Karen Attiah is an editor at the Washington Post.
She writes:
I have reached the regrettable conclusion that the Negro’s great stumbling block toward freedom is not the White citizen’s councilor or the Klu Klux Klanner, but the white moderate who is more devoted to order than justice; who prefers a negative peace which is the absence of tension, to a positive peace, which is the presence of justice; who constantly says, ‘I agree with you with the goals that you seek, but can’t agree with your methods of direct action.” — the Rev. Martin Luther King Jr., “Letter From Birmingham Jail,” 1963
I have reached a regrettable conclusion in the era of Trump. I no longer have hope in white America.
After White House press secretary Sarah Huckabee Sanders was politely asked to leave a restaurant in Virginia, discussion among the largely white political and media classes erupted into a firestorm over “civility” in the Trump era. Those of us whose identities have made us the direct targets of the Trump administration’s hateful rhetoric and discriminatory policies are told to not stoop to President Trump’s level. We are then fed cherry-picked quotes from black luminaries, often the Rev. Martin Luther King Jr. — “Returning hate for hate multiplies hate, adding deeper darkness to a night already devoid of stars” — or a favorite from Michelle Obama’s convention speech: “When they go low, we go high.”
The whitewashed version of a heroic, nonconfrontational King ignores the fact that he favored direct action and confrontation, and was painted as an extremist in his time. White Americans hated and jailed him. And ultimately, it was a white American who murdered him in broad daylight.
As for going high? Trump rose to power in no small part due to his promises to bury the political accomplishments of the first black president. It is easy for those who have privilege — the privilege of never being denied the opportunity to serve in the military because of their gender identity, of never being afraid of police brutality, of never facing anti-Muslim animus, of never being a migrant forcibly separated from his or her children — to lecture us who do not enjoy such privileges to conduct peaceful resistance in a way that doesn’t make others uncomfortable. But these demands for civility from the privileged, largely white political class who claim a desire to oppose Trumpism and injustice sound very much like the stumbling block of white moderates that King wrote about 55 years ago.
Those of us who knew we were under threat from Trump have, since Election Day 2016, been told that America’s institutions will protect us from Trumpism. Congress would be a check. The responsibility of the office of the presidency would humble him. None of this has happened. This week, the Supreme Court in a 5-4 decision decided to ignore the president’s Islamophobic rhetoric and upheld his ban on travelers from certain majority-Muslim countries, legally sanctioning Trump’s anti-Muslim animus into official policy. Now that Justice Anthony Kennedy has announced his retirement, Trump can shape the court even more in his own image for decades to come.
All of this leads to the question of hope. For those who have been working to fight for civil rights for people of all creeds, colors, genders and nationalities, it is a very dark time. What do we do?
In her book “I’m Still Here: Black Dignity in a World Made for Whiteness,” writer Austin Channing Brown says she has “learned not to fear the death of hope. In order for me to stay in this work, hope must die.” She writes: “I cannot hope in whiteness, I cannot hope in white institutions or white America, I cannot hope in lawmakers or politicians. I cannot hope in misquoted wisdom from MLK, superficial ethnic heritage celebrations or love that is aloof. I cannot even even hope in myself. I am no one’s savior.” Instead, she has decided to embrace the shadow of hope, opting to continue “working in the dark not knowing if anything I do will ever make a difference.”
After the past few days, I have decided to embrace the shadow of hope as well. This doesn’t mean I’m not encouraged by positive developments. It is good that federal judges are challenging Trump’s family separation policy. It is good that those of us from minority groups are organizing across intersectional lines. We should be heartened by the New York primary win of Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez, a 28-year-old community organizer from the Bronx who beat establishment-Democratic powerhouse Rep. Joseph Crowley. Her win is a reminder that in the face of Trumpism, and of establishment parties that are slow to respond to the needs of the marginalized, we will make our presence known. But we will continue to struggle, to write, to resist, to confront, to march and to dissent, even if it is done in the darkness. The struggles of our forebears demand nothing less.

Agree.
LikeLike
I agree with Karen Attiah whole heartedly, but so sad heartedly. Time to take off the gloves.
LikeLike
How are the words of professional victim Karen Attiah not as racist as the worst tRump bile? “I no longer have hope in white America.”
