Jesse Hagopian, star teacher and organizer, reports that the Seattle Education Association voted for a moratorium on all standardized testing.
This is a stellar example of teachers taking control of their profession and their classrooms. They are wresting control from uninformed legislators and the greedy testing industry, as well as Congress, which heedlessly imposes mandates without a clue about the damage they do to children, teachers, and education.
He writes:
I am bursting with pride for my union.
The Seattle Education Association voted at this week’s Representative Assembly to support a resolution calling for a moratorium on all standardized testing! This vote comes in a long line of organizing and opposition to high-stakes testing in Seattle.
In 2013, the teachers at Garfield High School voted unanimously to refuse to administer the MAP test. The boycott spread to several other schools in Seattle. When the superintendent threatened the boycotting teachers with a 10 day suspension without pay, non of the teachers backed down. At the end of the year, because of the overwhelming solidarity from parents, teachers, and students around the country, not only were no teachers disciplined, but the superintendent announced that the MAP test would no longer be required for Seattle’s high schools. In the subsequent years we have seen the movement continue to develop with Nathan Hale High School achieving a 100% opt out rate of the junior class of the Smarter Balanced test in 2015, with some 60,000 families opting their kids out of the common core test around Washington State.
whats-wrong-w-standardized-tests-infographic
Despite these heroic efforts to stand up to the testocracy, they are still trying to reduce teaching a learning to a score and use that score to punish students. Thousands of students will not graduate from high school across Washington State simply because they didn’t pass the common core test. The average student in the public schools in the U.S. takes an outlandish 112 standardized tests in the K-12 career–forcing teachers to teach to the test, rather than teach to the student. Study after study has reveled that these tests are a better measure of family income that aptitude. These test measure resources and your proximity to the dominant culture, negatively impacting English Language Learners, special education students, students of color, and low income students.
For all these reasons and more, my colleague Jeff Treistman, introduced a New Business Item (NBI) to bring before the Seattle Education Association this week to consider taking a bold stance against the outrageous over testing of students. Below is a short statement from Jeff explaining his reasoning behind the successful resolution, and gives us the language of the NBI. It is my sincere hope that the Seattle School Board heeds this resolution and moves to implement a “two year moratorium on all standardized testing, at the district, state, and federal levels and to open a public forum along with Seattle Public Schools on the best way to assess our students.”
Continue reading for the statement of Jeff Treistman, who introduced the resolution, as well as the text of the resolution.

Yeehaa!
LikeLiked by 1 person
“Thousands of students will not graduate from high school across Washington State simply because they didn’t pass the common core test.”
And that folks is prima facia evidence that through the state sanctioned testing regime the state, through its schools is unconstitutionally discriminating against some students due to inherent characteristics/capabilities. The state is not allowed to discriminate against other innate characteristics such as skin color, gender, disability and even non-innate religious beliefs. Why the hell is the state allowed to discriminate via mental capabilities rewarding some students and castigating, as with those above-mentioned thousands of students?
Especially considering the discriminating device, standardized tests have are rife with onto-epistemological errors and falsehoods and psychometric fudgings that render the usage of the results of said testing to be completely invalid. I can guarantee that some students will be denied that graduation because of the many errors in the standards and testing regime process. It can’t be denied.
“Any educational practice that is shown to hinder, block and/or otherwise cause an individual to not be able to indulge in any of aspect of his/her rights as stated has to be considered as harmful and unjust not only to the individual but also to society and therefore must rightly be condemned as educational malpractice and ought to be immediately discontinued. Trampled rights are rights that are non-existent and the educational malpractice that tramples any right is unjust and as noted in Alabama’s constitution “is usurpation and oppression” and as Missouri’s declares “. . . when government does not confer this security, it fails in its chief design.”
I contend that many of today’s federal and state mandates and even long standing educational practices are, indeed, malpractices that trample the rights of the most innocent in society, the children, the students of all ages attending public schools, in essence “it [public education] fails in its chief design.” Should the government through the public schools be sorting, separating, ranking, and/or grading students through logically bankrupt invalid practices discriminating against some while rewarding others? I contend it should not! Where is the justice in discriminatory practices? By evaluating those malpractices against the aforementioned purpose we will be able to ascertain whether or not they are just.” (From Ch 1 The Purpose of Public Education in “Infidelity to Truth: Education Malpractice in American Public Education” by D. Swacker)
LikeLike
Another comment on language usage. In the graphic (which is not shown here so you have to go to the link to see it) it states: “Multiple choice & short answer tests are poor measures of student achievement*”.
“Measures” and “student achievement” are the language of the edudeformers and privateers. Until we quit using their language and begin substituting more straight forward language that explicity explains what we mean, we’ll continue to lose the battle for public schools.
There is nothing, absolutely nothing being “measured” by those tests:
“The most misleading concept/term in education is “measuring student achievement” or “measuring student learning”. The concept has been misleading educators into deluding themselves that the teaching and learning process can be analyzed/assessed using “scientific” methods which are actually pseudo-scientific at best and at worst a complete bastardization of rationo-logical thinking and language usage.
*Never gave a damn about “student achievement”. I cared about whether the student was learning as much as she/he wanted to and could. Screw student achievement.
LikeLike
LOVE THIS!
LikeLike
What is the THIS?
