Trump held a press conference yesterday to boast about how effective he has been in aiding the people of Puerto Rico, who are American citizens.
The news coverage of Puerto Rico tells a different story.
Large parts of the island are without power. Some parts of the island will be without electricity for months. People need the basic necessities of life. No doubt Trump thinks this is “fake news” and that he is the best president ever, ever, ever, and he deserves our thanks.
Churches, synagogues, and mosques will be collecting supplies for the people of Puerto Rico this weekend. But that will not be enough. It won’t turn the power back on.
Why doesn’t Trump send in the Army Corps of Engineers to restore power throughout the island?
Why doesn’t he send tankers and ships loaded with food and water, with diapers and cleaning supplies, with medical supplies?
Why doesn’t he stop bragging and take action to save lives?
People will die because of his inaction and indifference.
Is he indifferent because Puerto Ricans speak Spanish?
Puerto Ricans are Americans. They deserve the aid and support of the federal government to pull through this emergency.
Dana Milbank of the Washington Post wrote an article probing Trump’s indifference to Puerto Rico and comparing it to his response to the hurricane damage in Texas and Florida:
Milbank wrote:
Suppose that the entire San Diego metropolitan area had lost electrical power, and it wouldn’t be restored for months.
Or, suppose that most of the ports, roads and cellular towers in the Seattle metropolitan area had been destroyed, and a major dam had failed.
Or, that most of the homes in the Twin Cities area of Minnesota were either damaged or destroyed in one day.
Or, that the combined populations of New Hampshire, Maine and Vermont had seen much of their forests and agricultural land wiped out.
Or, that the residents of Montana, North Dakota, South Dakota and Wyoming — combined — had lost access to food and clean water, leaving them vulnerable to cholera. And imagine that overflowing hospitals, without power, had no capacity to deal with an outbreak.
Now, imagine that in response to any of these scenarios, the president of the United States variously ignored the plight of the affected Americans (in all of the above cases about 3.4 million people, give or take), blamed them for their own troubles and provided inadequate help. This is precisely what is happening right now to the 3.4 million U.S. citizens of Puerto Rico, an island territory more populous than about 20 states. Hurricane Maria essentially wiped out these Americans’ ports, roads, electricity, communications, water supply and crops and many homes. Yet, a week after the storm, the response from the American mainland has been paltry.
There is no rush, as there was after Hurricane Harvey hit Texas, to approve the emergency funds that Puerto Rico will surely need. There has been no massive movement of military personnel and equipment to Puerto Rico: no aircraft carrier (one was sent to the Florida Keys in response to Hurricane Irma), no hospital ship (finally on Tuesday afternoon the Navy said it was sending one). The Post’s Joel Achenbach, Dan Lamothe and Alex Horton called the three Navy amphibious ships dispatched to Puerto Rico “a modest fleet given the scale of the crisis.”
President Trump, so visible when Harvey and Irma hit, all but ignored the devastation that Maria brought to Puerto Rico, devoting more attention to respect for the flag at NFL games. When he did turn his focus to Puerto Rico on Monday, it was to say that the island “was already suffering from broken infrastructure & massive debt” and that its “old electrical grid, which was in terrible shape, was devastated. Much of the Island was destroyed, with billions of dollars . . . owed to Wall Street and the banks which, sadly, must be dealt with.”
Two Trump Cabinet members, Energy Secretary Rick Perry (who traveled with Trump to Texas and Florida after hurricanes there) and Interior Secretary Ryan Zinke, made a joint public appearance Monday but didn’t even mention Puerto Rico. And the Trump administration said it would not assist Puerto Rico by waiving the Jones Act, which restricts the use of foreign cargo ships, after waiving the act in response to Harvey and Irma.
Why didn’t Trump care?

Video: Puerto Ricans Call for Aid Amid Catastrophe: “We’re American Citizens. We Can’t Be Left to Die”
Six days after Hurricane Maria slammed into Puerto Rico, 3.4 million U.S. citizens in the territory remain without adequate food, water and fuel. But as the massive crisis became clear over the weekend, President Trump failed to weigh in, instead lashing out at sports players who joined in protest against racial injustice. It took the president five full days to respond, with comments that appeared to blame the island for its own misfortune. We examine the dire situation in Puerto Rico with Yarimar Bonilla, Puerto Rican scholar, who wrote in The Washington Post, “Why would anyone in Puerto Rico want a hurricane? Because someone will get rich.” And we speak with Puerto Ricans in New York who have been unable to reach loved ones after nearly a week.
https://www.democracynow.org/2017/9/26/puerto_ricans_call_for_aid_amid
LikeLike
Trump wants Puerto Ricans to suffer. After he thinks it is their fault that a golf course with his name (that he didn’t own) on it that his family managed went bankrupt a few years ago.
That’s why he lies about helping Puerto Rico – because he knows his loyal supporters, the ones that don’t care that he spent decades groping women without their permission and bragged about it, that he refused to pay workers what he owed them, that he said he could shoot someone in Time Square and his supporters would stick with him …
Hillary was right when she said Trump’s supporters were deplorable people — as deplorable as Trump or worse.
LikeLike
Bingo!
LikeLike
Tragically, his core supporters don’t consider Puerto Rico to be American (nor could they find it on a map, or probably any place else). Therefore he will pay little, if any, political price. They’re too busy burning their NFL jerseys and cheering on tinpot police chiefs who prohibit their employees from working games and thereby forgo their extra pay.
