Nick Melvoin was elected to the board of the Los Angeles Unified School District with the most money ever spent on a school board election in American history. The money came from the charter lobby.
It was not hard to assume that he owed an enormous debt of gratitude to Eli Broad, Reed Hastings, Richard Riordan, Bill Bloomfield, and the other uber-rich who funded his election.
Yet, I feel sorry for Nick, whom I have never met.
Michael Kohlhaas just posted emails from his treasure trove of leaked materials that show that Nick was so indebted to the charter lobby that he asked them to write the resolutions that would benefit them. He didn’t write them himself. He asked the California Charter Schools Association to do it for him.
This has got to be deeply humiliating because it shows him to be a complete sellout, a tool.
I am embarrassed for him.
Kohlhaas finds it ironic that the Los Angeles Times endorsed Nick because he would be “an independent thinker.” It turns out that he is not an independent thinker. He is owned by the charter industry and he knows it.
Kohlhaas begins:
We’ve already seen that LAUSD officials, both elected and appointed, have a sickening penchant for sharing confidential materials with Charter lobbyists, giving them advance input into official policy proposals, and so on. I’ve recently reported, e.g., on an episode from September 2018 where Austin Beutner allowed Cassy Horton and Jed Wallace of the California Charter School Association to vet an upcoming speech and also to talk in advance with his speechwriterto explain what they thought ought to be included. Convicted felon slash former schoolboard member Ref Rodriguez did the same thing in March 2018 with respect to a board proposal.
And it turns out that, beginning in January 2018, LAUSD Board member and charter school bootlicker Icky Sticky Nicky Melvoin1was involved in a very similar scheme having to do with LAUSD policies on school facilities, a subject which sounds tedious but is actually bureaucratic code for real estate, a subject which is at the very center of the zillionaire plan to loot the public treasure-stores for their own gain.2
Basically the proposal, which seems never to have made it out of the secret meetings, would have called for LAUSD to list all its facilities so that the privatizers could choose which ones to target, to allocate facilities between charter schools and public schools based on excellence and student success rather than on need, to authorize a putatively neutral third party to settle disputes over co-location offers, to study how to sell or lease LAUSD property to charters, and to do something complicated with bonds used to fund facilities. It all seems incredibly shady, shady beyond belief.
No one knows how Kohlhaas got these emails but no one has questioned their veracity.
What he has revealed so far is the worst kind of corruption: intellectual corruption, moral corruption, ethical corruption. That may be even worse than dollar corruption because it shows a hole in your soul.
There must be many people trembling to think what might come next.

This stuff has to come out.
LikeLike
I don’t feel badly for Kohlhaas. He did this to himself, because he is _____ (fill in the blank). KARMA, the physics of life, is already happening to those liars and cheaters.
This country needs to: Pray for BRAINS. Haven’t had BRAINS since Reagan.
LikeLike
I think you meant to say,
“I don’t feel badly for Melvoin” not “Kohlhaas.”
LikeLike
People who sell-out force those around them to live in an impermanent swamp of shaky scruples. The family lives in fear of the next public embarrassment. They can’t respect the person they are forced to rely upon.
Feel sorry for Melvoin’s family.
LikeLike
Corrected…Nick Melvoin is the one.
Jack, thanks! I miss typed.
LikeLike
Boy, if you consider that Reagan had BRAINS, I have some great white sand beach ocean front property for sale cheaply over at the Lake of the Ozarks in central Missouri. Please contact me ASAP as lots are going quickly.
LikeLike
I include Reagan … he had NO BRAINS or much else except “Reading the Script and looking into the camera. He was the start of this Long ʻine of yahoos.
LikeLiked by 1 person
This post by Diane pointed out how sick this all is. Shook me up to the core. Still shaken, too.
I don’t live in the LAUSD, and I feel raped.
LikeLiked by 1 person
Your comment certainly didn’t seem like what we’ve seen from you before. My facetiometer wasn’t working! 😉
LikeLike
I was NOT clear. Thanks, Duane.
LikeLike
So much to say here.
