Noliwe Rooks published an article in the New York Times about the lessons that Mississippi Senator Cindy Hyde-Smith Teachers is about schools, segregation, our past and our present. The Senator gained a certain notoriety by joking about “a public hanging,” which in Mississippi means a lynching. Sadly, her open racism did not prevent her re-election.
Professor Rooks is a historian. She understands that the past is always with us.
She writes:
Racist violence, segregation and voter suppression are not shared historical jokes. They are our present. Unless we change course, they will define our future. Ms. Hyde-Smith claims not to have realized there was anything wrong with what she said. She has steadfastly refused to apologize. Perhaps most important, since her comments came to light, she has yet to publicly engage in conversation with constituents of hers for whom hanging is not a joke and voting is a hard-fought, continually challenged right. During the campaign, she did not acknowledge there was even a dialogue worth having. Perhaps this is because for much of her life she has been hearing only one side of an argument and doesn’t know or care that there is a larger conversation to be had. If this is the case, it may have something to do with where Ms. Hyde-Smith went to school and where she chose to send her daughter to school.
It was only a few days ago that we learned not only that Ms. Hyde-Smith had attended and graduated from a now closed, whites-only segregation academy called the Lawrence County Academy but also that she had chosen to send her daughter to Brookhaven Academy, which shared the same founding history. And as late as 2016, it had managed to maintain a strikingly white racial makeup, with one black child and five Latino children attending a school with 386 pupils in a town that is 54 percent black.
The most notable thing about the South’s segregation academies isn’t that they were racially segregated. Racially and economically segregated schools remain across all parts of the United States. What is notable is that taxpayer dollars financed these all-white schools at the cost of simultaneously creating poorly funded all-black public-school systems in the South. To put it simply, as the financial drain of taxpayer dollars from whites attending segregation academies decimated school systems educating black children, black communities, students and teachers paid a terribly high price to ensure that whites were educated with other whites.
Sometimes referred to as “freedom of choice schools,” segregation academies were a private school concept adopted in Mississippi and found across the South in the decade following the Brown v. Board of Education decision. They were conceived as a way to permit white parents to avoid sending their children to schools with black students and a legal way to work around the Brown decision, which did not apply to private schools. Throughout the 1960s and ’70s they flourished in large part because Southern state legislatures allowed white parents to use taxpayer dollars to finance their children’s education. The schools that Senator Hyde-Smith and her daughter attended were both founded in 1970. That was the first year that Mississippi public schools were forced to integrate statewide and not just take token measures.
Segregation academies were privately owned and run but largely financed by tax dollars, at least initially. As happened in other Southern states in the decades following the Brown decision, lawmakers in Mississippi authorized the use of vouchers to allow parents to pay for a percentage of the tuition at these schools. The practice was found unconstitutional in 1970 and, once various appeals were exhausted, banned in 1971. Up until that point, this money allowed white parents to receive up to $240 dollars per year. In Mississippi, depending on the school and the tuition charged there, that amount covered between 50 percent and 90 percent of the total tuition cost. By 1969, of the 49 schools receiving state-provided tuition vouchers in Mississippi, 48 were white-only segregation academies.
Professor Rooks makes the important point that segregation is pervasive. She reminds us that the segregation academies were the first examples of “school choice.”
Despite lots of winking, every one in the South is well aware why school choice was created. Nothing has changed.
For the first time in memory, we have a Secretary of Education and an administration prepared to abandon even a pretense of supporting school integration.
And Mississippi has a Senator who is a true believer in the Confederacy.
Segregation and school choice go together like a horse and carriage.
Noliwe Rooks (@nrookie) is the director of American studies at Cornell and the author, most recently, of “Cutting School: Privatization, Segregation, and the End of Public Education.”

“Racially and economically segregated schools remain across all parts of the United States. What is notable is that taxpayer dollars financed these all-white schools at the cost of simultaneously creating poorly funded all-black public-school systems in the South.”
Yes. Thanks for this post and to Professor Noliwe Rooks for this god-awful reminder of the borderless connection of the past and to the present…with only a “minor” difference between actual lynching and verbal approval of that practice from a newly elected official.
Betsy Devos is leading the charge for segregated schools and with the blessing of too many of citizens who, like her, claim to be Christians doing God’s will…likely with a mental image of the blue eyed, blond hair version of Jesus, a pious face looking upward, hands together in prayer.
The Old South is rising again.
LikeLike
Similar to Trump’s pick, Hyde-Smith (the candidate of racists) who teaches us about segregation, his Labor Secretary teaches us about U.S. justice. Recently, a woman convicted of voter fraud, received an 8 year sentence. Contrast that with the deal that Acosta, the Labor Secretary in line for Attorney General, gave a billionaire hedge funder, Jeffrey Epstein (represented by Dershowitz). Epstein, who Trump described as a good guy that he liked to hang out with, received a 13 month sentence as punishment for serial sex abuse (the case involved more than 30 accusers, allegedly including girls as young as 12). The Acosta deal allowed Epstein to leave his jail six days a week to work in his office. (One of Epstein’s accusers said her involvement with him began when she was working at Mar a Lago.)
