According to Politico, Alberto Carvalho will be the new Chancellor of the New York City public schools.
“Alberto Carvalho, who has led Miami’s public schools for the last decade, will be New York City’s next schools chancellor, Mayor Bill de Blasio will officially announce Thursday.
“Carvalho will replace Carmen Fariña, who has spent the last four years at the helm of America’s largest school system after de Blasio coaxed her out of retirement in late 2013. He will officially take over as chancellor sometime in the next month. The announcement was delayed because of the recent shooting at Marjory Stoneman Douglas High School in Parkland, Fla.
“De Blasio’s requirements for the role of America’s second-most-important educator were largely unspoken, but obvious: a longtime educator with experience running schools for vulnerable children, a Spanish-speaking person of color, and a New York City outsider who is also considered a rising star in the national education world.
“Carvalho checks every box.
“The current Miami-Dade schools chief is a Portuguese immigrant, and came to America illegally as a broke 17-year-old who had saved up $1,000 for the airfare from Lisbon to New York City. After leaving New York for Ft. Lauderdale and later Miami, he worked as a busboy and a day laborer. Carvalho was the first person in his family to finish high school. Fariña, the daughter of immigrants from Spain, was the first person in her’s to earn a college diploma.
“Carvalho started his 20-year career in Miami’s schools as a physics, chemistry and calculus teacher at Miami Jackson Senior High, where he earned the nickname “Mr. Armani” for his sartorial presence. He went on to be an assistant principal and deputy superintendent. Along with his current superintendent duties, he’s the principal of two Miami schools. He helped earn his reputation for being a savvy political operator while serving as a communications officer and a lobbyist for Miami-Dade’s schools.”

As an NYC teacher, I have to shake my head and ask why must we keep importing prominent “educators” from Florida?
Last I saw, despite public outcry, fourteen NYC schools are slated to be closed. This after the mayor said school closures are not the answer. Sadly, I see more closing in the future, especially since Carvalho loves charters.
LikeLike
“NPR has called him “a miracle worker.””
That statement right there is worrying. But I guess all is good because we’re supposed to celebrate that he reduced the number of tests for Miami-Dade. ““I believe in accountability,” Carvalho said then, according to The Washington Post. “But fewer assessments of higher quality are better. …” Yeah, let’s just keep trying to fix the testing problem. I’m sure we’ll get it right some day and find the one perfect BS Test. Remind me of the definition of insanity….
More quotes from the linked article:
“And perhaps most crucially, Carvalho has managed to walk a precarious political tightrope on school choice.”
““Rather than complain about the incoming tsunami of choice, we’re going to ride it,” Carvalho told the Miami Herald in 2014.”
“Carvalho’s official bio describes him as “a staunch believer in school choice” ”
“Moskowitz, Success’s CEO, included Carvalho on a list of potential chancellors that she encouraged de Blasio, her political nemesis, to consider.”
“In 2011, Carvalho helped implement a merit pay system — considered anathema to most teachers union officials, including Weingarten — that tied raises to teachers’ evaluation scores and provided bonuses for highly effective teachers.”
Sigh. I don’t have time to finish the article right now, but someone please tell me why I’m supposed to be happy about this guy?
LikeLike
Oh dear, it appears I stopped reading too soon:
“Carvalho has also had one notable brush with scandal. Several emails written in 2007 — a few months before he was named Miami superintendent — between Carvalho and a former Miami Herald reporter indicate that the two had an affair while Carvalho was a top deputy in the county’s school system. The reporter resigned from her job after the emails were made public.
And in 2016, a state ethics committee found that Carvalho might have violated Florida law by not reporting gifts he received that were worth more than $100. The committee did not take further action, noting that Carvalho was “forthcoming” about the incident and eventually reported the gifts.”
We have a winner, folks!
LikeLike
Wow! What is wrong with these people?
LikeLike
Under Carvalho’s reign a teacher with 15 years experience makes $46,000. The same teacher would have made $48,000 back in 2006 before he took over! NYC teachers better not expect to see a substantial raise any time soon. His fair well gift was sponsoring a constitutional referendum which would allow public school districts to be turned into charter districts. But if you like using technology in the classroom, he’s your guy. https://kafkateach.wordpress.com/2017/04/26/miami-dade-teacher-salaries-then-and-now/
LikeLike
He checks every box? Boy do you have a lot of research to do. Ask any Dade County teacher how they feel about Mr. Armani and I promise you they will not tell you that he checks every box. What a joke!
LikeLike
I admit my first reaction is to say “if Eva Moskowitz recommended this guy, there is something very wrong with him”. After all, Moskowitz’ has already made it clear that her idea of someone perfectly suited to lead education is Betsy DeVos, and Moskowitz spent a whole lot of time telling us how wonderful and terrific and caring Betsy DeVos was and insisting that Betsy DeVos was exactly the kind of educational leader whose values reflected Moskowitz own. And I certainly know that Eva Moskowitz still stands behind her strong endorsement of DeVos and has never once criticized a single action that DeVos has taken since the Senators listened to Moskowitz’ strong endorsement of DeVos and confirmed her.
So the fact that Eva Moskowitz is also insisting that Alberto Carvalho will be just as terrific as Betsy DeVos is and we should trust her good judgement on that does make me worried about how awful he must be to get the endorsement of someone whose idea of a great educational leader is Betsy DeVos.
