Two newsworthy items from Los Angeles:
First, the new school board elected charter chain operator Ref Rodriguez as its president. Rodriguez leads the PUC (Partnership Uplifting Communities) charter chain of 16 schools. Rodriguez called for unity after the just-concluded dirty election, the most expensive in U.S. history.
“LA SCHOOL BOARD PRESIDENT SEEKS UNITY AFTER UGLY ELECTION: New Los Angeles school board president Ref Rodriguez says he will kick off his tenure by reaching out to fellow board members in one-on-one meetings. The goal: helping the nation’s second-largest school district heal from one of the ugliest and most expensive school board races in the district’s history, he said. Rodriguez, who was elevated to president last week in a 4-3 vote, told Morning Education he wants to meet with his colleagues away from the public and media spotlights to build new relationships and work on old ones. That includes meeting individually with two new board members who were elected earlier this year, Kelly Gonez and Nick Melvoin, who share his support for charter schools. And it means finding common ground with each of the three board members who voted not to install him as president last week. Rodriguez also said he wants the board to get together soon and collectively commit to some “guiding principles.”
– The race is like a “cloud hanging over us” – The school board race pitted charter school backers against teachers unions, generating $17 million in campaign spending. Supporters of charter schools ultimately came out on top, shifting the board’s politics with the election of Gonez and Melvoin, two former Obama administration staffers, in May. Rodriguez, who joined the board in 2015, is now part of the majority that supports charters. But despite the victory, the race is like a “cloud hanging over us,” Rodriguez said. “What I’m hoping to do is unify this board and get past all of that rhetoric.”
– The divisiveness over charter schools has been damaging, Rodriguez said. “The media doesn’t help us any,” he said, adding that the “meat of the story” isn’t about school choice. Rodriguez ticked off a number of other pressing priorities – like addressing a multi-billion deficit made worse by underfunded pensions and declining enrollment, with students leaving the district for charter schools, for example. To improve the district’s finances, local education officials are also working to launch a unified enrollment system that would allow families to apply online to any school in the district. After some contentious debate last month, the board voted unanimously to approve $16.7 million for the new enrollment system, while excluding independent charter schools from it for at least two years. Rodriguez said he’s not sure if the board will revisit the issue with charter school supporters in the majority. “I’m not sure where we’ll end up,” he said.
– Rodriguez also stressed the need to highlight the successes of traditional public schools, while increasing collaboration between public schools and charter schools. “Charter schools are not a panacea,” he said. “They don’t have the ‘secret sauce’ when it comes to quality and we have to stop pretending that they do.”
Second item from Los Angeles: the salary of school board members was more than doubled, to $125,000 if they have no other job.

He really said this – “Charter schools are not a panacea,” he said. “They don’t have the ‘secret sauce’ when it comes to quality and we have to stop pretending that they do.”?
LikeLike
I am cynical but here is my take on this:
Charters in blue states are sick and tired of having to PRETEND to serve every student. They are sick and tired of having to promote that lie and maybe a few of them even feel guilty about it.
So, now they don’t have to! They have arrived! Betsy DeVos says no school should have any obligation to teach every child. Charters are no longer for every child and it’s a huge relief that charters can stop pretending to be. They were starting to get caught out with all their got to go lists! Luckily, their billionaire friends own the authorizing agencies so no problem, but like Trump eventually your bad deeds may catch up to you. How dandy that they aren’t bad deeds anymore! Charters are honest! We don’t have a solution so we’ll just happily “compete” with you for the best kids now! And throw back the other ones, of course, because how else can we make a profit?
Eli Broad signaled his approval of this new line by his refusal to oppose Betsy DeVos until after she had cleared the education committee and her Senate approval was guaranteed. Broad signaled his approval when his foundation gave their $250,000 prize to the charter chain with got to go lists, videos of model teachers punishing struggling (non-striver) students, and extraordinarily high suspension and attrition rates and retention (flunking kids) rates. To reward them for their great methods in separating the worthy from the unworthy kids.
Now that charters have a foothold, they can drop the pretense! They want to compete for the top kids and publicly acknowledge that they have no answer for most at-risk kids and therefore should have no obligation to teach any of them they don’t want to teach. Isn’t honesty grand?
LikeLike
that’s like the Serbians calling for a cease-fire. They’d use the time to re-supply for the next offensive.
LikeLike
Diane FYI–I live in but “below” the Los Angeles area–lots of slick ads for charter schools going on regularly at present on the main stations here. I don’t know if they are nationally aired.
LikeLike
Calling for unity after dubious tactics to beat out your opponent. Hm, where have I heard that before? Oh yeah, about a year ago.
LikeLike
The California Charter School Association is very much “like a cloud hanging over us.” Thanks, billionaire four letter words! So I have a question. What precisely is “collaboration between public schools and charter schools”? How can people who support competition for resources call for collaboration between competitors? Public schools will “collaborate” by making painful, unhealthy cuts to pay for the charter infestation? Then, public schools will help market charters by putting them on the District’s unified application? “Collaborate” means capitulate, wither and die. We refusio, Refugio Rodriguez.
