schools.
https://www.rev.com/blog/transcripts/donald-trump-speech-transcript-safely-reopening-schools-amid-covid-19-pandemic
Laura H. Chapman: It was SICKENING. All of those self satisfied ‘experts’ who bow as low as possible.
This country is in deep doo-doo and Trump continues to tell everyone how great everything is.
I read about 3/4 of it and couldn’t take anymore.
Thanks for the article. I sent it to people who will be as inspired as I was.
I tried, Laura, but couldn’t stand it. I have had my fill of listening to toadies grovel before Jabba the Trump.
“We should plan and prepare that our children WILL be back in school this fall,
BetsyDeVosED
says.”
‘We”. The only actual work she performs is speaking to the fellow members of the ed reform echo chamber and bashing public schools.
I’m surprised they noticed public schools are closed. Sure, it took them until July when schools open in August and all they offer is criticism, but I suppose we should give them a A+ for coming in to work at all.
Should we really be funding an entire federal agency that works in opposition to the schools 90% of kids attend? Wouldn’t that money be better spent on the schools themselves?
Casting so much well-deserved shade, as always, Chiara!
Would be very interested to see what would happen to charter school enrollment and staffing if they all decide to follow her lead and reopen.
Is it really too much to ask that we have people in “education policy” who attended public schools themselves and send their children to them?
I’m tired of listening to stern lectures from private school grads and private school parents on the schools they didn’t and don’t use and don’t support. I want an advocate for public schools and public school students deserve one.
I think it’s worth mentioning too, that despite the delusions of the Trump Administration that they are all-powerful monarchs, they can’t “force” public schools to open anymore than they can announce a snow day.
If there’s a health emergency in a state, county or school district the state, county and school district have now and will retain broad policing powers to open schools, close them, or open them partially.
It’s just another politically motivated exercise in public school bashing. No one should take anything they say seriously or (God forbid) follow their advice. They’re not serious people. They denied this pandemic existed for months, did no work at all, and now that they find their own careers are on the line they turn to their reliable punching bag- public schools.
Ask your local leaders to ignore the noise and keep working. We really are all in this together- not the Trump Administration, but public school parents and students and teachers. These are OUR schools and we can open them.
Perhaps, but Trump crony governors all over the country are following his lead and demanding full opening. And parents (some of whom have no choice because their employers won’t work with them, and others who follow Trump and thinks this is a “hoax”) are demanding it too. But staff are NEVER thought of in these plans.
I see your concern and I am not in the schools so easy for me to say, but we did just watch this same thing happen, where Trump crony governors all bowed to Dear Leader and denied the virus and those same governors are now begging people to wear masks and closing restaurants.
I just don’t think they’re all as stupid as the SAT cheater in the White House. They got burned the last time they followed these people off a cliff and they must know by now that Donald Trump and the Trump Administration work exclusively for Donald Trump and the Trump Administration. They don’t care what happens to those governors.
Columbus (Ohio) schools are opening only partway. That’s because the county they are in has a rapidly rising caseload. Mike DeWine isn’t going to override that, no matter how much bellowing the Trumps do.
And once any person is known to be sick, what protections will they be given financially? Who will take over teaching or cleaning or cooking if a person is sent home for a two-week quarantine? Will both the person at home and the person who has to be her/his substitute receive paychecks?
OK. Let’s assume that we are talking about classrooms full of kids, as envisioned by Trump and DeVoid, uh, DeVos, all wearing facemasks and/or face shields. A few things we don’t know
How effective are face shields and face masks of various kinds at screening outgoing virus particles? (N95 respirators are quite effective, but the studies I’ve seen indicate that face shields and other kinds of masks are only SOMEWHAT effective.)
How effective are face shields and face masks of various kinds at screening incoming virus particles and so preventing people from catching the virus from others? (N95 respirators are quite effective, but the studies I’ve seen indicate that face shields and other kinds of masks are MINIMALLY effective.)
How far will the virus travel in a small, closed room like a classroom? (The answer seems to be that small, aerosolized particles can travel far enough to traverse a typical classroom–much farther than six feet. Think of opening a bottle of perfume in one corner of a classroom. How far will that smell travel?)
