Politico Morning Education reports on Betsy DeVos’ attack on “choice.” She was talking about slavery, not schools. Ironic. She’s wrong about both. She has a gift for bad analogies, like comparing schools to Uber and taxis or food stands outside the ED building.
HOW DEVOS USED THE ABORTION, SLAVERY ANALOGY: DeVos, a Christian conservative, was talking about the Trump administration’s record of opposition to abortion and her own at the Museum of the Bible on Wednesday when she invoked the comparison, saying she was reminded of President Abraham Lincoln “contending with the ‘pro-choice’ arguments of his day.”
— “They suggested that a state’s ‘choice’ to be slave or to be free had no moral question in it,” she said, according to prepared remarks shared Thursday by the department with POLITICO. She said Lincoln reminded “those pro-choicers” that a vast majority of Americans viewed slavery as a moral evil. “Lincoln was right about the slavery ‘choice’ then, and he would be right about the life ‘choice’ today,” she said.
— Similar comparisons between slavery and abortion by conservatives have drawn intense criticism. Minority members of the Utah Legislature, all of them Democrats, condemned comments by GOP Lt. Gov Spencer Cox comparing abortion to slavery at an Eagle Forum convention earlier this month.
— In November, Michigan Senate Majority Leader Mike Shirkey, a Republican, called abortion a “scourge” that’s comparable to the scourge of slavery. State Sen. Erika Geiss, a Democrat who is black, called the remark “incredibly insensitive,” adding “I don’t think comparing something that is a reproductive health care choice for one in four women … has any place in a conversation about slavery,” the Associated Press reported.

My gawd…does DeVoodoo really believe her own words? If so, then she’s crazy.
The fact that she even said this shows how sick she is and has no business being Secretary of Education.
When will we get a decent Secretary of Education? It’s been eons.
LikeLike
It is evidently a requirement for the position of Secretary of Education that one have no relevant knowledge or experience and be a grifter.
Not surprising that the guy who gave you Trump University also gave you Ditzy DeVoid, aka Cruella DeVille’s younger sister, Clueless DeVille.
LikeLike
The Trumpeteers were shaken by the opposition voiced in Christianity Today. They are doing everything in their power to shore up the Evangelical vote prior to the election. Expect, during the run-up to the election, for Trump to make abortion his signature issue this time around. Trump, that model of Christian charity and grace, that profound scholar of theology, to whom faith is, ofc, so important.
LikeLike
Ofc Trump will not be removed. Despite this, the current “trial” in the Senate is extremely important. Puts it all on record.
BOB: [Lights candle] In memory of Republican integrity, which is gone but not forgotten.
LikeLike
I keep expecting to hear from women paid by Trump to have abortions. But fear they signed non-disclosure agreements.
LikeLiked by 1 person
Trump has always been able to juggle his precarious finances enough to pay a bunch of dirty lawyers. The Teflon Don 2.0.
LikeLike
Non-disclosure agreements with a liquidated damages clause perhaps.
LikeLike
There were no “pro-choice” arguments in Lincoln’s day. Rather, there were proponents of slavery who justified it (and viewed it as moral) on various specious grounds, including ones supposedly rooted in the Bible.
At least DeVos recognizes that “choice” is not per se good. That’s a beginning, though a small one, for a Secretary of Education whose mantra is choice, as if choice is always good, say, a choice between an underfunded public school and an authoritarian test-prep academy in the guise of a charter school.
Comparing a woman’s decisions about reproductive health to the “choice” to enslave other human beings is an outrage and a diminishment of the horrors of slavery.
LikeLike
I have an idea. Take away all of Betsy DeVos’s wealth and power. Then sell her to ruthless cartel traffickers, and a year later, we can discover if she still feels the same way … that is if she survives. The average girl or woman trafficked into slavery dies within 7 years after she is abducted. Most never reach 30.
LikeLike
DeVos and others had to fall down the strangest rabbit hole of all time to say something like that. Disturbed and disturbing.
LikeLike
Betsy didn’t fall down the rabbit hole. She was born in it.
Rabbit Droppings
Born in a rabbit hole
Raised in a brood
Certain to take a toll
Alice had viewed
LikeLike
I just listened to some of the Espinoza v Montana case on CSPAN. Four hatters were mad in the same hole as DeVos: Alito, especially Alito, Kavanaugh, Gorsuch, and Roberts. They argued that the Establishment Clause of the Constitution does not just prohibit the government from making any law respecting the establishment of religion, it also prohibits the government from making any law respecting the establishment of race. That way, they say, vouchers are for religious schools just like funding is for HBCUs. Breyer argued that “there is no Establishment Clause in regard to race,” but Kavanaugh interrupted by crying, screaming, and throwing beer cans at Breyer and the attorney for Montana. Then he ordered the Cheshire Cat to be beheaded and ran away.
