Rhode Island released the results of tests given last spring, 8 months ago. What’s with the testing company? The Trusty Turtle Testing Corporation, results reported in less than a year!).
One of the lowest performing districts in the state is Central Falls, the impoverished district where everyone was fired in 2010 to “reform” the schools (then the firing was withdrawn, but almost every adult in the school was gone within two years, because [as “reformers” insist] low scores are caused by “bad teachers”).
So why no improvement?
Remember Central Falls, the smallest and poorest district in the state?
The harsh treatment of the entire staff of the high school in 2010 received national attention. It was one of the first blows of the corporate reform movement. Those who led the campaign threatened to fire the entire staff—the teachers, lunch room ladies, and everyone else. The leaders were treated as heroes by Arne Duncan and President Obama. Zero tolerance for staff!
Now, eight years later, apparently less than 10% of the students are “meeting or exceeding expectations,” whatever that means.
The Superintendent of Central Falls called an emergency meeting to apologize to the community.
A daily reader of this blog who retired as a teacher in Providence sent me this article and commented:
“I remember the days when Gallo and Gist fired the good teachers of Central Falls. I remember the days when Obama applauded them for doing what they did and said he agreed with them being fired. I also remember Weingarten did nothing at the time-she never even showed up back then.
“The current test scores at Central Falls High School lower than when the entire faculty was fired in early 2010–for low test scores– with the blessing of Ana Cano Morales (still the President of Central Falls School Board), James Diossa (the current mayor, who was taught by the teachers whose firing he endorsed), Frances Gallo (“reform” superintendent), Deborah Gist (“reform” education commissioner), Arne Duncan (US Secretary of Education), and President Obama (who sang the accolades of Frances Gallo, quipping “…that something had to be done!”).
Victor Capellan, the current superintendent, has been part of their “reform” and their new “accountability” ever since.
“So much for “reform” and “accountability” after many talented and dedicated teachers were wounded and blacklisted. For what? What was done to those teachers (90 percent of whom left the school they loved within 2 years of the eventual ” settlement”) should haunt those who tortured them by treating them so unjustly.
“But none of that is in this article so readers will think this reporter is giving the true picture. Any suggestions?”
Back to my comment.
Try reading the rankings. They are confusing, if you look at them here. I would like to see them correlated with family income and proportions of students with disabilities and ELLs. But that is not what the State Education Department released.
Ken Wagner is the State Commissioner of Education. He came from New York state, where NAEP performance has been flat for 20 years. Maybe he and the legislature and the Fovernor should be held accountable for failing to fund the schoolsof Central Falls and the rest of the state.

Diane, as you noted at the time of that phony “school turnaround” massacre in 2010 when Obama praised the “success” of the charter Met School to the “failure” of Central Falls, in spite of the fact that Met School had lower NECAP scores: “it appears that the school with lower graduation standards rates higher in President Obama’s eyes.” And there’s no wonder why Obama prefers charter schools because you have also documented Obama’s strong ties to charter-pusher Democrats for Education Reform, whose stated purpose is “to break the teacher unions’ stranglehold over the Democratic Party.” And, as you have reported, now the incoming Democratic Party majority in the House of Representatives has selected DFER darling Hakeem Jeffries as Democratic House Caucus Chair. The Democrats’ pro-charter pattern since 2010 is clear: Top members of the Democratic Party don’t like public school teachers, their unions, and public schools in general and are no different than Republicans in that regard. So, more of the same kind of “education reform” can be expected to continue.
LikeLike
I CANNOT support the DFERS. They have caused so much harm.
LikeLike
These criminals are seldom held accountable, but these criminals always blame innocent teachers and punish them.
LikeLike
Yup!
LikeLike
We need to rethink how we assess children’s learning. These tests are probably inappropriate and lousy. Yes poverty, ELL. status, disabilities play a role. But I worked with this population my entire career. These children are bright, verbal and learn in a variety of different ways. Stop all this high stakes testing and definitely stop blaming teachers.
LikeLike
Yup!!
LikeLike
The mayor called the test scores a “public health emergency” and the superintendent called for “accountability” and drastic [draconian] changes. Sounds like they’re planning to fire everyone again, based on the usual test score believing, nation at risk, national security emergency, no child left behind because every student succeeds in a data driven race to the top with choices, blah blah blabbering blabbity blah blah blah. Test scores measure nothing except perhaps income level. It was true in 2010 and it is true in 2018. The mayor and the superintendent should know that, but they don’t, so they will not stop the churn and burn, constantly churning the lives and stomachs of teachers and students, periodically burning down the schoolhouse. Not smart. But then, that’s what happens when control of your local school gets captured by outsiders.