LikeLike
Puerto Ricans can’t vote. That probably is also why tRump doesn’t care about them.
LikeLike
Actually, they can and do vote.
LikeLike
You are right. Some of the information that I was given was incorrect.
LikeLike
At least I’m now assuming that this Googled reply is correct. [Who is The Wikianswers Community? Making the world better one answer at a time? Ugh.
………………….
Answered by The WikiAnswers® Community
Answers.com® is making the world better one answer at a time.
Yes. Puerto Ricans are US citizens, and all US citizens over the age of 18 (without certain felonies on their record) can vote in federal and local elections.
LikeLike
Puerto Rico is a commonwealth, not a state. The residents on the island are all American citizens, and they hold US Passports. They can freely relocate to the US Mainland at any time, and reside on the mainland.
They do NOT vote in US elections. They have no congressional representation, or senators. (They do have a non-voting delegate to the US house of representatives).
The do NOT pay US federal taxes.
see
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Federal_voting_rights_in_Puerto_Rico
LikeLike
Charles,
Do you suggest that we let Puerto Ricans die?
LikeLike
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Taxation_in_Puerto_Rico
LikeLike
Q Do you suggest that we let Puerto Ricans die? END Q
Reductio ad absurdum. I am suggesting no such thing, and you know it. The US Government should proceed with all possible haste to deliver humanitarian aid and necessary relief to the American citizens on the island of Puerto Rico.
President Trump, just announced that he is waiving the “Jones act” see
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Merchant_Marine_Act_of_1920
This suspension will enable ships from non-US nations to access the ports and disembark humanitarian supplies.
I am very interested to see if any other nations step in, and actually provide aid. When there is an earthquake or disaster in a foreign nation, the USA is often the first country to go in (This is a good thing!).
When Hurricane Katrina hit New Orleans in 2005, about 12 or so other nations offered humanitarian aid. The Netherlands provided engineering advice on how to pump out water, etc.
LikeLike
Trump waived the Jones Act immediately for Houston and Florida. He waited a week to do so for Puerto Rico. Why?
LikeLike
There was infrastructure in Texas and Florida, there was NOTHING LEFT IN PUERTO RICO. If it had been waived immediately there would have been no place for them to off load, or redistribute ANYTHING.
Did arm chair quarterbacking ever win a game? Pay attention and you can see there is a lot more happening than you think.
The Trump Inaugural Committee just announced a $3 MILLION dollar donation to three charities successfully operating in Puerto Rico. The funds are from the private donations it received for his inauguration.
LikeLike
I couldn’t believe that Trump said the problem is Texas has roads to bring in supplies. “Puerto Rico is an island in an ocean, a big, big ocean.” I am sure he knows about airplanes since he flies around in Air Force 1. He speaks like a twelve year old boy, and he is an embarrassment.
LikeLike
You offend twelve year old boys everywhere! 😉
LikeLike
Why am I not surprised that his is once again developing into the “lets beat up on Charles” narrative? If the President was out there on day one..it would not have been soon enough. Your criticism is unwarranted and an expected result of the political agenda you spout. Don’t try to make this Trump’s Katrina. He has been doing a terrific job. With the world situation and the natural disasters and the political issues at hand…I marvel at his stamina
FEMA had many days of preparation in anticipation of the Texas and Florida disasters. Maria happened suddenly to islands with poor infrastructure. Puerto Rico and the Virgin Islands situation is a logistical nightmare: Poor or no, power, sanitation, water, communications, roads, airstrip or ports. The governor praised the president for the help they were getting and you can be assured that much more will be coming in. Instead if jumping the gun and believing the lies being broadcast by various media sources, get some facts from the people on the island and the government officials there. You could always give to the multi president charity (perhaps the money will not go to the Clinton foundation this time…we see how Haiti rebuilt…not), Red Cross or religious groups. Samaritans Purse will keep you posted.
LikeLike
Airport virtually destroyed. With NO POWER GRID how do you plan to run the air traffic control center. Even fuel for generators is harshly limited because of the devastation.
Imagine for a minute what Texas and Florida would have been like with that kind of double whammy. Help still would have been faster than Puerto Rico because of proximity to restoring vital services.
Imagine sitting in your house in the dark with no roof to protect you from rain or wind. You have no power, no water, no sanitation … ALL MODERN CONVENIENCES HAVE BEEN WHIPPED FROM YOUR WORLD. Any preparations you did has been destroyed. Whatever you imagine will still be better than the reality they are living.
LikeLike
Answer: They are just BROWN people…in tRump’s mind.
LikeLike
Agree.
LikeLike
Sadly, he does not care about brown people. Kanye was right.
LikeLike
This misinformation just came out in an email from the WH. How much help can these people give to rebuilding when they are starving, have no medication, have no money because ATM’s are down and have no clean drinking water? They are going to die soon and Trump says things are going well. I read that American ships are charging high prices for basics so most Puerto Ricans can’t afford to purchase anything, even if it is available.
………………………
The federal government is continuing to provide life-saving and life-sustaining resources to Puerto Rico and the U.S. Virgin Islands. While significant progress in being made in the response to Hurricane Maria, recovery for Puerto Rico and the U.S. Virgin Islands will be long and will require the help of the whole community. As access to ports, airfields, and roads continue to open, resources will become more easily available to the hardest hit areas.
LikeLike
Carol, read about the Jones Act. It will sicken you. It explains the reasons for the high cost or resources.
