This article by Gus Garcia-Roberts won a prestigious journalism award for exposing the disgraceful conditions in schools that receive McKay scholarships for special education students in Florida.
This is the voucher program that Betsy DeVos hailed as a national model when she testified at her confirmation hearings a year ago.
“While the state played the role of the blind sugar daddy, here is what went on at South Florida Prep, according to parents, students, teachers, and public records: Two hundred students were crammed into ever-changing school locations, including a dingy strip-mall space above a liquor store and down the hall from an Asian massage parlor. Eventually, fire marshals and sheriffs condemned the “campus” as unfit for habitation, pushing the student body into transience in church foyers and public parks.
“The teachers were mostly in their early 20s. An afternoon for the high school students might consist of watching a VHS tape of a 1976 Laurence Fishburne blaxploitation flick — Cornbread, Earl and Me — and then summarizing the plot. In one class session, a middle school teacher recommended putting “mother nature” — a woman’s period — into spaghetti sauce to keep a husband under thumb. “We had no materials,” says Nicolas Norris, who taught music despite the lack of a single instrument. “There were no teacher edition books. There was no curriculum.”
“In May 2009, two vanloads of South Florida Prep kids were on the way back from a field trip to Orlando when one of the vehicles flipped along Florida’s Turnpike. A teacher and an 18-year-old senior were killed. Turns out another student, age 17 and possessing only a learner’s permit, was behind the wheel and had fallen asleep. The families of the deceased and an insurance company are suing Brown for negligence.
“Meanwhile, Brown openly used a form of corporal punishment that has been banned in Miami-Dade and Broward schools for three decades. Four former students and the music teacher Norris recall that the principal frequently paddled students for misbehaving. In a complaint filed with the DOE in April 2009, one parent rushed to the school to stop Brown from taking a paddle to her son’s behind.
“He said that maybe if we niggas would beat our kids in the first place, he wouldn’t have to,” the mother wrote of Brown. “He then proceeded to tell me that he is not governed by Florida school laws.”
“He wasn’t far off. The DOE couldn’t remove South Florida Prep from the McKay program, says agency spokesperson Deborah Higgins, “based on the school’s disciplinary policies and procedures.”
“It’s like a perverse science experiment, using disabled school kids as lab rats and funded by nine figures in taxpayer cash: Dole out millions to anybody calling himself an educator. Don’t regulate curriculum or even visit campuses to see where the money is going.
“For optimal results, do this in Florida, America’s fraud capital.
“Now watch all the different ways the flimflam men scramble for the cash.
“Once a niche scholarship fund, the McKay program has boomed exponentially in the 12 years since it was introduced under Gov. Jeb Bush, with $148.6 million handed out in the past 12 months, a 38 percent increase from just more than five years ago.
“There are 1,013 schools — 65 percent of them religious — collecting McKay vouchers from 22,198 children at an average of $7,144 per year.
“The lion’s share of that pot ends up in South Florida. Miami-Dade received $31.8 million, more than any other county in the state, and Broward was second with $18.3 million. Palm Beach ranked fifth, with its schools collecting $6.9 million.
“But there’s virtually no oversight. According to one former DOE investigator, who claimed his office was stymied by trickle-down gubernatorial politics, the agency failed to uncover “even a significant fraction” of the McKay crime that was occurring.
“Administrators who have received funding include criminals convicted of cocaine dealing, kidnapping, witness tampering, and burglary.
“Even in investigations where fraud, including forgery and stealing student information to bolster enrollment, is proven, arrests are rare. The thieves are usually allowed to simply repay the stolen loot in installments — or at least promise to — and continue to accept McKay payments.
“There is no accreditation requirement for McKay schools. And without curriculum regulations, the DOE can’t yank back its money if students are discovered to be spending their days filling out workbooks, watching B-movies, or frolicking in the park. In one “business management” class, students shook cans for coins on street corners.”
This article is a must-read. Voucher proponent Jay Greene of the Walton-funded University of Arkansas belittled the story and said it was published in a worthless tabloid. But the article subsequently won the Society of Professional Journalists Sigma Delta Chi Award for 2012, and Garcia-Roberts went on to become an investigative journalist at Long Island’s Newsday and now the Los Angeles Times.
Since the article’s publication, Florida has done nothing to correct the abuse of children with disabilities in the McKay program.
You see, children in public schools have rights. When they leave public schools, they abandon their rights.

Highway ROBBERY!
LikeLike
Cross posted at :
https://www.opednews.com/Quicklink/McKay-scholarship-program-in-General_News-Charter-Schools_Disabilities_Fraud_Schools-180128-16.html#comment687350
LikeLike
Compare the future of corporate controlled public education as described in this post to these top five most expensive K-12 schools in the world that are exclusively for the rich, powerful, and famous.
This post shows us what is in store for our children (the working class) while the video reveals the world of education for their children (the “filthy” rich).