LikeLike
Betsy wasn’t born in the rabbit hole.
Since Betsy is a viper, she slithered into the hole, ate the rabbits that lived there and confiscated the underground home the rabbits dug and maintained.
When the former rabbit hole gets dirty from Betsy the vipers filth, because she does not clean up after herself, she slithers to the next rabbit hole, eats those rabbits and takes over the underground home they dug and maintained.
Betsy the viper does this repeatedly until there are no more rabbits and no more clean rabbit homes to steal from the dead rabbits she swallowed whole.
Once Betsy is done with all the rabbits, she starts in on the gophers.
LikeLike
Poet, I’m glad that Diane is finally taking a weekend for herself, and my reply to your poem is having adventures in moderation Wonderland.
LikeLike
Theocracy in plain sight.
Huffpo reported today that media requested e-mails that allegedly show New Orleans Saints’ execs used a NFL.com e-mail account to help the New Orleans diocese strategize about limiting fall out from the sex abuse scandal.
Drew Brees, Saints quarterback, appeared in a video, “Bring Your Bible to School Day” (Washington Post, 9-16-2019). In 2018, Brees was thanked for his generosity to a charter school as reported by the Greater New Orleans Collaborative of Charter Schools. The Saints’ owner attended the event.
The Massachusetts Catholic Conference posted at its site, the religion-based arguments against public schools.
LikeLiked by 1 person
three words getting scarier every day: In Plain Sight.
LikeLike
Scary- weaponized religion-
The Oklahoma Catholic Conference site’s postings from RealClear and from the American Federation of Children.
LikeLike
DeVos has no moral compass!
LikeLike
One needs to note that slavery and abortion are concepts from the Democrat South. The Confederacy, compiled of ALL Democrats, defended slavery in the United States, and promoted its expansion into the West against northern Free Soil opposition. Among this group of Confederates, well Democrats, were KKK members who hated black people. And, one of the best well known KKK lovers was Margaret Sanger. Sad, you hate anyone who tells you the truth about Democrats. Please read this from History Center for more details…https://www.history.com/topics/reconstruction/ku-klux-klan P.S. One in two black children are aborted. One in two…..let that sink into your mind.
LikeLike
Um, no black children have ever been aborted. Or white, Latinx or Asian ones for that matter.
LikeLike
Dienne 77, are you serious, or are you insinuating that if you have an abortion it was murder?
“Abortion rates continue to vary by race and ethnicity”
Abortions per 1,000 women aged 15-44
27.1 percent Black non-Hispanic
18.1 percent Hispanic
16.3 percent non-Hispanic
10 percent White non-Hispanic
https://www.guttmacher.org/infographic/2017/abortion-rates-race-and-ethnicity
Unforced abortions are not murder and never will be except in the minds of ignorant, brain hacked, biased fools. Even if the Trump/GOP dominated Supreme Court rules abortion is murder, it will only be murder when a woman is forced to have an abortion or a pregnant woman is murdered and her fetus dies with her death.
LikeLike
Dienne may mean the word children is not a synonym for a a fertilized egg.
LikeLike
Dienne##, “The U.S. Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC) estimates that 66 percent of legal abortions occur within the first eight weeks of gestation, and 92 percent are performed within the first 13 weeks. Only 1.2 percent occur at or after 21 weeks (CDC, 2013)”
The baby is not a baby in the first trimester. The fetus is not a fetus in the first trimester. In the 1st trimester, it is called a zygote and at the end of the first trimester is about the size of a kidney bean, weight an ounce, and has no brain or nervous system.
“An embryo is the early stage of human development in which organs are critical body structures are formed. An embryo is termed a fetus beginning in the 11th week of pregnancy, which is the 9th week of development after fertilization of the egg. A zygote is a single-celled organism resulting from a fertilized egg.”
LikeLike
Thanks for the clarity. Lloyd. The abortion issue is contrived PR to rally the right wing. Republicans have no platform issue that is, in impact, consistent with New Testament scripture so they convinced the gullible to feel better about themselves under the guise of protecting zygotes.
Catholic cruelty- The USCCB donates $2.5 mil. to a clinic that promotes, to the exclusion of effective methods, a birth control method that fails 25% of the time. BTW, how often does the woman’s male partner blame her for the rhythm calendar’s failure?