LikeLike
I just copied this off of Fred Klonsky’s blog:
The Hill is reporting that President Trump refuses to waive the Jones Act restrictions on shipping aid to the island.
The Trump administration on Tuesday denied a request from several members of Congress to waive shipping restrictions to help get gasoline and other supplies to Puerto Rico as the island recovers from Hurricane Maria.
The Department of Homeland Security (DHS) declined the request to waive the Jones Act, which limits shipping between coasts to U.S.-flagged vessels, according to Reuters. DHS waived the act following hurricanes Harvey and Irma, which hit the mainland U.S.
The agency has in the past waived the rule to allow cheaper and more readily-available foreign vessels to supply goods to devastated areas. But DHS said Tuesday that waiving the act for Puerto Rico would not help the U.S. island territory due to damaged ports preventing ships from docking.
“The limitation is going to be port capacity to offload and transit, not vessel availability,” a spokesperson for Customs and Border Protection told Reuters.
In a letter to the department on Tuesday, Sen. John McCain (R-Ariz.) urged DHS to rethink the decision, citing the agency’s willingness to waive the Jones Act for relief efforts in the wake of hurricanes Harvey and Irma.
“The Department of Homeland Security has been given the ability to waive the Jones Act to accommodate national security concerns, and has done so twice in the last month,” McCain wrote. “These emergency waivers have been valuable to speed up recovery efforts in the impacted regions. However, I am very concerned by the Department’s decision not to waive the Jones Act for current relief efforts in Puerto Rico, which is facing a worsening humanitarian crisis following Hurricane Maria.”
McCain called the department’s decision “unacceptable” and warned that Puerto Rico faces a humanitarian crisis as the island’s 3.4 million people struggle to survive without power or clean water.
Officials estimate the island could be without power for up to six months.
“It is unacceptable to force the people of Puerto Rico to pay at least twice as much for food, clean drinking water, supplies and infrastructure due to Jones Act requirements as they work to recover from this disaster,” McCain wrote.
“Now, more than ever, it is time to realize the devastating effect of this policy and implement a full repeal of this archaic and burdensome Act,” he wrote.
LikeLike
But didn’t Senator McCain know there is no humanitarian crisis?
LikeLike
I think why Trump didn’t care about what happened to Puerto Ricans is pretty simple and obvious:
Puerto Ricans don’t have the right to vote for president, so Trump doesn’t need their help in the next election. (He probably doesn’t see them as American citizens, too.)
Puerto Ricans are also primarily of Hispanic origin, and we know what Trump really thinks about people of color. So ignoring the basic needs of Hispanics and trashing Black athletes who engaged in peaceful protests were ways for him to spend the weekend playing to his base of white racists and hold onto their votes so he can get re-elected.
EVERYTHING Trump does is all about him.
LikeLike
My husband went to Puerto Rico for work during the election between HRC and BHO. Hillary posters were everywhere!….and Hillary was due in to pay a visit. Puerto Rico is very pro HRC.
LikeLike
That must have been before Obama’s first term. They’re only allowed to vote in primaries.
LikeLike
There are 10,000+ governmental aid workers on the ground in Puerto Rico. There are Navy ships and personnel providing medical assistance and more. But, Puerto Rico has suffered such devastation after TWO category 5 hurricanes it will take MONTHS just to re-establish a BASIC INFASTRUCTURE.
There is NO POWER GRID, not even the skeleton of one exists. Without power they have NO water systems either. After the hurricanes in Texas, Louisiana and Florida there remained an infrastructure. There were still roads under the debris. Since they were so close, it was easy to wait on the sidelines a few hundred miles away. That was and is still not an option in Puerto Rico. The military is working hard and fast to clear roads and rebuild them and the bridges that were destroyed.
Then there was the dam that needed to be stabilized before it collapsed under the pressure of the additional waters from the hurricanes. It would have been suicidal to send people into harms way. There would have been no saving them … which is probably why authorities there were still calling for evacuations after the hurricanes had hit.
The situation in Puerto Rico is catastrophic and has been responded to appropriately. Now that things are stabilizing to a certain degree Congress can consider raising the Jones Act restrictions. There are limited options for ships and planes to enter … so it is the NATURE AND EXTENT OF THE DESTRUCTION that puts limits on helping in Puerto Rico. It will be MONTHS before they get power, communications, sanitation, local water sources and more. They have NOTHING resembling modern conveniences to even build upon.
Their hardship is not lessened by phoney criticism to gain political points.
LikeLike
I believe you and Fox news are the only ones who believe Puerto Rico is receiving adequate help. Where do you get your news? My sources totally disagree with your assertion that adequate help has arrived.
LikeLike
In Republicanese, “adequate” is something inadequately meant for others, not for themselves. The would never accept “adequate” for themselves because they are “deserving” of more than anyone not like them.
LikeLike
It is almost revolting listening to the claptrap that you spew
“For Hurricane Harvey, FEMA had supplies and personnel positioned in Texas before the storm made landfall on August 25. Within days, the number of FEMA employees, other federal agencies, and the National Guard deployed topped 31,000, FEMA said. In addition, FEMA supplied 3 million meals and 3 million liters of water to Texas to be distributed to survivors.
