Jamal Khashoggi entered the Saudi consulate in Turkey and never came out.
A note from Karen Attiah, Global Opinions editor
I received this column from Jamal Khashoggi’s translator and assistant the day after Jamal was reported missing in Istanbul. The Post held off publishing it because we hoped Jamal would come back to us so that he and I could edit it together. Now I have to accept: That is not going to happen. This is the last piece of his I will edit for The Post. This column perfectly captures his commitment and passion for freedom in the Arab world. A freedom he apparently gave his life for. I will be forever grateful he chose The Post as his final journalistic home one year ago and gave us the chance to work together.
The last Column:
I was recently online looking at the 2018 “Freedom in the World” report published by Freedom House and came to a grave realization. There is only one country in the Arab world that has been classified as “free.” That nation is Tunisia. Jordan, Morocco and Kuwait come second, with a classification of “partly free.” The rest of the countries in the Arab world are classified as “not free.”
As a result, Arabs living in these countries are either uninformed or misinformed. They are unable to adequately address, much less publicly discuss, matters that affect the region and their day-to-day lives. A state-run narrative dominates the public psyche, and while many do not believe it, a large majority of the population falls victim to this false narrative. Sadly, this situation is unlikely to change.
The Arab world was ripe with hope during the spring of 2011. Journalists, academics and the general population were brimming with expectations of a bright and free Arab society within their respective countries. They expected to be emancipated from the hegemony of their governments and the consistent interventions and censorship of information. These expectations were quickly shattered; these societies either fell back to the old status quo or faced even harsher conditions than before.
My dear friend, the prominent Saudi writer Saleh al-Shehi, wrote one of the most famous columns ever published in the Saudi press. He unfortunately is now serving an unwarranted five-year prison sentence for supposed comments contrary to the Saudi establishment. The Egyptian government’s seizure of the entire print run of a newspaper, al-Masry al Youm, did not enrage or provoke a reaction from colleagues. These actions no longer carry the consequence of a backlash from the international community. Instead, these actions may trigger condemnation quickly followed by silence.

“Instead, these actions may trigger condemnation quickly followed by silence.”
LikeLike
Horrifying.
I remember reading a Tom Friedman column (departing from my normal practice) shortly after MBS’s ascension. It was a hymn to the genius and foresight of MBS and his efforts to root corruption out of the Saudi economy by . . . imprisoning Saudi royals in a luxury hotel and threatening them until they signed away 95% of their assets. Friedman saw nothing even remotely worrying about the situation. He still seems to be on the fence about MBS (judging from the headlines to his columns, which I will not read).
LikeLike
. . . a massive clash and catalytic turning point in the history of Western civilization. It’s as if we’ve been putting freedom off for centuries; and now it’s finally come to the surface of world history, through a journalist’s death: Jamal Khashoggi threw down the gauntlet of freedom at the feet of not only the moral vacuity of tribalism and its old-style kingship, but its post-modern metamorphosis: fascism.
They probably cut off his fingers because he wrote with them. And if our own president, D. Trump, didn’t give the direct go-ahead behind the scenes, he did so indirectly by just the way he is, in particular, with the Press. CBK
LikeLike
If course trump is complicit and thereby our government. We knew the Saudis were after him and we didn’t even alert him. We let him walk into that embassy knowing that he possibly could be kidnapped back to Saudi Arabia. Instead he was killed. He probably refused to go. Does it hang uncomfortably on our heads, yes. This could be done to any journalist and it’s meant to send a message. Is that how we handle dissent, torture and kill it?
LikeLike
If we aren’t active and aware, this is the direction we are headed. A country with a population, under duress, mindless following the doublespeak of supposed leaders. Freedom is what we say it is, lies are alternate facts, enslavement is freedom. That’s why we must support the bluetsunami2018.
LikeLike
Your are right, Paula.
LikeLike
Yes. Unfortunately our anti-knowledge schools are paving the way for more anti-truth presidents like Trump. Teachers: ask yourselves this question –are we really arming our students to see through lies? Are we giving them the foundation of knowledge needed to understand government and policy issues? We glibly proclaim that we’re making critical thinkers, but is a skeptical stance really enough? Flat earthers are skeptics. Climate deniers are skeptics. Those who dismiss Hitler comparisons are skeptics. Our citizens will be unable to interpret the phrase “enemy of the people” if they have no idea of the context of such a remark; if they have not been schooled on fascist movements. This is but one example of the background knowledge we must give kids. Anti-fact ideology in education schools may be dooming this country. We’re unwittingly doing the work Trump wants us to do: squandering the opportunity to robustly inform students.
