You may hear choice zealots boasting about Jeb Bush’s “Florida Model.” As Tom Ultican explains here, they are delusional or just making stuff up (to put it politely).
Ultican relies on Sue Legg’s excellent report and digs down to show that the motivation behind Jeb’s so-called A+ plan was profits and religion, not education.
Jeb Bush and his friends have made Florida into a low-performing mess that can’t attract or retain teachers. But it has become a magnet for profiteers, grifters, and fundamentalists.
Ultican writes:
When the A+ Program was adopted in 1999, Florida had consistently scored among the bottom third of US states on standardized testing. The following two data sets indicate no improvement and Florida now scoring in the bottom fourth…
Last year, 21 percent of Florida’s students were enrolled in private and charter schools. The Florida tax credit scholarships (FTCS) went to 1,700 private schools and were awarded to over 100,000 students. Most of those students are in religious schools. Splitting public funding between three systems – public, charter and private – has insured mediocrity in all three systems.
Privatization Politics and Profiteering
To understand Florida’s education reform, it is important to realize that its father, Jeb Bush, is the most doctrinal conservative in the Bush family. He fought for six years to keep feeding tubes inserted into Terri Schiavo, a woman in a persistently vegetative state. Jeb was the Governor who signed the nation’s first “Stand Your Ground” self-defense law. During his first unsuccessful run for governor in 1994, Bush ‘“declared himself a ‘head-banging conservative’; vowed to ‘club this government into submission’; and warned that ‘we are transforming our society to a collectivist policy.”’
This is a deeply researched and eye-popping post.
Read it to arm yourself against rightwing propaganda.
The Florida Model is an abject failure.

It’s not just Florida. Jeb Bush has a disastrous track record across the entire country. Here’s what he enthusiastically promoted in Ohio:
http://innovationohio.org/2018/02/09/ecot-survived-until-this-point-because-of-considerable-political-influence-just-look-at-their-graduation-ceremonies/
None of it matters. He’s still the respected leader of ed reform nationally. They simply disappear all the disasters, never to be mentioned again. There’s zero debate or criticism or even discussion of Jeb Bush’s disasters. He is exactly as credible and respected in ed reform as he was at the beginning. He’s still running national education policy, and will I guess until he dies. Arne Duncan took direction from him and so does Betsy DeVos.
The former governor of one US state who was never elected to anything else runs policy for 50 million school children and families, now thru THREE consecutive presidential terms.
LikeLiked by 1 person
Jeb was a graduation speaker for ECOT
LikeLike
essential game plan: they simply disappear all the disasters…
LikeLike
“While battles rage in Wisconsin and Ohio over the collective-bargaining rights of teachers and other public employees, President Obama stood side-by-side Friday in South Florida at an education-themed event with former Gov. Jeb Bush, the man that many teachers in this state blame for threatening their jobs.”
I have a high school student. His entire time in school the former governor of Florida has directed public education. I can’t work to beat Jeb Bush in an election and get someone new, because Jeb Bush wasn’t elected to this position. Instead he just captured every single politician in power, Republican and Democrat, for decades now.
My grandchildren will be stuck with him, and there’s not a thing they or their parents can do about it. Whatever crackpot idea Jeb Bush comes up with, that’s what they get, because his cheering section fans out across the country and rams it through.
LikeLike
KA-CHING for the oligarchs.
I think all the deformers need to take those ridiculous tests.
And…I’d love to Common GORE Jeb.
LikeLike
Reblogged this on Crazy Normal – the Classroom Exposé and commented:
Arm yourself against rightwing propaganda.
LikeLike
Bush has had far too much influence on education in the state. He has imposed his failed plans on public schools for years. He is a shameless profiteer that trades on his family name.
LikeLike
Well, we wuz worried, there for a while, that Bob’s Real Good Florida School was gonna have to close afore the semester was out cause we done run through our funding, what with cost of the school huntin’ trip to Alaska with Governur Palin an all. (Its them sort of inovative curriculums that youve come to expect from Bob’s!) But the power of prayer is great, and we jist recieved a Innovative Schools Grant that’ll git us through to the end of the year.
Now, maybee youve not yet become part of the Bob’s Real Good Florida School family. An you may think its to late in the year to inroll your chyld. Well, today is yore lucky day, cause its not. You can still spend your Florida K-12 Academic Scholarship with us. No restricshuns! And even if yore chyld’s grades aint what they oughter be, we can give credit for life experiance and hep ’em out afore the end uh the school yeer. Some uh y’all have been asking, Well, Bob, that’s all dandy, but what state letter grade has Bob’s Real Good Florida School been gittin? Well, that’s party of the beauty of it. Bein a privut school using public funds, we aren’t graded like the govermint schools are. Thank you to all those legislaters who put the “tally” in Tallahassee.
Here at Bob’s, we make are own rules based on gospel truth. So bring your little scholur down to Bob’s, in back of the old K-Mart, and inroll him or her lickety split. We got English, the only official language of the sovereign state of Florida; sciance, all about Cain and Abel and the Dinosaurs and such; and so much more. MAGA!