How long will the virus remain in the air in a small, closed room like a classroom? (The answer seems to be that small, aerosolized particles will stay in the air for many hours. Think of opening a bottle of perfume in one corner of a classroom. How long will that smell linger in the air?)
What is the infection rate for exposure to aerosolized virus particles? (Some recent studies are indicating that aerosolized virus particles are a major mode of transmission.)
An average middle- or high-school classroom has about 25 kids in it. So, if there are six classes per day, that’s 150 kids. Each of those kids is expelling 0.5 liters, approximately, of air with each breath. In an hour, an average person takes about 960 breaths. So, each of those 150 kids will expel 475 liters of air into the closed classroom. That’s 71,250 liters of air breathed out into the classroom in a day by 150 people. (I’ve left out the teacher and any other adults who enter the class.) How many infected kids does it take to ensure that that air will have a fairly heavy viral load? What percentage of kids, on any given day, will be carrying the virus?
What is the rate at which kids get infected? (A recent study in The Lancet says that kids 10 and older get infected at the same rates as adults do.)
What percentage of infected kids are asymptomatic and not identifiable by means other than testing (e.g., by temperature checks or monitoring for coughing and other symptoms)?
How infectious are asymptomatic carriers?
What are the consequences, long-term, for other bodily organs and systems other than the lungs of having had coronavirus? Are these more or less severe for kids of various ages? What percentage of our kids will get infected, be asymptomatic, but suffer long-term brain damage or other extremely negative consequences?
How many kids, teachers, administrators, staff members, parents, grandparents, and other members of school communities will die as a result of this reopening?
Unknowns. Unknowns. Unknowns.
But, hey, who cares, Trump and DeVos and Pence and the other morons in the Trump clown posse seem to be saying. It’s just YOUR children. You can make more of them.
Here’s a blog post from an NYC teacher on the DOE’s first attempt at creating a back-to-school schedule. It’s disastrous. Anyone who has done even a small amount of scheduling for a school would poke holes in this scheme in a minute. Seems DOE paid some consultants between $1.2 – $3 million for this.
“Let’s look more closely. The heart of their suggestion (I’m choosing the easiest to follow) is to divide the student body in a given school into two groups, A and B. The A group would come to school during A weeks. During A weeks, the B group stays home and receives remote instruction. During B weeks it reverses. Group B comes in for classes; Group A stays home for remote instruction.
“A school schedule is not like a jigsaw puzzle. It is like a multi-dimensional, rotating jigsaw. We schedule students, of course. But we schedule rooms, we schedule teachers, we schedule classes, we schedule services, we schedule special classes, we schedule lunch.
“The DoE’s proposal did not look at any of that. When programmers (school schedulers) took a look the result, they just shrugged ‘no.’ Let me explain why.
“Space – They clearly miscalculated the space in schools. They seem to have forgotten that each room needs at least one adult. They used odd estimates. They engaged in massive wishful thinking.”
https://jd2718.org/2020/07/08/nyc-school-schedule-models-what-was-wrong-with-the-does-first-try/
A weeks and B weeks would still mean that teachers are exposed to the same number of students, and the benefits of schools touted by the AAP and others, as well as child care, would only be available every other week.
Not saying the idea isn’t better than what the district in which on teach is doing, which is essentially nothing but hand washing and “encouraging” masks, but I just want to make people aware. No good answers here.
DeVos: “This is more an issue of adults who are more interested in their own issues than they are about serving their students.”
Easy for her to say. She’s never worked a day in her life. Is there some realistic reason that adults in schools should NOT care about risking the lives of themselves, their students and their families?
Trump: ““They are asking schools to do very impractical things.”
I’ve picked select quotes from this article. There was no link. The IDIOTS all go to Fox.
Trump administration says it plans to use financial pressure to push schools to reopen buildings
By Matt Barnum Jul 8, 2020,
Trump tweeted Wednesday morning that he “may cut off funding” for schools if they don’t fully re-open. DeVos broached the issue as well in an appearance Tuesday night on Tucker Carlson’s Fox News show, though she was more circumspect.
“That’s definitely something to be looked at,” DeVos said, before noting that the vast majority of education dollars come from state and local sources.