It’s 99-percent vs the 1-percent and many of the 1-percent don’t give a crap about the rest of the world.
LikeLike
It looks like the 1% values liberal arts, humanities, diversity and creative expression in small classes. No robot teachers for them!
LikeLike
Very small classes too. “Very Small”
I heard 1 teacher for every 5 students.
LikeLike
Lloyd
That school looks just like a flying saucer.
If we are lucky, the billionaires are planning to leave earth in the not too distant future.
LikeLike
What if the billionaires are all illegal aliens from another planet orbiting another star far, far away in another galaxy?
LikeLike
If they were advanced enough to come here from that far away, i seriously doubt they would ever have come up with anything as dumb as Common Core.
In fact, to them, we would be little more than insects crawling around on the floor and they certainly would have no interest in our schools (for making money or anything else).
So, no, I don’t believe the billionaires are aliens. Far too stupid to be aliens.
LikeLike
They all came from the Klingon Empire or they are Alien xenomorphs.
There are twenty on this list to choose from.
http://www.syfy.com/syfywire/deadliest-aliens-in-science-fiction
LikeLike
HOW U.S. SECRETARY OF EDUCATION DEVOS
WOULD RESPOND TO THIS EXPOSE OF
FLORIDA’S VOUCHER PROGRAM / SCHOOLS
I’m sure a lot of people out there are thinking,
“Gosh, I’d love to confront Secretary of Ed. Betsy Devos with this article, and see her response. Perhaps that will turn her mind around about unregulated charter schools, and influence her to demand accountability and oversight for those schools. I’d love to see her response to this Florida article.”
Well, Devos has already been so confronted on multiple occasions.
Here’s one utterly infuriating and maddening example of how Devos responds to such a confrontation, and and and example of how she would likely respond to a reading of this article.
In short, pro-voucher ideology would trump any such facts.
Here’s that example:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=AjjvzKRiusM
This same outrages taking place in Florida are also taking place in other states such as Wisconsin. This led Wisconsin Congressman Mark Pocan to give a verbal version of this article in his questioning of Secretary Devos — describing a litany of problems arising from de-regulated, unregulated, privately-managed charter schools, finishing up with a knockout question: (Pocan 14-year veteran of the Wisconsin state legislature, where he served on that state’s education committee, so Pocan knows whereof he speaks)
“Would you send your children to one of these schools?’
DEVOS RESPONSE:
1) ( 02:06 – 02:10) “Congressman, thank you for your question”
— whenever Devos says such words, it’s an iron-clad guarantee that what follows will be a total non-response, and diversionary ducking of the question, as is the case with Congressman Pocan’s question;
2) ( 02:11 – 02:38 ) Devos tries to change — and actually succeeds in changing — the subject by bringing up Polly Williams, a now-deceased African-American female politician from Wisconsin who briefly endorsed charter schools and vouchers.
Devos does this in spite of the fact that Devos knows full well that Williams later recanted that support when Williams witnessed the same fiascos as Florida occur in Wisconsin, and Williams even claimed that she was duped and used by the voucher and charter industry.
In a quick exchange on this, Pocan responds to Devos invoking of Williams’ charter/voucher support by pointing out Polly Williams’ later recantation and opposition.
Instead of responding to this, Devos nitpicks and tries make Pocan’s misuse of the present tense the issue — Polly Williams, Devos claims, is now deceased, so we really don’t know what her opinion is, and we can’t question her.
Pocan fires back that no, Secretary Devos, you’re wrong. Before Polly Williams died, Williams came out strongly and publicly against charters and vouchers.
When Pocan tries to make this point, the dastardly and dishonest Devos then interrupts and tries to talk over him with canned talking points about Wisconsin’s voucher-charter program
DEVOS:
(sounding like robot, or pull-string doll)
“341 students originally and now 28,000 students in the city of Milwaukee … ”
Pocan had Devos trapped, so she just refused to respond, and blathered away her stock answer.
It’s infuriating to watch.
This Kellyanne Conway-esque (or Sarah Huckabee-Sanders-esque) move on Devos’ part worked like a charm, because with the conversation now focused on this irrelevant and misleading mention of a one-time pro-voucher/pro-charter politician (and eventual opponent), all the outrages that were initially brought up by Pocan are now obscured by the dust cloud of Devos’ diversion and obfuscation.
This both eats up time, and allows her to avoid all the facts presented by Pocan (again, facts similar to the ones in the Florida article that this post is about.).
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=AjjvzKRiusM
3) ( 02:39 – 02:46 ) Pocan returns to his “Would you send your children … ?” question, and Devos totally refusesto to answer, and again just repeats her canned talking points that are totally irrelevant to Pocan’s inquiry.
DEVOS: (robotic) “Today, 28,000 children are being sent there by their parents … ”
4) ( 02:47 – 03:25 ) Pocan points out, “Well, you’re obviously NOT going to answer my question,” then tries a different inquiry regarding the upscale private schools in Wisconis, which, unlike the corrupt private schools he just mentioned, provide a good education — but for people already attending, not lower-income minorities that attend the corrupt private schools funded by vouchers — the ones that Pocan mentioned in his introductory question
POCAN: “Let my ask a different question that you MIGHT be willing to answer.”