Let’s just start with this:
During the lead up to the UTLA’s historic and overwhelmingly successful strike last January, Nick appeared at a school’s parents’ meeting and, WITH ZERO PROOF, accused UTLA President of orchestrating the strike merely to advance his post-UTLA political career, stating that the UTLA Prez will use his leadership during the strike — and the reputation it will bring — as a springboard to a career in political office.
The context of this lie was Nick responding to these upscale, mostly white parents’ worries about their children’s safety during what was then the imminent possibility of a strike.
Will the parents be putting their kids at risk if they send their kids to a school with no teachers, and only a handful of administrators supervising hundreds of kids?
Again, part of Nick’s response is that their kids are being put in harm’s way because so the current UTLA prez can someday run for State Assembly, or whatever.
Sweet Jesus!
(3:34)
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=QDmojsw-Y8Q
(3:34)
NICK MELVOIN: “I don’t know WHY (UTLA President) Alex Caputo-Pearl is doing ANY of this (threatening to strike). Some people say that he wants to run for state office.”
NOTE the “weasel words” … “Some people say … ”
You know that that some people say 😉 that Nick learned this propaganda technique from his continuous watching of FOX NEWS.
You be the judge, and watch the “Some Sources Say … ” segment from the documentary OUTFOXED, with the classic “Some Sources Say” montage (at 17:57):
(17:31)
(17:31)
I haven’t watched Nick’s speech in a while, but I just started to rewatch it, and caught the following horror at almost the beginning of the video.
Besides the notion of the UTLA President’s appalling disregard for children, and his putting kids in harm’s way so he can jumpstart a political career once he leaves office, check out WHAT ELSE Nick puts in the parents’ heads.
At the beginning of the video, Nick gives his rationale for why there’s so many charters in L.A., and cites the fact that during his two-year TFA hitch at an L.A. public school, an “assistant principal was arrested for raping a student,” and that’s why parents are leaving public schools, and instead opting for charter schools where their kids won’t get raped. (By the way, the perpetrator is rotting in a jail cell, as he most certainly should be.)
Think about THAT one, folks.
Nick starts a meeting with PUBL.IC SCHOOL parents at a school with high academic achievement and overwhelming parent satisfaction with that school. This are parents who are concerned about their children’s safety and, instead of reassuring them, HE STARTS THE MEETING BY IMPLYING THAT THOSE PARENTS SHOULD REMOVE THEIR KIDS FROM PUBLIC SCHOOL IN FAVOR OF A PRIVATELY-MANAGED CHARTER SCHOOL BECAUSE PUBLIC SCHOOLS ARE, at least in part, STAFFED BY ADULTS WHO WILL RAPE THEIR CHILDREN.
Duh fuh???!!!!!
Am I inferring too much from Nick bringing up that horrific incident? I don’t think so. You can tell from these parents’ questions and reactions that they’re frantic and worried about their children’s well-being. That’s the freakin’ purpose of the freakin’ meeting … and then, without being asked, Nick brings up and puts in the parents’ heads a past incident of a child being raped by a school administrator. Prior to Nick bringing this up, no one else even mentioned this. Nick, and Nick alone, unilaterally injects this info right at the top of the meeting.
Duh fuh???!!!
That’s not exactly the way to put parents’ minds at ease.
LikeLike
Thanks Jack.
He knew what he was doing and what he was getting himself into.
“Nick holds a Bachelor’s degree from Harvard University, a Masters in Urban Education from Loyola Marymount University (LMU), and a law degree from the New York University School of Law, where he was a Root-Tilden-Kern Scholar.”
LikeLike
The parents at this meeting were not idiots. They saw right through Nick’s “Some say … ” diversion.
If you listen closely, one parent tells Nick right after he made the false and defamatory accusation that Caputo-Pearl was ordering a strike to promote C-P’s own self interest..
(3:37)
https://www.youtube.com/watch?time_continue=259&v=QDmojsw-Y8Q
(3:37)
PARENT: (to Nick) “Look, I don’t want to hear your attacks on people. I want to hear what you’re going to do to ensure the safety of our children.”
OTHER PARENT: “Yeah, just please get to the point.”