LikeLike
Can we create a NATIONAL AWARD FOR SEATTLE TEACHERS???!!!
LikeLiked by 1 person
I’ve loved Jesse Hagopian ever since he led the Seattle teacher’s refusal to administer standardized testing (I think it was the MAPS test – correct me if I’m wrong). My only caution (and Hagopian probably doesn’t need this caution from me) is that moratorium is not the same as abolishment and, in fact, can be dangerous. A moratorium can be used to develop “new and improved” (cough, cough) tests that will be harder to fight because, hey, look, we took all this time to consider your concerns and we put a lot of thought and care into this, so if you keep on objecting, we’re just going to have to assume you’re just being contrarian, so sit down and take your medicine like a good boy/girl.
Nothing less than ultimately abolishing the tests (and not replacing them with some variation of “competency or outcome based education” [sic] is acceptable..
LikeLiked by 1 person
Astute observation on the difference between a moratorium on and an abolishment of the tests, Dienne!
LikeLike
excellent placement for the COUGH COUGH warning…
LikeLike
Indeed, moratorium means re-group and attack from a flank. Agreed with your point.
LikeLike
I forwarded this blog to my state Senator Niemeyer [R-IN] and Representative Slager {R-IN] and wrote the following letter. I keep trying but getting through is like talking to a door. They send automatic replies stating that they get my emails and that I’ll be hearing back from them. HA.
……
Dear Senator Niemeyer and Representative Slager,
I wish Indiana would completely dismantle the standardized testing that is being demanded by politicians in public schools. I am thrilled to learn that Seattle teachers took control and got rid of standardized tests. All teachers need to take this step. Please realize that political control of education is destroying love of learning and creativity. That, and lack of funding, is why teachers are quitting and college students are not enrolling in education classes. Why work for nothing and then be dragged down by ‘testing to the test’? Schooling should be much better than this.
Quote: “The average student in the public schools in the U.S. takes an outlandish 112 standardized tests in the K-12 career–forcing teachers to teach to the test, rather than teach to the student. Study after study has reveled that these tests are a better measure of family income than aptitude. These test measure resources and your proximity to the dominant culture, negatively impacting English Language Learners, special education students, students of color, and low income students.”
Sincerely,
Carol Ring
Schererville, IN
LikeLike
But they did not “get rid of” the standardized tests. They are seeking a moratorium, which while it is a very good thing, one has to still be vigilant due to the concerns raised by dienne77 above.
“Study after study has reveled that these tests are a better measure of family income than aptitude. These test measure resources and your proximity to the dominant culture. . .”
And again, for the umpteenth time (as my mom used to say to me when I didn’t do something after her asking me a gazillion times) repeating the edudeformers’ and privateers’ meme that “standardized tests ‘measure’ something only serves to more deeply embed that meme. I’m pretty sure you don’t agree with that meme, Carol, but now your representative has just had another reinforcement of that false meme. Just a little * with an explanation of the falseness of the measurement meme would plant a different meme in his/her head.
And that is part of what we, those striving, attempting to save public education from the privateer vultures (sorry vultures, don’t mean to insult you) need to do at every opportunity-show the falseness and unjustness of those privateer memes and share especially with those who wouldn’t know any different.
LikeLike
Duane: Thank you for your insights. I have sent MANY emails to my state senator and representative. Many of those come from the writings that are posted on Diane Ravitch’s sight. She come from Chalkbeat Indiana.
Her WHOLE article was sent to them, not just the one quote. Hopefully, they will take the time to read the whole blog. My feeling is that they get a lot of news and only bother to read the things that support their beliefs.
LikeLiked by 1 person
Your “feeling” is more likely spot on!
LikeLike
opps. This sentence doesn’t make any sense. Have to do better proofreading. “She come from Chalkbeat Indiana.”
I have sent articles to my senator and representative from Chalkbeat Indiana that well describes the disasters of what is happening in education in this state. My belief is that they know where I stand. I’m only one person who speaks out. Most people are too busy surviving in a bad economy to know what is happening.
LikeLiked by 1 person
Quite correct in your last thought.
I appreciate that you take the time to contact your representatives. I wish more would do so.
LikeLike
Wars are seldom won in a day. This war will take years, decades. Heck, this war against public schools, teachers, teachers’ unions, children and parents started back in 1983 or even earlier.
LikeLike
Corporate reform is dying now
LikeLike
Not fast enough for me.
LikeLike
It is morphing. The new face is “doing well by doing good” which means more projects like pay for success contacting in preschool, “healthy” living, and earned reputation credits.
LikeLike
The Chicago Teachers Union has won contract language allowing teachers to vote on the administration of any tests not mandated by the state:
https://www.ctunet.com/blog/putting-a-stop-to-unnecessary-tests
LikeLike
Christine: “A serious side effect: counselors are so busy with test prep duties on top of huge caseloads that they lack adequate time to counsel students who need the help they’ve been trained to provide.”
When are teachers going to get strong enough to say, “Enough is enough” and demand that all testing stop? I wish this was the next step in really helping kids.
LikeLike
Hooray for Washington state teachers and the moratorium on standardized testing. Just BEWARE. This isn’t over. The deformers are regrouping for online education and then testing. Also BEWARE of Competency-Based Education as well. Been there, done that.
LikeLike