Southold and Greenport are adjacent towns on the North Fork of Long Island. I have been fortunate to meet the superintendent who shares responsibility for both districts. His name is David Gamberg. I have visited high school plays, seen (and consumed) the products of the school garden, and watched musical performances of his students. I live in both Southold and Brooklyn, and while both are located on the same island, they are worlds apart. The headlines in Brooklyn are about crime, politics, corruption, major real estate deals, etc. The front page of the Suffolk Times, in which David’s article appears, is about the decision by the owner of the local “department store” (actually a small, old-time hardware store whose owner is renowned for the guitars he sells and plays) is moving his store next-doors. Goofy things happen here, and no one sees them as goofy but me. Rothman’s Department Store is famous in local lore because Albert Einstein, who summered here, came in to buy sandals. In his thick German accent, he said “sun-dials” and the owner regretted that he didn’t carry sun dials. Eventually, the two became fast friends. Southold boasts a great observatory, the Custer Institute, and its website has a photograph of Einstein and David Rothman, the department store owner. No one knows if Einstein ever visited the Custer Institute. Typical North Fork.
David Gamberg writes here about the learning experiences that shape students and ultimately shape communities.
He is very much a believer in active, engaged learning. His communities are lucky to have this wise man as their educational leader (by the way, opt out numbers in the North Fork were high).
He begins:
I am convinced that the foundation of good education is about the concept of building — building a school, building community, building relationships and building a sense of self.
This belief started to form in me as a young teacher, a teacher who began his career working in a school for incarcerated students. I remember being alongside students whose life story and life trajectory left little hope for the future. I recall wondering as a young educator — what can I do to alter their story, their path in life? The idea that we can help shape or reshape what seemed to be a child’s destiny represented a challenge for me, both personally and professionally.
School “works” for many students to provide a pathway into the future, a foundation of rich experiences that inspire and form the basis of their life stories. I wondered: Why not with these students?
I realized that many other factors conspired to bring them to this point. Education and schools can never be fully responsible for the outcomes that our students achieve; yet I wondered, what could be a key ingredient to reshape their view of the world? What could be something so powerful that it could reboot the system, rewire the hardware, stimulate a new emotional connection to the world around them?
I thought that having them build something, having them make a physical change in their environment, would change them as well. This, I thought, could reawaken their spirit; they would imagine themselves rebuilding their souls while rebuilding their surroundings. Shape the world around you and you shape yourself in the process.
Tending a garden offers students a chance to shape their environment and participate in the natural transformation of seed to plant. Building a greenhouse teaches students all subject areas, including math and science. Creating a gallery or museum display involves a student in a real process of honoring history and art. Putting on a drama or musical production shapes the experience of others, as the audience becomes the beneficiaries of our students’ talents and contribution to the larger community.

AND … help others realize that they CAN VOTE WITH THEIR TIME and MONEY EVERY DAY. Hit the deformers where it counts.
LikeLiked by 1 person
AND may many who understand this truth decide to run for office.
LikeLike
Yes you can teach them to tend a garden but to what ends. Is there a great need for gardeners?
In general, most kids can learn by doing. They can learn almost anyway you teach them but ultimately they will not learn more or remember longer.
Yes of course more factors go into a good life than just education. In fact education of the masses has almost no influence on the economy except maybe to make them obedient purchasers of technology in their adulthood.
Most will never get out of poverty. Education does not create its own jobs. I mean getting a high school diploma or a college degree is no guarantee of a job — getting a degree in Computer Science does not generate a job in Computer Science that you will fill.
As a mater of fact only 27% of all college graduates get a job in their field.About 50% never get a job that requires a college degree, so except for making them more knowledgeable citizens going to college was wasted.
I will not go farther because I have already done this in posts here and in my e-books.
Suffice it to say that education is not a way out of poverty or into the middle class, which is and has been for some time now, shrinking.
LikeLike
” The world is full of educated derelicts” – Calvin Coolidge. The fact that 27% of college graduates, do not obtain a position in their field, shows me that there is a mis-match between what college students are learning, and the positions available.
Maybe if more young people would stop taking degrees in Italian Literature or Recreation, and more in STEM fields, the abundance of college grads obtaining work outside their field would be diminished.
LikeLike
Oh give it up. The alleged STEM shortage has been debunked around here many times. Do keep up. Just because I can’t get a Ferrari for $1.25 doesn’t mean there’s a shortage of Ferraris. Just because Gates can’t find enough computer folks to work for minimum wage doesn’t mean there’s a STEM shortage.
LikeLike
For the latest information, about the employment situation in the engineering fields, see this link:
http://bit.ly/EngineeringOutlook
===============
There are shortages of qualified engineers in SOME fields (ex: Petroleum Engineering), and surpluses in SOME fields (ex: PhD Biologists)
You will concede, that there is a surplus of liberal-arts graduates, in fields like Italian literature, recreation, etc. Else, why are so many college graduates unable to find a position, in line with their academic background.
LikeLike
see
https://www.linkedin.com/groups/2449309/2449309-6349326094973313025?midToken=AQE4OHpJtIITDA&trk=eml-group_announcement_message-null-4-null&trkEmail=eml-group_announcement_message-null-4-null-null-s8xcg%7Ejbfgf3ux%7Enz-null-communities%7Egroup%7Ediscussion&lipi=urn%3Ali%3Apage%3Aemail_group_announcement_message%3BZnIOHd9KR6Kh5TPN8p4HWg%3D%3D
for the latest employment outlook in sciences/engineering.
LikeLike
Please, Charles. Expecting honesty from an engineering trade group about STEM employment is like expecting honesty about the effects of cigarettes from RJ Reynolds. Find better sources, please.
LikeLike
“…except for making them more knowledgeable citizens going to college was wasted.” And who needs knowledgeable citizens anyway? You’d think we lived in some sort of democratic society or something. What fanciful merriment! All we need are gunships and the factories that produce them. Who are we going to Invade Next, Chales?
LikeLike
One of the best way to build a community is for stakeholders to collaborate with one another to build a shared vision built on consensus. If people want to invest in their community, one of the best investments is to have a strong public school system that will attract families looking to build a better future for themselves and fellow members of the community. Public education is a valuable public asset that needs to be cherished and protected from outside interests. Most public schools are the hub of social interaction with various team sports, plays, concerts, food drives, car washes, boys and girl scouts, etc.
Some school districts like the one in which I worked had a strong social conscience, The elementary schools partnered with a nursing home where the students performed concerts for the residents at various times during the year. Our high school did a monthly “Midnight Run” where high school students gave out food and donated clothing to the homeless in Manhattan.
LikeLike
Ah yes, retired teacher, but what was the economic return on building a strong social conscience? (snark alert)
LikeLike
Einstein in sandals? I can’t imagine it …!
LikeLike
Yes, Einstein in sandals. A true story.
LikeLike