EPIC FAIL for the Nick-ster.
I’m just having my doubts about Nick’s vaunted Harvard education, and perhaps Harvard itself. Did Nick actually think that pulling this shabby trick would work, that parents would leave the meeting thinking …
“You know I went in here seriously worried about my kids’ safety at understaffed school campus during a strike, but now that Board Member Melvoin has alerted us to it, parents’ real concern and focus should be the teacher union president’s nefarious plans to use the strike to run for office years from now, after he leaves union office.” … ?
Seriously. Is that how Nick’s mind operates?
LikeLike
Totally agree—I was shocked by the rape comment and the Caputo-Pearl comment. His fear mongering is a page from Trump’s book (see his candidacy announcement speech referring to Mexicans as rapists). Unbelievable.
LikeLike
Then “Slicky Nicky” can give his board seat to Alex Caputo-Pearl. Problem solved!
LikeLike
“Charter school bootlicker Icky Sticky Nicky Melvoin” cannot have a hole in its soul if it doesn’t have a soul.
And without a soul, it can’t be human. That’s why Melvoin is an “it”.
LikeLike
“There must be many people trembling to think what might come next.”
Unfortunately this assumes that many who create these shameful poicies have a soul and have not been thoroughly corrupted–intellectually, morally, and ethically.
LikeLike
Charter companies are businesses that compete for funds against the school district. It is the charter industry, not the charter charity. What would happen if, for example, someone on the executive board of PepsiCo was caught letting Coca-Cola executives secretly write policies for his own company, thus sabotaging PepsiCo? A federal grand jury would convict him of industrial espionage. That’s what this is, industrial espionage. I joked earlier about Nick Copying off the CCSA during a quiz, but this is much more serious than cheating. Melvoin has been caught committing a very serious crime.
LikeLike
I love Kohlhaas’ snarky cartoons and those imagined — he-didin’t-really-say-this,-but-that’s-what-he-really-means-/-thinks — dialogue balloons that accompany them:
Here’s the one for the piece being discussed.

Again you can read the piece here:
http://michaelkohlhaas.org/wp/2019/07/15/in-january-2018-just-mere-months-after-millions-of-dollars-in-charter-school-money-bought-icky-sticky-nicky-melvoins-election-to-the-lausd-school-board-he-asked-the-california-charte/
LikeLike
There’s no shortage of unelected interests writing U.S./state policies and laws. It’s rumored that Fordham originates education policy in Ohio. ALEC writes state laws across the nation for the Koch’s.
The question is why we pay for the ruse of the puppets acting as middlemen.
The Squad, Justice Democrats and Bernie give us hope for the America that citizens have sacrificed so much for.
LikeLike
Linda,
I agree: “The Squad, Justice Democrats and Bernie give us hope for the America that citizens have sacrificed so much for.”
LikeLike
Don’t be sorry for that asshat for one minute, Diane.
Born with a silver spoon in his mouth, he lived his whole life in Brentwood and attended the most exclusive private schools in Southern California. He was given everything he wanted from birth.
He went on to Harvard via connections that his Hollywood producer/UCLA professor father has and joined TFA for the sole purpose of jumpstarting a political career.
He taught for two years at a local junior high, while simultaneously obtaining his teaching credential and masters degree in education. What kind of attention do you think he gave his students?
One-third of the way through his second year of teaching he had already applied to law school, with the full intention of leaving the profession and becoming a politician.
He used his TFA and family connections to pave his way to some cushy, education-related analyst positions, then prostituted himself with Broad, Hastings the CCSA and others.
He deserves every bit of the reaming he will get over the next year and, if he runs for reelection, I will be down on a street corner in Mar Vista with a big placard showing the triangular relationship between:
Charterist billionaires handing $6M to Melvoin…
Melvoin handing control of the schools to Beutner…
Beutner handing schools over to charterist billionaires…
Caption will be:
“Hand-jobs All Around!”
LikeLike
I agree one should not feel sorry for any of these people.
They made their bed and now have to lie in it.
And lying is what they do best.
Their very lives are a lie.