Trump tweeted that he disagreed with the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention — part of his own administration — which has issued guidance for schools around social distancing and school hygiene. “They are asking schools to do very impractical things. I will be meeting with them!!!” Trump wrote.
DeVos claimed that any resistance to a full reopening was based on self interest. “There is no excuse for schools not to reopen again,” she told Carlson. “This is more an issue of adults who are more interested in their own issues than they are about serving their students.”
Nicolle Wallace in 2019 a registered republican, just called Trump’s threat to cut off federal funds if schools do not open fully “ghoulish.” I wish more people had that kind of courage, but then both Trump and Tucker Carlson feed on these media provocations.
Well, there’s a lot of wisdom in the comments above.
What can I say that hasn’t already been said -and usually better?
I get the feeling that the wheels are about to come off this thing….first our public schools and then the whole democracy comes tumbling down behind them…since public schools are such a bedrock institution in our nation.
I sure hope we get some good news…and fast!
“The Buffalo News” reports that New York State school districts are being required to submit plans for reopening by July 31. What??? Today is July 8? That’s a bit more than 3 weeks from now.
https://buffalonews.com/news/cuomo-schools-decision-to-be-made-first-week-of-august/article_0215e4a8-c130-11ea-a0f3-ff606c71cacf.html?utm_source=newsletter&utm_medium=email&utm_campaign=cuomo_schools_decision_to_be_made_first_week_of_august&utm_term=
I remember it took my school 3+ months to come up with a new policy for kids wearing hats in school. Hats! Now we’re pondering life protecting masks and hundreds of other vital concerns.
The report says NY Governor Cuomo is holding off on a decision about reopening schools until sometime between August 1 and 7.
In a way, it reminds me of the Common Core, Race to the Top etc…. except this time writ large and deadly for all involved: create an impossible situation then blame the schools when it can’t be done.
Of course, DeVos and Company want to wreck the public schools. What about the kids and teachers caught in the maw of her obsession?
And, does anyone know, what’s up at Barron Trump’s private school? I found one reference that says that question is a “top trending topic” on Twitter right now.
https://www.mercurynews.com/2020/07/08/will-ivanka-trump-send-her-kids-back-to-school-will-trump-have-barron-return/
All I can say is I’m very lucky to have all of you on here.
John, when you submit your plan, make sure it’s cost-free.
….Or costs less than what was planned pre-pandemic since school budget cuts are looming….
Insanity defined.
Exactly, Diane. Preposterous.
If Schools Reopen This Fall, More People Will Likely Die. Full Stop.
William Rivers Pitt, Truthout
PUBLISHED
July 8, 2020
We are dangerously unready to thrust millions of children into the enclosed close-quarters reality of school.
The front page of Tuesday’s Miami Herald tells you all you need to know about the rising dread and panic being felt across the country by millions of parents with school-age children. Bang in the center of that front page is the headline, “Miami-Dade restaurants, gyms closing to fight COVID surge.” Snuggled in to the left-side column is another headline: “Florida schools ordered to reopen in August.”
For those of you bereft of a calendar, August is next month.
Raise your hand if you think this country is anywhere near prepared to allow millions of children to occupy school buildings while the pandemic is surging to levels unseen even in the grim days of March and April. Keep your hand raised if you believe this current and unprecedented infection surge will “disappear” in a month, as Donald Trump so devoutly hopes….
The situation could be at least partially ameliorated if Congress chose to fund workers who must stay home to teach their children, or if the administration had begun preparing for this eventuality months ago. There are ways it can be done, even as the school experience itself will have to absorb some radical changes.
None of this has happened, and will not happen soon, even as we careen toward a dangerous reckoning with the school bell next month. There are solutions, but under the leadership of Trump and McConnell, there is only noise and death.
As matters stand, and unless something astonishing happens, we must face the fact that reopening the schools at this juncture could be a calamity of national proportions. This places millions of people in a disastrous situation, but the dangers that lie on the far side of reopening now are worse.
https://truthout.org/articles/if-schools-reopen-this-fall-more-people-will-likely-die-full-stop/?utm_source=Truthout&utm_medium=email&utm_campaign=Truthout+Share+Buttons
“Calamity” appears to be an accurate word from what I am now reading…
Tragedy…disaster..