Pocan then points out that, at these upscale private schools funded by vouchers, 75% of the kids who got voucher money — money taken from traditional public schools, resulting in gutting of those schools — ALREADY ATTENDED THESE PRIVATE SCHOOLS, and presumably would have without the voucher program.
Those students and families didn’t move to private schools because of the opportunity that vouchers provided them — they would have attended those private schools regardless, anyway. The only difference is that now, they pay a reduced tuition … all of that at the expense of children remaining in the traditional public schools, where programs are gutted and teachers leave the school or the state because of dismal salary and benefits, resulting in a lower quality of teaching in the classroom.
Therefore, all that Wisconsin’s voucher program — the one lauded by Devos and which she falsely claimed Polly Williams ultimately backed — did was gut and damage the public schools, with minimal change in the student bodies of either the private schools, or the traditional public schools which were being gutted.
Furthermore, 2/3rds of the parents who accessed voucher money — again, the transfer of which gutted the public schools — made over $100,000/year, which is a lot of money in the Midwest (but not so in Los Angeles or New York City.)
So the program gives voucher money to families who, the first place, don’t need and never needed the tuition money pay for private schools that they already could afford.
(By the way, this is pretty masterful performance by Pocan. … Cheers Mark, if you’re reading this.)
… and you know what’s coming next, now don’t you?
Another Devos diversion.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=AjjvzKRiusM
4) ( 03:26 – 04:24 ) Devos ducks the question, then starts blathering away about Milwaukee.
DEVOS: “Well, I want to applaud Milwaukee for empowering parents to make the decisions that they think are right for their children.”.
Devos ignores the point just made by Pocan.
Pocan JUST POINTED OUT THAT THOSE PARENTS — the ones WHOM DEVOS “applauds” FOR “make the decisions that they think are right for their children” — HAD ALREADY MADE THAT “decision” to send their kids to private schools, and would have done so, with or without the voucher program. The program, once again, just takes money away from the traditional public schools that need it, and helps those $100/000-annual-earning parents put more money in the bank, or spend it on whatever.
Devos then goes back to the robot talking points,
DEVOS: “I know the 28,000 students that attend … the choice of their parents… ”
Pocan replies that “So you don’t think those (voucher-funded private) schools should be held to any accountability?”
Again, Devos is non-responsive.
Keep in mind that Pocan served for 14 years in Wisconsin’s legislature, serving on the Education committee, so he knows his stuff, but Devos refuses to be responsive to any of the facts and arguments he makes.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=AjjvzKRiusM
5) Frustrated, Pocan then refers to the original Trump-proposed federal budget that was publicly supported by Devos.
Pocan points out that, to fund the proposed federal voucher program, Trump’s proposed budget would have — had it been passed as proposed — would have “zeroed out” or ended “mental health programs, arts programs, Special Olympics, etc. “… all to provide funding for a federal voucher program, which would have all the problems of the ones in Wisconsin, Florida, and in other states.
Pocan is emphatic, saying that “after 14 years in the (Wisconsin) legislature,” (where Pocan served prior to being a Congressman) the voucher program has “produced dismal results’, and is undoubtedly “a failed experiment.”
POCAN: “So my question is, ‘Will the federal dollars you’re proposing go down the same failed path that did in Wisconsin, as the voucher money goes to people WHO ALREADY ATTEND THE SCHOOLS?”
… get ready for another Devos diversion:
6) She totally avoids the question, and claims that “for those 28,000 students,” that is success for those students.
7) Pocan fires back, “Madame Secretary, seriously, you’re not answering the question, so let me try a different question.”
8) The Republican Senator chairing the committee, “Give her an opportunity to answer the question.
9) Pocan replies in exasperation, “She’s answering a DIFFERENT question than the one I’m asking, so at some point, my five minutes will be up. (and he’ll never get a straight answer out of her).”
10) Pocan then repeatedly asks her that if the U.S. Dept of Ed. led by Devos will “have any accountability standarts” for proposed federal voucher program, or for the current state voucher programs?
Again, she continually ducks the question.
That’s all for now. I’m late for my spin class.
LikeLike
There is only one cure for someone like DeVos. It is a 9-mm chunk of solid metal that weighs 7.5 grams. In China, when this 7.5-gram chunk of solid metal is used in an execution that resulted from a death sentence in a Chinese court, a bill is sent to the family of that executed person for the price of that 7.5 grams of metal.
LikeLike
The McKay “scholarship” is a way for wealthy people to get a tax credit while students get warehoused in a school of dubious quality. These classified students do not have the same protections that they would have in the public schools under IDEA. It is a crooked system, a product of Jeb Bush’s reign of terror.
LikeLike