Hurricane Irma: Even more federal personnel responded to Hurricane Irma when it made landfall in Florida on September 10. More than 40,000 federal personnel, including 2,650 FEMA staff, were in place by September 14. In addition, FEMA had transferred 6.6 million meals and 4.7 million liters of water to states in the Southeast after Irma as of the 14th.”
http://www.cnn.com/2017/09/26/us/response-harvey-irma-maria/index.html
Local officials told CNN that 4,000 Army reservists were at work on the island already—although that figure doesn’t match official reporting coming out of the Pentagon or FEMA. (It may, predominantly, include the members of the Puerto Rico National Guard, which includes roughly 8,400 Air and Army National Guard troops.)
So that number is actually 4000 . Now I am sure the National Guard has been mobilized. The other 4400 will be there as soon as they swim out of their living rooms . The rest of that number includes 5-700 FEMA personnel and naval resources on the way . As well as a handful of aircraft and and troops on ships waiting to be deployed.
http://www.slate.com/articles/news_and_politics/politics/2017/09/the_trump_administration_s_disaster_response_in_puerto_rico_after_hurricane.html
But it is an “Island in a big Ocean” ,which is why when the storm was predicted to hit . At least 9 or 10 days ago plans had to be ready to get way more resources there . But like New Orleans they were not ” real Americans” ,many speak another language and have dark skin . Or there would have been a different response.
Heck of a job Donnie
LikeLike
The Atlantic Ocean? I don’t think tRump knows where Puerto Rico is located. Trump is thrilled with the praise he is getting from government officials in Puerto Rico. Unbelievable. His narcissism is out of touch with reality.
……………….
From newyorker.com: The Distance Between Donald Trump and Puerto Rico
The President has failed to convey that the humanitarian disaster following Hurricane Maria is happening in America, rather than some place distant from this country….
…Trump has, so far, focussed on how different Puerto Rico is, and what its people owe him, which is, above all, their gratitude.
“We have been really treated very, very nicely by the governor and by everybody else,” Trump said later, during a press conference on Tuesday afternoon with Mariano Rajoy, the Prime Minister of Spain. Trump was referring to the governor of Puerto Rico, Ricardo Rosselló, and his colleagues. “They know how hard we’re working and what a good job we’re doing.” When a reporter nonetheless asked Trump whether he had perhaps spent a disproportionate amount of time tweeting complaints about N.F.L. players kneeling during the national anthem, when he should have been rallying support for Puerto Rico, Trump bristled, and insisted that his attacks on the players were important for America. Then he went back to talking about what he had done for Puerto Rico—“I have plenty of time on my hands”—adding that the governor “is so grateful for the job we are doing. In fact, he thanked me specifically for fema and all the first responders.” Trump described that praise as “incredible” and “amazing,” and said, “We have had tremendous reviews from government officials.”…
At the press conference, Trump repeated that the big problem with getting help to Puerto Rico was “a thing called the Atlantic Ocean. This is tough stuff.”
https://www.newyorker.com/news/amy-davidson-sorkin/the-distance-between-donald-trump-and-puerto-rico
LikeLike
Do you suppose he could figure out how to get aid to Hawaii if they were hit by a horrific natural disaster?
LikeLike
The Pacific is an even bigger ocean than the Atlantic. That would present a problem. I imagine tRump could find Hawaii…IF he has a golf course in Hawaii that hasn’t gone bankrupt.
LikeLike
He would ignore Hawaii because Obama was born there. Or, as Trump would say, claimed to be. I recall he sent a team of private detectives to Hawaii and they found amazing things, but he never reported on what they found. Their way to the men’s room?
LikeLike
How happy the people must be. Help is coming over the next 180 days. People are going to die of help doesn’t come immediately!!
…………..
This was just sent out by the WH:
Hurricane Maria
Yesterday, President Donald J. Trump received two briefings on hurricane recovery efforts in Puerto Rico and announced an amendment to the Puerto Rico and U.S. Virgin Islands disaster declarations. These amendments will provide additional disaster assistance by authorizing additional federal funding for debris removal and emergency protective measures over the next 180 days. “Over the last several weeks our Nation has been tested by the destructive force of Mother Nature,” the President said in yesterday’s press conference, “but we will respond to it with an even mightier force: the resolve of the American spirit.”
LikeLike
the resolve of the American spirit…..HMMMM sounds like all Americans need to open their wallets and donate to the GoFund me page of choice. Just like we have Fake news, I’m sure there are plenty of fake donation pages just waiting for all that American Spirit to start flying around.
LikeLike
The Governor of Puerto Rico is very satisfied with the federal cooperation it has been receiving from this administration. He went so far as to say they have NEVER RECEIVED THE KIND OF COOPERATION FROM ANY OTHER PRESIDENT.
LikeLike
Linda…I believe the governor was satisfied with FEMA and their pencils and clipboards. How come it has taken 6 days for our leader to decide to send essentials to the Americans living in the territory of Puerto Rico? Sorry, but 6 days is a long time without water, food and medical supplies.
LikeLike
It didn’t take that long. But they had no airport, no sea ports, no roads, bridges out, no power NOTHING. Under those conditions (in the ocean and miles from ANY sort of staging area) circumstances are DIFFERENT! Response has actually been rather quick, given their locale and current primitive status. Even Samaritans Purse can only make two flights in per day!
LikeLike
Hey Linda, what the Governor of Puerto Rico is saying, doesn’t sound like he’s very satisfied. He is thankful forTrumps “consideration” of the problem. Spin it all you want, but Trump has turned his back on American citizens living in a US territory.
