I did not get this essay from Bob Shepherd in time to post it on Columbus Day. Some years ago, I read the book by the priest Bartolomeo de las Casas to which he refers, and it made me so sick with disgust and sorrow that I could not finish it. Some illustrations show the Spanish conquistadores turning people on a spit, as if they were pigs. Too harrowing for me.
A Short Love Letter to Prezidoodle Donnie Trumpty-Dumpty
Re: Chrissie Columbus, by Robert D. Shepherd
We have two national holidays named after people, one for the Rev. Dr. Martin Luther King, Jr., and one for Christopher Columbus.
Columbus thought he had landed near Japan. He wrote a letter back home saying that the natives were so “artless” and “generous” that it would be easy to have whatever he wanted of them. He was, ofc, looking for a quick and easy route to the Far East so that he could trade in spices, silks, gemstones, and so on. When he didn’t find those, he set up a quota for gold to be delivered to him by every native over 14 years of age. When they didn’t meet their quotas, he cut off pieces of their anatomy–fingers, hands, feet. But there was no gold.
Terrified by the prospect of displeasing his sponsors back home, he hit upon enslaving the natives to work in mines and to produce crops that could be traded or sold. He instructed his overseers to pull one of the enslaved natives from the fields every once in a while and slaughter him or her in full view of the others to encourage them to work harder. He wrote a letter back home telling a friend that it was easy to keep his men in line by rationing out to them the native females for sexual purposes. He said, “THOSE FROM NINE TO TEN are now in demand.” He set armored dogs on the indigenous babies and toddlers for sport. He instituted the first European-run slave plantations in the New World AND the first trans-Atlantic slave trading. In a couple decades, he had almost entirely wiped out the Caribbean Arawaks–an estimated quarter of a million of them.
We have a contemporary account of these depredations by a priest named Bartolomeo de las Casas who, horrified, witnessed them first-hand and wrote a book to try to get King Charles V, the Holy Roman Emperor and King of Spain, to make it stop. In his book, A Brief Account of the Destruction of the Indies, de las Casas tells how the Spanish celebrated Easter by hanging thirteen Indians from a gibbet–one for each of the apostles and one for Christ–and flaying them alive. And there are bits about how much fun Christopher’s men had cutting open the bellies of living pregnant women and pulling the babies out.
So, Martin Luther King, Jr., and this guy, Columbus, notable for enslavement, genocide, the most ghastly conceivable tortures, and trading in children for unspeakable purposes–the fellow just honored as a “courageous . . . man of faith” in a proclamation by, you guessed it, agent Orange himself, Prezidoodle Donnie Trumpty-Dumpty.

Many thanks for posting this account, and to inimitable Bob for writing a stunning summary of it, terrible unbearable as it is, one of many truths our schools never let us learn. The Rethinking Schools group issued the booklet ‘Rethinking Columbus’ before the 500th anniversary of 1492, which helped move the idea of replacing this holiday with an Indigenous Peoples Day.
LikeLike
yes yes yes. It’s long past time that this holiday be renamed.
LikeLike
Perhaps the thing that we react to more than anything is the expectation that Europeans should have known better. Even Las Casas took the view that Europeans were supposed to be parents to the “children” who were theArawaks. Meanwhile the rival British used the words of Bartolemeo against the Spanish as propaganda, even as they carried out their own atrocities in their colonial activity. We still see the story of European domination as a civilized society dominating various uncivilized, inferior populations. In fact, LasCassas was exactly right. The Europeans were willing to sacrifice everything for immediate wealth. They were no more civilized than the natives who dismembered their attackers.
LikeLike
One might persuasively argue that the Europeans were less “civilized” while at the same time were more technologically advanced in most regards.
LikeLike
After a less gory, but equally scathing discussion of the exploits of Columbus, I recall the honest response of one of my fifth grade ELLs that happened to be from the Dominican Republic. She blurted out. “So why the h*ll do we celebrate this guy?” Out of the mouths of babes…..
LikeLike
I knew it was terrible but oh my, this priest’s account is ghastly! I know the American Italian culture hold him up and honor him every year, but when will they learn that he was pure evil and should not be honored?
LikeLike
It will probably take a while. For generations we have been taught that Columbus was this great hero and explorer. Francis Bellamy created the Pledge of Allegiance in 1892 on the 400th anniversary of Columbus’s “discovery,” in part to honor the “great” navigator. We have many cities named after Columbus and then there’s the District of Columbia, Columbia University, etc. Maybe we could substitute Amerigo Vespucci, assuming he wasn’t a rapacious beast like Columbus. Our treatment of the indigenous peoples is nothing to rave about and in many cases just as bad as Columbus.