LikeLike
I so agree, Ponderosa. HISTORY is the content our curriculum needs most now. “Civics” is fast becoming irrelevant. The mechanics of voting for representatives, representatives passing a bill — the checks and balances of tripartite democracy– needs to be taught in a historical & economic context, for history, propelled by economics, can show us how civic democracy is currently being undermined. And show us where it’s happened before, & the consequences…
LikeLike
Glad you agree, bethree5. Jefferson said we must “inform” the masses if we were to keep this republic afloat. INFORM. Not sharpen critical thinking skills. Provide INFORMATION –because that and that alone is what empowers our in-born thinking skills. Yet doing something as humble as this is treated as laughably primitive by the pompous frauds in our education schools, who clearly think they’re smarter than Thomas Jefferson. No, they tell us, we must shift to teaching 21st Century skills. We mustn’t teach history or science facts; we must teach kids to be historical or scientific thinkers. Forget about facts; teach literacy skills so that once they graduate they’ll be able to pick up information from texts on an as-needed basis. Just-in-time delivery of facts, like in our revered American corporations. Yeah, right. As if, after graduation –between work and raising kids — your average Joe or Jane is going to start reading tomes on world history so as to interpret political events correctly! Building a foundation of knowledge takes a long time. If it doesn’t get done in K-12 years, it’s not going to get done. Our schools fecklessly leave our citizens’ minds prey to crafty Russian propaganda and Trump’s noxious, democracy-destroying lies.
LikeLike
Walter Cronkite’s wisdom is something that is needed today.
……………………….
We are on the precipice of being so ignorant that our democracy is threatened.
Walter Cronkite
I am dumbfounded that there hasn’t been a crackdown with the libel and slander laws on some of these would-be writers and reporters on the Internet.
Walter Cronkite
Not only do we have a right to know, we have a duty to know what our Government is doing in our name.
Walter Cronkite
Success is more permanent when you achieve it without destroying your principles.
Walter Cronkite
It is not the reporter’s job to be a patriot or to presume to determine where patriotism lies. His job is to relate the facts.
Walter Cronkite
We’ve always known you can gain circulation or viewers by cheapening the product, and now you’re finding the bad driving out the good.
Walter Cronkite
Ethics must be reintroduced to public service to restore people’s faith in government. Without such faith, democracy cannot flourish. Your ambitious agenda is filling a desperate need.
Walter Cronkite
LikeLike
If we’re not teaching knowledge, we’re teaching ignorance.
Great quotes, Carol.
LikeLike
Trump is the face of an impotent, ugly America.
While Trump has been President, his banker, the head of the Russian state, acted as if he was immune from consequences in killing private citizens in England, a nation that is a friend to America. While Trump has been President, his patron, the head of Saudi Arabia, has acted as if he is immune from consequences in killing a journalist, in Turkey, America’s ally. While Trump has been President, grifting became the norm for his cabinet. While Trump has been President (and before), his Party in the House and Senate trampled democracy, including suppression of the vote. While Trump has been President, his appointees in departments and bureaus like Education and Interior and the FCC, gave American oligarchs free reign to take assets owned by the American people. While Trump has been President, he courted and cheered divisions based on race, sex, and religion. His wealthy Australian crony, Rupert Murdoch, fanned those flames.
Abandoning civility is the minimal response required of Democracy’s “mob”.
LikeLike
Exactly. Trump’s pal Vlad has been killing journalists for many years now.
Riddle me, riddle me, riddle me this . . .
Who am I?
I am. . . .
From New York
In the construction/building trades
Launder money for mobsters
Evade taxes
Do lots and lots and lots of big cash deals
Brag constantly about my wealth and my genius
Have the “best” of everything
Keep my tax returns and sources of income very, very secret
Have a violent temper
Have a thing for junk food
Demand loyalty oaths from subordinates, and if they
don’t deliver, get rid of them
Thrive on obsequiousness from those around me
Am constantly paranoid about betrayal
Constantly ridicule others
Constantly make up belittling nicknames and think that this is extraordinarily funny
Gesticulate a lot
Have two expressions: 1. utter rage and 2. smirk
Am casually and profoundly racist
Am extraordinarily narcissistic
Have a comb-over
Wear expensive, dapper suits
Am a serial abuser of women
Mangle the language
Am a blowhard
Cannot utter a sustained, coherent thought
Conduct business out of my “club”
Constantly complain about “fake news”
Encourage attacks on journalists
Constantly praise strongmen
Am surrounded by dirty lawyers
Am subject to lots of investigations that don’t stick
Brag about how they will never catch up to me
Figured it out yet?
Gotti. John Gotti.
LikeLike
Independents journalists are an endangered species in Putin’s Russia. Many have been murdered.
LikeLiked by 1 person
Bob,
You provide a succinct, inclusive and accurate portrait of
Trump. Thanks. The piece should be posted on office walls throughout the country with the universal “don’t” sign attached.