All this whiny drivel will do is alienate the people who would otherwise (that is otherwise if you weren’t calling every white person in America a racist) support fairness for all.
Sine the author above likes to generalize and stereotype based on race I’ll take a swing at it too.
Perhaps the author should take a look at Black America and ask why they don’t support LGBT rights or any other issues that Liberal and Progressives do. Black Americans consistently lag very far behind white Americans in supporting civil rights for Gay Americans. Moreover, black Americans consistently do not see the struggle for gay rights as a civil rights issue.
Perhaps she should take a look at why Black America has one thing in common with Dems and Liberals and Progressives: Civil rights for blacks. Everything else is what Black Americans have in common with the exact southern evangelical racists who are stepping on the heads of black Americans.
Black Americans showed up for half black Obama but couldn’t be bothered to vote against tRump with the same effort. How does the author think those facts embolden our Racist In Chief in the White House? Easy; he seems them as weak ineffectual self-serving cowards only concerned with who they perceive as their own. Moreover, I think tRump’s hatred of Obama is personal not race based. Obama was an asshole to tRump and baited him every chance he got. Obama largely brought this upon himself but humiliating tRump publicly several times. So I think you have an answer desperate for a question.
There are many reasons Hillary Clinton lost. Mostly her own faults as a person and a candidate. But let’s also be honest that there wasn’t a white voter surge for tRump despite the black narrative about that. Black Americans simply didn’t bother to vote against tRump in the same numbers they did agasint Romney and McCain. I’d suggest the author look all I’ve said up but she doesn’t seem to research anything before publishing so I have no hope she’ll care about facts inconvenient to her career as a victim but I’ll still hope for Black America.
Perhaps the author should consider that she has the President she deserves.
LikeLike
None of us has the president we deserve. I wouldn’t wish Trump on my worst enemies. He is dismantling our democracy, bit by bit.
LikeLike
“None of us has the president we deserve. I wouldn’t wish Trump on my worst enemies. He is dismantling our democracy, bit by bit.”
We absolutely have the President we deserve. I’m pretty sure this is exactly how Democracy works. There have been no surprises with tRump. He’s doing exactly what he set out to do. Exactly what he said he’d do.
So if you were breathing in America and you saw that man talking on the news, and he was everywhere in the news for a long time, and you didn’t bother to vote, then you got what you deserve. Ask anyone near 100 years old and they will assure you this country has survived far worse than that idiot in the White House.
The job of President has been on an imperious path for decades. tRump’s move to the extreme right is only made possible because the Clintons and Obama move the center so far to the right that tRump doesn’t look extreme to tens of millions of Americans. Just because a great many of those people feel like they have nothing left to lose doesn’t make them all racists.
Moreover, there is no excuse for calling all white Americans racist. Tolerating that, or worse tacitly endorsing it, is exactly what a few people like Bill Maher have been warning us about for decades. We ignored it. And now look what we have done.
LikeLike
Pat,
Who was worse than the Orange Idiot?
I can’t recall. He is a genuine bred-in-the-bone fascist. When have we ever had a fascist president?
LikeLike
@ Pat W. Martin: I am Charles E. Martin, maybe we are related. The American electorate chose electors, pledged to Mr. Trump. Many liberal/progressive people chose to sit the 2016 election out, and then got what they deserved. Silence is Consent.
There have been few surprises by this president. He is doing what he said he would do.
Not all white Americans are racists and bigots. And the USA does not have a monopoly on that. I have travelled all over South Africa, and have seen the apartheid system up close.
We have had presidents “worse” than the current occupant. We have a congress and a Supreme Court, to serve as “checks’. And we have an election coming up in November, where we can express our wishes.
LikeLike
We have never had a president worse than Trump. He is enriching himself and his family, in violation of the Emoluments Clause in the Constitution. He has betrayed our allies and allied the US with our enemies. He is a traitor.
Can you name even one president who did either?
LikeLike
White guy here.
Perhaps Pat Martin should bugger off.
LikeLike
Black Americans may well save this country. As for Obama humiliating Trump – did he make the big baby angry? Maybe he spoke truth to other power. Trump has personal animus, but is also nodding to his base undoing all accomplishments engendered by the black guy. How else can you explain support for policies that are hurting them, such as health care? We were all disappointed by the turn out in the last election, but it is also the fault of the Bernie Bros (and Sisters) who refused to vote for Clinton, and didn’t show up, or voted for Stein.