It’s like I’m on the Titanic on April 15, 1912 and I see an iceberg looming in the distance and I run up to the bridge and worse than no one being there at the helm……..there’s a depraved madman and his gang….
Are there any Back-to-School Sales on hazmat suits?
Great idea!👏🏼👏🏼👍👍
Also funny:
https://www.washingtonpost.com/opinions/2020/07/08/we-cant-wait-schools-reopen-safely/
I’m becoming more and more convinced that opening schools is just as disastrous as opening up states. It’s simply a matter of time before Trump will be blaming someone for the disasters happening in school districts across the country. If COVID-19 wrecked havoc on cruise ships, it will do the same in enclosed classrooms.
If teachers aren’t retiring or quitting en masse, it’s because they are desperate. I never had any money left at the end of a summer when I was teaching in the States.
I wish TIME had links to all of their articles. There was no link to this article. CDC has issued what it thinks is safe for schools. There is no way a public school has the means to do what is considered necessary. Trump says it is impractical. It shouldn’t be ‘impractical’ if we truly cared about our children and adults in schools. I’m sure wealthy private schools will be doing what is best for their elite.
………………………………….
With No End in Sight to the Coronavirus, Some Teachers Are Retiring Rather Than Going Back to School
BY KATIE REILLY
JULY 8, 2020 1:27 PM EDT
When Christina Curfman thought about whether she could return to her second-grade classroom in the fall, she struggled to imagine the logistics. How would she make sure her 8-year-old students kept their face masks on all day? How would they do hands-on science experiments that required working in pairs? How would she keep six feet of distance between children accustomed to sharing desks and huddling together on one rug to read books?
“The only way to keep kids six feet apart is to have four or five kids,” says Curfman, a teacher at Catoctin Elementary School in Leesburg, Virginia, who typically has 22 students in a class. Her district shut schools on March 12, and at least 55 staff members have since tested positive for the coronavirus. “Classrooms in general are pretty tight,” she says. “And then how do you teach a reading group, how do you teach someone one-on-one from six feet apart? You can’t.”…
But the health risks are greater for some educators and other school employees, including bus drivers and custodians, than they are for children. Adults over age 65 account for the vast majority of COVID-19 deaths in the U.S. And 18% of public and private school teachers and 27% of principals are 55 or older, according to federal data. That’s why researchers at the American Enterprise Institute warned of a “school personnel crisis,” recommending in May that school districts provide early retirement incentives or create a “virtual teaching corps” for those who feel safer working remotely.
“I still have not seen any state really address this in their reopening plans. There’s passing references to schools needing to do something for their vulnerable population, but you just don’t see the activity that would match the personnel challenge that schools are going to face,” says John Bailey, an American Enterprise Institute visiting fellow, who wrote the May report. “We shouldn’t be putting teachers in a situation where they have to decide between their financial security and their health security.”…
In Connecticut—where a union survey found that 43% of teachers think they’re at higher risk for severe illness if they contract COVID-19 because of their age or an underlying medical condition–
In Michigan—where 30% of teachers told the Michigan Education Association they were considering leaving teaching or retiring earlier than planned because of the pandemic—…
There’s no evidence that teachers are retiring en masse. In the middle of an economic crisis that has left millions unemployed, including public school employees, many teachers aren’t looking to flee the profession, despite their concerns about this fall….
The Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC) recommends that schools space desks six feet apart; seat only one child per row on school buses; discourage students from sharing toys, books or sports equipment; close communal spaces, such as cafeterias and playgrounds; and create staggered drop-off and pick-up schedules to limit contact between large groups of students and parents. On Wednesday, Trump said he disagreed with the CDC’s “very tough & expensive guidelines for opening schools. While they want them open, they are asking schools to do very impractical things.”…
40 9th graders per class. A less than 900 square foot metal trailer. 20 “buddy tables” and 40 chairs. No tables can be further than 3 feet apart because of space issues. That’s what I face this fall
Threatened Out West: Do you have a strong union that can stop this madness? I’m sorry for the lack of space.
I’d forgotten about overcrowded schools having temporary makeshift places for classrooms outside the brick building.
This is a disastrous situation. Nobody should have to work under these conditions. Can you start a petition or do anything?
TOW is in Utah. Union? I don’t think so.
