New York is a blue state but has a divided legislature. Democrats control the Assembly, and Republicans control the State Senate. Republicans are not the majority of the State Senate. They are in power because of a small group of renegade Democrats who vote with the Republicans. They are called the Independent Democratic Caucus, and they hold the balance of power. Governor Andrew Cuomo likes the divided legislature, as it enhances his power.
The Alliance for Quality Education (AQE) investigated the IDC and discovered the source of their ample funding: Hedge fund managers and equity investors who favor charter schools and privatization.
Its report, called “Pay to Play: Charter Schools and the IDC,” lays out the political contributions that fuel the IDC campaigns:
“The IDC received $676,850 from charter school political donors.
“Over the past six years, the Independent Democratic Conference, a group of breakaway Democrats who support Republican control of the New York State Senate, have received $676,850 from charter school political donors. These political donors, including hedge fund managers and their political action committees, have been rewarded by the IDC as seen in the 2017 state budget where privately-
run charter schools got much larger funding increases per pupil than public schools. The IDC-Republican advocacy for privately-run charter schools at the expense of public schools runs counter to the IDC’s public pronouncements that they are championing public school funding and the Campaign for Fiscal Equity. The IDC is empowering pro-privatization, pro-Trump Republicans to run the State Senate even though it hurts the more than one million public school students they represent.
“The table below is lists the charter school-af liated individual and political action donations made to IDC members and to committees speci cally bene ting the IDC.
“Senators Hamilton and Peralta are not included in the list of IDC members shown below. Senator Jesse Hamilton joined the IDC on November 7, 2016. Senator Jose Peralta joined in January 2017. The two senators however, have a long history of receiving donations from the charter industry. Over the years, the donations they received come to a total of $ 11,500 for and $26,500 for Peralta. This money is in addition to the total shown in this report.”
Open the link to see the list of donors.
Why does this connection matter?
A Republican Senate can be relied on to prevent tax increases on the wealthy. This matters to them even more than charter schools. Bottom line: the 1% prefer charters instead of tax increases to pay for smaller classes, early childhood education, and the services that would help children and public schools.

Speaking of exposed:
Read about Alex Honnold’s free solo climb of El Cap in Yosemite.
Now that’s what I call “exposed”.
“Exposed and composed”
Three thousand feet of air
With not a rope to catch
A climb of utter terror
That Honnold did dispatch
LikeLike
And if you want to get a feel for just how exposed Alex was
Watch this
http://video.nationalgeographic.com/video/news/170606-alex-honnold-el-capitan-vin-spd
Sorry for the off topic post, but, in my opinion, this is one of the most remarkable feats (physical and mental) ever accomplished and has lots of lessons for school Deformers (if they only paid attention)
LikeLike
It IS cool. Sometimes when we’ve done a unit on philosophy in my government class, I’ve shown the students the 60 minutes interview with Honnold. (Along with the enjoiner: do not try this at home.)
So Poet, I actually don’t think your comments are that far off topic.
As I wrote last week on my Facebook page about the climb, “Incredible. In an age that seems to disparage expertise, this is what a real expert can do.”
Of course, I was thinking of Trump and all the other political hacks who are destroying our nation, including our public schools. Trump’s only expertise seems to be in promoting himself. And, in telling lies. Big lies.
Honnold the climber is a class act: intelligent, humble with a wry sense of humor.
As for the IDC (Independent Democratic Circus) in Albany, well, they are clearly anything but independent.
LikeLike
Alex IS a class act.
And actually, i’d say that most climbers are.
You can’t fake it and lie about your abilities. Gravity does not allow you to do so.
LikeLike
We should send (force) all the IDC members to climb the same route, the same method – no ropes; no safety gear. They either reach the top on their own or …
LikeLike
I’ll be there at the top with my soccer cleats on to stomp upon thier hands as they pull themselves up over the edge of the cliff onto safe ground.
LikeLike
Is it possible to file the cleats so they are razor sharp and wire them to a battery so they are hot with electricity?
LikeLike
Go ahead and steal some thunder, Lloyd.
Yes. . . I propose we market them to Nike and Adidas . . .
Are you in? I need a business partner.
LikeLike
I’m in as long as we have the power to make every member of Congress that backs the Kremlin’s Agent Orange to climb that rock face without safety gear. If they don’t survive or reach the top safely, they must resign from their elected positions and lose their citizenship. Maybe Saudi Arabia will take them in, because, after all, in Saudi Arabia, there are no protestors.
LikeLike
No need to even don your cleats.
These people wouldn’t make it ten feet off the ground before they would be frozen with fear.
LikeLike
The amounts of money sloshing around in our political machinery is obscene and certainly not in the interests of the 99% of the population. How to get the money out of politics? Bernie is certainly aware of the problem and has been sounding the alarm for years, we need more Bernies. In a way, Bernie is comparable to the rock climber, Alex Honnold. One man against a giant mountain of greed and out of control plutocracy.
LikeLike
Joe,
Please read Gordon Lafer on “The One Percent Solution.”
LikeLike
The solution is to stop rewarding (i.e., voting for) those who perpetuate the system, whether Democrats or Republicans. The Democrats need to know that we’re not going to just turn to them because they’re not Republicans. But so long as people are so fearful of the “greater evil” that they will always reliably vote for the “lesser evil” all we will ever get is evil.
LikeLike
Although the amount is not exactly chump change . It is not exactly a significant amount of money when divided . I suspect these Democratic defections can be explained better by their connections to Cuomo than by the 100,000 that might come their way .
If teachers in NYSUT gave 10 dollars a month to a COPE fund that would create a war chest of almost 50 Million a year . not a match for corporate money . But it puts 700,000 in perspective . 10 a weak for a teacher in NYCs wealthier suburbs would be more appropriate.
