The New York Times showed that Trump tariffs on cars will boomerang and hurt Trump voters in South Carolina, Tennessee, and Alabama.
“BRUSSELS — President Trump has complained about seeing too many German cars on Fifth Avenue, and threatened heavy tariffs on the companies that produce them. There is a good chance, though, that those Mercedes-Benzes and BMWs were not only made in the United States, but made by workers who voted for Mr. Trump.
“European companies have turned Alabama, South Carolina and Tennessee into auto manufacturing powerhouses in recent years, churning out cars not just for American buyers but also for export to China and Europe. Germany’s three biggest carmakers all have facilities there, and Volvo Cars, which is owned by a Chinese company but based in Sweden, began producing at a new plant in South Carolina just last month.
“Yet being major employers in regions that voted heavily for Mr. Trump has not protected them.
“With barely a peep of resistance from his own party, the president has threatened tariffs — expected to be 20 percent — on imported cars and car parts. In a prelude to such a move, he has ordered an investigation into whether the imports pose a threat to national security. Trade restrictions could be put in place within months. And if he follows through, the European Union has pledged to retaliate.
“The damage would be far-reaching, draining an estimated $14 billion from the United States economy. If other countries retaliated, the cost would skyrocket to nearly $300 billion, the European Union’s Washington delegation said last week.
“Carmakers, both foreign and domestic, say such penalties would severely damage their lines of supply, interfere with exports and eventually force them to curtail operations in, of all places, Republican strongholds.
“Mr. Trump won 63 percent of the vote in Spartanburg, S.C., home of BMW’s biggest factory anywhere in the world. But Allen Smith, president of the Spartanburg Area Chamber of Commerce, said the president’s tariffs would threaten the region’s livelihood.
“For BMW and its many, many suppliers scattered across the state and region, you’re talking tens of thousands of jobs,” Mr. Smith said. “We would all agree with the president’s overall aim to improve trade with America’s interests top of mind. But getting to that end by inflicting so much pain on American business is the wrong approach.”
“Mr. Trump’s threat to impose auto tariffs would be the latest manifestation of his willingness to alienate longtime allies and American companies, ostensibly to protect domestic jobs. He has already imposed levies on steel and aluminum from the European Union, Canada, Mexico and other nations, and on Friday will place tariffs on $34 billion worth of Chinese products.
“But this new front in the trade war carries substantial risk not just for the auto industry but for Mr. Trump and Republican officeholders nationwide, given the impact that a full-blown trade war could have on American jobs tied to the auto industry.
“Virtually all cars made in the United States contain imported parts. Unlike steel and aluminum tariffs, whose costs may not be obvious to most consumers, automotive levies would show up in showrooms within weeks. Sticker prices would rise by hundreds if not thousands of dollars. That is why Ford and General Motors, alongside foreign automakers, have also roundly condemned the protectionist measures.
“The times are gone that a producer was only headquartered in one country with production in that country and exporting from that country to the rest of the world,” said Erik Jonnaert, the secretary general of the European Automobile Manufacturers’ Association, in an interview in Brussels.
“The economic impact would be greatest in a triangle demarcated by BMW’s factory in Spartanburg; Daimler’s Mercedes complex in Tuscaloosa, Ala.; and Volkswagen’s plant in Chattanooga, Tenn…
“Over time, the European carmakers have expanded their operations in those regions not only to build vehicles for American buyers, but also to serve customers in places like China. Last year, Daimler added 900 jobs to its American operations, which also include truck factories, and it is investing $1 billion to expand the Tuscaloosa operation to produce electric vehicles and batteries.
“Mr. Trump’s contention that these companies may present a threat to American national security, though, has thrown that growth into doubt.
“BMW exports 70 percent of the vehicles that it makes in Spartanburg, about 270,000, helping to reduce the trade deficit that Mr. Trump often complains about. BMW plans to add 1,000 jobs in Spartanburg as part of a $600 million expansion. If trade tensions continue to escalate, BMW warned in a letter on June 28 to Wilbur Ross, the commerce secretary, the result could be “strongly reduced export volumes and negative effects on investment and employment in the United States.”
There is nothing Trump supports that helps the 99%!!
And just think, Atlanta has a brand spanking new Mercedes-Bendz Stadium. But perhaps that’s all about football, and football is all about Trump’s kind of patriotism that disallows protest.
https://www.mercedes-benz.com/en/mercedes-benz/sports/football/the-new-mercedes-benz-stadium-in-atlanta-video/
As so many people have commented, Trump wears blinders and never looks at or even considers the bigger picture.