LikeLike
You need to check the science on this. The people who voted for Bernie, just like the people who voted for Nader, would not have voted for anyone else. I know plenty of these people. They are very principled and they will not just vote for whoever the Dem Establishment tells them to. If you don’t know any of those kinds of voters then you should try to meet some. They aren’t cheerleaders who get behind whoever they are told to by Sheeple Control. And they don’t care about the PC crap of voting for someone because of superficial qualities like skin color or being born without a penis.
Hillary lost for several reasons including the Dem Party was more interested in electing a woman than in winning or in giving Dem Voters who they wanted. But the main reason she lost to the worst candidate ever is all to do with her being a bad candidate and a worse person. Perhaps more black voters in Michigan would have voted for Clinton if she’d had enough care to visit them. Or Wisconsin… But she didn’t. That sends a message. Apparently, they received the message.
There was also an element of plain old bad luck in Clinton’s loss. A candidate like her was just the very opposite of what the country was looking for. There’s an interesting idea about how American voters look for the opposite in some ways of whoever was last President. If Obama has been less of a Wall Street Ivy League Bro then Clinton would have coasted to victory. Or, as a comedian said, ‘You Dems voted for the black half but got the white half! HAHAHA’
Unless Dems do the hard work of blaming themselves for the loss tRump will have a great chance of a 2nd term. And I see no evidence any Dems are looking within for fault. So keep calling every white person a racist and then tell me again in 2020 how you didn’t deserve tRump’s 2nd term.
LikeLike
Two terms of a fascist and this country will never be the same.
LikeLike
“but I’ll still hope for Black America.”
Save your lecture and keep your hope.
Black America doesn’t need your hope.
If you see a wrong that needs to be made right, YOU need to DO something.
Get your people, and do better. Get on the side of justice or get the hell out of the way.
LikeLike
Clinton was not a bad candidate, she was targeted as such, blacks don’t hate all white people but the system does reward white privelege more than any other group. No trump is not solely responsible for the swing of fascism that has affected our country but he’s benefitting the most from it now. We must fight for the right to control the democratic narrative in America now or let the corporate, fascist state take over and Diane’s right, we won’t have the same country anymore. We have to do it, not wait for the detached demos or the spineless Repubs to act, we must and it has to be in November, we have to show up
LikeLike
OMG – Clinton was a monumentally bad candidate, I believe. I also believe democrats must face that opinion and at least try to understand why so many of us think so.
LikeLike
Being very white, save for a possible smidgen of Native American blood, I still think Karen Attiah has it right. I would only add that “don’t rock the boat” is a human trait not confined to one skin color. MLK was far from universally loved for stirring up trouble in more than the white community. Still, change never comes cheaply, and it certainly seems to carry more than its share of pain for those who are in the line of fire. People can argue over tactics, but some battles are going to require taking off the white gloves once in awhile. So much is just wrong with the Trump administration that we cannot ignore. I admire those who manage to always present a cool and in control image, but, while I am not good at it, I think there is a place for more “in your face” styles.
LikeLike
Here is my secret wish.
I recalled when Rupert Murdoch was testifying before Parliament about his newspaper’s nasty habit of wiretapping people, and a protester came very close to hitting him in the face with a cream pie. His then-wife, Wendy Deng, jumped up and saved him from the indignity. I have a few thoughts, dreams really, about which of our leaders deserves a cream pie. But it would be a far, far better thing to elect a Democratic Senate Majority this fall.
LikeLike
A cream pie is nice, but I find my thoughts on this subject drifting to tar and feathering.
LikeLike
I’m mot a violent person. When I am watching a movie and it turns violent, I close my eye. I tend to think that ridicule is more effective and I don’t have to lose my eyes.
LikeLike
I can remember as a teenager during the civil rights era arguing with my dad, a blue collar, union card carrying conservative, about MLK. I saw King as an amazing leader and speaker fighting for justice. My dad called him a “trouble maker,” even though we both agreed on equal rights in theory. Dad felt King was going about it the “wrong way.” What is the right way when we see fifty years of progress go up in flames? Elizabeth Warren recently commented tearfully contemplating our collective future in one of her recent speeches. My dad is long gone, but I haven’t changed. I still admire King and his legacy, and I am still proud to be a “bleeding heart,” my dad’s term for me. We are all still waiting for equal rights and treatment under the law.