LikeLike
Thank you, Bob. Well done.
LikeLike
I’m really not understanding why this is all about Trump. U.S. presidents have been strongly allied with the Saudis for decades now and we’ve turned a blind eye to Saudi atrocities, including the fact that 15 of the 19 hijackers that killed nearly 3,000 people were Saudis. The Saudis have been bombing the snot out of Yemen for many years now (since at least the Obama years) creating one of the worst humanitarian crises in history, yet Obama said nothing. Many, many other dissidents have disappeared and likely murdered over the years, all without a peep from the U.S.
But now that a WaPo journalist has disappeared and is likely murdered, now we’re supposed to be outraged at Trump for not saying anything? I mean, if this is what it takes to get people outraged about Saudi Arabia, then better late than never, I suppose, but once again let’s not pretend that time started in January 2017.
LikeLike
The Saudi/911 connection not a simple one. But the US is MORE, not less, complicit. Osama bin Laden was from a favored family that did big construction projects for the Saudi government and became radicalized by reading an Egyptian named Sayyid Qutb, who had lived in America and wrote books about how Western culture was going to overrun Islam (women singing on television, oh my) and called for jihad to stop it. The US recruited such radical Islamists for its war against the Russians in Afghanistan. Reagan’s “freedom fighters” there were the Taliban. Osama became famous throughout the Middle East after he and a few pals used American stinger missiles to stop a convoy of Russian tanks during that war. Like Saddam Hussein, he was our creature. We created him.
LikeLike
Agree, Bob.
LikeLike
“We created him.” There is truth in that. I have been thinking on this theme, observing how those who hurl epithets at public schooling think of govt & public institutions as “other,” when in fact the status of our govt & our public institutions precisely reflects the values we hold, as reflected in the values advertised by those we have elected over recent decades & what they have wrought.
[Tho many convinced to vote for conservatives since ’80’s believed their socially-conservative values would gain stature, they were hoodwinked by political vultures whose only interest was in robbing the public Peter to pay the corporate Paul on the run from global competition… & now those voters feel the pinch: “Other” is how one views a govt in which one feels one no longer has a voice.]
For confirmation, we can look at a bigger picture: the geography of our country & those that border us to the south, where we find our wealthy nation ringed by a chaos of poverty & violence, bulging against our border w/immigrants seeking any kind of work & refugees seeking asylum from gang warfare… In large part, the consequence of a century of rapacious US foreign policy… How we, w/in our borders, resemble that larger geography! Every center of wealth is bordered by vast urban & rural poor/ violent slums… That we have a “national opioid epidemic” is symptomatic of the hopelessness bred by increasingly non-representative govt indifferent to the public good– reflected in drug gang warfare stretching from Texas to Panama.
LikeLiked by 1 person
Excellent points, all! Our drug laws have created the black market in drugs. They are the reason why the drug cartels exist. OUR CREATION. Do what Portugal did and decriminalize drugs, create needle programs, identify and treat addicts instead of criminalizing them, and that part of the problem would pretty much go away as it did in Portugal.
LikeLike
Thank you…a word of reason.
We cannot change the culture and morals of the Middle to coincide with ours. Saudi Arabia is an extremely dangerous part of the world where women are less than second class and Christians are persecuted and Sharia law is paramount. I am very sorry for this man and Daniel Pearl and all American religious and journalists that are being persecuted. Trump has managed to get several hostages home without a ransom being paid and is working on peace. Stop the blame Trump mantra. It is getting pretty old and certainly predictable.
LikeLike
Trump is working for control, not for peace. That you do not see this only means that you have not yet been attacked. Your time will come, or you will join in the attacks on your fellow human beings. There will be no middle ground.
LikeLike
April,
Republican Peter Thiel (a Trump ally who spoke at the convention) plans to attend the economic summit for Saudi Arabia because of greed. Others have refused to attend because of Khashoggi’s murder.
Thiel’s opinion that women shouldn’t have the right to vote is well-known.
To be a Republican is to be a hypocrite, which April and Thiel prove.
Thiel, who is gay, is going to Saudi Arabia for the meeting, a nation that has the worst LGBT rights record in the world.
LikeLike
April,
How did you feel about Trump congratulating the Congresman from Montana for beating up a reporter?
It is true that we can’t change Saudi Arabia, you are right.
But the danger is when we act like Saudi Arabia, and they change us.
LikeLike
You see Trump as working for peace? Personally, I don’t see it.
I see his ONLY interest as hoping to turn the global-trade ship around so that US regains hegemony over– or at least parity with– nations that have been eating our lunch due to our offshoring mfg/ labor to developing nations. And I don’t see him making much headway: his antiquated tariff plans have some value as a threat/ chess-play, but on the ground have done nothing but scare the market into volatility & harden the Chinese; his NAFTA ‘reform’ is tepid at best– his w/dwl from TPP has put us at a disadvantage– & his refusal to play ball w/EU seems a missed oppty. Meanwhile, he, like his predecessors, kisses up to the US multinationals w/nary a move to counter the heart of the issue.