We can only hope. Their pain and anxiety concerning our Dear Leader’s (shall we be generous and call them) policies gives me great satisfaction. Especially when they whine and still say they will give our Dear Leader the benefit of a doubt if they are only hurt in the short term. Let’s hope, for them, it’s the long term.
“We can only hope” may be the operative phrase. In the aggregate right now it is only 180 per American family. How that translates to any given industry or state per family may be significantly different.
““But this new front in the trade war carries substantial risk not just for the auto industry but for Mr. Trump and Republican officeholders nationwide,…”
We can dream of this getting through to Trump’s loyal voters. It’s too bad that hitting them in the pocketbook will cause rippling effect disaster. Remember, Trump is a failed businessman who lives to bully. He falsely believes that he has superior intelligence and is above the law.
What will it take to bring this full blown idiot down?
The GOP are cowards. I am not a subscriber to WaPo and only got this message.
..
Senate approves symbolic criticism of Trump’s tariffs following failed efforts to block them
The Senate on Tuesday passed a nonbinding measure calling for Congress to have a role in tariffs imposed on the basis of national security, an implicit rebuke of President Trump’s move to tax imported steel and aluminum from Canada, Mexico, the European Union and other trading partners.
The measure does not explicitly criticize Trump, nor would it have any power to force a White House course change. Republican Sens. Bob Corker (Tenn.) and Patrick J. Toomey (Pa.) had previously sought a vote on a more forceful push for congressional oversight of Trump’s tariffs, but their efforts were not backed by GOP leadership and did not get a vote.
Great article stating that Trump nor any of his administration can be trusted. Love this quote, “Any action taken by this president* while in office should be considered prima facie as either corrupt or incompetent until proven otherwise.”
……………
This President* Never Deserves the Benefit of the Doubt
By Charles Pierce, Esquire
11 July 18
Over the weekend, there was some slanging and banging on the electric Twitter machine over a very interesting topic: whether or not it is Good Journalism to continue to cover extensively the president*’s gin-up-the-rubes rallies, at which he says the same stuff, over and over again, as though there is any real news value in anything said by this moldy bag of old resentments.
One side argued, with some logic, that, like it or not, the guy is the president* and what he says has inherent news value simply because he says it. The other side argued that he is still Donald Trump, and that, among our presidents, he is uniquely unqualified, uniquely uninformed, uniquely unoriginal, and, most important, uniquely compromised, although to what extent we won’t know until Robert Mueller unleashes the hounds this fall. Therefore, goes this line of thinking, covering this guy as though he were Dwight Eisenhower, or W.H. Taft, or James K. Polk—which is to say, giving him the benefit of the doubts that accrue to his office—is to obscure the unique threat to our institutions that this president* embodies with a cloud of dangerous political banality.
Any action taken by this president* while in office should be considered prima facie as either corrupt or incompetent until proven otherwise. Anybody hired by this administration* should be considered prima facie unqualified for the job given to them. And any judges nominated should be considered prima facieunworthy of having been nominated simply on the basis of the president* who nominated them.
The phrase is, “sui generis.” Get used to it….
https://www.esquire.com/news-politics/politics/a22094866/donald-trump-sui-generis/
Charles Pierce is the greatest.
Its difficult to understand the evilness that this president and his swamp minions give off. It hard to understand why he and his base hate everyone so much. Peter King spoke about how the Europeans were snobbish on TV today. A grown man talking like a high school student. It didn’t take long for Trump to reduce people to his sick level of high school maturity..
Trump was so smart why didn’t he serve in Viet Nam he is so brave. His campaign promise was to ensure you lost your job, now that is a winning slogan stated by a person who has no understanding of the world.
Nothing he does makes sense because his goal is to destroy the country and especially the people who voted him into office. Maybe he will give British Boris the do nothing hater a job in the white house administration of haters
I think most of what Trump does, Tweets and vocalizes is designed to further Putin’s goals —- to destroy the United States and the EU.
ENTER The Justice Democrats (stage left): “The aim is to create a genuinely populist Democratic party, which neutralises Trump’s brutal demagoguery and speaks to people across the political spectrum who have been alienated by the corruption and drift of mainstream politics.”
https://www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2018/jul/11/america-left-alexandria-ocasio-cortez-new-york-primary
https://www.theguardian.com/us-news/2018/jul/11/alexandria-ocasio-cortez-bronx-primary-win
The “Justice Democrats”? Is that a thing now?
Did you read today that Alexandra won another primary in a district she wasn’t running for next to the district she won — she wasn’t even listed on the ballot. Enough voters wrote her name in and she won, but the law doesn’t allow her to run for two Congressional seats.
