James Hohmann writes today in Washington Post that Ohio Governor DeWine should pay attention to history: Abraham Lincoln did not cancel the elections of 1864.
”Abraham Lincoln rejected calls to postpone the 1864 election amid the Civil War, even though his reelection remained very much in doubt until the capture of Atlanta that September. “If the rebellion could force us to forgo or postpone a national election, it might fairly claim to have already conquered and ruined us,” the 16th president reasoned.
”To be sure, Lincoln was not facing a global pandemic with a highly contagious novel coronavirus that epidemiologists fear could kill more than a million Americans if not quickly contained. Officials reported 18 new deaths across the United States on Monday, bringing the nationwide total to 85, with more than 4,450 cases now confirmed in the country and the real number thought to be far higher because of problems distributing the test.
”But Lincoln was fending off an existential threat to the country’s survival. And his principle that the elections must go on has guided generations of leaders facing crises. During the influenza pandemic a century ago, for instance, local election officials across the country chose not to postpone voting in primaries during the 1918 midterms.
”On Monday night in Ohio, Franklin County Court of Common Pleas Judge Richard Frye rejected a temporary restraining order supported by Ohio Gov. Mike DeWine (R) to postpone the state’s primary until June. He warned that rescheduling the election would “set a terrible precedent.” The judge explained during a court hearing that “there are too many factors to balance in this uncharted territory.”
“That didn’t deter DeWine. A few hours later, his director of public health ordered polls closed on account of a statewide emergency. “During this time when we face an unprecedented public health crisis, to conduct an election [Tuesday] would force poll workers and voters to place themselves at an unacceptable health risk of contracting coronavirus,” the governor tweeted. Overnight, without issuing an opinion, the Ohio Supreme Court denied a legal challenge to the order to postpone the primary. This means that there will not be in-person voting in the Buckeye State today.
“The only thing more important than a free and fair election is the health and safety of Ohioans,” DeWine said in a joint statement overnight with Ohio Secretary of State Frank LaRose (R). “Logistically, under these extraordinary circumstances, it simply isn’t possible to hold an election tomorrow that will be considered legitimate by Ohioans….”
“Even as President Trump showed a new seriousness about the outbreak, he told reporters that he didn’t think it was necessary for Ohio to delay its primary. “I think postponing elections is not a very good thing,” said Trump. “They have lots of room in a lot of the electoral places. … I think postponing is unnecessary.” He added that he defers to individual states.
“For the foreseeable future, debates over delaying primaries and elections are poised to become normal. “In Arizona, the Maricopa County Elections Department closed 78 polling locations, citing widespread shortages of cleaning supplies. Now, rather than being limited to their local precinct, voters may cast ballots at any of 151 geographically dispersed polling centers,” Amy Gardner, Elise Viebeck and Isaac Stanley-Becker report. “Poll-worker shortages in Florida prompted one election official in Pasco County, north of Tampa, to draft sheriff’s deputies, school district workers and county employees to fill in.”
Suspicion, fear, concern: Is Ohio setting a precedent for the national election of 2020?

As a couple in our mid-sixties, with my husband undergoing chemo, this was a highly appreciated move on the part of our governor. We were both extremely conflicted about voting. We always vote in person, so had not ordered an absentee ballot. This was in no way a political move on his part – it was in the interest of the health of every American, especially those in a compromised situation. We are both firm Democrats but completely support this decision of his.
LikeLike
Well said, Denise!
LikeLike
Dewine isn’t smart enough to have planned for legislative support for his change, something he might have thought of during his abundant press conferences.
LikeLike
As an Ohioan myself, I disagree. This sets a dangerous precedent. Defying legal orders legitimizes the further dissolution of checks and balances. It exposes the wolf in sheep’s clothing that Frank LaRose is, a true Orange foot soldier. This is the American problem: basing views of politics and policy on how it affects them or thinking the limited range of their experiences to make narrow decisions about big, important issues.
LikeLike
People who are ill or traveling always have the option of early voting. I have cast absentee ballots on several occasions.
LikeLike
Greg-
Exactly.
LikeLike
We need universal registration and universal absentee ballots.
LikeLike
Not fair Democrats might win every election lol The only way republicans win is by preventing people from voting.
LikeLiked by 1 person
That is exactly the case, Joel, and ofc the Repugnicans are quite aware of this.