LikeLiked by 1 person
Is our children learning???
LikeLike
ROFLMAO! They is, and at Bob’s, they’s safe, to, cause all are teachers is locked and loaded!
LikeLiked by 1 person
Oh, an I almost forgot. A great big thank you to all the parunts who heped proofread that marketing message above!
LikeLiked by 1 person
add that to the one which goes something like, Teach a child to read and he or her can pass a literacy test…
LikeLike
All this is true.
But public schools are hurting themselves by adopting –with alacrity –crap curriculum and discredited methodologies like constructivism. This is a preventable self-inflicted wound. One reason we’re so vulnerable to attack by Jeb Bush and his creepy friends is that the majority of us educators keep peddling crap that dismays kids and their parents. You may bristle at these words, but I invite you to shadow a student at a typical K-8 school today. Please, sit through every stinking class, from 8 am to 3 pm, if you can stomach it. You will find confusing lessons, tedium, a dearth of learnable content, hopelessness. Yes, the testing that’s been imposed on us is a big factor in why we have this crap curriculum, but most teachers lack the intellectual wherewithal to critique it. It looks OK to them. They defend it. Diane rightly worries about the deprofessionalization of teaching. It’s already been deprofessionalized. 99% of us lack independent judgment. We go with the flow, even if it’s awful. We are blind to its awfulness. We trust our anything that’s been published. If it’s published, it must be quality (so much for the critical thinking we say we value and teach!. Again I blame the education schools that brainwashed us with their half-baked, ideologically-based (instead of empirically based) pet theories instead of making us free thinking intellectuals with a solid foundation of professional knowledge. Few teachers can think outside the box. We teachers ourselves are the victims of a bad education.
Or so it seems to me.
LikeLike
Working in the textbook publishing industry, Ponderosa, for part of this period of Ed Deform, I saw this first-hand–the breathtaking distortion and narrowing of the curriculum to accord with the Gates/Coleman bullet lists and to turn it into test prep. It’s sickening and sad. There’s a terrible irony to the fact that the material peripheral to the Common [sic] Core [sic] State [sic] Standards [sic] calls for teachers to use complex, foundational texts when the ELA “standards” themselves are simply lists of vague, abstract, content-free “skills” based on the lowest common denominator Educratic groupthink of previously existing state “standards.” Since that’s all that will be tested, that’s all that’s taught. In the new batch of Cored curricula, content and coherence are out the window, and many of my friends in educational publishing have been quitting or changing careers rather than continue to be part of it. There are some few brave English teachers who do lip service to the data walls and data chats and the puerile Gates/Coleman bullet list and continue, as best they can, to ignore the new curricula and to teach English. But this is getting harder and harder to do, and many of the young teachers don’t remember a time, pre Deform, when curricula and pedagogy in ELA actually made sense.
LikeLike
And meanwhile in New Jersey … this just came out today in the latest Economist magazine. Someone knowledgeable about the situation there might want to send a response to their editor?!??
https://www.economist.com/united-states/2019/05/16/cory-booker-helped-turn-round-newarks-schools
LikeLike
The Economist is pretty conservative and is all-in for charters. We use the magazine for debate, and it’s great for international news, but for some issues, education in particular, it’s very privitization-favorable.
LikeLike
Bush declared himself a head-banging conservative.”
I think Dubbya banged Jeb’s head a few too many times when Jeb was young.
The whole family are nutcases.
LikeLike
But, ofc, his “Mission Accomplished,” W can now spend his days painting puppies. Trump, for all his issues, at least has not (yet) taken us into another major war, to no purpose, costing trillions of dollars and hundreds of thousands of lives.
LikeLike
It’s interesting what conveniently short memories Repugnicans have. They were all in on that war. Now that their guy, IQ45, says that he opposed it, they all admit that it was a horrible, tragic, disastrous mistake.
LikeLike
Trump is getting ready for war with Iran. He said he will send 100,000 troops to the Middle East. Can anyone explain why?
LikeLike
Who knows. Maybe Putin and Trump talked, during their recent phone call, about more news that they expect to break about the Trump-Russia connection, as the House delves into the murk of Trump’s finances prior to the 2020 election. One way to deflect criticism there would be to engineer a high-profile international squabble between Trump and Putin over Iran, one that they could then step in and negotiate, thus pulling the world back from the brink of major international conflict and giving both men a Hollywood-style hero statesman makeover. In other words, a “Wag the Tongue” scenario. But hey, I write fiction these days, so my imagination might be a little hyperactive.
LikeLike
Well over a hundred thousand people (that’s the minimum from IBC, but some researchers like those at John’s Hopkins estimate over a million) would still be alive in Iraq if Dubya had pursued a career in puppy painting instead of politics.
LikeLiked by 1 person
Yeah, I said “hundreds of thousands.” The numbers are unclear.
LikeLike
And they depend on whether you count only battlefield casualties or the incidental casualties in the civilian population from a) disruption of medical supplies and hospitals and food and b) poisoning of the environment, with significant long-term effects
LikeLike