It’s the thing now. It’s the thing to come. Justice for the working class, for immigrants fleeing for their lives and for a better future, for the inclusive everyone — for my students — is the future. Socially responsible. Social justice. Social Democrats.
LCT: “Justice for the working class” It sounds beautiful BUT how many of the working class adore the Orange IDIOT and will never vote for any justice. They like looking down upon someone lower on the economic scale…immigrants, browns and blacks. tRump is giving them what they want.
Forget the word ‘socialism’. Bernie was yelled at for using such a ‘demeaning’ word. I voted for Bernie but too many people cringe at the thought of ‘socialism’. They don’t understand what it means but it obviously is something that would destroy the US. How do we change that limited thinking?
When I hear the words “social justice” these days, I head for the door.
Enough voters WROTE IN HER NAME that she won.
LCT: That was in a heavy Democratic locality. Try that in Indiana or Idaho. “Socialism’ is a dirty word according to Repubs who worship the Orange Monster.
carolmalaysia – yes, but in Indiana+ and Idaho+ they think Hillary Clinton is a socialist, so it does no good to go further right to try to persuade those folks to vote Democrat. Go left and explain to people – as Bernie did – what democratic socialism is all about and how it benefits people. When you poll individual planks of the socialist platform, people overwhelmingly support them. People want us out of foreign entanglements. They want banks regulated (or even broken up). They want smaller, friendlier, community-based companies rather than large multi-national corporations who can buy everything. They want strong public education. They want healthcare. They want affordable college – even tuition free public and community college. They want environmental protections. In other words, they want all of what democratic socialism has to offer, they’ve just been trained to fear the word “socialist”. Bernie started to change that. We need more of that.
I don’t mean to smear all people of Indiana or Idaho. There are plenty of informed, intelligent voters in all red states. But those states happen to have a higher percentage of low information voters who are prone to be lured into ignorance, religious fundamentalism, racism and/or hatred as a way (they think) to soothe their anger about the increasing lack of control and decreasing standard of living they have been experiencing.
dienne77: Well stated.
I grew up in Idaho and now live in Indiana. I’m astounded at the number of low information voters in both states. Even intelligent, educated people can fall into this if they get their information from Fox.
So much for Trump who isn’t smart enough to understand intelligence briefings. Fox is making money off of telling Trump and his followers how wonderful he is.
Lloyd Lofthouse
That 2nd district may not have been all that much of a fete you might have been able to measure voter turn out on your fingers and toes.
dienne77
I fully agree and you may not win in the first election cycle. You may not win the second but eventually, you will. The alternative is already been tried and all one has to do is look at the electoral map.
carolmalaysia
We will never know what the working class would do if they are never given the opportunity to have an alternative. Amazing how Trump latched on to several left-wing populist Ideas.
So we are talking trade. Whose issue was the objection to Multilateral trade agreements written by corporate elites.
Whose issue was an objection to temporary!!!! work Visas either H1Bs or H2Bs. Which is not the same as immigration except that on the high end of the wage spectrum many of those workers convert to permanent status.
So it is complicated. On both issues, we are picking winners and losers. You don’t want to pretend that it is any different. The multiplier effect of the Washington consensus on trade was up to 15 million lost jobs in manufacturing regions. Which may have been offset by other jobs in other jobs throughout the economy. Or perhaps they weren’t. Since the end of the recession in 2003, the prime age worker participation rate has been 2-3% lower than between 88-99.
Now it would be a rare day that I found myself in agreement with the man whose rant is credited with launching the tea party. Friday morning when the employment number was released, Rick Santelli explained the stagnant wage growth. Real unemployment may be closer to the U6 number 6.8%. So like data in education we can put on rose-colored glasses and make it prove whatever we want it to.
If the economy is running at full steam; why are so many fewer male and female workers between 25-54 years of age out of the workforce.
If the economy is running at full steam why is wage inflation nonexistent.
But do I believe that the Trump voter is actually motivated by economic distress? NO!
But Dean Baker does cut through the nonsense on trade.
http://cepr.net/publications/op-eds-columns/six-lies-on-trade
Hillary? Who’s that?
:o)
I couldn’t’ resist.
Hilary Swank
And I’ve been wanting to write this for hours.
Who would win if we threw Donald Trump, Bill Clinton, and G. W. Bush naked into a 12 x 12 cage together and they were told that no one eats or drinks until only two of them remain and one is dead?
Donald Trump, Bill Clinton, and G.W. Bush walk into a bar. Franklin Delano Roosevelt tells them to leave.
FDR only tells them to leave? I was hoping for more. Maybe he could send them to an internment camp in the middle of Death Valley.
