The Los Angeles County Board of Education has denied renewal to a troubled charter school in the Inglewood school district.
The school has a long history of self-dealing, conflicts of interest, and a mixed academic record. This charter demonstrates that even “non-profits” can be very profitable to its owners.
The California Charter Schools Association is on high alert because of a change in state law that allows local districts to weigh in on the future of charter schools, especially their fiscal impact on public schools and whether they duplicate what the public schools are already doing.
The Los Angeles County Board of Education voted Tuesday to close an Inglewood charter school with a lengthy history of financial problems and mixed academic performance that illustrated flaws in California’s oversight system.
The board’s unanimous decision marks the third time it has attempted to shut down a charter school run by Today’s Fresh Start, a nonprofit started by a wealthy couple, Clark and Jeanette Parker of Beverly Hills. The group currently operates two charters on three campuses in Los Angeles, Compton and Inglewood.
A Times investigation published last year found that although the Parkers have portrayed themselves as philanthropists, they have made millions from their charter schools.
The schools paid more than $800,000 annually to rent buildings the couple own, financial documents showed. They contracted out services to the Parkers’ nonprofits and companies and paid Clark Parker generous consulting fees, all with taxpayer money.
The couple spent tens of thousands of dollars on lobbyists and campaign contributions to many of the people responsible for regulating their schools, including school board members and state elected officials.
The Parkers have denied any wrongdoing, calling the claims against them baseless and manufactured by opponents of their schools.
The board’s Tuesday vote, which affects only the Inglewood charter, leaves the future of the school, its staff and its more than 400 students in doubt.
Jeanette Parker declined to comment following the decision.
Under current California law, Today’s Fresh Start can appeal the county’s decision to the State Board of Education. A possible appeal would most likely be heard before July, when a new law takes effect that significantly limits the state board’s power to approve charter schools that have been rejected elsewhere.
Decisions like the county board’s vote to close Today’s Fresh Start are rare. Los Angeles County is home to more than 350 charter schools, most of which are routinely renewed every five years by the local school districts where they are located. Only six schools appealed renewal denials to the county in 2017-18 — the last time appeals were heard — and three were denied.
In their recommendation to close the school, consultants hired by the county voiced concern about students’ stagnant performance on the state’s standardized English language arts tests and said the school hadn’t met the necessary academic criteria to be renewed. On both English and math tests, students’ scores increased between 2015 and 2017 and spiked upward in 2018 before declining last year. The overall picture, they wrote, was “troubling.”
The consultants also raised questions about the nonprofit’s management and fiscal practices, adding that many of their concerns had surfaced more than a decade ago when the county board last tried to close one of the organization’s schools.
“It should be noted that concerns regarding conflicts of interest and self-dealing were significant bases for revocation 12 years ago,” the report stated. “Those concerns regarding conflicts of interest and self-dealing have continued to follow [Today’s Fresh Start] to this day.”
I still think it’s wild that anyone can invent a job for themselves in charterworld and be 100% paid by the public.
These people created lucrative jobs for themselves, and all on the public dime. They create a new publicly-paid position and then hire themselves. Incredible.
Imagine if an actual public school employee did this- ran all purchases of the district exclusively through their family business. That person would be in prison. It’s just Tuesday in edreformworld. No one questions it at all.
Try this in some other government entity. Set up a kiosk at the courthouse and appoint yourself as the free market county recorder, then collect public funds and pay yourself. It’s unique to the wacky world of charters.
Wow! The L.A. County board is wildly anti-education, having been appointed by a relatively corrupt city council. Before now, I don’t remember them ever falling out of love with a charter. I guess Goliath is really falling. I will take a little credit for that on this day, the United Teachers of Los Angeles’ one year #StrikeAversary. When we fight, we win. Inglewood Unified, you owe UTLA a solid. Fresh Start, you owe Inglewood millions of dollars.
It’s the case of LA County Board members throwing one of their darlings under the bus. When enough evidence has been presented [and indictments have been filed] they cut ties.
It actually works in their favor, making the public think that they are impartial.
For those not in the know, the LA County Board oversees all local school boards within Los Angeles County (e.g., LAUSD, Long Beach). It has been pro-charter for the last 20+ years.
Guess how Fresh Start got its fresh start? Two big old federal CSP grants: $215,625 and then $234,375