In thinking back over the past decade, Peter Greene realized that Michelle Rhee was one of its defining figures.
For a time, she was everywhere. The media loved her stern and angry visage. She graced the cover of TIME and NEWSWEEK. She appeared on the Oprah show, NBC’s Education Nation, “Waiting for Superman.” And then she was gone.
For years, she was the face of the “reform” movement, a crusader set on busting unions, firing teachers and principals, and leading the way to nirvana. At one point, she boldly predicted that she would turn the public schools of D.C. into the best in the nation. After Mayor Adrian Fenty lost his race in 2010, Rhee stepped down as chancellor of the D.C.schools and launched StudentsFirst, which was anti-union, pro-testing, pro-Charter, and pro-voucher. Then it disappeared, never having raised the $1 billion she predicted.
Now the face of that same movement is Betsy DeVos, and the media doesn’t love her the way they loved Rhee, even though their goals are identical.
Like many of the big names in education disruption in the oughts, Rhee skated on sheer chutzpah. There was no good reason for her to believe that she knew what the heck she was doing, but she was by-God certain that her outsider “expertise” was right and that all she needed to create success was the unbridled freedom to exert her will.
And in 2010, it was working. The media loved her and, more significantly, treated her like a go-to authority on all educational issues. They fell all over themselves to grab the privilege of printing the next glowing description of the empress’s newest clothes. She was more than once packaged as the pro-reform counterpart of Diane Ravitch (though one thing that Rhee carefully and consistently avoided was any sort of head to head debate with actual education experts).
For the first part of the decade, it kept working. Students First became a powerhouse lobbying group, pushing hard for the end of teacher job protections. She was in 2011’s reform agitprop film Waiting for Superman. LinkedIN dubbed her an expert influencer. She spoke out in favor of Common Core and related testing. A breathless and loving bio was published about her in 2011; in 2013 she published a book of her own. She had successfully parleyed her DC job into a national platform.
2014 seemed like peak Rhee. I actually decided to stop mentioning her by name; I felt guilty about increasing her already-prodigious footprint. She seemed unstoppable, and yet by 2014 we knew that the TFA miracle classrooms, the DC miracle, the TNTP boondoggle, the StudentsFirst failures (far short of 1 million or $1 billion). Rhee was the Kim Kardashian of ed reform, the popular spokesmodel who did not have one actual success to her name. She was increasingly dogged by her controversies.
And then, in the fall of 2014, Michelle Rhee simply evaporated from the ed scene.
Greene traces the trajectory of her rise and fall in this post. What a spectacular rise it was, what an inglorious fall.
The parade has passed by, and she is no longer its leader. She is not even in it.
Diane’s posts seem to be in my wheelhouse today…
Speaking from San Francisco, 90 miles from Rhee and Johnson’s Sacramento home: Rhee faded away from public view basically simultaneously with her husband. The coverage of Johnson’s alleged sexual assaults/harassment was getting intense, and that seemed to be the way they handled it — just fade out of sight. Meanwhile, StudentsFirst never got close to reaping the mega-millions it proclaimed it would (after a wildly hyped start on Oprah), but it certainly raked in some bucks, and where did those bucks go? Seems like Rhee and Johnson may be living comfortably, put it that way.
I was in Sacramento on — I know the exact date — Sept. 11, 2015 — I know this because there was a town parade and event that day. Johnson’s term as mayor was close to its end. He and Rhee were in the town parade and spoke at the event, but it was kept low-key. StudentsFirst still existed at the time but had also become low-key. I went to look at the StudentsFirst office (again, this operation was WILDLY hyped). It wasn’t quite a mail drop, but a step above one — one occupant of an anonymous office building above a T-Mobile store, with only a tiny listing on one of the buttons at the front door to announce itself, and no sign of life.
Sacramento Bee, 3/21/16
Kevin Johnson’s accusers detail their claims of sexual misconduct on HBO show
https://www.sacbee.com/news/local/article67680237.html
I checked Rhee’s twitter feed. She has posted twice in the past six months.
I checked her LinkedIn profile. A post from 2014 had her speaking about being in Washington DC and functioning as an entrepreneur. The comments on that performance were mostly from other entrepreneurs and some DC parents who though she was great.
Henry Mencken’s observation is a fitting one for Rhee and rest of the falling stars of corporate education reform: “I confess that, for my part, it [democracy] greatly delights me…Does is exalt dunderheads, cowards, trimmers, frauds, cads? Then the pain of seeing them go up is balanced and obliterated by the joy of seeing them come down.”
yet not obliterated for the so many she and others like her have pushed completely out of beloved careers: it is hard for many to even see her name
Henry Mencken’s observation is a fitting one for Rhee and rest of the falling stars of corporate education reform: “I confess that, for my part, it [democracy] greatly delights me…Does it exalt dunderheads, cowards, trimmers, frauds, cads? Then the pain of seeing them go up is balanced and obliterated by the joy of seeing them come down.”
Speaking of bees, Rhee used to love to tell the story of how she one grabbed a bee and ate it in front of her students to show them how tough she was. This incident gave the following term to my dictionary of Deformish, aka Reformish, which is a language belonging to the Goblish language group.
bee eater. Unqualified but dependably Reformish sociopath in position of authority, after Michelle Rhee, famous for eating a bee, firing teachers, shameless self-promotion, and making unsubstantiated and false claims about progress during her tenure.