ONE THING THEY HAVE IN COMMON: Hate. Now they have a president who personifies it! The message doesn’t matter – they love it that he GETS AWAY WITH SPEWING HATE!
Tea Partiers hated government. Koch and friends co-opted them.
Republicans hated big government. Now they love it because they got the power.
Wealthy blame the immigrants and “welfare” seekers because they ($) have to pay for public education and public services.
Pro-lifers hate Supreme Court.
Poor folks blamed corporate America.
Farmers blamed cities
Wall Street and Corporate production hate Regulation.
Racists hate everyone.
As for the “barely a peep” – – The only poster in any State Rally for Senate or House should be “IF YOU ARE SILENT YOU ARE COMPLICIT.. and just wait!”
Isn’t this sweet! Doesn’t it feel wonderful to no longer be forgotten! What a pile of SH**!! Pence is a sycophant of the lowest order. [He was once my governor in Indiana. There was a good chance that he wouldn’t have won the governorship in the next election. Sorry that he isn’t a long forgotten page out of history.]
This comes from the WH:
In The Kansas City Star, Vice President Mike Pence explains how the Trump agenda is working for America’s heartland. “The results we are seeing in Kansas City and across the country are nothing short of remarkable. Since Kansas and Missouri elected Trump, businesses large and small have created nearly 3.7 million new jobs across the country,” the Vice President writes. “Under President Donald Trump, the forgotten men and women of America are forgotten no more.”
The Los Angeles Times has run a front page report on a typical Middle America city in Missouri where the Trump tariffs have already cost jobs — but where Trump supporters remain loyal to Trump. The #1 issue with Trump voters is immigration, not jobs, and even when they lose their jobs because of Trump policies, they remain enthusiastic about him because he is attacking immigration. The reported biggest feat that white Middle America has isn’t losing jobs and health care — it’s that the white race will become the minority race in America. Nothing else matters to them but that whites remain the majority in America. And so long as Trump continues rolling back immigration levels and deporting immigrants, they will remain loyal. Democrats need to get that hard fact through their heads: Nothing is going to break Trump’s core away from him. Democrats must focus on winning-over the independent voters and turning out the vote of Democratic Party members. Progressive people are the worst when it comes to actually voting. All mouth and protests, but stay-at-home on election day because their particular pet issue wasn’t given top attention by the Democratic Party. That’s because there’s no such thing as a “progressive ideology”. Progressives are just a gaggle of splinter groups that each support only their own narrow pet agenda.
On this issue, Leo Gerard has more credibility than Charlie Pierce.
Do you have a link?
“The times are gone that a producer was only headquartered in one country with production in that country and exporting from that country to the rest of the world,” said Erik Jonnaert, the secretary general of the European Automobile Manufacturers’ Association, in an interview in Brussels.”
DUH!!!
Amazing we have such an antiquated dunderhead in WH – here he is, ticking off another economic-reality-check-free campaign promise made to his core of anachronistic dunderheads, no doubt in direct defiance of expert advice…
P.S. Thanks Diane for continuing to post political as well as ed topics. The two are inextricable anyway, & I always find I need to keep my political/ history brain updated in order to make sense of educational developments. And it is always a learning experience to share conversation with the sharp minds posting here.
Sometimes people actually get what they vote for….
The Jeep I am driving here in Hungary was made in Italy.
In this global economy, tariffs seem to make little sense: even if a car is put together in a certain country, its parts are almost always made in many different countries.
It has been that way for years. A John Deere tractor was run by a German fuel pump and a French alternator. In 19770. Surely even Trump knows that. So why is he doing it? To stir his anti-everything base. We have returned to the days of the 1830 Know-nothing party, which was essentially against everything Catholic. They never got elected.
“So why is he doing it?”
Well, it’s probably also true that US cars are heavily taxed in the EU.
Fiat, an Italian company, owns Alfa Romeo, Chrysler, Dodge, Ferrari, Jeep, Lancia, Maserati, Ram and SRT.
Trump is now working the Supreme Court as a means to get rid of Mueller. His appointment of Justice Kavanaugh would make this possible.
Good for George Will, a conservative columnist, for realizing the Orange IDIOT is unfit for his job.
………………………….
George F. Will: Is Trump correct that Mueller’s appointment was unconstitutional?