LikeLike
What people like Senator Hyde-Smith and Donald Trump are telling us is that isolation breeds contempt. “Choice” is a system through which racism can be underwritten by public funds. Privatization often targets minority communities, and options for schools available to minority students.often result in creating more segregation. As Dr. Terry-Long pointed out not all choice is equal. Choice often results in segregation and separate and unequal treatment.
After reflecting on Dr. Zhao’s address, I think our country is losing is way by becoming more exclusionary whether by testing or race. As he pointed out, America should be proud of its place in the middle of the pack in international tests because our diversity is our strength. If tests scores were the main determiner of success, the United States would be a failed country. Our country is known for innovation and technology. We have numerous Nobel Prize winners and patents. Our inclusionary public schools have contributed to this success. We need to continue to serve our people a solid education as the the next big idea may come from someone other than a member of the 1%. “Reformer” Pondiscio kept repeating the stale reformer meme, “A student should not be limited by his zip code.” We should answer that public schools in all zip codes should offer a quality education.” The solution is not separate and unequal treatment, but access to opportunity for all in an integrated society.
LikeLike
The curious aspect of the Reformer claim that “our schools are failing” is that they are really saying “our nation is failing.” 90% of the American people were educated in public schools. These are the people who made our country the leader in technology, culture, economy, and the military. We are a great world power. The area where we lag is equity. We have far too much poverty. The public schools did not create poverty. Our tax code—written to exacerbate inequality—produces what it was designed to produce: inequality, the super-rich, desperate poverty, and a shrinking middle class.
LikeLiked by 1 person
Pasi Sahlberg said, “America does not have an education problem. It has a poverty problem.” Sadly, current policies are making it worse.
LikeLike
and the more our schools are invaded and our chidlren’s curricula dangerously narrowed, the more testing results are made the goal over entrepreneurial, creative thinking — the more those who would rule can manipulate the tax codes and strategically degrade commonwealth legislation. Hmmm, sounds just like a plan which led us directly to 2018.
LikeLike
Jim Crow is well and alive. SO SAD. It’s obvious that the DEFORMERS like JIM CROW Laws.
LikeLike
“Despite lots of winking, every one in the South is well aware why school choice was created. Nothing has changed.”
It is unfortunate, but a lot has changed. The chief change in the south has been the addition of millions of people who moved here from the rust belt since 1980. Many of these folks are friends of mine, but they are a new type of southern voting citizen. They combined with southerners who had been handed their guilt in print for three generations to form what now manifests itself as Donald Trump by a 60 to 40 margin.
Is new southern voter moved here because taxes were too high in the older industrial parts of the country. They feel no guilt for slavery. In their minds, they inherited the birthright of correctness from their grandfathers who fought slavery. They will vote their pocketbook every time. They want all the services they took for granted elsewhere with none of the taxes. Taxes are a result of “government waste” to these people, who join generations of people who have prejudices so deep seeded that they do not even know they are there. Many of the new southern voters find common cause with the old population in the new racism that has arisen over the issue of immigration.
This latter phenomenon supports the idea that it was not so much slavery that produced racism, but racism that produced the acceptance of slavery and other forms of exploitation during the period of imperialism. As Laura pointed out with such linguistic perfection above, there is no border between historical periods. Would that there were. Maybe we could build a border wall.
A border wall with the past looks like great public education. Education walls off the errors that plagued us in our past with knowledge of that past. It points us to a future without prejudice and hostility to those different from us. But it is, like another border wall I hear about, very expensive. Southerners have historically been adverse to that expense. Philander Priestly Claxton, first secretary of education under William Howard Taft (it was not a cabinet position then), found it necessary when he was in positions of advocacy of education in Tennessee to go about the state holding education revival meetings. It was a hard sell. It is still a hard sell today. Claxton was educated in a one roomed school called Turrentine Academy, which was reported to have been burned twice during the 1890s.
Many of he changes that have swept over my south have been for the better. People do not live in chicken houses anymore. Rural poverty is not as grinding as it once was. Children who are poor are not easily identifiable by the wood smoke smell and body odor I recall in my youth. But it is still here in ways harder to recognize. There is want and desperation, and it feeds a narrative that those in want could work their way out of it if they just tried. As yet, it has not fed the narrative that a great education might go a long way toward solving our problems.
LikeLike
Roy,
You might add that there are Southerners like Hyde-Smith, some elite like her, some poor and working class, who never got past the old style racism of just hating black people.
LikeLike
Hyde-Smith’s victory is all the more weird since more than 1 in 3 people in MS is black.
LikeLike
One in three is not enough to win an election
LikeLike
In theory, it could be enough: the exact percentage is 37%, and the voter turnout in November was at most 50% in MS.
LikeLike