LikeLike
Wasn’t it Trump’s first wife who said the book he most admired was Hitler’s Mein Kempf? I recall, she said he kept the book by the bed and had favorite passages marked that he read over and over.
LikeLike
Do you have a source for this, Lloyd?
LikeLike
“Donald Trump’s ex-wife once said Trump kept a book of Hitler’s speeches by his bed”
https://www.businessinsider.com/donald-trumps-ex-wife-once-said-he-kept-a-book-of-hitlers-speeches-by-his-bed-2015-8
“Ivana Trump told her lawyer Michael Kennedy that from time to time her husband reads a book of Hitler’s collected speeches, My New Order, which he keeps in a cabinet by his bed. Kennedy now guards a copy of My New Order in a closet at his office, as if it were a grenade. Hitler’s speeches, from his earliest days up through the Phony War of 1939, reveal his extraordinary ability as a master propagandist.”
https://www.vanityfair.com/magazine/2015/07/donald-ivana-trump-divorce-prenup-marie-brenner
LikeLike
I dont believe this story. I don’t think Trump has ever read a book. Or an essay. Or a speech. He gets his news and views from FOX.
LikeLike
Maybe he had someone that worked for him read the book or books for him and mark the top five quotes with a highlighter so DT could read those. I still don’t think he’d understand the context.
LikeLike
What’s DT for, Lloyd? I thought the initials of Red Rat is RR.
LikeLike
Well — tongue in cheek — DT stands for Donald Trump but it also stands for Deep Throat, Dark Tower, Devil Trigger, Doing Time (this is wishful thinking for President DT), Death Touch, Dark Throne, Death Trap, Decay Time (how long will it take for President DT to rot from the inside out), Drive-Through (his diet) — and they all fit Donald Trump in some way.
LikeLike
He does watch youtube videos, and no doubt Mussolini ones. Just watch the puckered lips and more https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=RNX2V5wXDWg
LikeLike
Having read it in English decades ago and given up many times on the German version, I can believe that our Dear Leader once read this. One would have to be incredibly vacuous, self-centered and delusional to think they would find anything in there to be profound. He checks off all the categories. And he probably took the entire decade of the 80s to get through it.
LikeLike
Did you see this, Lloyd? A red alert from a Yale “sage on the stage” (proves the value of sages on stages, IMHO. Imagine a constructivist’s version of this lesson!):
LikeLike
Well, pretty good vid, but it’s absolutely not true that Orbán of Hungary makes the Soros influence a Jewish conspiracy. He makes it what it is: a billionaire trying to influence a country’s politics.
LikeLike
I’ve read that Soros is the opposite of the Koch brothers.
In other words: Soros funds progressives vs Koch brothers building a theocratic kleptocracy
Soros has about 400 millionaires in his organization vs more than 2,000 millionaires and billionaires supporting the Kochtopus.
LikeLike
True. But this is where can see exactly that NO billionaires should be allowed to exist. In case of Soros, he is considered progressive in the US and supports socialistic changes, but he really is trying to change the politics in Hungary despite the fact that the vast majority of the voters elected Orbán. Yeah Orbán may want to be a king if he was allowed (and he is working hard at it), but there was no better alternative—at least according to the Hungarian voters.
Soros’ money buys muuuuuuch more in a small and poor country than here in the US. He could, in fact, change the course of politics single handedly.
LikeLike
I agree about no billionaires. It’s time to enact a 92-percent tax for annual earning over 1-million dollars and starting at 1 billion the tax jumps to 100-percent.
LikeLike
100%. Sounds appropriate. Mabbe a yearly inprisonment of 6 months could also be instituted for these freedom and choice loving individuals.
LikeLike
When found guilty, the more wealth the convicted felon has, the longer the sentence.
Imagine how long Bill Gates or the Koch brothers would have to serve if they were caught guilty of even tax evasion?
Would one lifetime locked up for each billion dollars be enough?
More than 80 lifetimes for Bill Gates
Almost 45 lifetimes for each Koch twin.
How many lifetimes would Betsy DeVos end up with?
LikeLike
Thanks for the history.
Ohio’s capitol needs a new name, fewer MAGA jerk supporters of Trump, no Fordham Institute and, an “Our Revolution” government.
LikeLike
And your culture heroes are . . . ?