“Peace”-wise, he’s been rattling cages of NKorea & Iran, & undermining NATO, & all but encouraging Russia to grab more of its pre-1989 borders; meanwhile doing nothing to abate the war in Afghanistan, & happy to let Saudi Arabia go on murdering Yemenis… This guy is not a peacenik.
LikeLike
April: “Stop the blame Trump mantra. It is getting pretty old and certainly predictable.”
Trump lies continuously and you don’t know truth from his versions of what he wants people to think. I’m tired of the lies, the hatred, the fear, the ignorance, the belittlement of everyone who doesn’t worship his every thought and I’m tired of people who agree with Trump. How do you know where he stands since it changes every time he decides to put out another demeaning Tweet?
I remember a time when presidents had the intelligence to hold press conferences. Trump doesn’t have that ability. He would probably explode if he had to face intelligent journalists who wouldn’t accept his paddle about his ‘wonderful, best ever presidency’.
Trump is an ignorant want-to-be-dictator. Anyone not loyal is thrown out and replaced. Where are the adults in the room to restrain him? There are a large number of people who detest Trump and he has earned every one of us.
Have you gotten the $4,000 promised by Trump in the ‘wonderful, Christmas present for the middle class’ tax cut? Just wait long enough for the deficit to continue to expand and see what the GOP cuts next. They are already saying Medicare, Medicaid and Social Security are on the chopping block. Apparently the GOP think middle and poor America should die early. Die before you need services that the US can no longer afford.
LikeLike
** . . . still waiting to see his taxes . . . . ** CBK
LikeLike
At one of his rallies, Trump just lauded Greg Gianforte, a Montana congressman, for assaulting a reporter. For every assault or assassination of a journalist that goes unpunished, Trump becomes emboldened. That is the danger. He does not respect the First Amendment and never will. As a result we are now on the road to facism. He is an extremely dangerous man because he has no conscience.
LikeLike
“For every assault or assassination of a journalist that goes unpunished, Trump becomes emboldened.”
You nailed it right there. It is ultimate-Trump-style to haul out for red-meat-core-baiting purposes a 17-mo-old [criminal] physical attack on a journalist [which did not prevent Gianforte from winning a Congressional seat the following day (though conviction, fines, community service followed)]– in the immediate wake of the internationally-denounced torture/ dismemberment murder of a US-resident journalist while abroad. (And just after Trump had waffled back& forth over whether it really happened– kissing up to his Saudi-Arabian royal buddy/ US ally/ perpetrator).
What Trump is saying here is, journalists are your enemy: punch ’em out or kill/ dismember ’em, same thing. Once again, making me & any thinking, ethical citizen highly embarrassed to have my country represented by this criminal cretin.
LikeLike
bethree5 “Creeping fascism.” CBK
LikeLike
Kashoggi was not a real journalist, he was a US and Saudi (belonging to the wrong faction, obviously) intelligence asset posing as one, which is the reason for all the indignation. The murder of an actual journalist would hardly have stoked the media outrage machine the way the gruesome murder of this political operative has.
His death really represents declining US influence in the region, with MbS apparently confident he could act with impunity to make an object lesson about what will happen to those in the Kingdom who oppose him, even if they have US intelligence agency connections.
It was also a stick in the eye of Turkey’s Erdogan, who seeks to re-establish Turkish-Ottoman influence in the Muslim world, at the expense of the Saudis.
Sure, we can create chaos in the region – just look at Iraq, Libya, Syria, etc. – and thus profit centers for the politically-connected, and sell the weapons used to foment that chaos (likewise a huge profit center for the the Lockheeds and Blackwaters of the world) but we can no longer get things to go our way there.
LikeLike
Michael, the Washington Post considered him “a real journalist.” His last article read as the work of a “real journalist.”
Which conspiracy theorist have you been reading lately?
LikeLike
Weren’t you a wee bit offended that a hit team was waiting for him in the Saudi Consulate and the first thing they did was to cut off his fingers?
As a “real writer,” the symbolism was apparent to me.
LikeLike
Paraphrasing- “Putin hails sunset for the U.S….” (Huffpo)
Trump, the “strongman”, diminished the U.S. in every way possible to the glee of anti-democracy despots.
LikeLike
He is one of them. An anti-democracy despot wannabe.
LikeLike
Sorry, but I can’t get past the first paragraph. I keep rereading it over and over again and it just sends me back to the beginning. I keep looking for something sensible before moving on, just can’t find it.