Washington • The president, who might not be fully acquainted with the pertinent Supreme Court case law, says the appointment of Robert Mueller as special counsel was unconstitutional. The president’s opinion, because it is his, is prima facie evidence for the opposite conclusion. It is, however, not sufficient evidence. Consider the debate between two serious people who have immersed themselves in the history of the Appointments Clause, which says:…
Two intelligent lawyers disagree about this momentous matter, concerning which the Supreme Court’s nine justices might eventually be dispositive. If Mueller’s appointment is challenged, and the case gets to the court, and five justices reason as Calabresi does, Mueller’s subpoenas, indictments and other acts will be null and void.
I found this article from The Salt Lake Tribune that you might be interested in: https://www.sltrib.com/opinion/commentary/2018/07/11/george-f-will-is-trump
There is more truth to this than we’d like to admit.
……………….
Man Wins “Why Trump Shouldn’t Go to Prison” Essay Contest..Satire from Andy Borowitz, from the New Yorker
The man, Brett Kavanaugh, received his award for the winning essay at a ceremony at the White House on Monday night.
WASHINGTON (The Borowitz Report)—A Washington, D.C., man has won a nationwide essay contest on the topic “Why Donald J. Trump Shouldn’t Go to Prison.”
The man, Brett Kavanaugh, received his award for the winning essay at a ceremony at the White House on Monday night.
Kavanaugh’s essay, which was distributed to the press shortly after he was announced as the winner, reads as follows: “Donald J. Trump should never go to prison because he is the President of the United States and the President of the United States is a very important person in the country…
https://www.newyorker.com/humor/borowitz-report/man-wins-why-trump-shouldnt-go-to-prison-essay-contest
I generally support most (not all) of Pres. Trump’s economic policies. I must break ranks here. Tariffs cost jobs, increase prices, and stifle competition. Everyone, from the individual consumer, right up to management and the government, loses.
The late, nobel-prize winning economist Milton Friedman, advocated eliminating all tariffs on trade, and opening up all worldwide markets to free competition.
This trade war, is going to be a disaster for every one.
Going back to education topic: A bill that needs your attention – Republican Senator Co-Sponsors Police State Bill
Recently Texas U. S. Senator John Cornyn signed onto the College Transparency Act of 2017 (S.1121) that will overturn the ban on a federal student data system and establish lifelong tracking of individuals by the federal government. Supporters of the bill are licking their chops, claiming that support from the second ranking GOP Senator signals passage.
The bill purports to be about transparency and analysis of Federal aid programs, college majors and future earnings. Yet the facts below show there is far more to the bill than what the public is being told.
All enrollees in higher education will have their personally identifiable information (PII) collected without notice or consent, right to opt out, or right to review and correct data.
All private student data will be shared among multiple federal agencies, including the U.S. Department of Education’s Office of Federal Student Aid; Social Security Administration; Census Bureau; and Departments of Treasury, Defense, and Veterans Affairs — with others likely to be added.
All of the collected data along with data already held by federal agencies will be stored in a central federal database and routinely updated – in perpetuity.
There are no limits on the purposes for using the data.
The Commissioner of Education Statistics is required to periodically review the data elements and add more as needed.
Even though data provided to researchers is without identification, it’s easy to identify the individual.
It does not mandate security audits and encryption and protocols for detection and notification of security breaches or address limits on data retention and minimization.
There is no reason for the federal government to collect data on college students because each public, private and for-profit two-year and four-year institution reports data about all students who entered a degree or certificate program, whether or not they are enrolled full-time or are first-time students.
This brings up the question, then, about why the federal government needs personally identifiable information about a student. Or why it is involved in federal aid to students. Or even why it is involved in higher education, a right that is left to the states under the Tenth Amendment.
Critics of the bill, including Congresswoman Dr. Virginia Foxx who authored the 2008 amendment that bans a student database, are highly concerned about the total loss of our Fourth Amendment right to privacy if the ban is overturned.
They have good reason to fear because the federal government has a long track record of lying to the American people about their seizing unconstitutional control over a function, demanding data, and then stripping people of their Constitutional rights through strangling regulations over their lives.
The D.C. establishment lied about the No Child Left Behind reauthorization of the unconstitutional Elementary and Secondary Education Act of 1965 and the latest reauthorization, Every Student Succeeds Act. Despite claims to the contrary, these bills seized more federal control over education while demanding massive quantities of data on students.
To accomplish this, the feds required each state to create a longitudinal database system to store PII that is collected during standardized testing and while children are using online curriculum programs.
Once there is a national student database, it will be a simple matter to connect all state databases with the national database. And there you have it. A dossier on each person like that found in China and other totalitarian nations.
If the College Transparency Act of 2017 passes, the federal government will be able to track you throughout your life using education, financial, medical, employment, wage, and workforce data.
It’s unlikely the D.C. swamp is going to listen to the people and stop this Orwellian bill dead in its tracks.