Talk about taking advantage of a crisis!
The rightwing extremist Heritage Foundation has issued its own report on how to recover from the pandemic. They cover it with patriotic glitz to make it appear like a government report, which it is not. It calls itself the “National Coronavirus Recovery Commission. But it is just a self-aggrandizing report from a rightwing think tank funded by the usual suspects.
The Task Force consists of people who share the Heritage view that government is evil, as are public schools.
Tucked into its recommendations is this: eliminate public schools and certified teachers.
That will help America sink back at least a century in educating its children, perhaps even two centuries.
Perhaps you will not be surprised to learn that the lead person on education was Kevin P. Chavous, CEO of the notorious for-profit K-12 Inc. online charter chain, noted for high attrition, low graduation rates, and low test scores–and above all, high profits! In 2019, Chavous’s total compensation was $4.3 million for his estimable services. But in the nature of for-profit enterprises, there are always new worlds to conquer, new markets to open up.
On page 5:
The Commission recommends that states help families return to work with access to K–12 education by making existing education funding student-centered and portable. Many parents and guardians who now find themselves in charge of teaching and monitoring their children’s educations are unable to access the public schools they pay for through their taxes and are looking for continuity in their children’s education. States should immediately restructure per-pupil K–12 education funding to provide education savings ac- counts (ESAs) to families, enabling them to access their child’s share of state per-pupil funding to pay for online courses, online tutors, curriculum, and textbooks so that their children can continue learning. Students are currently unable to enter the K–12 public schools their parents’ taxes support. They should be able to access a portion of those funds for the remainder of the school year in the form of an ESA. Parents would receive a por- tion of their child’s per-pupil public school funding in a restricted-use account that they could then can use to pay for any education-related service, product, or provider of choice. Additionally, state restrictions on teacher certification should be lifted immediately to free the supply of online teachers and tutors, allowing anyone with a bachelor’s degree to provide K–12 in- struction online. Research suggests that there is little if any difference in student academic outcomes between teachers who are traditionally certified, alternative- ly certified, or not certified at all. States should work with school districts to reopen districts based on data about where the disease is prevalent or waning. Deci- sions about whether to keep schools closed should be medically determined by zip code, tied to districts. Dis- tricts that have low incident rates should begin plans to
reopen, and all school districts should have emergency response plans (including quick transitions to online learning) if they are forced to close again.
The Commission recommends that states remove occupational licensing requirements. States have im- posed numerous occupational licensing requirements that in many instances are simply artificial barriers to entry that can inhibit individuals’ ability to pursue en- trepreneurial work. These should be eliminated. Simi- larly, states should extend reciprocity so that licensed individuals in one state are not subject to additional requirements in the new state. Eliminating or signifi- cantly reducing occupational licensing requirements can help to get people back to work and can also provide a state with access to individuals with high-demand skills. For example, Massachusetts created a one-day approval process to license doctors with out-of-state licenses as a means to expand access to medical care in response to the virus.
Peter Greene also saw this phony “commission report” that pretends to be an official document but is just another anti-government, anti-public school self-aggrandizing piece of propaganda.
He writes:
While Trump has announced a variety of groups he wants to gather together to charter a pandemic recovery for the nation, there’s one group that is already on the job– and their plans for public education suck.
The National Coronavirus Recovery Commission– doesn’t that sound grand? It sounds like a real official government thing, only it isn’t, exactly. It’s the project of the Heritage Foundation, a right-tilted thinky tank that has been a major policy player in DC since the days of Ronald Reagan.
He notes the presence of one Kevin P. Chavous, who has made good money by running with the rightwing crowd, a sector not known for their devotion to racial equality and civil rights.
Well, look. It’s Kevin Chavous, the big cheese at K12, the 800 pound gorilla of the cyber school world, the one funded by junk bond king Michael Milken and founded by a McKinsey alum (anoter early investor– Dick DeVos). They’ve had more than their share of messes (like the time the NCAA decided K12 credits don’t count). But the Trump administration has been good times for them. And Chavous used to help run the American Federation for Children, Betsy DeVos’s dark money ed reform group, from which he called for the privatization of post-Katrina New Orleans education. Do I need to add that he has no actual education background?
Want a reason to vote for Joe Biden? Read the Heritage Foundation report with their plans for a dark future.
This wish list from the Heritage Foundation has the Trump “whole of government” rhetoric. It ignores the fact that the current response to the pandemic on matters related public education are being determined by Congress, and with provisions in the CARES Act one example.