LikeLike
Many –most? –Trump supporters would have voted for Ben Carson over Hillary. It seems to me the significance of racism in America may be less than progressive orthodoxy would have it. The Trumpsters hate all Whole Foods shoppers; they only hate some blacks.
LikeLiked by 1 person
“The whitewashed version of a heroic, nonconfrontational King ignores the fact that he favored direct action and confrontation….”
Yes, very true, but that action and confrontation always came from a place of love (agape) even – especially – for the oppressor. MLK, like the Christ he worshiped, would have served Sarah Sanders had he been in a position to do so.
LikeLike
Fluck Sarah sanders, if she’s a public figure, expect feedback from the public. Democrats want to feel that their party is fighting back for them, not just sitting back allowing lying trump and his minions the last word on everything. If trump is innocent, why is he disrupting the Russian investigation instead of allowing it to come to its own conclusion? It’s time to speak out, kudos to Maxine Waters, who needs ss protection more than that lying Sanders.
LikeLike
So much of the animus that is pervasive appears to be fed by media, both social and news. A day rarely passes that an African American isn’t the victim of some white injustice. While these events are terrible and unconscionable, unfortunately they have probably been the norm for centuries. What is difficult is that the constant “in your face” throwback that Caucasians are hit with as if all of these things are related to racism. It is getting hard to take I am beginning to think that I am under attack because of my race as in all white people are racists. It makes for defensiveness.
This is the most divisive time that I remember in America in my 65 plus years. I hope there is a solution but until it appears I will keep my head down. I feel uncomfortable for even posting this. I despise Trump and everything that relates to him or his supporters. I keep hoping that SOMETHING will happen but the craziness continues. For me it is heartbreaking. I expect it is like that for many others.
LikeLiked by 1 person
The system is racist and it benefits white people, if you haven’t realized this in 65 yrs, there’s not much enlightenment for you now
LikeLike
What system are you referring to in your post. I would like to know so that I can steer clear of it. It is frightening to think that it is out there.
LikeLike
I think messages have gotten mixed. I think everyone in their right mind knows this is a time to protest, not be civil. We merely must watch the tone of our protests so that they do not liken us to our gutter-rat president. Marches, fine. Denying tables to evil lackeys, fine. Mean-Tweeting, maybe not.
LikeLike
A whole new world order of difference between telling Sanders we can’t in good conscience serve you due to the policies you represent and yelling, “Go home, Sarah! You’re vermin!”
LikeLike
What’s “White America”?
LikeLike
People who don’t want the ongoing quest for equality, dignity, and resistance to white supremacy to get in the way of brunch or a golf outing. And they certainly don’t approve of athletes taking a knee.
LikeLike
So it’s some subset of white people who brunch, play golf “outings,” and don’t like Colin Kaepernick. Phew, I was afraid I was white for a second there.
LikeLiked by 1 person
When I think about athletes taking a knee, I think about these guys. WOW!
https://www.washingtonpost.com/news/retropolis/wp/2017/09/24/they-didnt-takeaknee-the-black-power-protest-salute-that-shook-the-world-in-1968/?noredirect=on&utm_term=.bc3fc7d5895e
LikeLike
In 2016 pollsters found one common factor among future president’s supporters: They ALL responded AGREE to: “People like me do not have a say in anything.”
Think about it.
Who wasn’t sitting at the cool kids table during the Obama years?
Wall Street boys, Rich suburbanites, blue collar losing jobs, overregulated business owners, farmers, the Nf******RA all felt on the outs – blamed an African-American president, a too smart (and bad campaigning) woman, and scape-goated immigrants, folks in poverty, and the unpatriotic kneeling African-American NFL.
They all wanted some screaming and yelling, bad mouthing anyone who stood up to him, hit the right buttons of patriotism and the military and the swamp of old school DC democrats. And used his code and right wing playbook to make sure the white supremicists and rich right wingers knew he had their backs.
He won.
The gop white boys are scared to death to speak up for what they know is right or wrong.