LikeLike
You wrote what I was just thinking about absentee ballots. But don’t expect today’s GOP to implement something honest and fair that would make them extinct as the dinosaurs.
The Republican Party of Lincoln started to die with Richard Nixon and was long dead by the end of G. W. Bush’s presidency.
Today, we have The Deplorable Desperado, Liar-in-Chief Donald Trumpistan leading the want-to-be brutal-autocratic GOP of the United States. Trump and his rectum sucking administration are dreaming and plotting how they can take advantage of COVID-19 to stop the election in November.
LikeLike
It did not start to die with Goldwater ?
LikeLike
Berry Goldwater lost the 1964 presidential election. He was never the president. If you want to quibble, we could also say that the beginning of the end of the GOP started the moment President Eisenhower warned the country about the birth of the Military-Industrial Complex that loved the wars in Korea, Vietnam, Iraq, Afghanistan and everywhere else the U.S. has sent troops to kill or die.
A lot of wealth in the United States was birthed in rivers of blood all over the world.
LikeLike
I think this move in Ohio was wise, but the dithering of state officials making it a last minute decision was really bad. Four states have postponed elections.
In my opinion, there are much bigger threats to the 2020 Presidential elections than this rescheduling. Among these are active voter suppression efforts, disinformation campaigns and the use of AI and bots to propagate these, and the sophisticated means of targeting messages to likely voters, aided by data voters have contributed to Facebook, Twitter, and other social media.
Trump’s briefing today provided another occasion for self-aggrandizement and an attack on the press for showing the crowds of people in the nation’s airports, returning from Europe as authorized by Trump, but with not an ounce of forward thinking about their arrival, need for checks for symptoms of virus transmission, keeping social distance, and so on.
This impulsive move, a surprise to his own staff, created chaos. He expected nothing but praise from the press. He did not get it. See also the rumor mills and need for a response to these. https://www.military.com/daily-news/2020/03/16/army-white-house-issue-warnings-about-coronavirus-hoaxes-and-scams.html
LikeLike
So what happens in November when the virus may have increased even more? Postpone the general elections until the virus is under control………….when? The nation should be gearing up for vote by mail for the general election, if that is even possible.
LikeLike
Exactly. Universal voting by mail.
LikeLike
It’s time for some “unpresidented” leadership.
LikeLike
Dewine never met a news cycle that he didn’t want to be in.
His dithering created drama and more media coverage. Fully expected.
LikeLike
I also disagree with Diane Ravich, whom I agree with on so many other things. There was a primary scheduled in NYC on 9/11 and it was postponed. It is very wrong to endanger the lives of poll workers and voters, wrong and very troubling, casting doubt on the good faith of the DNC in suggesting this, or worse, forcing it through, thereby at the very least destroying their own legitimacy through reckless conduct.
LikeLike
I disagree.
The governor was wrong to cancel it as he did.
DeWine could have changed the process so all registered voters could vote by mail on a later date after the ballots were printed and mailed. It is called problem-solving, something teachers used to teach their students before the advent of high stakes tests started to destroy K-12 public education in the U.S.
LikeLike
In my opinion, Governor DeWine could have made this decision sooner and could have set in motion a process for mail-in balloting.
LikeLike
That was my opinion, too.
LikeLike
I agree with you both. DeWine is the same breed as Portman—benign, “serious” appearance, always speaking in barely audible tones—enabling the worst tendencies of the Right while appearing to be “reasonable.” The dithering of DeWine on this was strategic; he appeased the Right as long as he could and took “executive” action that strengthened their case.
LikeLike
Greg’s correct.
Portman’s only goal is to stay in D.C., rendering whatever principles he has to a very narrow scope.
Dewine similarly impedes a nation that strives for decency, reasoned decisions and a free people.
LikeLike
Harold,
Gov. DeWine May or may not have made the right decision. Florida went ahead and had a larger turnout than 2016. I hope now he plans for mail-in balloting.
LikeLike
And that was what I was talking about in my comment: instead of canceling the primary, he could have changed the date and switched to mail-in ballots.
LikeLike
Mr. Lofthouse, did the governor (actually it was the Ohio health department), ever say it was to be cancelled forever? I did not understand that. There is no harm in putting it off. We are only in March. If people are to vote in person, steps must first be taken to see that voters and poll workers are protected from infection. (Contrary to what Mr Biden said, it is not safe to congregate in groups of ten. You can be infected by just one person. Or the air they have breathed) Delaying it will allow time for that to be done. Also, spare me the didacticism. I am older than you.