LikeLike
GregB If MF is not a Russian bot-hackster, it’s what one would say. CBK
LikeLike
You miss my point, Diane, et. al., and trying to trivialize it by falsely calling it conspiracy mongering doesn’t help.
Kashoggi’s murder was horrifying, but so is starving Yemeni children and turning them into pink mist, something we have been complicit in (and which Kashoggi supported, at least initially) since before Trump assumed office. Yet, it is his murder that raises all the outrage, and very few in official Washington seriously suggest that Lockheed go on a cleansing diet and earn a few billion less off the blood and suffering of the Yemeni people.
Why is that? Oh, right, because Kashoggi was “one of ours.”
And yes, while Kashoggi may have been a “writer” of opinions, I stand by my statement that he was much more of a political operative than a journalist. For God’s sake, haven’t you read the articles about him? They make it quite clear that for decades he was “close to” the Saudi government (though clearly the wrong faction at the moment). He spent years in a leadership capacity at newspapers in that theocratic dictatorship; what else would he be, if not a political operative? That is, after all those good times hangin’ with his pal Osama Bin Laden… whose death he publicly mourned in 2011.
For those of you still holding fast to your 8th grade civics class view of politics and US history, there is a long line of “journalists” who started out or evolved into becoming political/intelligence operatives and primarily remained so, as the Church Committee revealed in the 1970’s: Cord Meyer, Tom Braden, Arnaud de Borchgrave, up through Judith Miller (of Iraq war infamy) of the Times. Even that official scribe of Beltway power, Bob Woodward, got his start as young man with naval intelligence, before being hired by the Washington Post. Starting at least with Allen Dulles and the early Cold War, the CIA actively cultivated ties with journalists, at the Washington Post in particular.
Government officials and spooks often flatter and seek to cultivate journalists; sometimes they hire them. Kashoggi appears to have been one of those types of “journalists” who hover and flit between government, media, think tanks and intelligence services. Thus the hyperventilating and outrage over his murder: it hits a little too close to home for these folks, while Yemen is far away and filled with poor, powerless people…
You also conveniently ignored my point about this affair representing a conflict between the Saudis and the Turks, over which state is to officially represent Islam. No small beer, that…
Kashoggi’s murder was indeed horrifying, and if it leads to the downfall of MbS and a reduction in Saudi atrocities in Yemen – unlikely though that may be – then something good will have come of it. But by focusing on his unfortunate demise while ignoring our complicity in the suffering of thousands of people in Yemen, you unwittingly echo Stalin’s cynical statement that “The death of one person is a tragedy; the death of a million is a statistic.”
LikeLike
Yes, the apologists for Khashoggi’s brutal murder say he was allied with terrorists. It’s all over the rightwing websites and blogs.
Michael, don’t fall into the Trump trap of false equivalence. When anyone says anything bad about Putin or Kim or any other vicious dictator, he says, “we have done plenty of bad things too.”
But we don’t assassinate critics. We used to have moral standing in the world. Moral equivalence removes the possibility of fighting for anything better because “we are all bad.”
No! I reserve the right to fight for what’s right and for freedom of speech. We are not as bad as Russia and North Korea. We don’t murder dissidents and gun down or dismember journalists.
LikeLike
I never repeated any of the claims that Kashoggi was allied with terrorists, nor was I engaging in moral equivalence. I was simply pointing out the inarguable fact that Kashoggi resided in the nether world of government and spy agency connections, think tanks and the “manufacturing consent” section of mainstream media, which is the fundamental source for the continuing outrage at his murder.
To my way of thinking, that does not qualify him as a journalist, so much as a political operative whose job was to act as a media broker for government policies. He was long-time a “player” in Saudi politics, which should call his status as a journalist into question, and also suggests that he got caught up in the factionalism that is taking place in that cesspool of power and religious fundamentalism.
To point out those facts does not justify or minimize the horror of the crime; it points out the political dynamics behind its prominence.
My other purpose was to illustrate the gross hypocrisy of people being horrified at this (truly awful) crime, yet willfully ignoring the US GDP-boosting war crimes taking place in Yemen.
Have you seen Rep. Adam Schiff, Lockheed Democrat and a leader of the McResistance to Trump, call for embargoing arms sales to the Saudis? No, and it’s not likely you will.
It’s not only Trump who’s engaging in this gross double standard, and it’s not “moral equivalence” to suggest that we might do well to ask people living in Libya, Iraq, Syria, et. al. about our “moral standing.”
They might might have some uncomfortable observations that burst our bubble of “American exceptionalism.”
It might also help us wake up, shake off our moral vanity, gather our courage, and try to redeem the country at home and abroad.
LikeLike
Like it or not, Khashoggi was a journalist.
LikeLike
Oh, and for Catherine King:
Russia! Russia! Russia!