LikeLike
The Govenor of Puerto Rico clearly stated that he was very pleased with the administration’s response. It seems previous presidents have all but ignored their little island, but Trump is stepping up.
I know it doesn’t fit your fake narrative, but not much does. Spin it and it is still not the TRUTH. Push your political agenda when you can provide facts.
LikeLike
“The Govenor of Puerto Rico clearly stated that he was very pleased with the administration’s response.”
………….
I’m sure the Governor of Puerto Rico has learned to “please” tRump if he wants anything.
LikeLike
Since the Puerto Ricans are totally dependent on the U.S., the governor is hardly likely to berate Trump. They have no vote, so they have no clout.
LikeLike
As my friends here know, I like to spew German terms every now and then (pretentious, moi?). LG is a wonderful example of a Mitläufer. Can’t think of a better one. She’ll go down fighting no matter what facts might be in her way.
LikeLike
Has anyone seen these disaster declarations? And the Amendment for 180 days?
Did anyone in the WH hear the report of the airdrop of personnel needed to clear rubble in order to inspect the damage to communications, roads, buildings, everything? Have they seen the pictures acquired by people operating camera-equipped drones?
What about the role of the drug companies who located in Puerto Rico for huge tax breaks that ended several years ago. Will they pitch in or walk away? My guess is profits before people. I would love to be wrong.
Commercial flights in and out of San Juan can be booked. Some are leaving San Juan with empty seats because there is no power or system for using computers for seat assignments. A dear friend has booked a flight to San Juan in early October in order to check on her family. Getting to her home in Ponce is another matter altogether.
In theory, Trump has command of all of the resources needed to aid Puerto Rico and the Virgin Islands. He does not care, nor do members of Congress who are saying and doing NOTHING.
LikeLike
We are too solicitous for government intervention, on the theory, first, that the people themselves are helpless, and second, that the Government has superior capacity for action. Often times both of these conclusions are wrong.
Calvin Coolidge
LikeLike
Please go move to Puerto Rico.
LikeLike
Well, not that they want you any more than we do, and apologies for inflicting you on them. But I’m just betting that in the event of a disaster, you’d be the first one begging the big, bad gubmint to come and save you.
LikeLike
OH NO…Charles can take care of himself. He’s probably made sure that he exploited every tax loophole to keep the most money for himself. He don’t need no stinkin’ gubmint handouts.
LikeLike
Q Charles can take care of himself. He’s probably made sure that he exploited every tax loophole to keep the most money for himself. He don’t need no stinkin’ gubmint handouts. END Q
I am personally offended by this remark. I put up with a lot of s*** here, but this is beyond the pale.
I pay my taxes, like every other honest American. I am not a wealthy person, with legions of CPAs to seek loopholes.
LikeLike
I have no desire to do this. I own a home in Virginia, and I work here.Puerto Rico was an economic train wreck, before the hurricane. Why in the world, would you suggest such a thing?
LikeLike
Charles, as he is wont to do, always teaches us, just not in the way he intends; the lessons we must learn are invariably in the opposite direction of what he intends. It is worth remembering that Coolidge left office just less than 8 months before the October crash that led to the Great Depression (Hoover was not amused). He, much like our Dear Leader, installed people who were diametrically opposed to the missions their cabinets and agencies were meant to uphold—especially in the areas of finance and banking—which led to catastrophic results.
But to Coolidge’s credit, his harvest of neglect was reaped shortly after he left office, so he was not around to be held accountable. The last three words of the quote Charles chooses to use are correct, he just doesn’t realize that they refute everything that comes before them. Like all ideologues, actual experience seems to have never mattered to him. I would love to see him recite that quote right now in Puerto Rico. I have a feeling he would literally not survive the response he would get. It would likely be a case of justified homicide.
LikeLike
I am 100% supportive of humanitarian efforts to relieve the distress of our fellow American citizens on the Island of Puerto Rico. Nevertheless, I believe that, in many cases, private charities and individuals can assist the victims on natural disasters AS WELL AS government.
Calvin Coolidge is one of my favorite presidents. Here is why:
http://www.slate.com/articles/news_and_politics/history_lesson/2006/09/help_call_the_white_house.html
“The Government is not the insurer of its citizens against the hazards of the elements. We shall always have flood and drought, heat and cold, earthquake and wind, lightning and tidal wave, which are all too constant in their afflictions. The Government does not undertake to reimburse citizens for loss and damage incurred under such circumstances. It is chargeable, however, with the rebuilding of public works and the humanitarian duty of relieving its citizens of distress.” (Calvin Coolidge, 1927 Annual Message to Congress)
LikeLike
I’m not sure why I responded to you earlier, especially since it’s such a waste of time. The Coolidge quote you cite is, to put it charitably, tripe. Sounds good, not based in reality. A couple of examples: federal (taxpayer) support for Katrina relief totaled more than $110 billion, private charitable contributions totaled between $4-5 billion. As Charity Navigator stated: “The donations for Katrina made up a small portion — less than 4 percent — of the total given so far to help rebuild the Gulf Coast region. The federal government has spent more than $110 billion, according to the Chronicle of Philanthropy.” The same will hold true for Harvey, Irma, and Maria relief.