There are 13 GOP women representatives in the House with 2 planning to retire. 186 men. No black people. The bishops and the mostly male Catholic Conference directors can’t reconcile their faith, politics and genderand race exclusion.
Makes me proud to be a Democrat and supporter of Pastors for Texas Children and an opponent of the Koch network.
LikeLike
I wonder what the pro-life crowd would say to justify these passages from the Bible.
Deuteronomy 28:53
During the siege and hardship that your enemy will impose on you, you will eat the fruit of your womb, the flesh of the sons and daughters whom the LORD your God has given you.
Lamentations 4:10
The hands of compassionate women have cooked their own children, who became their food in the destruction of the daughter of my people.
LikeLike
Well now, that’s disgusting.
LikeLike
“Truth about Democrats”- party labeling has changed in the years since the 1860’s. Lincoln would be in the progressive party today.
Would Rand Paul be in the WHIG party?
Try harder to make better points, “truth”.
LikeLike
Truth, your name should be Tainted Truth.
You forgot to include what happened to the Democratic Party after President LBJ signed the Civil Rights Act (CRA) into Law. This is called cherry-picking and when someone cherry-picks the facts and leaves out a lot of those facts, they are misleading anyone that reads or hears what they think.
The Democratic Party of today, after the CRA, is not the Democratic Party of the old, racist South.
What happened to the Jim Crow Democratic Party? ANSWER: Those Democrats switched to the Republican Party, took over the GOP with help from Republican Presidents Nixon, Reagan, Bush and Bush, and Donald Trump, and turned the GOP into the racist party it is today.
“How the ‘Party of Lincoln’ Won Over the Once Democratic South”
Democratic defectors, known as the “Dixiecrats,” started a switch to the Republican party in a movement that was later fueled by a so-called “Southern strategy.”
“The night that Democratic President Lyndon B. Johnson signed the Civil Rights Act of 1964, his special assistant Bill Moyers was surprised to find the president looking melancholy in his bedroom. Moyers later wrote that when he asked what was wrong, Johnson replied, ‘I think we just delivered the South to the Republican party for a long time to come.’ …
“To understand some of the reasons the South went from a largely Democratic region to a primarily Republican area today, just follow the decades of debate over racial issues in the United States. …
https://www.history.com/news/how-the-party-of-lincoln-won-over-the-once-democratic-south
LikeLike
“…that a vast majority of Americans viewed slavery as a moral evil.”
False. The first anti-slavery publication in America came out of Jonesboro, Tennessee in 1819, published by Elihu Embree (whose name stands as a monument to naming people weird things). His Manumission Intelligencer preceded William Lloyd Garrison’s Liberator by a decade of so. By the Mexican War, only a few people opposed slavery, and even the ones who did mostly thought non-Europeans were inferior, not people.
Opposition to slavery coalesced around the Free Soil Movement, one of the ultimate components of the new Republican Party in 1854. It was arguably the most important of the factions within the party, and its proponents feared that the land taken in the 1846 war with Mexico would mostly be taken over by those who owned slaves. The Bleeding Kansas incident was a result of competition for land, not philosophical distaste for slavery. The exception was John Brown, whose attack on a pro-slavery settlement earned him a status of extreme fear among slave owners and hero status among eastern intellectuals like Thoreau and Emerson.
Still, the majority of the people in the north did not care one bit about the slaves themselves until Uncle Tom’s Cabin popularized a singular, false narrative about the nature of slavery. Plantation slavery was as rare as modern-day billionaires (and was just as destructive to society). The real character of slavery was much more pernicious and was generally ignored by everybody because Africans were not really thought of as people except by a remnant whose ideas did not really take root until the Twentieth Century. After the war, they threw the freed slaves under the bus (or at least the nineteenth century equivalent) and began to blame Africans and poor whites alike for their poverty.
Thus what is a good analogy is that those who have blame those who do not have. Some things never change.
LikeLike
Thanks for giving readers accurate context.
LikeLike
Simultaneous to the abortion rhetoric, the USCCB gave $2.5 million to clinics that promote the rhythm method to the exclusion of other birth control- a method that fails 25% of the time. When women get pregnant on the rhythm method, who do you think their partners blame?
Secretary of State Pompeo, when angered by a female reporter’s questions demanded she show him Ukraine on a map- condescending behavior used exclusively to put women in their place.
Women who vote Republican are fools.
LikeLike
Last year, the State Dept. website promoted a speech by Pompeo that focused on him as a Christian leader. He’s Presbyterian.
66% of Americans want separation of church and state.
LikeLike