But so do the democrats. Who’s screaming and yelling at him. Who’s calling him out for changing the narrative on guns, immigration, and protest.
He’s convinced America that every immigrant is in the MS-13 gang. That African-Americans are anti-military and unpatriotic. That intellectuals and research are bad things.
We march. “We” got more votes. We listen to the right (left) tv and radio. We’re nice – but at least speak.
But the folks who represent us with few exceptions are silent.
Rise up!
LikeLike
I miss the Kennedys. For some strange reason I can’t think of any Democrats other than Bernie Sanders and some lady named Pocahontas.
LikeLike
“Who wasn’t sitting at the cool kids table during the Obama years?
Wall Street boys, Rich suburbanites,…”
I had to read that several times to make sure you’re saying what I think you’re saying and i’m still not sure. You’re seriously saying that Wall Street and rich suburbanites felt left out of Obama’s presidency? Well, I guess I can’t tell anyone else how they feel, but if that’s the case, talk about professional victims! Wall Street boys and rich suburbanites were among the biggest winners of the Obama presidency! The people who should have felt left out (along with the blue collar workers that you properly included) are black people. Obama did nothing for them other than lecture them about respectability and fatherhood (while locking up ever increasing numbers of those fathers).
LikeLiked by 1 person
Ask those folks about regulations to protect the environment and, oh, kids’ breathing. Ask them about regulations on their coal mines, factories, excessive drug prices, Ask them about melting ice caps. Prison reform. And, ask them about having a President who wasn’t rich, male, and white. They boo hoo felt left out.
Come on – they could have been making zillions and it wouldn’t matter, President Obama would still be black, Hillary would still be an intellectual who didn’t shut up when they entered the room, Bernie actually had loyal followers based on principles. They found their boy. A screaming, prejudiced rich white guy.
If you didn’t like that analogy, try this one:
In the spirit of Beverly Daniel Tatum’s “Why Are All the Black Kids Sitting Together in the Cafeteria” — well, in 2008 the black kids – and the environmentalists, women, lgbtq, DACA kids and a lot more started sitting ALL OVER THE CAFETERIA – and those other kids didn’t like that. They increased gun sales, found their scapegoats, bought up their newspapers and Fox/Pravda and found a guy with no scruples to scream.
LikeLike
Definitely true. Obama was the consummate candidate of and for the professional classes. Among the bankers and “white shoe” lawyers in NYC with whom I worked and socialized at that time, there was an instinctive understanding that he was “one of us,” and that he had a baseline level of managerial competence that could be trusted without reservation. He was the kind of person that members of the professional class want to work with and work for.
LikeLike
Yep
LikeLike
It is unfortunate that ‘white people’ is used as though the terrible incidents are all due to racism. For the black person it surely does seem so. Reason tells him that not all white people are the same way but emotion wins out and too many see the cause of the pain in ‘white people’, unfortunately.
There has to be protest, and struggle, for nothing is achieved without it. Yet we must all be on guard and as Akademos says we must watch the tone of our protests. That is not easy, and it will test us as we go forward, as we try to address women’s rights, labor issues, public education, injustice on blacks, and try to vote in a democratic majority. I am reminded of the words of Terry Goodkind: ‘if the road is easy you’re likely going the wrong way.’ We are headed in the right direction.
LikeLike
Well, I agree with Karen Attiah, and I am disheartened by some of these comments. How dare anyone call her a “professional victim”?
LikeLike
We are in the age of name calling – either side, it is the “new normal”. Aarrgghhh!!! I hate that term.
LikeLike
This is a defeatist column. White America will be the voting majority for the next 30 years minimum. So basically she is saying, I give up.
LikeLike
Too much focus on group identity. Not enough focus on policies that advance the interests of all working people.
LikeLike
Thank you, Flerp.
Most Black and Latino people are workers. Most women are workers. Most LBGT people are workers. Most people are workers.
Let’s start there, with universal concrete material benefits, directed primarily toward the working class.
LikeLike
I identify as white, and find my self confused by the generalization: “White America”. I’m not sure what “White America” is. Is it a working class, “Middle American” christian of European descent with conservative values? I don’t identify with that. Thats not who I am. I think there’s all kinds of white people in America. What is White America?
A lot of white people voted against Trump, possibly even more than voted for him.
