Dear Readers,
For reasons unknown to me, many of your comments are being held in moderation.
That means that they won’t be posted until I personally approve them.
This is happening to many people who are regular readers.
I can’t explain it.
WordPress never accepts responsibility for anything.
In the past few years, WP has kicked readers out completely, blocked them from receiving the blog or commenting. I have contacted them on behalf of many people, and WP always says it is the readers’ fault. My own brother was kicked out, and I lost hours trying to restore him.
I don’t know what’s going on with WordPress.
If your comments are delayed, it’s because I am offline, as I was last night when I went to dinner and theater. I came home to find 24 comments in moderation.
I am truly sorry that the Blog is hosted by WordPress. At this point, with six years of history on this site, I suppose I’ll just have to deal with it.
I sincerely regret the hundreds or thousands of readers who were excluded from the blog without my knowledge or theirs.
Diane
Diane Ravitch's blog 
But I’m still actually in moderation, right?
LikeLike
no
LikeLike
Then something is going on, because every one of my comments has gone into moderation for the past month or more.
LikeLike
yes, you were in moderation because you over-annoyed me. I forget why.
LikeLiked by 1 person
Okay, except that one.
LikeLike
“I like beer.”
LikeLike
Welcome to Trumplandia. CBK
LikeLike
William Cozart
Is WordPress controlled by Republicans? And therefore controlled by a group of unprincipled human beings who are doing everything in their power to destroy American democracy (e.g. the Kavanaugh confirmation).
LikeLike
I wonder, too.
LikeLike
Diane, the main reason appears to be that there is a list of verboten words that, if used in a comment, will automatically send a comment to moderation. One such word is the last name of a certain SCOTUS nominee who likes beer. Another such word is the name “Ch@rles” — here substituting an ampersand for the letter “a” to avoid moderation. Having never moderated a WordPress blog, I don’t know how you would go fixing this. But I would assume it’s fixable.
LikeLike
WordPress has a stable of “Happiness Engineers” who are supposed to fix problems. They are very cheerful. I seldom get the same one twice. They never fix the problems.
The biggest problem is the incessant banning of readers who no longer receive the blog and are not allowed to comment.
I don’t know how many but the number is very large.
LikeLike
FLERP,
Send me a comment with Kavanaugh’s name and also the word “Charles” as a test.
LikeLike
You can tell that the Supreme Court hearings has totally thrown me off my work schedule. I have two more chapters to write to finish my book.
I can usually blog and write the book at the same time, and keep up with Words with Friends, but the SCOTUS hearings have knocked me back where the book is concerned.
LikeLike
Diane I still think the Democrats are playing Charlie Brown to the GOP’s Lucy.
I’ll be surprised if this new FBI investigation doesn’t prove to be just another football that will be grabbed back by the GOP once the Democrats think they are going to get some fairness. CBK
LikeLike
Kavanaugh likes beer. Do you like beer, Charles?
LikeLike
that comment went into moderation.
Now try to write one with only one name, then another with the other name.
LikeLike
My name is Brett Kavanaugh. I liked beer. I still like beer.
LikeLike
Kavanaugh went into moderation.
LikeLike
Charles in Charge was an American sitcom starring Scott Baio. It aired for a total of 126 episodes over five seasons.
LikeLike
So did Charles!
LikeLike
I told you!
LikeLike
I think I fixed the Charles problem, as our very own Charles is always in moderation to prevent him from posting comments here 100x a day.
I put down his email instead of his name.
Kavanaugh is inexplicable as there is no such name in moderation by me.
LikeLike
done
LikeLike
Well that was fun! FLERP!/Diane CSI.
LikeLike
OMG Diane I am in awe that you have only two chapters left while meanwhile hosting a very active & fun [for me] several months here!? Scarcely a day has gone by w/o multiple current posts, or a couple of meaty ones, or — briefly — links to past posts worth a re-visit.
Wow!!
LikeLike
Loved the beer jokes!
LikeLike
Diane, I’m sorry that this issue of moderation puts more pressure on your time. Who wants to look and find 24 statements that you have to approve? I’m glad that you do this because I’ve had many that go into moderation.
Using the K******** name in its full is a guarantee. Why is a mystery.