Another example. In cancer research funding the biggest source of annual non-governmental funding comes from the American Cancer Society which in 2016 totaled about $150.5 million. The National Cancer Institute, the largest of the National Institutes of Health, funded more than $5 billion in the same year. That funding is spread out through peer reviewed research in cancer institutes throughout the nation. All those well meaning walkathons, galas, golf tournaments, etc. don’t raise a fraction of what taxpayers fund. And what we fund is actually much too low to capitalize on the best scientific ideas that should be supported.
See how that works? When there are major public needs, the well-meaning intentions of people, most of whom are looking for tax deductions as they “do good works” doesn’t add up compared to public funding. Public funding is geometrically more likely to address major problems. And your example of the 1927 Mississippi Flood mythology doesn’t add up to the reality of the actual costs involved. See the most comprehensive history of that episode, John Barry’s “Rising Tide.” Sounds nice, like a Coolidge quote, but it doesn’t add up to the real world costs a civilized country needs. After all, you’ve lived in Mozambique. How does that charity funding plus lack of public funding add up to solve real problems? Where is their savior of a Coolidge? Perhaps in the mythology you choose to believe rather than the empirical evidence the rest of us demand.
LikeLike
Q . After all, you’ve lived in Mozambique. How does that charity funding plus lack of public funding add up to solve real problems? Where is their savior of a Coolidge? Perhaps in the mythology you choose to believe rather than the empirical evidence the rest of us demand. END Q
I lived in the People’s Republic of Mozambique. When I was there, the average income was about $360 per year. It was one of the poorest nations on earth.
They looked to Karl Marx and Frederich Engels, to take them all to the promised land. The country was (and is) a socialist train wreck.
The government spent, but their paper money was worthless. The official exchange rate was MT40 per dollar, but the free-market rate was MT1600 per dollar.
The Republic of South Africa is next to Mozambique. South Africa has a free-market economy, and it is where many Mozambicans wanted to immigrate. (South Africa was run by the white Afrikaner government then).
Mozambicans looked to the free market for freedom, which their socialist government could not provide.
LikeLike
Nice of you to ignore all of my argument and focus on the most minor and insignificant part of what I wrote. So back to the point: can you name one example of the “many cases” you cite when “private charities and individuals can assist the victims on (sic) natural disasters AS WELL AS government”? First, I know you won’t find one “AS WELL AS”, which is you didn’t write “better.” Well, perhaps if you go back to the loaves and fishes from the Sermon on the Mount. But might have just been effective marketing and p.r.
LikeLike
Glad to see the Red Cross and Catholic Relief Services step up to the plate when there are natural disasters but they do not have the resources of the federal government.
LikeLike
Calvin Coolidge? Really?
LikeLike
Calvin Coolidge is one of my favorite presidents. Here is why
https://imprimis.hillsdale.edu/calvin-coolidge-and-the-moral-case-for-economy/
Calvin Coolidge brought in a budget surplus, and left office with a smaller federal budget, that he started with.
LikeLike
Of course you would quote Hillsdale, a libertarian College that refuses any federal aid for its students.
LikeLike
Dang, that must make him the country’s best president! Funny how the Great Depression followed 8(?) months after he left office. Hoover got blamed for Coolidge’s failure to regulate the “free” market.
LikeLike
No serious historian would ever rank Coolidge as one of our best presidents. Nevertheless, no serious historian holds Coolidge responsible for the Great Depression. That is absurd.
Coolidge was a man of impeccable integrity, and personal honesty. He cherished limited government. Historians are giving his presidency as serious look, again.
Some historians (and amateur historians like myself) believe that FDRs economic policies not only exacerbated the depression, but actually hindered the recovery. see
LikeLike
Well, since you declare it absurd it must be so. Coolidge’s policies had nothing to do with the Great Depression. I will not argue that he was a not man of impeccable integrity and personal honesty. What that has to do with cherishing limited governing, I am not sure. In his case, it probably means that he was absurdly naive. Unfortunately, the businessmen/oligarchs who supported him were not equally virtuous. Whether Roosevelt hindered the recovery or not depends on how you define the recovery. The guy going back door to back door looking for odd jobs may have had something to say about that. Everyone admires the proud poor man who takes nothing from anyone that he didn’t earn with his own two hands, especially when it lets them off the hook. My town benefited greatly from those “make work” projects Roosevelt championed. those work camps were certainly not vacations. Of course, we all know it was really the multitude of charitable organizations that saved the millions who lost their jobs because of financial shenanigans allowed under loose regulation. H-m-m-m, sounds familiar doesn’t it? Doesn’t everyone remember how those responsible for the 2008 financial meltdown caused by shady financial manipulations all went to prison?… Lost their jobs?… Paid huge financial penalties?… Said they were sorry?
LikeLike
And here is what Fox ‘news’ has to say:
Rachel Campos-Duffy, Rep. Sean Duffy: Making Puerto Rico great again | Fox News
It’s been reported that President Trump is considering a trip to Puerto Rico to see first-hand the devastation caused by Hurricanes Irma and Maria. With this visit comes the opportunity to help make Puerto Rico great again. | Fox News
President Trump won’t go to Puerto Rico to fundraise or campaign. He’ll go to show the people of Puerto Rico that he cares, to see the island-wide damage up close and personal, and to make sure that the federal government and mainland Americans don’t forget about our fellow citizens struggling in Puerto Rico.
President Trump’s business reputation as a “doer” who can get results is essential now more than ever, as the hurricanes have knocked out most of the island’s power and basic infrastructure.
Moreover, with his extensive experience in the tourism industry, President Trump is uniquely positioned to understand and empathize with the effects of Irma and Maria on the island’s fragile economy.