LikeLiked by 1 person
Our political discourse should be about how to advance the interests of all working people. As Michael F. notes, most people are working people, regardless of race, ethnicity, gender, or sexual orientation.
This kind of focus on group identity leads to political discourse that’s about how to assign blame or responsibility to groups and how resources and rights should be reallocated among groups. It has a Balkanizing effect that is completely contrary to the notion that all groups are, essentially, people who have to work for a living and who are in immediate crisis when they are unable to work — whose strongest interests are in being able to retire with dignity, to have access to healthcare without the risk of financial ruin, to have social safety nets in place that protect them when they cannot work, etc.
Political discourse based on group identity is particularly dangerous because Balkanization creates its own momentum. You say you “identify as white.” I suppose I do, too, in the sense that I know which box I’m supposed to check on paperwork, but it’s not remotely a strong feature of my identity, and I suspect it’s not a big part of your identity either. But it’s my belief that, as the US becomes less and less “white,” and more and more focused on the sins of “White America,” white Americans’ racial identities will become increasingly sharpened. Today, “white culture” exists as a real concept only on the far right and certain portions of the far left. On our current trajectory, I expect it to be a concept widely shared among white Americans in the not-so-distant future. This would be a fantastic development for the Republican Party, or whatever political party occupies that space in the future.
LikeLike
FLERP, you hit the nail on the head! I identify first as an old woman, not every old woman. Also, I identify as a person. There are a lot variances in all of us and no one on this earth is the same in all ways than any other.
People find reasons to search for likeness. They choose a church, political party, school, philosophy, lifestyle. To lump all white folks, black folks, young folks, or old folks in the same pot is an injustice.
Generalizations abound but that is all they are. There are also reasons for stereotypes. My mother’s family came largely from Ireland. The Irish are drunks or so we have been told. They even named paddy wagons after the Irish but I don’t drink, nor am I a racist just because of my ancestry. I am an individual as are we all.
LikeLike
Nope, the racial wealth gap must be closed and reparations must be done.
LikeLike
No, trump got more votes from white men and women.
LikeLike
Our political discourse should be about how to advance the interests of all working people. As Michael F. notes, most people are working people, regardless of race, ethnicity, gender, or sexual orientation.
This kind of focus on group identity leads to political discourse that’s about how to assign blame or responsibility to groups and how resources and rights should be reallocated among groups. It has a Balkanizing effect that is completely contrary to the notion that all groups are, essentially, people who have to work for a living and are in immediate crisis when they are unable to work — whose strongest interests are in being able to retire with dignity, to have access to healthcare without the risk of financial ruin, to have social safety nets in place that protect them when they cannot work, etc.
Political discourse based on group identity is particularly dangerous because Balkanization creates its own momentum. You say you “identify as white.” I suppose I do, too, in the sense that I know which box I’m supposed to check on paperwork, but it’s not remotely a strong feature of my identity, and I suspect it’s not a big part of your identity either. But it’s my belief that, as the US becomes less and less “white,” and more and more focused on the sins of “White America,” white Americans’ racial identities will become increasingly sharpened. Today, “white culture” exists as a real concept only on the far right and certain portions of the left. On our current trajectory, I believe that “white culture” will be a concept broadly shared among white Americans in the not-so-distant future. This would be a fantastic development for the Republican Party, or whatever political party occupies that space in the future.
LikeLike
Apologies for the odd double-posting here.
LikeLike
I totally agree with this, we can not wait, trust whites, even moderates who want us also to be civil and accommodating with these repub racist. They will exclaim how bad trump is in public and vote for him privately. Metoo will say how immoral he is and yet defend his policies even when they take away control of their own bodies. Many people of color, mostly black have always known the nature of trump. Hispanics have had to learn how hated they are to actually make a change. Those old school Cubans in Florida will find out after he takes their Medicare/acid and social security away. They’ll feel like they’re still in Cuba under Castro who didn’t take their greedy asses. Anyway, if people allow this trump cult in all its corruption to disrupt our institutions, we didn’t have much faith in them in the beginning. Is allowing the full fruition of democracy, along side people of color with equal opportunities worst than fascism in America? We’ll see in November.
LikeLike
go back to Africa then lol, you won’t be missed
LikeLike