LikeLike
To bad their beds are not made of blazing hot coals.
LikeLike
Can’t spell “evil mon” without M-E-L-V-O-I-N
LikeLike
Steve,
You missed a couple wrinkles in the Melvoin story.
Before Melvoin ran for LAUSD Board, he wrote an infamous op-ed where openly cheered and salivated for (in his words) “a hostile (corporate) takeover” of LAUSD. Here’s Melvoin’s infamous “hostile takeover” op-ed.
https://www.the74million.org/article/opinion-maybe-a-hostile-takeover-is-precisely-what-the-los-angeles-unified-school-district-needs/
However, during the campaign, this op-ed resurface, and Nick had to back-pedal. He then flip-flopped and said that he re-thought his position, and that he no longer believed in the need for “a hostile corporate takeover” of LAUSD Schools, and would be a Board Member for all schools — public and private charter, all in a successful effort to trick Westside progressive voters into voting for him.
In short, Melvoin lied. … and these email documents brought to light on Kohlhaas’ website definitively prove this to be the case..
I’ve talked to those Board District 4 folks about this latest stuff from Kohlhaas, and my anecdotal interviews show that — had they known that Melvoin would do all this (and also install a non-educator such s Beutner as Super) — those same voters said that THEY NEVER WOULD HAVE VOTED FOR NICK MELVOIN.
“We (the progressive Board District 4 voters) got played,” said one of them to me, and he sounded quite vexed.
If this isn’t grounds for a recall movement, then I don’t know what is.
Also, while Nick was doing his 2-year stint at Markham Middle School (which years later allowed him to bill himself on the California ballot at “Nick Melvoin — Teacher”) and in the years following, he spent his time as a major figure in pushing two eventual union-busting and tenure-/-due-process-for-teachers-destroying lawsuits: the “Reed” lawsuit and the “Vergara” lawsuit.
Without going into much detail, the wealthy, school-privatizing, union-busting promoters of both of these legal fiascos tried to put a “Kids First” facade on them, while in truth, both “Reed” and “Vergara” had nothing — NUH-THING!!! — to do with improving the education and educational outcomes of poor children of color. Both had initial success, but were eventually reversed when higher courts saw them as the total crocks of sh#% that they were and are.
Here’s Nick testifying for Vergara (a couple years after leaving Markham, and perhaps while Nick was in law school .. I’m not sure), and recounting his involvement with Reed:
Nick claims that he joined TFA and taught in an LAUSD school because he saw “education as the Civil Rights cause of my generation,” and while teaching putting Kids First “was the only factor guiding my decision” to be a teacher.
Right, Nick. That’s why you dumped your students after two years, to then go to law school, and later go into politics, where you’re currently promoting an agenda of privatiztion-via-charterization, and teacher union busting? Whatever you say, dude
Later in the video, Nick pins the blame for his abandoning his students on the teachers union contract, claiming that his disgust with “seniority-based system” drove him to leave … and, of course, “start thinking about law school.”
Later still, you hear Melvoin talk about Shirelle Reed, the putative plaintiff in the bogus Reed lawsuit. On the stand, you hear that Nick admit that it was he who personally recruited her to be the front person — low-income girl of color — for Reed.
Shirelle Reed, you see, was Melvoin’s student. As a TFA Corps Member, in lieu of — or perhaps in addition to — all that boring teaching stuff, Nick basically infiltrated the public school system to recruit students for union-busting lawsuits fronted by those students, but which, in fact were actually orchestrated and funded behind-the-scenes by privatizing billionaires — some of the same folks that bankrolled his $10 million (and successful) campaign for LAUSD School Board.
(18:21)
(18:21)
NICK MELVOIN: “Shirelle Reed was my student .. the main (Reed) plaintiff was a student of mine… I wrote a signed declaration (regarding Reed and his experience teacher her, and that advocated the destruction of all teacher tenure rights)* that was submitted to the court, but I was also involved with organizing the other* (Reed) student plaintiffs .. organizing the effort to bring that lawsuit, and bring attention to the lawsuit.”