Boo !!!
Dimitri, my Russian control agent, has instructed me to ask you to consider how the All-Russia-All-The Time narrative works out for the Dems next month, and in 2020 when Trump is (likely to be) re-elected, in part thanks to the privilege protection racket – actual journalist Aaron Mate’s term – that is “Russiagate.”
A few uncomfortable fact-related questions:
Remember when Flynn was going to bring Trump down?
Remember when Manafort was going to bring Trump down?
Remember when Papadopoulos (with such deep and sinister political connections that he put his high school participation in the the Model UN on his resume) was going to bring Trump down?
Good times…
Instead, perhaps we should remember when Rachel Maddow ignored Trump’s trillion-dollar transfer of wealth to the Overclass, and more of his actual crimes, so that she could instead hyperventilate about these factual and political dead ends?
LikeLike
Michael Fiorillo: I am against the US backed war in Yemen. I want us to help people instead of having a Congress, and a president, who give ever more money to the military complex. I am against fighting in Libya, Iran Syria and et. al. We have military forces in at least 70 countries. When is it ever going to be enough when so much money is involved?
American exceptionalism is something that is taught in 5th grade. I’ve lived long enough to know and understand much more. We cannot kill our way to peace. We cannot bomb and destroy for 17 years and not have people hate us. In my opinion, it is the direct reason that there are people who are becoming more and more violent in their outrage.
The killing of a journalist is never justified. He spoke the truth of what is happening in Saudi Arabia and was killed for that reason. Trump is having a hard time accepting that his ‘friends’ in Saudi Arabia can be murderers. Trump is easily manipulated by foreigners who know that all they have to do is pretend to recognize just how wonderful Trump is. He responds to dictators just like they are his ‘friends’. He sees people whom he doesn’t like, [Ex: Merkel who is a woman and one of our country’s allies] as lower beings on the scale of importance.
I have signed petitions against the sale of arms to Saudi Arabia. This is not a country that can be trusted. It sends money to schools that preach a violent form of Muslim religion…Wahhabism. It treats women as third world with no rights and prevents any form of protest. It is Trump’s dream world. He wants to be dictator in a world where women are put down, no protests are allowed and he can speak and everyone listens and bows.
LikeLike
Michael Fiorillo “Russia . . . Boo!”
Well, if the shoe fits . . . . And with others here, I’m not happy with selling arms to “kingdom’s” either. So stop with the false equivalence thing–it’s a worn-out sophistic ploy. If you are speaking from the heart, I doubt you’re happy with Russia’s (or anyone’s) interference with our elections either (Boooooo!?). CBK
LikeLike
Michael,
Why do you get so upset when anyone criticizes Trump?
Are you ok with the brutal murder of a journalist, cutting off his fingers one by one, for symbolic value, then beheading him, dismembering him, and carting his body away in suitcases?
I truly don’t know why Rachel Maddow offends you.
Trump has been laundering Russian mo eye for years and boasted about it.
He also boasted about selling apartments to Saudis for “$40 million, $50 million, whatever. Why shouldn’t I like them?”
Why are you defending him and attacking anyone who criticizes him?
LikeLike
No surprise, Peter Thiel, one of Trump’s admitted tech tyrant cronies, who pronounced women voting and a capitalistic democracy as an oxymoron, plans to attend the Saudi economic summit.
LikeLike
Peter Thiel, Germany’s Worst Export, ever…
LikeLike
Well, there was Fred Trump’s dad.
LikeLike
Off topic- (1) a 4th Scott Walker cabinet secretary has endorsed his opponent. (2) 538’s polls suggest possible Democratic candidates replacing Republican governors in Wisconsin ( the Koch’s man), Michigan (the DeVos’ man), Pennsylvania, and Florida (the Bushes’ man).
LikeLike
Pennsylvania’s Republican gubernatorial candidate is Uihlein’s man.
LikeLike
Alvin Toffler wrote “Future Shock” published in 1984.
“Future Shock is about the present. Future Shock is about what is happening today to people and groups who are overwhelmed by change. Change affects our products, communities, organizations—even our patterns of friendship and love.
“Future Shock vividly describes the emerging global civilization: tomorrow’s family life, the rise of new businesses, subcultures, life-styles, and human relationships—all of them temporary.
“Future Shock illuminates the world of tomorrow by exploding countless clichés about today.
“Future Shock will intrigue, provoke, frighten, encourage, and, above all, change everyone who reads it.”
34 years later, we are living in that world and it is getting worse!
LikeLike
Thanks for mentioning the Toffler book. I think it came out before 1984, however. Maybe 72?
LikeLike
Thanks, Lloyd. I was just thinking about the ways in which the groundwork is laid for the emergence of a DYSTOPIAN society.