LikeLike
Age does not equal wisdom. When someone uses age in a spitting contest (figuratively speaking), it doesn’t matter who spits the farthest.
Someone who is 30 could be better educated, have better critical thinking skills and problems solving skills than someone else that is 80.
Evidence: Donald Trump (age 73) vs. AOC (age 28). I think it is a safe bet that AOC would beat Trump in all three categories plus she is honest and he is not. But he would certainly beat her for lying and being a con man.
LikeLike
You should treat everyone with respect and not hector or talk down to them, regardless of their age. I assume you are a teacher and used to patronizing your pupils. I don’t appreciate being talked to that way.
LikeLike
Harold,
Welcome to the community. We learn each other’s idiosyncrasies.
LikeLike
Who is patronizing who, Harold?
Did I say you had no wisdom? Nowhere in my comment did I allege anything about you as you have done to me.
You said, “I assume you (Lloyd) are a teacher and used to patronizing your pupils.”
Definition of patronized: “Treat in a way that is apparently kind or helpful but that betrays a feeling of superiority.”
Yes, I was a public school teacher for thirty years from 1975 – 2005 in schools with child poverty rates of 70 percent or higher and that is where I preferred to teach because I was born into a family living in poverty. I enjoyed teaching in those schools worked 60 to 100 hours a week, 25 hours teaching and the rest planning lessons, calling parents, correcting student work, et al.
I never patronized my students, and I never knew a teacher that patronized their students. Teachers are professionals and professionals treat their clients/students with respect. At least they used to before Teach for America came along funded by arrogant billionaires spending hundreds of millions of dollars to destroy public education because these billionaires think like fake billionaire Donald Trump who keeps reminding the world how he is smarter than everyone else on the planet.
No, it would be rare to find a public school teacher like Donald Trump who has said and inferred many times that he is smarter than everyone else.
https://www.washingtonpost.com/news/answer-sheet/wp/2017/02/09/president-trump-is-smarter-than-you-just-ask-him/
Public school teachers care so much for the education of their students, they buy supplies for their classrooms out of their own pay as I did. In fact, I always spent more than the IRS allowed me to deduct on my income tax.
“The average amount spent was $479. About 44 percent spent $250 or less, while 36 percent spent $251 to $500. Teachers who spend their personal money on children’s classroom needs are able to reduce their taxable income by $250.”
https://www.usatoday.com/story/money/personalfinance/2018/05/15/nearly-all-teachers-spend-own-money-school-needs-study/610542002/
LikeLike
If a president can defy a judicial order and congressional subpoenas, then he destroys the concept checks and balances and the very concept of federalism that is theoretically linked to self-governance. If a governor can decide not to prepare and allow any circumstances to overtake him to call off or postpone an election, there is “harm in putting it off.” He sets a precedent for others to build on. What if the president decides it is in the national interest, regardless of the issue, to postpone an election in which he is a candidate? Who decides the timetable? What if the president controls the military? Do diseases take precedence? Or invasion of foreign invaders? Or do real Americans make the decision. Spare me.
LikeLike
Too bad that the “land of the free” doesn’t have more thinkers like GregB.
LikeLike
Harold,
Did Ohio’s health director act independently or, at the behest of Dewine? – the health director, a governor loyalist?
LikeLike
What nonsense. Ohio did the right thing. As for me, I’m voting by mail.(NYS)
LikeLike
That is what others have said here. Instead of canceling the primary elections, change the date and do it by mail.
And, that government should be clear that is what he is doing instead of playing political games for idiots and the corrupt, while Americans die.
LikeLiked by 1 person
Oops. I thought he was rescheduling, not cancelling. That’s just not right.
LikeLike
From what I’ve read, his statement sounded ambiguous, probably intentional, so he can back peddle later if he gets a backlash.
LikeLike
Ohio law gives the Department of Health sweeping power of “quarantine and isolation.” Director Amy Acton cited http://codes.ohio.gov/orc/3701.13v1. In my opinion, much more direct than the ill-fated attempt to use a civil suit.
LikeLike
How much influence did Dewine have in Amy’s decision?
LikeLike