Both Reed and Vergara were and are utterly bogus. Reed was reversed on appeal, resulting in a settlement that involved greater funding and smaller classes for Markham and the other schools involved in the Reed case — which is what the union and education activists wanted all along, NOT the destruction of teacher tenure.
Vergara was also revered on appeal, in a strongly worded verdict agreeing with the defendants that the case and its arguments were completely bogus, and unsupported by both the evidence and witness testimony. The California State Supreme Court agreed with the Appeals Court, and refused to even hear it.
Regarding the 2009-2010 and 2010-2011 layoffs (or RIF’s .. Reductions-In-Force) that included Nick, all but 1,000 of those were rescinded before the start of the school year, with the RIF-fed teachers being placed at their own school, at another school, or as substitutes until a position opened up either that year or in a future year. A small number of those who did not want to stick around moved to charters.
Nick claims that these RIFfed-then-rehired experiences so demoralized him that it contributed to him leaving the teaching profession.
Oh yeah. I personally know dozens of current teachers who experienced the same thing as Nick back doing those two school years, but somehow did not follow Nick out of the profession, but stuck around and today are some of LAUSD’s strongest veteran teachers.
Why the-Hell could they do this, and Nick could not? Because Nick’s 2-year stint was never about Nick seriously taking on teaching as a profession, but merely — as he later falsely projected on UTLA President Alex Caputo-Pearl — it was about Nick using his short cup o’ coffee in the classroom to bolster his credibility as an education activist/expert and sell himself as a successful candidate for the LAUSD School Board, and … some say -;) … higher offices after leaving the LAUSD Board.
LikeLike
Holy cow.
LikeLike
Let’s hope more bad things befall him. Schadenfreude and all that.
LikeLike
I’m going to take a stab at writing a Michael-Kohlhaas-style dialogue balloon that would go with a cartoon of Nick Melvoin … a somewhat long-winded dialogue balloon, at that.
I highly doubt that, ten years ago, when Nick was being interviewed to teach at Markham Middle School, he told the principal interviewing him what he was actually planning to do while working as a Markham teacher, and then afterwards.
Thus, the cartoon would be then-TFA-Corp-Member Nick Melvoin’s job interview with the Markham principal:
INTERIOR: MARKHAM MIDDLE SCHOOL OFFICE – SPRING 2009
Nick is on one side of the desk and the Markham principal (and perhaps other Markham or LAUSD administrators) are on the other side of the desk interviewing Nick.
INTERIOR:
MARKHAM MIDDLE SCHOOL PRINCIPAL’S OFFICE –
SPRING 2009
NICK MELVOIN: “You know, Principal So-and-So, before you hire me to teach here at Markham, I think it’s fair for me to inform you that, in addition to all that teaching stuff, I’m going going to be acting as an undercover agent for corporate, anti-public-school interests who are out to privatize existing public schools, yours included, and also to bust teacher unions — an anti-public school mole, if you will.
“And then, pursuant to that end, while I’m teaching here at Markham, I’m going to troll for and seek out low-income students of color, whom I will enlist and exploit as window dressing plaintiffs in corporate-funded, privatizing lawsuits that will weaken the public school system through the weakening of teacher unions and tenure — all with an astro-turf, faux-Kids First outer gloss, of course — as these lawsuits will, in turn, with a severely recently weakened teacher union opposition, make public schools easier to convert to charter schools and thereby privatize them …
“You know, I’ll be doing all this in addition to all that other teacher stuff I’m supposed to do, such lesson planning, grading, record keeping, classroom instruction, parent conferences, etc. After all, I’m going to be getting those five weeks TFA Institute training this coming summer, and that will be plenty of training to do my job right.
“Oh yeah, and then I’m going to take the stand myself in these lawsuits and, in public, viciously smear many of my colleagues here at Markham, and characterize them as a bunch of lazy, long-time veteran teachers — you know, your current teaching staff — and say that they just play movies all day, and basically half-ass it instead of teaching students, and, furthermore, who are enabled in this student-hating sloth by evil teachers unions and their evil tenure and due process protections that all are part of an evil, corrupt status quo that puts lazy adults’ interests ahead of kids interests…
“Oh, and don’t forget: that corrupt status quo also will, by implication, also include you, too, Principal So-and-So.