LikeLike
I agree. There can be no compromise with the private sector, charter school movement. What they are doing with all of these little games is to become legitimate in the public psyche until almost everyone considers corporate charter schools acceptable as part of the public education system in the U.S.
LikeLike
LCT,
You know, “collaborate” with the invaders who have come to take your city.
LikeLike
I guess they didn’t learn anything from the War in Iraq. How could charters think they would be greeted as liberators. Shock and Awe-ful.
LikeLike
The problem is conflict of interest when a public school board members is elected to a public school board and has affiliation with privately managed charter school; or like Besty DeVos, is philosophically and historically committed to advancing privately managed charter school interest.
While California has no law preventing those that sit on a charter school board from sitting on a charter school board and a school board at the same time, it is a moral and not a statutory conflict of interest. Oakland had last school year the situation regarding a charter school that closed with the President of its school board setting on a charter school board at the same time he was the Oakland School Board President. No law, no legal harm that public school board member has a conflict of interest.
What makes school board members sitting on a public school board problematic is that the interest of the public school is a public interest and the interest of a charter school is a charter school interest.
A tangled mess is created trying to keep those two interests separate. A school board member, with a charter school conflict of interest calling for cooperate relationship between charters, means the call is for blinding himself, other board members and the public, to the fact that when the California charter school law was written the State Legislative intend was to for the public and private to compete.
Electing a school board member with an interest in a charter school is like having the CEO of Coke on the corporate board of Pepsi.
LikeLike
Jim…..you are right on. That’s what Corcoran and his “party of three” did in Florida. Hopefully all the school districts in this state slap a lawsuit on them for passing the nastiest education bill (illegal since it contained more than 1 item-against Florida law) on record. I hope they all burn in hell.
LikeLike
The charter industry wants Los Angeles, they want puvlic school resources and not “collaboration.” They have nothing to offer except trouble.
With the support of the Bill & Melinda Gates Foundation, 23 cities to date have signed District-Charter Collaboration Compacts, now called “Gates Compacts.”
These are formal agreements between school districts and charter schools, typically in the form of memorandum of understanding signed by one representative of the charter schools and one from the district.
These compacts have been marketed as a means to “ensure equal access to high-quality schools for all students.” They are not. They are a means for charters to extract resources from local districts ranging from no cost or low cost access to facilities and central administration services to participation in contracts for transportation or food service, having the district take on the job of special education for students, permitting students in charter schools to use sports facilities and the like. about seventeed of the “compact” cities are also in portfolio districts, where there is a unified enrollment scheme for alls chools and each school is supposed to be “autonomous,” disposable, like a bad stock in an investment portfolio, close the school if it is “underperforming.”
Some of the Gates contracts do not call for “sharing resources and responsibilities.” They focus developing “collaboration plans”or specify how the parties will share resources and responsibilities, or they detail structures for how collaboration plans will be developed. This is a way of saying that the changes that the Gates foundation wants cannot be executed quickly, especially the elimination of collective bargain, the introduction of merit pay, changes that put test scores front and center in accountability schemes.
The “bait” for signing a Compact has been a grant of $100,000 from the Gates Foundation with the prospect of securing additional grants if there is progress in meeting the terms of the compact.
The compact agreements for each city can be viewed at http://www.crpe.org/research/district-charter-collaboration/compact-cities. This whole program is managed by the Center for Reinventing Public Education. It publishes updates and informal evaluations of the program in a select number of these cities.
District-Charter Compact Cites, inaugural or renewal year of participation, Status reports are usually available for year the compacts were evaluated. I could not open any of these evaluations, although I did so over a year ago.
Aldine, TX 2016; Austin, TX 2013; Baltimore, MD, 2013; Boston, MA, 2016, 2013; Central Falls, RI, 2016, 2013; Chicago, IL, 2015, 2013; Cleveland, OH, 2016; Denver, CO; 2016, 2013; Franklin-McKinley, CA, 2015; Grand Prairie, TX (no report available); Hartford, CT, 2015, 2013; Indianapolis, ID (no report available); Lawrence, TX (no report available); Los Angeles, CA, 2015, 2013; Nashville, TN 2013; New York City, NY, 2013; Minneapolis, MN (no report available); Philadelphia, PN, 2013; RSD New Orleans, LA, 2016, 2013; Sacramento, CA, 2015, 2013; Spokane, WA, 2015;
Spring Branch, TX, 2013; Tulsa, OK, 2015.
Here is one of the early MOU overtures for Los Angeles, 2010.
http://www.crpe.org/sites/default/files/LosAngeles_Compact_Dec10_0.pdf.
