One of the biggest scandals associated with charter school finances has to do with “related parties.” That means that the school engages in financial transactions with a “related party” and money changes hands and ends up in the pockets of friends.
The Gulen schools are one of the nations’ largest charter chains. They are somehow associated or owned by the imam Fethullah Gulen, who lives in seclusion in the Poconos of Pennsylvania. General Michael Flynn apparently offered to extradite Gulen because the Turkish Government blames Gulen for a failed coup. Gulen schools have been accused of hiring Turkish contractors who were not the low bidders on contracts. You can tell a Gulen Charter by the large number of Turks on the board of directors and Turkish teachers.
In Rochester, New York, the local newspaper has uncovered a shady deal between related parties involving a Gulen charter school.
The story reads in part:
“A real estate holding company based in Syracuse cleared more than $300,000 in profit at the expense of a charter school in Greece earlier this year, according to real estate and financial records obtained by the Democrat and Chronicle.
“Both the company, Terra Science and Education Inc., and Rochester Academy Charter School, which opened in 2008 as the first local charter high school, have evident connections with each other, and broadly with the nebulous network of Fethullah Gulen, the reclusive and controversial Turkish cleric living in exile in rural Pennsylvania.
“Both the school and Terra deny there is a connection, but the D&C investigation has found numerous examples of overlapped personnel, lax invoicing, a lack of auditing and shared community affiliations.
“Many Gulen-suspected schools across the country have entered into questionable real estate transactions with related parties, something critics label an attempt to siphon off the public money charter schools receive for their pupils. The importance for Monroe County residents, though, is the disbursal of hundreds of thousands of public dollars to a connected organization.
“Such transactions, while not illegal, point to an oversight weakness in charter schools, which rely more heavily on contracted space and services than traditional public schools.
“The Democrat and Chronicle has rebuilt the timeline of the deal that generated the substantial return for Terra.
*May 2016: Terra Science and Education Inc. buys a shuttered school building on Latta Road from Our Mother of Sorrows Church for $700,000.
*August 2016 to June 2017: Terra spends between $1.2 million and $1.5 million in renovations. Rochester Academy Charter School (RACS) leases the building from Terra in the meantime for $30,000 a month, paying a total of $300,000.
*June 2017: RACS purchases the newly renovated building for $2.5 million — at least $300,000 more than Terra’s costs for purchase and renovation, not including the lease payments.
“The fat profit margin for Terra comes from public funding intended for the hundreds of students attending the school — about $5 million in 2016-17, and growing as the school adds grade levels each year.
“Under normal circumstances, if a developer turned a $300,000 profit after owning a property less than one year and selling it to a public school, it would be evidence of ruthless commercial skill for the one party and hapless poor luck for the other.
“When there is evidence the two parties are connected, it is a different story.”
Bottom line: Taxpayers were ripped off.

For more info on the Gulen mess see Empire of Deceit: An Investigation of the Gulen Charter School Nerwork, from Amsterdam & Partners (2017(.
LikeLike
Bottom line: Taxpayers were ripped off.
Again, and over and over again.
LikeLike
Mercedes Schneider has a blog post with links to the Empire of Deceit. I encourage you to read the blog post and click on the links. It gives the number of H1- B visas granted in each state . PA has 109 H1-B employees. https://deutsch29.wordpress.com/2017/12/03/turkish-gulen-schools-in-america-interactive-map-and-more/
LikeLike
This is why “nonprofit” doesn’t mean anything with charters.
Need much more than “nonprofit” to know what they’re doing.
LikeLike
This is ed reform privatization guru Osborne with his “new idea”:
“The author suggested that independent school districts could contract with a network of autonomous, accountable public campuses operated by independent organizations – preferably nonprofits. That way, operators could streamline rules and establish the right pay scale, programming, personnel, and educational model for its campus(es).”
Can someone tell me how this is different than privatization? Anyone?
He’s telling them to hire private contractors to run their schools.
This is somehow new and different than the privatization mantra we have heard for 20 years?
He knows that ‘school districts” consist of schools, right? Why have a school district at all if all they do is act as a pass-thru for contractors? That’s not a “school district”. It’s an accounting gimmick.
He beings all these sales pitches with diatribes against public schools. Then all the carefully chosen panelists (all of whom agree with him) all recite that they are “agnostics”.
It’s nonsense. Why don’t they just say what they’re about? They prefer ANY charter school to ANY public school. This is shown in everything they say and do. Why bother with this “agnostic” baloney? How dumb do they think people are?
No dissenters are ever invited to these cheerleading sessions, so no one ever questions any of this. It’s just accepted as “truth”.
https://therivardreport.com/education-experts-public-schools-must-embrace-change-to-succeed/
LikeLike
Ed reformers are moving on privatization, BTW. They used to insist charters must be “nonprofit”.
They no longer say that. Now they spout this wishy-washy mush about how they “hope” the privatized systems they’re selling will be nonprofits.
Because that always works, right? if you ask contractors nicely they’ll voluntarily comply!
There is NO compromise they won’t make to privatize public schools. None. Nonprofits, for profits, transparent, opaque, high performing, low performing- none of that matters.
What matters is schools NOT be publicly owned and operated.
LikeLike
Is anyone in our government ever planning on looking into how this Gulen religious group managed to completely capture our politicians?
What can this possibly be about? Is there some reason this one chain of charter schools seem to steal taxpayer funds with impunity and no one in law enforcement ever does anything about it?
LikeLike
I noticed that Osborne omits Cleveland when he’s out selling privatized “portfolios”
It’s odd because all of ed reform promoted the Cleveland Plan- they designed it and they marketed it.
Then I realized why Cleveland has been replaced by Cincinnati at lobbying events- it’s because “the data” is in on the Cleveland “portfolio” plan and it isn’t good.
They disappear the projects that fail. Cleveland has been erased.
When Osborne comes to your city selling his privatization scheme ask him about Cleveland. Make him address it, because people in Cleveland were sold the same “portfolio” model they now sell all over the country.
LikeLike
This is so depressing. As a New Yorker and an American, I am flabbergasted that someone can enter from another country and dismantle the public education system by stealing from taxpayers.
LikeLike
The Office of Inspector General of the U.S. Department of Education has issued a report that, because of their lack of accountability to the public, charter schools pose a risk to the Department of Education’s goals. The report finds that “Charter schools and their management organizations pose a potential risk to federal funds even as they threaten to fall short of meeting the goals” because of financial fraud and the artful skimming of tax money into private pockets, especially hedge fund pockets. Yet, charter schools don’t even appear on your radar.
If nothing else is required of charter schools, one thing must be required so that charter schools are accountable to taxpayers and inform taxpayers as to how taxpayer money is actually being spent; that one key thing is: Charter schools must be required to file the SAME detailed, public domain financial reports under penalty of perjury that public schools file.
Charter schools will cry out that this is “too burdensome” — yet public schools file such reports. What would the outcry be if public schools were “freed” of this “burden”? Why, the outcry would rattle the very heavens! So, why is it that private charter schools are allowed to get away with taking public tax money and not have to tell the public on an annual basis how those public tax dollars are spent?
Charter schools bill themselves as “public schools”, but Supreme Courts in states like New York, Washington and elsewhere are catching on to the scam and have ruled that charter schools are really private schools because they aren’t accountable to the public because they are run by private boards that aren’t elected by voters and don’t even have to file detailed reports to the public about what they’re doing with the public’s tax money.
LikeLike