“Next, I’m going to ditch this dump after finishing my two years of working as Eli Broad’s and others’ mole to attend law school on the East Coast, and then return to run for the LAUSD school board — using my two years here at Markham to give me faux credibility, as, in my campaign, I will pretend to be a progressive or liberal on education, to trick the overwhelmingly progressive voters of L.A.’s West Side into thinking I’m one of them, when I’m really not.
“And then, finally, once I’m elected, I will act as at the school privatization industry’s puppet, and continue to smear unionized teachers at traditional public schools — my former colleagues at Markham and your current teaching staff included, of course — and vote against them getting health benefits, and fight tooth-and-nail any salary raise, while simultaneously acting as a paid ventriloquist mannequin for the privatizing charter school industry, letting them write LAUSD Board Resolutions that close public schools in favor on non-union, privately-managed charter schools who funded my campaign to the tune of $10 million, resolutions that will grease the process of turning public school campuses over to charter operators, even though those same public schools have existed on those campuses for over a century, and then present those resolutions as my own, when my corporate masters actually wrote them.”
LikeLike
Now, tell us what he Rheely thinks.
LikeLike
Thanks for all of your posts, Jack.
LikeLike
This imagined Principal interview of TFA Corps Member Nick Melvoin is important because every public school principal or public school district official must now or should now know that any (but not every) TFA Corps Member whom they interview to work at their school or district is a potential Nick Melvoin — “a plague bacillus” which that principal or that district official is unwittingly inviting into and letting loose into the “body” of your school or of your school system, and one that could eventually weaken and kill that body.
That “bacillus” analogy includes all the TFA Corps Members’ post-TFA career (SEE TFA’s “Leaders for Educational Equity”, which places former TFA’s in political office, or positions of authority within school districts.), as those two years of mediocre-at-best teaching gives them credibility, as they claim to have worked as “a public school teacher,”
Oh, and don’t forget the billionaire-privatizer-funded, TFA-staffed “Fifth Column” groups such as “Educators for Excellence”, and “Teach Plus,” which bill themselves as “alternatives to traditional teachers unions.” Yeah, right!
By the way, the “plague bacillus” quote comes from Churchill.
Please indulge as I give a little history lesson.
Years after the World War I and after the Soviet takeover of Russia, Churchill wrote about what went on behind the scenes. He described how, at the height of World War I, the German High Command came up with a brilliant idea to get Russia out of German’s two-front war.
They knew of a revolutionary exile named Lenin, then found him and his forlorn followers languishing in Switzerland and struck a deal. They would smuggle this bald bastard and his men behind enemy lines into Russia, riding in a sealed train through Germany, and then through neutral Scandinavia, in exchange for something from Lenin, once he and his minions overthrew the Tsar. (It actually turned out to be the overthrow of Kerensky’s Provisional Government, which took over after the Tsar abdicated.)
As his end of the bargain, Lenin, once in power, would then sue for peace, and Germany could then put the entirety of its war machine on the Western Front against France, England, and (later) the United States.
WINSTON CHURCHILL: “They turned upon Russia the most grisly of all weapons. They transported Lenin in a sealed train, like a plague bacillus, into Russia.”
It worked like a charm. Had the United States not entered the war shortly after this, the Germans would likely have won.
This 9-minute video …
… shows a dramatization of the Kaiser agreeing to this plan “with the greatest reluctance”, as he foresaw that this scheme might eventually backfire on Germany, that the Lenin-led Bolshevik “monster” thus created in Russia would one day conquer Germany, which it did in 1945… well the eastern half of Germany, anyway … which was under Soviet domination from 1945 until the Berlin Wall coming down in 1989.
If you want a REALLY deep dive into this lesser-known chapter in history, check out this lesser-known feature film about “The Sealed Train” that carried Lenin (played by a white-faced Ben Kingsley (!!!), of all people), which was made in Italy by Italians, if you can believe THAT:
LikeLike
worth knowing- thanks
Fred Koch made money off of the Russian people’s misery while Stalin was in power…a footnote in history.