LikeLike
I’ve been working on some crime fiction. A bit of sample dialogue:
“Ya see, the Boss of this other family whacked one of our guys. Cut him up still alive. Nasty business. But it sent a message. So, the Don sent one of his capos to talk to this Boss, who coughed up a cool 100 million. That’s how things work in the Mob.”
What do you think? Too unrealistic?
LikeLike
The mob boss that coughed up the $100-million should also have to give up a few of his elected minions.
“Look, make this go away, and I’ll cough of a hundred million clams, two Senators, five Congressmen. and a dozen state legislature representatives.”
“Nah, you got to throw in at least one Governor and then its a deal,” the capo replied.
LikeLike
Where this analogy breaks down, ofc, is that Trump did not, would not consider Khasshoggi one of our guys. Trump is all about silencing journalists. His administration has just stepped up, big time, prosecutions of people leaking to journalists. And his hateful Fake News rhetoric has emboldened these attacks on journalists by actual strongmen (instead of wannabe ones like Trump himself).
LikeLike
Here’s why I think this matters. Now they’re questioning if he was a journalist (as if that matters). Next they’re going to question whether he was a Republican. Then they’re going to question if he was white. At least that’s what they’d like to turn into a new protocol.
LikeLiked by 1 person
Realistic as ****!
LikeLike
What a moving piece by Mr. Khasshoggi!!! A piece about the silencing of journalists. . . . Wow
LikeLike
Silencing journalists. Hmmm. What well-known American political figure has made railing at journalists and encouraging violence against them a standard part of his stand-up routine ever since he entered the political arena as a candidate? I wonder. . . .
LikeLike
Now it’s being reported that one of the Saudis seen entering the embassy has been killed in a “car crash” on the way back to Saudi Arabia. Isn’t that a coincidence? What do you want to bet that the others will succumb to other forms of fake death. All of them will disappear and there will be no one left to tell the story of how Jamal Khashoggi walked into an embassy and never walked out.
LikeLike
Saudi Arabia has the worst LBGBT rights record in the world.
The violent, anti-democracy extremists who lead Saudi Arabia are hosting Trump’s greedy ally, tech tyrant, Peter Thiel for an economic summit. The Saudis could show him the brand of welcome that Khashoggi received. Thiel thinks women voting is anathema to capitalistic democracy. Saudi Arabia, a nation that denies women rights, is the perfect place for Thiel…if only he wasn’t gay.
LikeLike
Like so many, I stayed up through the night following Twitter as Arab Spring unfolded far away from California. Mr. Khashoggi’s perspective piece here made me gasp tracing the circle from hope to quiet desperation in just 7 years and feels eerily prescient. Thank you, Diane, for spreading his last column. His death is on American hands as surely as Awlaki’s was and Assange’s or Assad’s may become. Our chimp commanders have thrown Osama into the sea, driven Saddam into a hole, Mubarek into a caged circus animal, Gaddafi into dirt, opting again and again for the mobster plot or the most primitive cruelty and it’s getting worse: Israel and ICE are turning their reptilian rage loose on children. I’d rather not point fingers at immature tribal societies because I see no evolution at all among the power-crazed in our own.
LikeLike
Is Bernie the only sane voice in Congress? Are we so dependent upon oil from SA that murders in a consulate don’t matter? Murder in Yemen doesn’t matter? The export of a violent Muslim Wahhabism doesn’t matter?
…………………………………………….
Bernie Sanders on Saudis: U.S. can’t have “ally who murders in cold blood”
BY TIM MARCIN ON 10/18/18 AT 4:18 PM
…”I have long been troubled by the nature of the relationship between the U.S. and Saudi Arabia,” Sanders said in a video posted to Twitter. “And in light of the likely Saudi murder of critic Jamal Khashoggi, I think it is time for us to thoroughly re-evaluate that relationship. Saudi Arabia is, and has always been, a despotic dictatorship in which dissent is not tolerated, in which women are considered third-class citizens and which has spent the last several decades exporting an extreme form of Islam, Wahhabism, around the world.”
Later in the video Sanders added, “We cannot have an ally who murders in cold blood, in their own consulate, a critic, a dissident. That is unacceptable by any government, but especially by one so closely supported by the United States.”
Much of the video from Sanders also focused on the ongoing crisis in Yemen. The senator said Saudis are currently “devastating” Yemen with a “catastrophic war” with U.S. support. The senator called it a war that has caused a humanitarian disaster…
http://www.newsweek.com/bernie-sanders-saudi-arabia-us-ally-murders-cold-blood-relationship-re-1177209
LikeLike
This sounds as if Khashoggi was brutally murdered. This article comes from the UK. There are many journalists who are ‘mysteriously’ missing. Truth comes at a very high price.