Yup. So many folks/ press articles talking as tho kids going back to brick&mortar school en masse is the key to everybody going back to brick&mortar workplaces en masse. It’s a failure to digest the current reality. Adults are returning to brick&mortar workplaces, but not en masse. Many continue working from home, & will be going to office just once in a while. Smallbiz workers previously shut down are returning in small numbers, hampered by spatial distancing reqts: customers won’t return if it doesn’t look safe. True for bigger venues as well.
President Trump on Wednesday intensified his demand that schools fully reopen this fall, slamming the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, pressuring it to loosen guidance and threatening to cut funding for schools that do not open.
The CDC was already planning to issue new guidelines for schools in the coming days. But Vice President Pence on Wednesday explicitly tied the effort to Trump’s ire.
“The president said today we just don’t want the guidance to be too tough,” Pence told reporters. “And that’s the reason next week the CDC is going to be issuing a new set of tools.”
I guess the right has abandoned states rights? King TRUMP and Madam DeVos have spoken
Hahahahahahahaha.
That’s what I think about Trump & Rep/ libertarian dittoheads’ covid-era 180.
“OMG! We actually NEED public schools! What were we thinking [when buying into every anti-pubsch anti-union plan to dump pubschs, plumped by appetizing big $sw/hw lobbying/ campaign donations to digitalize/ privatize public ed]?”
“They’re… gasp… babysitters for onsite workers! Workers… need babysitters!”
“Yeh, yeh, promote all the blurbs about poor/ high-risk/ minority/ hungry kids needing those pubschs to reopen or they might be permanently damaged!”
“(Just don’t offer any fed help to reopen w/ covid safety protocols– covid’s a hoax– masks are for wusses– covid’s in the rear-view mirror, just reopen already. Love me them public schools!”)
Betsy DeVos – The Scam-way Grizzly Grifter Queen – just another Trump swamp thing ….
What a pile of horse manure.
………………………………
Indiana schools can choose to give IREAD test in the fall, despite state superintendent’s concerns
By Emma Kate Fittes Jul 8, 2020, 11:48am EDT
Indiana districts can opt to give the state’s third-grade literacy exam to fourth-graders this fall after many students missed the high-stakes tests when the coronavirus closed school buildings.
The State Board of Education voted 9-1 Wednesday to allow schools to administer the makeup IREAD3 even though State Superintendent Jennifer McCormick — who voted against the measure — raised concerns that the test wasn’t created to be used to measure progress.
Administrators can use the extra IREAD exam to assess the reading skills of fourth-graders early in the school year, board members said, to help students catch up after months without in-person instruction. Typically, third graders who don’t pass the test after at least two attempts are held back, but the fall test won’t have any ramifications.
Nationwide, state leaders are scrambling to figure out how to quickly assess students after an unprecedented gap year in testing data, and how to navigate federal standardized testing requirements as schools reopen.
“I certainly appreciate the fact that it’s optional,” said Board Chairman B.J. Watts. “Without a doubt, we understand that there’s been educational loss over the last several months. I think this gives schools a tool.”
The move could slow McCormick’s push to scrap the test entirely, which was bolstered by the one-year cancellation. She has called for Indiana to use its more general standardized test, ILEARN, to assess reading ability, although the state board has yet to consider the idea.
Schools already have other tools for assessing students, McCormick said before the vote, and IREAD wasn’t built to be “diagnostic.” The state spends “a lot of money” on testing, she said.
IREAD costs the state $300,000 a year, according to the Indiana Department of Education. The department is still negotiating how much it will pay for the cancelled spring 2020 exam, said spokesman Adam Baker.
State leaders have not discussed trying to make up for the missed year of ILEARN in grades three to eight after the federal testing requirement was lifted for one year. High schoolers who didn’t finish the 10th grade ISTEP exam before it was cancelled will be required to make up the exam to graduate.
Redfield is a Trump appointee.
Despite covid-19 cases, White House task force urges schools to reopen
July 8, 2020 | 2:23 PM EDT
Vice President Pence, CDC Director Robert Redfield and Education Secretary Betsy DeVos doubled down July 8 on the push to reopen K-12 schools in the fall.
https://wapo.st/2W1CtCy