LikeLike
I haven’t experienced this issue on my blog. I can say that if someone puts multiple links in a comment that will send someone into moderation. If they comment from a new IP address that can do it as well. I set all my comments to moderation last Winter when a crazed woman repeatedly attempted to go after me with false accusations about my family. As well, she exhibited tons of anger towards anyone who disagreed with her. Maybe it is just some weird kind with WordPress right now. Or something is up because you speak so many truths that some don’t want to get out!
LikeLike
It is very odd.
People who have commented here for years have been put into moderation. Not by me.
I have had a longstanding problem with WordPress simply banning readers, some of whom have been receiving the blog for years.
Then when I try to work it out (unsubscribe, resubscribe), they can’t get back on.
LikeLike
My speculation was that “moderation” was a catchall for a few things. One was related to the volume of comments that came in simultaneously. “Moderation” winnowed the amount to a manageable queue number. The comments were held to be distributed at a later time, providing for a more regulated flow through the circuits (for lack of a better word). Diane’s website is popular which creates the need for safeguards to prevent crashing the website.
LikeLike
Everything in moderation, including this comment.
LikeLike
FLERP! Your name used to get my comments put into moderation. Along with many other mysterious reasons I could never figure out except that it is wordpress.
LikeLike
There was a period when I was in moderation (I had assumed I was blocked entirely, but maybe it was just “moderation”) for bad behavior.
LikeLiked by 1 person
hanging out with guys like Duane…
LikeLike
I appear to be in perpetual moderation as my posts often prove to be inconvenient. It is hard for me to tell, but i don’t think responses to my posts are moderated, but that might be because people refer to me as TE, rather than my name.
LikeLike
You are always in moderation because you are argumentative and hostile, bordering on hostility. I don’t trust you to speak with civility as one is expected to do in my living room.
LikeLike
In the six years of posting here, have I ever been uncivil?
LikeLike
Not uncivil. Caviling. Negative. Quarrelsome. Nitpicking. Seldom a positive contribution. Maybe never. Your contributions are solely to point out how wrong everyone else is. If this were a dinner party, you would never be invited back.
LikeLike
I am glad that you have no reason not to trust me to “speak with civility as one is expected to do in my living room”.
I must admit that others in your living room do speak uncivilly to me. One of your guests repeatedly hurled misogynistic sexual insults at me with everyone’s silent approval. That is how the ideological purity of the blog is maintained.
LikeLike
There is no such thing as “silent approval” on a blog. There are thousands of readers every day. Silence is not consent.
I said you are civil but you are also negative, quarrelsome, and a fault-finder. You play the role of the know-it-all who arrives to prove everyone else not as smart as you.
The Blog is not ideologically pure, although we do share respect for teachers and opposition to privatization of public goods and services. Some part of this approach bothers you. You play the role of the nay-sayer. If you were writing on a wine blog, you would be saying that wine is bad for your health.
Misogynistic insults are usually directed at women. I haven’t seen any directed at you.
LikeLike
Yes, I have noticed that if I type K’s full name, I get put into moderation. This is the first I have ever been in moderation.
LikeLike
Different theory- Too many comments coming in at the same time? “Moderation” is like the spillway for dams?
The simplest answer.
LikeLike
Who owns “World Press”? Are they, by chance wealthy Republicans?
LikeLike
The wellbeing of civilization — from the financial market to basic communication — has been placed under the efficacy of faulty algorithms.
LikeLike
In other words, the blog and all of civilization is VAM damned.
LikeLike
Isn’t it fun to have the fate of your comments decided by a computer algorithm! The fate of your social networking life decided by algorithms! The fate of elections decided by algorithms! Imagine having your employment and reputation, your whole life, decided by an algorithm. VAM is ridiculously wrong — no, not ridiculously; there’s nothing funny about it.
LikeLike
Don’t feel badly, Diane. It’s not your fault. Computers and software and the Internet are great–when they work. I have had tons of problems with all of these over the years.
And yet, this is how I’m supposed to “personalize,” and how I’m supposed to, “engage the students.” Except that nothing works the way it’s supposed to, and I don’t have enough computers relative to my huge class sizes.
Tech is NOT the savior many think it to be, but you’re certainly doing your best to use it to a good end. Thank you for all you do.
I hope dinner and the theater was fun.
LikeLike
Haven’t you heard? Computers can do it all, and there’s no need for the pesky teachers that actually expect to be paid….at least according to Gates and company.