LikeLike
For one, Jesus Christ (not the one that Franklin Graham, Josh Duggar, Jay Sekulow and the church of prosperity claim to worship, but the one that Rev. Barber honors by example). A second (imperfect) is Martin Luther King. A third is Abraham Lincoln about whom Donald Trump understands nothing. Fourth and fifth, Dwight Eisenhower (imperfect) and a general who constructed and got support for the Marshall plan. Diane Ravitch, Bernie Sanders and all who are funding progressives in 2018 are also culture heroes.
The anti-Christs are those from the financial sector who drag down GDP, those who trample American democracy with their votes for Republicans, the richest 0.1% funding DINO’s and Republicans (all of whom are now Koch/ALEC libertarians), and those plotting to destroy common goods so that profit can be taken from creating misery for others e.g. Bill Gates, DFER, the Fordham Institute, the Hoover Institute, and SIEPR.
LikeLike
Seriously? Is THIS GUY is one of your “culture heroes,” Harlen? How about Pol Pot? Another hero? Or is it just that mythologizing mass murderers is something we should do because of the power with which those myths bind people together, as the Soviets did with Lenin and Stalin, as the Chinese did with Mao? What exactly is your point here, Mr. Underhill?
LikeLike
“And your culture heroes are . . . ?”
Why do you need one?
LikeLike
The book may have been “My New Order” a collection of Hitler’s speeches and he may or may not have a copy of Mein Keimpf. It is anyone’s guess if he read either.
His message, designed for his audience, are simple and jingoistic. Not hard to door or to deliver, as long as you know how to press the right buttons. Think of preaching and be confident in your message.
I could do it in a classroom. That is why it is important to have ethical teachers, and probably why Billionnaires want to control curriculum.
LikeLike
Trump is a masterful demagogue. He could recite the telephone book and his mobs would go wild.
LikeLike
Trump could read from the Bible and claim he wrote it and his forever-Trumpers would believe him.
LikeLike
One of Trump backers said she liked him because he didn’t talk down to people like her (as evidenced by his incoherency and small vocabulary). Trump bullies those in the weight classes below him but, presumably that’s o.k. with his supporters because he bullies anyone who stands in his way of taking money and anyone who expresses a position different than his.
LikeLike
That’s a very good point. He is the embodiment of disparate people whose innermost fears and resentments were given life when they could easily find, communicate and work with on their collective grievances and hates. I noticed this for the first time seeing David Duke live in front of an extremely friendly audience. If you closed your eyes and focused on the words, there was literally nothing there and what little that was decipherable was too far out to take seriously—if you weren’t one of them. I later listened to Hitler speeches and found the same thing. A good Italian friend of mine assures me that Mussolini was a droning idiot. Their audiences heard what they wanted.
What they all have in common is the myth of charisma embodied in a bombastic, but ultimately empty package. Oh, and willing audiences who lost the ability to detect shame or empathize with those who are ultimately like them; you know, the ones they vilify the most.
LikeLike
Reblogged this on David R. Taylor-Thoughts on Education and commented:
Interesting.
LikeLike
I got my PhD from Ohio State Univ. in Columbus OH. I wouldn’t mind renaming the place to Mingo because that was the tribe living in the area. Their fate?
Captain William Crawford led an attack against this village leading to the dispersal of the Mingo among other tribes.
LikeLike
yes yes yes
LikeLike
LikeLike
I used to use this song in my classes to help the students understand that not all “celebrate” Columbus Day. Lyrics in English.
Driven by the strength of his mind
In the solitude of his imagination
With the faith that makes the mortal omnipotent
On the brow of the sun, Columbus sails
Accompanying him are the rebel
The unbeliever, the brave
Hope and despair
Future soldiers
Warlords and cardinals
The warrior and the seed of a nation
Plebeian next to the nobleman
In the same two-step
For gold and passion for Conquest
And Columbus is his Admiral
And God bears the banner
of imperialist Castile and Aragon
Devils and madonnas
Ignorants and the educated,
Idealists, mercenaries and patriots,
Innocent and guilty,
Rich, poor, the miserable all
Intertwined in their search for glory
That was the best moment
Of the great mistake
When, facing the impossible
the lone heart beats
They started
Betting on the soul
With invincible hope of he
who has been a loser
They finished
Humiliating the sky
Destroying its stars
And urinating on the moon and the sun
The cross that later blessed the genocide
was the one that at the beginning spoke of love
The injustice does not end for the Indian
Five centuries have not calmed their pain
Positive and negative
are mixed into the inheritance
From 1492
Today, without the intention of offense
To the one who thinks differently
I conmemorate but without celebration
LikeLike