……
Jamal Khashoggi: Saudi journalist ‘had fingers torn off one by one’ as ‘consul tells hitmen: “Do this outside”‘
Mr Khashoggi vanished after entering the Saudi consulate in Istanbul, Turkey, on October 2 – here’s all we know so far about the case
BySophie Evans
15:30, 17 OCT 2018
Missing Saudi journalist Jamal Khashoggi had his fingers ripped off before he was decapitated by a 15-strong hit squad, it is claimed.
Mr Khashoggi, 60, a critic of the Saudi leadership, was last seen entering the country’s consulate in Istanbul, Turkey, on October 2.
Once inside, he is said to have been tortured by the squad – allegedly including a ‘Dr Death’ and a man with ties to the Saudi Crown Prince.
He had his fingers brutally torn off as his killers spent seven minutes murdering him and dismembering his body, media reports claim.
Chilling audio footage, taken that day, reportedly captures Saudi Arabia’s Consul General telling the suspects to “do this outside”….
https://www.mirror.co.uk/news/world-news/saudi-journalist-jama-khashoggi-decapitated-13431750?utm_source=sharebar&utm_medium=email&utm_campaign=sharebar
LikeLike
The free press is the enemy of bullies and bigots, corruption and conspiracy, injustice and injury, and mobs and murderers.
LikeLike
The free press is small, about 10 percent of the total. The other 90 percent is the corporate media and they are not free. The Corporate media is slaved to profits and whatever the biased corporate overlords want to lean toward: left, middle or right.
LikeLike
The free press is, yes, the enemy of Donald J. Trump, the inept and unconscionable president.
LikeLike
Political operative, critic, journalist.
Murder is murder.
Let the investigation be transparent and draw global attention.
LikeLike
State-authorized torture and murder is an anachronistic atrocity.
LikeLike
Kim and Putin are anachronistic monstrosities.
Trump is sketch-comedy satire horrifyingly entering into the fold of reality, though not truth.
LikeLike
Faith in democracy feels anachronistic in these times, alas.
LikeLike
The three of them should be on a deserted island together with no way off. The sea will rise.
LikeLike
A deserted island is too close.
I think Mars would be better. They can live in the habitat left behind by Mark Watney, the stranded astronaut from “The Martian”.
And if the habitat isn’t there when they arrive, oh well, too bad.
LikeLike
Sickening.
LikeLike
We’re Supposed to Believe Khashoggi Died Boxing in the Saudi Consulate??
By Michael Moore, Michael Moore’s Facebook Page
20 October 18
Of course that’s it!! KHASHOGGI DIED BOXING! Trump and the Saudis are now on the same page: “An argument broke out between Mr. Khashoggi and men who met him inside the Saudi Consulate in Istanbul on Oct. 2, leading to ‘a fistfight that led to his death.’” (NY Times) So, if I’m to understand it, Khashoggi’s face ran into a Saudi man’s fist, a fist so sharp it beheaded him and then accidentally dismembered him.
LikeLike
Gee, I wonder why this interview was done on Faux.
……….
Khashoggi’s death was a ‘rogue operation’ that the crown prince was not aware of, Saudi foreign minister says..WaPo
In an interview with Fox News, Saudi Foreign Minister Adel al-Jubeir denied that Crown Prince Mohammed bin Salman had any prior knowledge of an operation that resulted in the killing of journalist and Post contributing columnist Jamal Khashoggi in the Saudi consulate in Istanbul. His statement comes amid mounting pressure on Mohammed and global calls for a transparent investigation.
“This was an operation that was a rogue operation,” al-Jubeir said. “This was an operation where individuals ended up exceeding the authorities and responsibilities they had. They made a mistake when they killed Jamal Khashoggi.”
LikeLike
Saudi Arabia is putting more money into lobbyists. Wouldn’t it be great if we had a Congress, and a president, who couldn’t be bought off? Trump has already been manipulated by the Saudi’s false worshiping of our ‘great leader’.
……..
More recently, some lawmakers have increased pressure on the Trump administration to press the Saudis to end the war in Yemen. And Saudis have fought to sink legislation — dubbed “Nopec” — that would allow antitrust officials to sue the Organization of the Petroleum Exporting Countries and its members for collusion.
The country has dramatically stepped up its investment in its Washington to meet the rising challenge. “The kingdom’s spending on U.S. lobbying and consulting, which had dropped from $14.3 million in 2015 to $7.7 million in 2016, surged to $27.3 million last year, according to public records,” my colleagues Tom Hamburger, and Beth Reinhard and Justin Wm. Moyer report in a deep-dive into Saudi lobbying that posted last night. “More than 200 people have registered as agents on behalf of Saudi interests since 2016, according to lobbying documents posted by the Center for Responsive Politics.”
LikeLike