And, of course, for a time, she was so prominent that people spoke of Deform as Rheeform and of the Resistance as the CounterRheeformation.
https://bobshepherdonline.wordpress.com/2014/02/22/from-the-reformish-lexicon/
Ofc, what happened in DC is that the schools didn’t improve despite the standardized testing, the test prep, the VAM, the teacher and principal firings, and achievement gaps did not close. So, in that respect Rhee truly was a pioneer. She showed the absolute failure of Deform to fulfill its promises before anyone.
Richard Whitmire wrote an admiring bio of Rhee titled “The Bee Eater.” That was shortly before she disappeared.
Bee eater also sounds like beater.
But I am sure that is just a coincidence in Rhee’s case, since she only taped kids lips shut with masking tape.
I had to look online to see if you the “taped lips shut with masking tape” was just a metaphor you were using. I guess not – yikes!
It was not a metaphor. Rhee boasted to an assembly of new teachers in DC that she put duct tape on her students’ s mouths, and when she pulled it off, some were bleeding. Not funny but she thought it was.
A sociopath, and so, ofc, the Deform/Disruption Movement made her into a hero
She should have paddled them – no bleeding.
Rhee might as well eat a porcupine or scorpion for all I care. She is a coward, a villain, a fraud, and she thinks her fading will also fade the accusations against her hubby and the ensuing victims coming forth.
She may as well stick her head deeply into sand!
Quicksand . . . . . .
But somehow I don’t sense this as good Rhee-dance . . . .
She might pop up on HSN or QVC trying to sell stockholder shares in a charter chain. She’ll be right up there with Susan Lucci peddling perfume . . .
Just finished reading your “reformish-lexicon” blog post. So cathartic – wish I had read this when you first posted. Thanks!
Gosh. Thank you, beachteach!
I once invited Rhee to speak at the summer conference of the Association of Teacher Educators summer conference in DC. She accepted the invitation and decided not to show, sending the National Teacher of the Year in her place. Of course, she appeared on the DC news just the next morning so she was obviously not ill, as she said. I guess she really wasn’t up for a discussion of her policies with teacher educators but then, that wasn’t a surprise either. Her rudeness was. I am certainly glad she’s history. She caused so much harm with her ill conceived ideas and her moxie.
When Michelle Rhee was at the height of her post-DC glory, we were both invited to debate by Lehigh University for a handsome fee. I accepted, so did she.
Then she said she preferred to have two vs. two. I agreed. Then she wanted three vs. three. I thought the debate had just turned into a panel discussion, but I agreed.
Then she canceled.
I showed up on the appointed date and conducted a mock debate, playing both sides.
I won.
I love this story so much!! :-)!!
She was a fraud and a flake even then. She was a candle in the wind that burnt brightly for a time and then was extinguished. I’d to say the same about the disruptors.
What a wonderful story!
And I must say that I am impressed, Diane. When I debate myself, I always lose!
That’s hilarious, but Rheeally all jokes aside, it’s a good thing Rhee didn’t show. Being in the same room with her can be dangerous. She’s liable to put you on national television and fire you, or tear skin off your lips with duct tape. It’s no fun, getting hit with a broom. Be careful!
No really, Michelle Rhee was an unfeeling terror.
They should have paid you her fee too!
But what is Rhee doing now? I am sure, she survives well, and she didn’t have to take a custodian job in one of the charter schools she helped create.
Chris Barbic, the first pope of the failed Achievement School District in Memphis is surviving well while working for the Arnold foundation. He is now part of a group called the City Foundation which pushes for the portfolio model “in every city”. Joining Barbic in this exciting new effort to demolish public education is Kevin Huffman, the ex of Rhee and the ex edu Commissioner of my state.
Note that Barbic and Huffman, though they completely failed in their leadership mission, are referred to as “big names in school reform”. Wow.
Several big names in education reform are teaming up to start a new organization designed to change how schools are managed in cities across the U.S. — and they say they’ve already raised $200 million.
The City Fund, as the group is being called, will push cities to expand charter schools and district schools with charter-like autonomy. It represents a big increase in visibility and influence for advocates of the “portfolio model” of running schools, a strategy that’s been adopted by cities like New Orleans, Denver, and Indianapolis.
Others involved include Chris Barbic of the Arnold Foundation; Kevin Huffman, the former Tennessee education chief; David Harris, who previously led the Mind Trust, an Indianapolis-based group; and Ethan Gray, the president of the nonprofit Education Cities.
https://chalkbeat.org/posts/us/2018/07/31/the-city-fund-portfolio-model-200-million/
See my earlier post in the thread. It’s clear that Rhee and her husband both decided to go quiet and live lives out of the spotlight after a number of explosive sexual harassment accusations against him. It’s not clear what ever was done with the large amount in donations reaped by Rhee’s now-dead, once-hyped-to-the-skies operation Students First, so presumably they have a nice financial cushion, put it that way.
The Broad Academy is proud of Barbic who is their graduate. Read how they describe his role at ASD as if it was a success.
Oops, the link: https://www.broadcenter.org/alumni/directory/profile/chris-barbic/
I sense a consultant-driven-comeback book and publicity tour in the offing! Complete with salacious drivel about how she had to break free from the clutches of her manipulative husband who kept her from being her.
And, of course, any failure can just be blamed on teacher unions. All she has to do is mention ‘teacher union’ and everyone will shake their head in disgust and agree with anything she says.