LikeLike
Oh, and as Lenin in the first clip (from the mini-series FALL OF EAGLES) it’s Dr. Xavier from X-MEN, and Captain Picard from STAR TREK … Patrick Stewart.
LikeLike
A large number of the people who supported Nick in the school board election base their knowledge of charter schools on the Palisades Charter Complex consisting of several elementary schools, one middle, and one high school in the Pacific Palisades/Brentwood area. Palisades Charter Complex schools are “Affiliated” charters–which are essentially public schools who obtained permission to choose their own curricula and adminster curriculum funds.http://laschoolreport.com/affiliated-charters-a-successful-model-on-its-way-out/
In the Palisades Charter Complex, if the school is a student’s neighborhood school (under the regular LAUSD model), then a student may attend. Any other available spaces are filled through lottery. Anybody may apply. The elementary school populations are mainly white and affluent, with the middle and high schools being much more diverse. These are the schools that Nick’s constituents think of when they hear the words “Charter School.” Most of these constituents are deaf to any attempts to educate them about the broader issues of charter schools. All they are worried about is making sure that the schools in the Palisades Charter Complex retain their charters, and they take district attempts to regulate the majority of charter schools which are NOT “affiliated” as a direct threat to the Palisades complex. As usual, it’s the HAVES worried that someone will take something from them. , Nick is the “local boy.” He went to the kinds of schools that they send their kids to, goes to the same synagogue, runs in the same circles. They like his parents. All the wrong reasons to vote for someone. His political epitaph will read “And he seemed like such a Nice Boy.”
LikeLike
I’m not sure about the elementary and junior high schools that feed into Palisades, but Pali is certainly NOT an affiliated high school. It was one of the first schools in LAUSD to go independent (once they saw that Granada could negotiate such a bargain).
LikeLike
The elementary schools are definitely affiliated charters. I was assigned as an itinerant district teacher to some of them.
LikeLike
You are correct–Palisades Charter High IS an Independent Charter, but it began Charter status as an Affiliated.
LikeLike
Thank you, as this is incredibly important.
Palisades Charter schools are not like other charters, It’s actually a shame that they even use the name “charter” because that now means something else.
I suspect that almost every teacher here would like what Palisades Charter is because it is a school run by the teachers and (I believe) the parents in the school. It is not the kind of school that most people think of when they think “charter”.
Melvin’s views are actually aligned with the other kind of charters — those run by connected people funded by billionaires who hate public education.
But low-interest voters in Melvoin’s district don’t understand this.
I think if some outside organization tried to open a bunch of “real” charters in the Palisades, Nick would be in real trouble. Because he would have to support a school opening that could compete with the Palisades public charters but pick and choose their students and send back all their unwanted students to Palisades “old style” charters, which have to take and keep every student in their zone and are responsible for their education regardless of whether they find it profitable to teach that student.
LikeLike
Many thanks to Jack for posting additional material above regarding scoundrel Melvoin.
LikeLike
Robert, I just found some more good stuff.
It’s an article that gives a Before & After picture of some of the pre-Melvoin / post-Melvoin changes (i.e. weakening & withering) of charter school oversight at LAUSD, since Melvoin’s pro-charter board took over LAUSD. (The charter folks just lost that majority in May when Jackie Goldberg was elected to take the place of convicted crook Ref Rodriguez, so maybe things will now improve.)
Here’s that gem of an article:
https://citywatchla.com/index.php/2016-01-01-13-17-00/los-angeles/16972-are-lausd-s-charter-schools-really-public-schools
It’s especially apt, as it’s not written by a pro-union, or anti-charter partisan, but by a parent who served both as Treasurer for, and on the Board of a prominent Los Angeles charter school: Los Feliz Charter
School for the Arts.
Thus, perhaps in some folks’ eyes, it may carry with it a little more credibility than a piece written by someone else with a bias.
Written in January during the strike, Tony Butka talks about his involvement during the first years of Los Feliz Charter’s early
years after its founding in 2010, and its gradual — to use Butka’s words — “morphing into a private school using public funds.” That “morphing” led Butka to resign in protest from his two positions with the charter school.