LikeLike
Lower New York state is full of savvy, educated people that have the skills to investigate collusion and conflict among different groups. If other states scratched the surface, they would discover similar information. In general, charters and vouchers are a gigantic pay to play scheme. Our laws are now favoring privatization due to privatization lobbies. If we follow the money, we will find similar cause and effect relationships between cash and political action. I blame our politicians for not protecting our young people from commercialization and monetization. Dangling dollars in front of money driven people is like the smell of blood to a pitbull. It is irresponsible, reckless and harmful to our young people. It treats our future voters like “jars of mayonnaise.”
New York has the potential to change its constitution in November. Those hedge funds are throwing money at advertising to entice citizens to vote to amend the constitution so Cuomo and the hedge funds can vandalize the common good. All regular New Yorkers stand to lose a lot more than any gain. NYS retirees, both current and future, have a lot to lose if Cuomo and his hedge fund posse prevail.
LikeLike
On the contrary, the only thing protecting public employee pension funds and the Forest Preserves (the only ones of their kind in the country) in the Adirondacks and Catskills is the current state constitution.
All NYS teachers and public employees, and lovers of wild nature, must vote “NO!” next November on whether to have a constitutional convention, despite the false propaganda that it’s purpose is to institute good government reforms.
LikeLike
1) this is way too “in the weeds” to wake up anyone in New York State that isn’t already politically active on this stuff. I can guarantee there won’t be one teacher in the state who gets turned on to this and activated that hasn’t been already. I had to explain to 2 colleagues yesterday who James Comey was.
2) NYSUT and VOTEcope. My view is that NYSUT leadership is so laughably incompetent that any vote cope money they receive may actually boomerang back around and do more harm than good. I don’t want NYSUT adding their voice for example to the NYS constitutional convention debate! They will surely do 2 things a) get more people in the state wanting a constitutional convention because NYSUT will remind everyone of why they hate us overpaid teachers, and b) NYSUT leadership is generally successful at only 2 things: losing and accomidating. I certainly don’t want them having a voice in the constitutional convention thing. Next thing you know theyll say we should have one because they were promised teachers wouldn’t be harmed. Beyond that NYSUT’s voice on charters, vouchers, privatization, etc etc has been meaningless at best and damaging to our side at worst. The only other voice on the landscape that is worse than NYSUT leadership is Randi Weingarten.
I won’t give to VOTECOPE until there is a complete overhaul of NYSUT leadership that I am confident wont drive us into a tree.
LikeLike
I donate to VOTECOPE as retiree and when I was an active member. While I am not crazy about NYSUT or the AFT, I believe something is better than nothing. Without money NYSUT cannot run ads to counter the vitriol of the hedge funds. You know what happens when the billionaires flood the public with their lies. Look at what happened in California. It is the people we need on our side, and to reach them, it costs a lot of $$$.
LikeLike
NYSTEACHER
To my knowledge the labor movement in NY is pretty much uniformly opposed to a State constitutional convention.
http://nysaflcio.org/noconcon/
“I had to explain to 2 colleagues yesterday who James Comey was.”
That is a profoundly sad statement and it is further amplified by the fact that you are talking about supposedly educated people .
The sadder part is, it represents the biggest failure on the part of organized labor. The failure to educate and engage its membership to become a politically potent force.
I believe Lofgren is on your reading list.
“It would have been hard to find an uneducated farmer during the depression of the 1890s who did not have a very accurate idea about exactly which economic interests were shafting him.”
His most recent piece , “When Should We Use the ‘T’ Word?”
LikeLike
Another SCREAM!
Thanks, Diane!
OMG! Such deceit is unbearable re: this Republic.The TWO party system is BROKEN. We need more parties and candidates other than the GOP and the DNC.
LikeLike
I don’t disagree with your conclusion, but understand that one party spent well over a generation trying to mold your opinion such that both parties were seen as BROKEN and Government seen as bad.
They succeeded because the other party accommodated their wishes .No one was more responsible than Billy Bob
“The era of big Government is over. But we cannot go back to the time when our citizens were left to fend for themselves. Instead, we must go forward as one America, one nation working together to meet the challenges we face together. Self-reliance and teamwork are not opposing virtues; we must have both.”
“the Age of Reagan was so overwhelming that even a Democratic President had to work within its limits, making this speech almost a counterweight to President Lyndon B. Johnson’s 1964 State of the Union,” which was the War on Poverty’”
https://www.washingtonpost.com/news/the-fix/wp/2014/01/26/the-3rd-most-memorable-state-of-the-union-address-bye-bye-big-government/?utm_term=.4914c8e105cb
LikeLike
The IDC seems to be Quisling adjacent.
LikeLike
My “union” consistently backs candidates I do not support.
LikeLike
In her last paragraph, Diane hits on a critical issue that needs more attention. The charter school “industry” is really about creating a cover story for multi-billionaires who pump money into our elections.
It’s much better for appearances for wealthy donors to political campaigns to disguise themselves as educational “philanthropists” who are “concerned” about poor children needing better options. Don’t get me wrong, they love charter schools, but the greater aim is gaining control of statehouses.
NY is a great example, where the IDC is preventing Democrats from assuming control of the legislative agenda. And charter school money is the rocket fuel that keeps them going, even after the Democrats regained a numerical majority following a special election last month.
CHECK OUT founding IDC member David Carlucci doing a song and dance when he was asked if he supports charter schools and whether he takes charter school money: https://truthagainstthemachine.com/index.php/2017/03/22/independent-democratic-conference-deny-school-funding-poorest-districts-ny/
LikeLike
Cross-posted at https://www.opednews.com/Quicklink/Pay-to-Play-Charter-Schoo-in-General_News-Assembly_Caucus_Charter-Schools_Cuomo-170612-357.html
LikeLike