Here are some other reports on Los Angeles from the Center for Reinventing Public Education. http://www.crpe.org/custom-search?keyword=Los+Angeles
LikeLike
Thanks for the heads up. I’m not sure who can put a stop to it, though. The richest man in the world is going to have lots of fun playing with the 4 public school enemies within the Los Angeles Board. He won’t even need to offer the hundred grand drop in the bucket to get us to sign up for the strings attached grant. The Board would sell Los Angeles for a dollar, one dollar, like Trading Places.
LikeLike
The same bait is used in Gates-funded Frontier Set for higher ed.
“Georgia will implement business models for collaborative course development and delivery.”
LikeLike
No doubt Cleveland signed on because the district’s CEO is a Pahara Institute Fellow.
The slime in Louisiana ed reform is reported at Deutsch 29 blog.
LikeLike
To all gullible and greedy edu-entrepreneurs/ philanthro-capitalists:
Today, in your mind, money is everything or the ultimate power.
Tomorrow, whenever democracy will not exist, your descendants will suffer because of your current gullibility.
We do not need to go back in History in the past of thousand or hundred years ago. We only need to observe many countries from poor to rich or from savage to civilized. This conscientious observation will awaken our soul about the importance of being kindness and humanity towards each other.
I would like to give some examples about NOT being humanity = killing opponents
1) In this link:
Ex-President of Brazil Sentenced to Nearly 10 Years in Prison for Corruption
By ERNESTO LONDOÑO JULY 12, 2017
Quote from reader:
Kaari, Madison WI 4 hours ago
If this were the 60’s or 70′ s former President Lula da Silva simply would have been gunned down by the far right, as so many leftists were in Latin America. Now they just jail them
Anyone who spoke of sympathy for the vast poor majority in that region was feared as a communist or worse. This included priests and nuns, many of whom were assasinated. Ask the Mothers of the Plaza in Argentina.
Do not forget that the current right wing Brazilian president is also seen as very corrupt.
2) In this link:
Liu Xiaobo, Chinese Dissident Who Won Nobel While Jailed, Dies at 61
By CHRIS BUCKLEY JULY 13, 2017
Readers pick:
HaoyuKevinWang
Washington, DC 4 hours ago
“For hatred is corrosive of a person’s wisdom and conscience; the mentality of enmity can poison a nation’s spirit, instigate brutal life and death struggles, destroy a society’s tolerance and humanity, and block a nation’s progress to freedom and democracy. I hope therefore to be able to transcend my personal vicissitudes in understanding the development of the state and changes in society, to counter the hostility of the regime with the best of intentions, and defuse hate with love.”
These were Mr. Liu’s words at his trial in 2009. Many of us are angry now, but please pause for a moment and reflect.
NYT Pick
Laura
Traverse City, MI 5 hours ago
What a selfless man, who chose to live uncomfortably and dangerously in the hope that his efforts may improve the quality of life for others. A light that burns in the darkness burns brightly and his will be sorely missed. We should all take up the slack.
Much love and my condolences to his wife, Liu Xiaobo. Rest in peace.
In short, all upcoming descendants from current edu-entrepreneurs and philanthro-capitalist will lose their democratic rights and will not be intelligent enough to sustain their wealth and power = the absolute and universal law of “evils follow evils” or bad deeds will suffer in the end.
Being kindness without gullibility and greed = good deeds return good deeds. Back2basic
LikeLike
I give them credit for admitting ed reform is relentlessly negative about public schools, and cheerleaders for charter schools.
It’s true. This “movement” is ridiculously skewed pro charter and anti public school.
What that means as a practical matter is they are harming children in public schools- that’s the majority of kids in Los Angeles.
Go the US Dept of Ed website and read any of Betsy DeVos’ speeches. According to the US Department of Education public schools are terrifying places full of bullies and low achievers – “factories” where children are mistreated and most of them are headed straight to prison.
Compare how she depicts public schools (and public school students) with her glowing reviews of charter schools.
It’s absolutely outrageous. And federally funded.
So good for the Los Angeles charter supporters for admitting they bash public schools and promote charter schools, because it is blindingly obvious to anyone outside the ed reform bubble.
LikeLike
The new school board members probably realized most of the kids in that city attend public schools, so they better at least pretend to have some interest in public schools.
If so, they’re smarter than Congress and the President – who don’t seem to have picked that up.
LikeLike
The leaked Broad plan to charterize half of Los Angeles put charters on their heels a bit. DeVos’ confirmation did some more. Now they use more secretive tactics than before. We’re on the left coast. Back door tactics are for blue states and cities; front door attacks on unions are for red states and counties.
LikeLike
One comment: UGH!
LikeLike
The Policy Director for Rodriguez’ LAUSD is an Education Pioneer Fellow. It doesn’t require guessing to know who funds Education Pioneers- $7.6 from Gates.
LikeLike
Broad, Gates, and Walton now own the LAUSD board.
LikeLike