At the beginning, Butka recalls how LAUSD’s Charter Division previously had exerted more rigorous, annual oversight of the budget and operations of the school. Under LAUSD’s earlier version of oversight, his kids’ school’s charter board abided by the Brown Act, which gave public access to the charter school’s meetings, and required public notification and input to major decision-making.
However, as the pro-charter forces — abetted by the California Charter School Association and its lawyers — gained greater influence at LAUSD, all that went out the freakin’ window.
That led to Butka quitting in disgust.
In this article, Butka further claims that in 2017, that on-going de-regulation and weakening of charter school oversight then went into hyperdrive, once the pro-charter majority — which now included CCSA-backed and new Board Members Kelly Gonez and Nick Melvoin — asserted control of LAUSD’s operations.
(Just as Butka was writing this article, however, California’s Attorney General Xavier Becerra resisted the Charter industry’s lobbying, and declared that, yes, charters must follow all the provisions of the Brown Act, and also the Public Records Act, which led to blogger Michael Kohlhaas making charter schools and school privatization one of his primary interests, and Kohlhaas started publishing some of the most outrageous private documents and emails on the charter phenomenon yet seen.)
Post-Melvoin, and with the help of Melvoin’s backers at the California Charter Schools Association (CCSA)— i.e. Melvoin’s chief-of-staff is Sarah Angel, a former higher-up in the CCSA — that annual review of budgets and operations “morphed” into five years, the term to its renewal. In essence, the word went out to charter operators:
“Do whatever the-hell you want during the 5-year term of your charter, and no one will be any the wiser.”
Not a good idea, as that led to sh%*-shows such as the Celerity Charter School fiasco, where the disgraced former CEO Vielka McFarlane is now rotting in jail, after being caught caught and convicted for embezzling $2.5 million. Her Co-CEO Grace Canada also pleaded guilty to being part of this larceny, and will be sentenced in the fall.
Now, in response to this, did the Melvoin-majority LAUSD board close the Celerity schools?
Fat chance.
Instead, the Melvoin-majority Board — with Melvoin as that board’s “Vice President” — allowed them to re-organize, change its name to “ISANA Charter Schools,” and continue its still-unregulated operations. Parents/students being recruited to this crooked organization have no idea of its checkered history, which again, owes its post-scandal existence to the supposedly “Kids First” Melvoin & Co. having its back, and allowing them to continue operations.
LikeLike
Nicky’s story is full of fun facts. A a local Lausd supporter got ahold of Richard Riordan’s ( former privatization friendly L.A. mayor) autobiography in which Riordan takes credit for recruiting Nick at a dinner party at Nick’s parents, to be the plaintiff in the Union busting Vergara trial. Not only is he a tool of the Charter Machine, but he is a dedicated union buster…..all while earnestly promoting himself as some sort of progressive. Talk about entitlement!
LikeLike
Two more things about Nick Melvoin:
1) He was the prime mover of the plan to gut the OIG, the Office of Inspector General, that investigates and uncover charter scandals. “If we don’t discover any charter scandals, why, it’ll be as if they never happened. Awesome!”
Here’s a tweet about that:
https://twitter.com/ResearcherGrace/status/1151660170725847040
2) Also, on the day he was inaugurated as a member of the LAUSD Board, in July 2017, he voted “Yes” on a CCSA-backed motion to more than double (almost triple) his new salary, the salary of an LAUSD Board Member.
Here’s a tweet about that:
(with a link to an L.A. Times article about this)
https://twitter.com/thejoepost/status/1151873565064478720
LikeLike
Holy cow. This is fraud.
LikeLike
This has just gotten to me … so MESSED UP … “that” word ‘charter’ again.
LikeLike
Here’s a great tweet / thread that from Jennifer Berkshire’s Twitter, which begins with an “eye-popping” admission from the charter school industry’s secret meetings, contained within one of the emails docs uncovered and released to the public by Michael Kohlhaas, and discovered by Berkshire:
and also this:
LikeLike