LikeLike
The mayor and superintendent are the REAL public health emergencies.
LikeLike
These walking, talking viral plagues are not the only ones that are in need of emergency medical lobotomies.
If we started the list with Donald Trump, we’d still be adding names a week from now working ten hours a day.
LikeLike
Is there a computer strong enough to generate such a long list? It might need trans-Atlantic cables to transmit enough electricity for the computer to endure.
LikeLike
& add to those 2 Gov.Gina Raimondo…an honest-to-G-d, real DINO.
(Wasn’t there some past trouble {way before, however, she was elected Guv} w/the SEC & some investments?)
Please, someone, enlighten us.
LikeLike
Let’s PLEASE not forget how Duncan and Obama flew to this district to give a public speech about how right the BOE was in firing everyone. More than 50% of the teachers were rehired about a year later even though they were deemed to be ineffective in the initial firing. I guess Obama could not make up his mind . . . Or maybe he was politicizing it for his own gain.
G.W. Bush Jr. hated public education, but he was a pussycat relative to Obama. Either way, both presidents were enemies of true learning and teaching.
And BTW, isn’t it grand that Michelle Obama should come out with her new mantra, “Oh, I’m just a regular girl. I’m just like any other woman in daily, ordinary life in this country. I’ve had my ups and downs. Believe me; it’s not easy!”
Yes, she is just like all of the struggling women who work every day to make ends meet, except that she and her husband are enjoying book advances worth tens of millions of dollars, and they have both worked very diligently to shutter and privatize as many schools in Chicago as they could get their claws and fangs on.
Struggle is so easy to be shard with the masses when you’re worth big bucks.
Ladies, don’t you see yourself in Michelle? Meet me at the yacht club and let me know . . . .
LikeLike
Well-said.
LikeLike
Oh, & Wikipedia describes Gov. Raimondo as “American politician & venture capitalist.”
She was formerly the State Treasurer. During which time, I might add, she travelled to other states (ILL-Annoy, for one), giving the powers that be ideas about how to stifle state pensions.
Speaking lies to power, as it were…
LikeLike
Governor Gina Raimondo is firmly in the Reformer camp. Her husband Andy Moffitt roomed with Corey Booker at Yale Law School, then went on to McKinsey, where he led education reform (aka privatization) efforts. She is a DFER favorite but doesn’t need the money the hedge funders raise.
LikeLike
There is always more money to incarcerate criminals and never enough money to provide the kind of education and support children need to stay out of jail…. and always a way to shift the blame for the struggles of poor children to classroom teachers who work hard in dire conditions but never a way to find funds to help improve those conditions. Welcome to the plutocracy where more money raised by higher tax rates on the most affluent among us is NEVER the solution.
LikeLike
The reformers will never blame poverty, Never. If they do, they will have to do something about it.
LikeLike
Well, if the corporate drones/minions had to do something about poverty, the corrupt corporate reformers of everything honest and public would probably resort to the Soylent Green Solution where there will always be the poorest 10-percent of the population to scoop up and turn into food pellets. They’d make a profit from that too.
LikeLike
Time for a third party? Time for more than three.
LikeLike
“He came from New York state, where NAEP performance has been flat for 20 years.”
So?!
The spector of NAEP scores raises it’s ugly head again. NAEP suffers all the same errors and falsehoods, and psychometric errors that render the usage of any of the results for anything COMPLETELY INVALID.
OH, but NAEP is a kinder, gentler standardized test. . .
. . . not!
Perhaps it is kinder and gentler. . .
. . . Would you like some arsenic in your tea, madam?
LikeLike
Oh, I am so tech deficient at posting links, but went back & found these:
From Providence Journal: “Pension Allegations Against R.I. Gov. Raimondo Have Nine Lives” (4/29/17) & “SEC Names Raimondo in Pay-to-Play Scheme with Investment Firm Oaktree” (7/12/18) & “Raimondo’s Ties to Hedge Funds & Private Equity,” among a raft of other articles.
So–how is she still in office?!
I’ll say this for ILL-Annoy: at least our governors get tried & sentenced!
LikeLike
And yet the unions still supported Obama and raimondo….you get what you pay for
LikeLike