LikeLike
Grr, you are so right ThreatenedOutWest. It burns me up that pubsch K12 teachers have to put up w/trialling all that rigid, binary, glitch-prone malarkey, much less being forced to use it (to “personalize?”). Computer apps strike me as so, just, wrong right now, in the 1st 2 wks of my yr providing PreK Span enrichment [where I am free to teach the way I find best]. At ages 2.5-5, class groups are wildly different from each other in terms of ability/ degree of engagement (but I suspect that’s true at any age based on my brief yrs teaching hisch). I am kept completely on my toes adapting content — at one end slowing & simplifying to avoid overwhelming, at the other end, diving forward into techniques I notice they’re ready for long before expected.
LikeLike
And sometimes, the mess is done by one’s own school district. The district that I teach in has its own in-house grading system, and it worked pretty well. THEN, they decided to start a new system, but launched it before it was fully done, and it had NEVER been tested. It’s be a catastrophe, and every teacher I know is SO upset about the extra time it takes and the many flaws that it has. But the district told me that “we’re not going to change it, so you’ll just have to adapt to it.”
LikeLike
Sorry ThreatenedOutWest, just catching up on responses after being out w/a virus. So can I assume that the district’s new grading system is — computerized, full of bugs & glitches? Or maybe just totally user-unfriendly, or requires more teacher input but helps teacher less? What about its precedent, the system you liked — also computerized?
LikeLike
I enjoy reading your political perspectives on issues, Diane. While I agree with 100% of the educational opinions, I disagree with many of the other political opinions. But I always find what you write to be well reasoned and interesting.
LikeLike
Thanks. I wondered about this, as my comments regularly get the “moderation” thingie.
LikeLike
Not so much for you. CarolMalaysia is the one most likely to be in moderation.
LikeLike
WordPress (as is the case with most other Internet services like email sites, etc.) is frequently updating their software to add features, fix bugs, and plug security holes. Sometimes “improving” some features inadvertently breaks others. Best to just report the problem in as much detail as possible and hope it gets fixed. Of course, no one wants to spend their time doing this kind of thing, but it is critical to proper software upkeep.
I worked in the software industry for some time, and most complicated programs have lengthy “to-be-addressed” bug lists. Often bugs on these lists are only triggered infrequently or by unusual configurations or by high traffic volumes. It is analogous to having a sporadic problem in your car, taking it to a mechanic and then finding out that it can not be fixed because it doesn’t recur while the car is at the shop. Very annoying!!
When one fully understands the underlying complexity of modern software, it is amazing that things generally work out reasonably well! All told, despite these annoyances, Diane, your blog has performed well and provided a valuable service to an extremely large number of people. I, for one, am thankful for it.
LikeLike
Thank you, David. Just this morning I got a letter from a reader in Germany who told me that he has not received a post in three weeks. This is the second time he has been kicked off by WordPress. I referred the problem to them. I wonder how many others were kicked off and didn’t think about contacting me to ask why.
LikeLike
That’s exactly why it is important for people to speak up, but, of course, then things can go to the other extreme when they do!
LikeLike
Diane, quite often I have to click on the WorldPress icon before anything will be printed. Either that or I’d have to sign in again and I lost my password.
I know that Gordon Wilder misses getting your posts. He was not able to get back on.
LikeLike
I went thru several iterations of screen names and email accounts to find something that kind of works. Now I get posts on one account and answers on another. I’m sure some comments never make it to me.
LikeLike
PS – usually the tech support people that you contact via chat are “first level support.” If something is really annoying and you don’t seem to be making progress, try asking to have your problem escalated to someone higher up in the organization who is more familiar with the details of the software. While most companies do not allow customers to talk directly to a software engineer, occasionally it does happen.
You have a high volume blog, but the WordPress software is also used to run many major sites such as the New York Times, etc., to the best of my knowledge. Those sites, however, obviously run the software on their own computers and have their own IT staff. For WordPress’ hosted sites like yours, I wouldn’t be surprised if you were in a pretty high traffic percentile. I would think this fact would make you more deserving of a higher level of support.
LikeLike
And finally in response to some comments above, I don’t think the WordPress founders are Koch brother allies. They developed their blogging software with the idealistic intent to allow everyone to publish their point of view and facilitate democracy, not hinder it.
LikeLike