I looked at the report. It seemed to be calling for a money-follows-the-student policy for the rest of this school year, and with total ignorance of the pattern of school closures already announced by April, 20 the date of this report. In any case, this document is just another example of using the pandemic as an opportunity to call for more deregulation, and in the case of education, pushing the idea that anyone can provide educationt, no qualifications required, except perhaps for a college degree.
Expertise in any field is not wanted. Otherwise the Heritage would not be so active in helping Trump get elected and with freedom to install a bunch of bobble-headed dolls in his cabinet.
https://www.ncsl.org/blog/2020/04/01/-cares-act-gives-state-education-funding-flexibility-in-wake-of-covid-19.aspx
“The National Coronavirus Recovery Commission– doesn’t that sound grand? It sounds like a real official government thing, only it isn’t, exactly. ”
You have to love how the political lobbying/influence industry hasn’t missed a beat in this crisis.
Not “essential workers” by any stretch of the imagination, but none of them have been furloughed 🙂
Billionaires still have plenty of money to spread around.
Schools may be closed but the Professional Public Schools Critics Association continues to churn out criticism!
and there are reports that more than a few teachers are resigning or thinking of resigning: they can see the “forced outsider idea ” future being written on the wall
The “package of services instead of schools” idea is very popular in ed reform. The idea is each parent puts together a set of services with “their” allotment of school funding from a set of private contractors.
Ed reformers have never understood or valued the central role public schools play in communities. I’m convinced they never will. They didn’t get it even though we saw massive protests when they shuttered schools in places like Chicago. Just- woosh! Right over their heads.
They see public education as a set of contract service providers. You just “curate” a list and you’re good to go. Remember when DeVos set out her vision of public education as like the food truck outside her office? That’s the mindset. That’s why DeVos sneeringly refers to “buildings” and Arne Duncan insists all kids need is an internet connection and laptop for “anytime, anywhere learning”. They simply do not value the schools role.
People really won’t be dumb enough to trade their existing public school systems for a vague promise of a voucher so they can purchase education services from private providers, will they?
They know this is a massive reduction in funding for public education, right? They know parents will actually be the unpaid regulators and teachers for these “services”, and K12 will just provide a cheap, canned “playlist” that they could put together free?
I remember how much Michigan ed reformers wanted to allot parents for this “disruption”- it was 5000 dollars. Michigan public school parents know that’s a 50% cut in public education funding, I hope.
These free market fanatics act as though nothing should stand between them and their profiteering. Professional teachers are those that have met a certain level of training in order to practice. Would anyone want to hire an untrained doctor, dentist, plumber or electrician? Every discipline has a certain minimum level of qualification in order to practice, and teaching is no different.
Publishing misleading “studies” is nothing new to the deformers. They continue to try to appear legitimate, but they are not. They are fraudsters that trade in disinformation and propaganda. To quote “our fearless leader,” maybe one day we will wake up, and it will be gone. It will be a miracle! That is my hope for the sleazy, disingenuous disrupters and their evil attempts to monetize public education.
This trash report is not even a study. It is an aggregation of right wing opinion.
Good god, these people….
GREED and immorality go hand-in-hand.
The deformers PRETEND they care about kids, when in fact, our young are just dollar signs to them.
For months now, I have been receiving in my daily mail envelopes from various con artists designed to look like notifications from the IRS or the Social Security Administration, using the same or similar fonts, logos, and other graphic design other elements. These all peddle fake services to seniors that are made to look like government services–survivor benefits, funeral plots, supplemental insurance, reverse mortgages, etc. etc. Well, what the Heritage Foundation has done here is the same shtick. And, ironically, what they’ve done here shows what happens when you privatize everything. You leave everything open to the unfettered operations of skillful con artists like the folks at the Heritage Foundation–the sort of people who will try to make their partisan politicking look like material from an independent, nonpartisan government commission. Not surprising in the age when the guy who have you Trump University is our president.
Thanks. This document is a self-serving batch of opinions from a group of well-funded right wing extremists, masquerading as a government report. The fake packaging bothers me as much as the recommendations.
I really have to start proofing my comments more carefully! So many typos. LOL.
My brother sent me today a picture of a piece of mail that he received from some unscrupulous company. It is addressed from something called the “Credit Stimulus Department” and contains a check. According to the fine print, if people deposit the check, they have agreed to a loan with a 140 percent APR.
This is just like what Trump did with his Trump University. And it’s just like what the Heritage Foundation did with its “Coronavirus Commission” report. Diane nailed this. Unethical. Disgusting.
Well of course the Heritage folks recommend that crap.