His business background will also help him fully appreciate the consequences of the current debt crisis plaguing the island. Looking at the images of devastation coming out of Puerto Rico, it’s hard to believe that anything could inflict as much damage as the winds and rains of these Category 4 hurricanes. But long before Irma and Maria, Puerto Rico’s irresponsible government policies led to economic recession, joblessness, massive debt, and an unprecedented exodus to the U.S. mainland. Tens of thousands of Puerto Rico’s most talented and ambitious citizens have made the painful decision to leave their families and their beautiful island in search of opportunities on the mainland, and countless thousands more will be forced to do the same if there is no decisive action to rebuild the island.
The Republican Congress has taken the lead in trying to help Puerto Rico restructure its debts and make the necessary reforms to get back on its economic feet through a bill introduced and passed last year called PROMESA…
http://fxn.ws/2wWgEoB
LikeLike
Sickening. Blame the victims.
LikeLike
Oh my goodness. What would happen to tRump if he had to Twitter more than 140 words? He’d just have to keep repeating and repeating words like, “wonderful, greatest, the best ever, magnificent, incredible, amazing, tremendous and fantastic”. I hope this version doesn’t pass the test. 140 words is enough to make me sick.
…..
Twitter is testing a version of its service that would double the length of a tweet, to 280 characters.
LikeLike
He could say “me” and “I” at least 200 times
LikeLike
I just read this in Slate:
“Meanwhile, Congress is working on an aid package, which House Speaker Paul Ryan said would come in October.”
LikeLike
The Political Travesty of Puerto Rico
By David S. Cohen, Rolling Stone
…But there’s another hugely important reason Puerto Rico has struggled, and will certainly continue to struggle, to get the aid it needs: It has no real representation in its own national government. In other words, the Revolutionary War rally cry of “taxation without representation” is everyday life in Puerto Rico.
Puerto Rico is an American territory of about 3.5 million people. As a territory, Puerto Rico has only one, non-voting member of Congress (currently Jenniffer González-Colón). If Puerto Rico were a state, based on its size, it would have five voting members of the House of Representatives and two senators.
Think of what a difference that would make for Puerto Rico right now. Those seven members of Congress – members who would have actual voting power in the House and Senate – would be able to make a case to their colleagues about the need for immediate help to Puerto Rico. González-Colón can do that now, of course, but her voice is much less powerful because she is by herself – and, more importantly, because she can’t vote, she has no power to wield with other members.
If she could vote, her vote would be on the minds of other members of Congress, who would be more inclined to listen to her in order to have her on their side in the future. And if she could vote along with six other Congress members from Puerto Rico, they would be a sizable bloc that would be hard to ignore.
Further compounding the problem, Puerto Rico has no real say in who the president is. As a territory, Puerto Rico votes in the primaries for both parties, but has no representation in the Electoral College that determines who becomes president. (This is true of all U.S. territories, as John Oliver made clear in a powerful segment two years ago.)
Long ago, the Supreme Court gave its blessing to this situation in a series of cases from the early 1900s called the Insular Cases. These had to do with whether Puerto Ricans, now that they were part of the United States, had constitutional rights. The Court held that territories do not have all constitutional rights, particularly when it comes to self-government. As former Puerto Rican Supreme Court Justice José Trías Monge has written, the decisions tell us that, under the Constitution, there is “nothing wrong when a democracy such as the United States engages in the business of governing others.”
In short, Puerto Ricans are American citizens who have no real say in what the American government does. That’s why Gov. Ricardo Rosselló’s statement Monday about the devastation in Puerto Rico ended with this sentence:
“Given Puerto Rico’s fragile economic recovery prior to the storms, we ask the Trump Administration and U.S. Congress to take swift action to help Puerto Rico rebuild.”
The key word there is “ask” – because, without any say in what his national government does, asking is all Rosselló can do…
LikeLike
“Territory” is a euphemism for “colony,” which is also confirmed by the fact that the Jones Act makes imports (which, on an island, means almost everything) expensive, while all sorts of tax breaks make production costs cheaper, while denying tax revenues to the island.
Trump and his supporters are apparently hoping that the people of Puerto Rico will just die quietly.
LikeLike
The Jones Act had to be waived during Harvey and Irma as well. It isn’t just business competition, but security that foreign ships in American ports of entry would pose. This is a losing democratic mantra. If there was any truth to it you would NOT see the U.S. helping Mexico after their last earthquake. This is in spite of the fact that Mexico’s promised aid to Texas was rescinded after it’s first earthquake.
Puerto Rico is a unique set of circumstances. Not only have they experienced a set of uniquely devastating disasters, but their infrastructure was crumbling before this. They are also over $70 billion dollars in debt and I do not know the progress, if any, that has been made since it was restructured in January, 2016. They are on a pathway to become the fifty-first state, so why would we turn our backs on them?
LikeLike
You conveniently forget that Trump did not even have the basic courtesy to offer the condolences of the U.S. after that earthquake. Help was rescinded because of his total lack of compassion. The Mexicans were offended and rightfully so.
LikeLike
tRump, finally gave in and did what was right. McCain was one of the first Repubs to want this to happen. Why are major events announced on Twitter? Good grief.
…………..