But there do seem to be some differences — Carvalho started some programs to reduce out of school suspensions of high schoolers while Moskowitz insists that huge numbers of non-white kindergarten children are far too violent to be allowed on any school premises and that suspending Kindergarten and first graders is the only proper way to deal with the violent natures that she insists so many of the very youngest children exhibit in some of her charter schools with virtually no white students.
And Carvalho did seem to be more interested in providing choice WITHIN the public school system instead of letting a private group come in and open private charter schools that pick off only the cheapest to teach students that they could profit from teaching. And then send the rest back to the public system.
Betsy DeVos proved that she was exactly the type of educator that Moskowitz told us she would be when she so strongly endorsed her. I hope that Carvalho ends up not being a Betsy DeVos copy who Moskowitz would never criticize because everything she does is perfect, and instead ends up taking actions that make Moskowitz attack and criticize him she way she attacked and criticized Farina (but never her beloved Betsy DeVos). If Carvalho is just the Betsy DeVos clone Moskowitz probably expects and hopes he will be, I will be fighting to get him replaced. I hope he is not and I would like to hear more from him and about him.
LikeLike
This does not sound good.
LikeLike
I don’t think De Blasio knows what he’s doing. He’s not a bad guy; just doesn’t know.
LikeLike
Ostensible success. Gee, where have we seen that before? In this climate. How stupid or desperate are people getting?
LikeLike
Carvalho is a staunch supporter of school choice, be it in the form of magnet schools or charters. He came recommended by Eva Moskowitz and the district won a Broad Prize on his watch. It is a positive development for NYC families.
View at Medium.com
This on-topic, TOS compliant comment was submitted at 11:31 EST Feb 28 2018
LikeLike
That’s a recommendation that makes most of us queasy.
However, Tim, Carvalho is a good friend of Randi Weingarten.
LikeLike
Says something (that we already knew) about Randi.
LikeLike
Diane could you ask Mr. Carbajo what is going on with Hiealeah Education Academic . The Mayor city and the Principal by the way he knows me very well . I got to much information if he refused to comment I can help to provide any information regarding the problem with Hialeah Education Academy. Inc never work the right way when Charters should fallow the rules of the Public school sistem. I’m very upset because I never receive any explanations regarding all the Complains I did I have he complains on my files ready to send it to you ! Why Carlos is leaving now ? Miami is not a big market city by the way he has done a great job but the Charters Supporters are using the power of the money plus political figures to protect Choices “ Mr . Carlos tried hard but with hands tied. I hope from the big Apple he expose the problem with this city with the corruption of the Charters schools.
>
LikeLike
So, De Blasio is now so captive to so-called reform interests that Moskowitz gets to have a say in choosing the new Chancellor?
It’s quite a world we’ve devolved into when this is what your “friends” do…
LikeLiked by 1 person
Yeah, this appointment looks problematic, as the postmodernists like to say.
Another disappointing choice from a mayor for whom I am beginning to regret voting.
LikeLike
“Accountability”, Charters, a “savvy political operator”… Sorry, but this sounds like the same old toady for the billionaire class in new Armani suits. The onward marc of public-education and democracy off of a cliff continues.
LikeLike
Update, Carvalho turned down Deblasio’s offer. Not sure what the point of the theatrics were. I guess he needed an ego boost and a bunch of glowing articles written about him.
LikeLike
Too bad for us teachers in Miami-Dade. And too bad for the students. We’re stuck with this dictator and charlatan till 2023 now.
LikeLike
Hi Diane. I know that this post is from two years ago, but could you please clarify to people that this post was from an article in Politico by Eliza Shapiro, and actually not your own writing and opinion? Many teachers in Miami Dade County Public Schools erroneously attributed the opinions expressed here, especially the glorifying of Carvalho as “checking all the boxes” to you, when in fact it was Shapiro who wrote this.
I’m confident that you know enough about education in Florida education, and the situation in Miami-Dade, to not fall for the ‘Carvalho is a savior’ nonsense view. In reality the supposed gains made in the past 12 years of his tenure – raising the graduation rate from 57% to 90%, not having any schools with F grades, and the A rated school district argument are exaggerated to say the least. When you are able to artificially inflate school grades and graduation rates through strategic manipulation of data, drilling kids with test prep to pass standardized exams, allowing principals to engage in questionable testing practices, placing low level kids into AP classes so that they are not required to take State-mandated and graduation requirement End of Course exams, scrubbing transcripts of failing grades through ‘grade forgiveness’ and redirecting kids to ‘leadership classes,’ pressuring teachers to be lenient and pass kids or change their failing grades in your class, and a series of other questionable practices that are common in mdcps under carvalho, it becomes clear that the “magical transformation” of schools in Miami-dade is not so. Measuring whether real learning has taken place is not always demonstrated by fancy statistics and data, and the slick operator Carvalho has done a nice job of convincing almost everyone that the kids of Miami have and continue to do exceptionally well academically (when in reality the vast majority still cannot read at grade level and do not have basic grade level math skills). It would be great if you would research the supposed success of mdcps and scratch the surface to reveal the truth. I think many people would be quite surprised.
LikeLike