BREAKING NEWS
The Trump administration waived a law that officials said was slowing efforts to get food and medicine to Puerto Rico after Hurricane Maria
Thursday, September 28, 2017 8:56 AM EDT
The Trump administration said on Thursday that it would waive the Jones Act for Puerto Rico, a century-old shipping law that Puerto Rican officials said was slowing efforts to get supplies to the island.
Sarah Huckabee Sanders, the White House press secretary, announced the decision on Twitter, saying that President Trump had authorized the waiver after a request from Gov. Ricardo A. Rosselló of Puerto Rico.
LikeLike
The governor knows to be gentle, kind and appreciative to tRump. It is the only way to begin to get any help for the island when people are dying. How thoughtful of tRump to say that the island was ‘virtually destroyed’ at a rally introducing his tax reform.
…………….
Puerto Rico Officials Say ‘People Are Going to Die’ After Hurricane Maria
By Joe Difazio, International Business Times
28 September 17
A week after Hurricane Maria hit Puerto Rico, the island is devastated. The Category 4 storm struck Puerto Rico with winds of 155 mph. The island is now almost entirely without power, which threatens people at hospitals.
“People are going to die,” said Dorado Mayor Carlos López Rivera about dialysis patients in the town on Wednesday.
Gasoline, crucial for running electrical generators, is also hard to come by. Half of the country is without water and only 20 percent of Puerto Rico’s cell towers work. Food and water are being shipped in by sea and by air by the Federal Emergency Management Agency, but more is needed. Rural areas, in particular, are not getting the supplies they need.
“It’s life or death,” San Juan mayor Carmen Cruz told CBS News Tuesday “People are starting to die already. People are really dying. I’ve put them in the ambulances when they’re gasping for air.”
At least 18 have died in the U.S. territory so far.
Puerto Rico’s governor has thanked the President Donald Trump for his response but said that the island needs more help.
“He has been acting proactively,” said Gov. Ricardo Rosselló to the New York Times Tuesday. “We still need more, and the president understands that and his team understands that.”
Many hospitals have been put out of commission by the storm, and the ones that are operating are run by diesel generators.
Infrastructure in Puerto Rico was also badly damaged. In addition to the electrical grid, road and bridges have been washed out and ports are operating at a limited capacity. Puerto Rico’s main airport in San Juan has been devastated, and groups of people are stranded there with the hopes of getting out. There 10 flights in and of the airport Tuesday, and officials anticipate only around 18 on Wednesday.
“Let me begin by saying that our hearts and prayers go out to the people of Puerto Rico and the US Virgin Islands, who are suffering in the wake of yet another catastrophic hurricane,” Trump said. “Their island was virtually destroyed,” said Trump at a rally introducing tax reform.
LikeLike
Roy Moore’s Victory Only Adds to Trump’s Power Over the GOP
By Frank Rich, New York Magazine
…After Puerto Rico’s governor warned of a coming “humanitarian crisis” and a potential mass exodus, Trump seems to be finally turning his attention there, planning a visit for next week. What took so long?
Hmm … First, he had to tend to his new NFL culture war so he could fire up his base and distract it from the health-care collapse. Second, he may have only recently discovered that Puerto Rico is an island, but he did know that Puerto Ricans speak Spanish and no doubt regards them as rapists and criminals. Third, he may have been wasting time trying to add Puerto Ricans to the travel ban until John Kelly or some other minder pointed out that they are American citizens. Fourth, his highest priority was to try to help his cronies get their money out of Puerto Rico before any storm refugees could: As Stephanie Ruhle of MSNBC helpfully pointed out when analyzing the Trump tweet attacking Puerto Rico for its “massive debt” to bankers and Wall Street, one of the biggest investors there is the hedge-fund billionaire John Paulson, a major Trump backer.
Just another week in Trumpland.
http://nymag.com/daily/intelligencer/2017/09/frank-rich-roy-moore-and-the-trumpist-takeover-of-the-gop.html
LikeLike
JOHN Paulson gave Eva M’s charter chain $8.5 million in 2015
LikeLike
Eight days after Hurricane Maria struck Puerto Rico, some relief and supplies are beginning to arrive in San Juan, but little aid is reaching outlying areas.
More Photos of the Crisis in Puerto Rico
ALAN TAYLOR 12:58 PM ET 35 PHOTOS IN FOCUS
Eight days after Hurricane Maria struck Puerto Rico with devastating force, some relief and supplies are beginning to arrive in the capital of San Juan. However, the Associated Press reports that many on the island are “still waiting for help from anyone from the federal or Puerto Rican government. But the scope of the devastation is so broad, and the relief effort so concentrated in San Juan, that many people from outside the capital say they have received little to no help.” Puerto Rico’s governor says he intends to ask for more than a billion dollars in federal assistance.
Read this:
http://www.theatlantic.com/photo/2017/09/more-photos-of-the-crisis-in-puerto-rico/541428/
LikeLike
I’m still hearing few, if any, comments about what ISN’T being done for the U.S. Virgin Islands. Granted, it’s fewer people, but they’re still Americans–and not just those who have moved there from the mainland!
As for whether Trump would respond to a disaster in Montana, Wyoming, and the Dakotas…I doubt it! Too few voters in those states. Even Lumber Liquidators don’t build stores here!
LikeLike
I would guess most of that oversight would have been handed over to Zinke and members of FEMA.
LikeLike
FEMA is a part of the Orwellian named Department of Homeland Security, not the Department of Interior. Zinke is too busy trying to make Interior a resource brothel for his corporate overlords.
LikeLike